Hostname: page-component-7bb8b95d7b-nptnm Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-09-17T17:03:01.164Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A Forum or Mansio in Carlisle?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2011

Ian Caruana
Affiliation:
Carlisle

Abstract

Image of the first page of this content. For PDF version, please use the ‘Save PDF’ preceeding this image.'
Type
Notes
Information
Britannia , Volume 27 , November 1996 , pp. 345 - 353
Copyright
Copyright © Ian Caruana 1996. Exclusive Licence to Publish: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

78 I am grateful to Border Engineering Co. Ltd. for permission to monitor the sewer-digging programme and to their employees on site for their interest and tolerance while the recording was under way. The City of Carlisle funded the site work through the provision they made for watching-briefs when I was with the Carlisle Archaeological Unit; unfortunately this has not extended to preparing data for publication which has been completed since leaving the Unit. Philip Cracknell drew the figure. David Breeze read a draft of this note and made many useful suggestions which have been incorporated in the final text. Finally, I would like to thank Graham Morgan of the University of Leicester for his work on the analyses of the mortar and plaster.

79 I.D. Caruana, The Roman Forts at Carlisle : Excavations at Annetwell Street, 1973–84 (forthcoming); idem, The Early Roman Forts at Carlisle: Excavations on the BBC Radio Cumbria Site, Annetwell Street, 1990 (report in preparation).

80 Caruana, I.D., ‘Carlisle: excavation of a section of the annexe ditch of the first Flavian fort, 1990’, Britannia xxiii (1992), 45109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

81 Britannia xix (1988), 438.Google Scholar The most accurate modern summary of Roman Carlisle is ‘Carlisle’ in CM. Daniels (ed.), Handbook to the Eleventh Pilgrimage of Hadrian's Wall (1989), 24–31.

82 A similar set of observations was published by the City Surveyor after the sewers were first constructed in Carlisle, McKie, H.U., ‘Remarks and memoranda as to the subsoil, debris, and ancient remains discovered in cutting the sewers in the city of Carlisle’, Trans. Cumb. West. Antiq. Arch. Soc. O.S. iv (1879), 337–43Google Scholar. For some reason no data were available for Abbey Street, ibid., 340.

83 G.C. Morgan in Caruana, op. cit. (note 79).

84 Hogg, R., ‘Excavations at Tullie House, Carlisle, 1954–56’, Trans. Cumb. West. Antiq. Arch. Soc. N.S. lxiv (1964), 1462.Google Scholar

85 J. Gillam in Hogg, op. cit. (note 84), 38.

86 Davison, D.P., The Barracks of the Roman Army from the 1st to 3rd Centuries A.D., BAR Int. Ser. 472 (1989), 218–20.Google Scholar

87 Breeze, D.J., ‘Excavations at the Roman Fort of Carrawburgh, 1967–1969’, Arch. Ael.4 1 (1972), 96.Google Scholar

88 ibid.

89 Proc. Soc. Antiq. of Newcastle3 iv (1910), 136.Google Scholar

90 Birley, E., Richmond, I.A. and Stanfield, J.A., ‘Excavations at Chesterholm-Vindolanda: third report’, Arch. Ael.4 xiii (1936), 221–33, figs 1–3Google Scholar

91 J.N. Dore and J.P. Gillam, The Roman Fort at South Shields (1979), 23.

92 Birley et al., op. cit. (note 90), 232.

93 Charlesworth, D., ‘The hospital, Housesteads’, Arch. Ael.5 iv (1976), 1719.Google Scholar

94 A.S. Robertson, Birrens (Blatobulgium) (1975), 39.

95 Gentry, A.P., Roman Military Stone-built Granaries in Britain, BAR 32 (1976), 55–6, table 4.Google Scholar

96 A. Johnson, Roman Forts (1983), 101.

97 e.g. Bewcastle : Gillam, J.P., Jobey, I.M. and Welsby, D.A., The Roman Bath-house at Bewcastle, Cumbria, CWAAS Res. Ser. 7 (1993), 24–5.Google Scholar

98 For the presence of legionaries see Britannia xvii (1986), 437, No. 11Google Scholar; Britannia xx (1989), 331Google Scholar, No. 5. Davison, op. cit. (note 86), cites the use of mortar at Caerleon, Chester, and Vindonissa without suggesting its use was a status symbol distinguishing legionary and auxiliary barracks. From experience at Carlisle the sand in foundations at Chester could well be mortar with the lime leached out.

99 Forster, R.H. and Knowles, W.H., ‘Corstopitum: report on the excavations in 1910’, Arch. Ael.3 vii (1911), 145–65 and pl. IIIGoogle Scholar. Summarised by Birley, E., ‘Excavations at Corstopitum, 1906–1958’, Arch. Ael.4 xxxvii (1959), 1220.Google Scholar

100 See, for example, the town plan given in P. Salway, The Frontier People of Roman Britain (1965), fig. 5.

101 R. Birley, Vindolanda: A Roman Frontier Post on Hadrian's Wall (1977), 33, fig. 4; 70–1, figs 16–17. The longest vicus buildings appear to be XXXII and XXXIII with a maximum length of about 36 m: ibid., 46–7.

