Skip to main content Accessibility help

The Effect of the Direct Historical Approach on the Development of Theory in Plains Archaeology: A Comment on Mitchell's Analysis of the MBP Legacy

  • Donna C. Roper (a1)


Mark Mitchell's analysis of the legacy of the Missouri Basin Project (MBP) identified the direct historical approach as one discourse that shaped the MBP legacy. While that identification is certainly correct, the discussion is too limited in two ways. First, the use of the direct historical approach for tracing ethnicity was more limited than is generally recognized. Second, and more seriously, the rich documentary and ethnographic record of the Plains Village lifeway became a too readily used source of specific analogies for reading the archaeological record. Theory became irrelevant. Some of the numerous inaccuracies this produced are only recently being corrected.


El análisis de Mark Mitchell del legado del Missouri Basin Project (MBP) identificó el “Enfoque