102 Higham, N.J. and Jones, G.D.B., ‘Frontier, forts and farmers: Cumbrian aerial survey 1974–5’, Arch. Journ. cxxxii (1975), fig. 2.Google Scholar

103 Salway, op. cit. (note 100), fig. 8.

104 Birley, E. and Keeney, G.S., ‘Fourth report on excavations at Housesteads’, Arch. Ael.4 xii (1936), pl. xxii.Google Scholar

105 J.S. Wacher, ‘Yorkshire Towns in the Fourth Century’, in R.M. Butler (ed.), Soldier and Civilian in Roman Yorkshire (1971), fig. 24; B.C. Burnham and J. Wacher, The Small Towns of Roman Britain (1990), 112, fig. 30. The exception is the mansio which occupied 0.5 ha (ibid., 113). No detailed plan of this mansio appears to have been published.

106 For early Piercebridge see the aerial photograph in M. Millett, The Romanization of Britain (1990), illus. 64. The courtyard-building is shown in Britannia x (1979), 286, fig. 6.Google Scholar

107 Britannia xv (1984), 277Google Scholar; xvii (1986), 376; for plan see Britannia xxiii (1992), 268, fig. 8.Google Scholar

108 P. Bidwell in Daniels, op. cit. (note 81), 87.

109 R.J. Brewer, ‘Venta Silurum: A Civitas Capital’, in B.C. Burnham and J.L. Davies (eds), Conquest, Co-existence and Change: Recent Work in Roman Wales, Trivium 25 (1990), 80–3; Britannia xxiii (1992), 225 and fig. 3Google Scholar; Britannia xxv (1994), 252.Google Scholar

110 Brewer, op. cit. (note 109), 81–3; J. Wacher, The Towns of Roman Britain (1974), 378 and fig. 7.

111 Wacher, op. cit. (note no), 378–9.

112 J. Collingwood Bruce, Handbook to the Roman Wall (13th edn, CM. Daniels, 1978), 94.

113 Birley, E., ‘Excavations at Corbridge, 1906–1958’, Arch. Ael.4 xxxvii (1959), 17.Google Scholar Birley's argument was that Site XI was intended for a legionary principia but the structural argument could support either principia or forum.

114 H. von Petrokovits, Die lnnenbauten romischer Legionslager während der Prinzipatszeit (1975), Bild 20.

115 Wacher, op. cit. (note no), 60 and figs 10–11.

116 D.J.P. Mason, Excavations at Chester: 11–15 Castle Street and Neighbouring Sites 1974–8: A Possible Roman Posting House (Mansio) (1980), 83.

117 Salway, op. cit. (note 100), 170–3.

118 Birley, op. cit. (note 101), 44–6, fig. 10.

119 Salway, op. cit. (note 100), figs 6–7.

120 ‘Form, Function and Interpretation of the Excavated Plans of Some Large Secular Romano-British Buildings’, in P.J. Drury (ed.), Structural Reconstruction: Approaches to the Interpretation of the Excavated Remains of Buildings, BAR 110 (1982), 289–308. To this list can be added an aqueduct: G.R. Stephens, ‘Civic aqueducts in Britain’, Britannia xvi (1985), 199200.Google Scholar

121 A list of mansiones in Britain is given in Mason, op. cit. (note 116), 84–5. See also P.J. Drury, The Mansio and other Sites in the South-eastern Sector of Caesaromagus (1988), 130–5; Burnham and Wacher, op. cit. (note 105), 19–21; 34–8. E.W. Black, Cursus Publicus: The Infrastructure of Government in Roman Britain, BAR Int. Ser. 241 (1995), which covers the subject in detail, appeared after this note was written.

122 Measurements taken from Higham and Jones, op. cit. (note 102), fig. 2; a similar plan appears in N. Higham and G.D.B. Jones, The Carvetii (1985), fig. 29, where the scale appears to be wrong.

123 Mason, op. cit. (note 116), 83.

124 Black, E.W., ‘Newstead: the buildings in the western annexe’, PSAS cxxi (1991), 215Google Scholar; Pitts, L.F. and Joseph, J.K. St, Inchtuthil: The Roman Legionary Fortress, Britannia Monograph 6 (1985), 207–22Google Scholar; Christison, D. and Buchanan, M., ‘An account of the excavation at the Roman station of Camelon near Falkirk, Stirlingshire, undertaken by the Society in 1900’, PSAS xi (1901), 371–3Google Scholar and pl. V.

125 Caruana, I., ‘Carlisle’, Current Arch., lxxxvi (1983), 7781.Google Scholar

126 Evans, E., Dowdell, G. and Thomas, H.J., ‘A third-century maritime establishment at Cold Knap, Barry, South Glamorgan’, Britannia xvi (1985), 57125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

127 G.C. Boon, Isca (1972), 60–1.

128 JRS lv (1965), 224, No. 11; Higham and Jones, op. cit. (note 122), 9–10, suggest that the caput Carvetiorum might have been near Brougham.

129 Millett, op. cit. (note 106), 66–85, and table 4.4. 130 Wacher, op. cit. (note no), 379, fig. 82.

131 L. Jacobi, Das Rb'merkastell Saalburg bei Homburg vor der Hohe (1897), II, Taf. XIII.

132 A.L.F. Rivet and C. Smith, The Place-names of Roman Britain (1979), 157–60, 162–4.

133 Black, op. cit. (note 121), 23–4; Caruana, op. cit. (note 125).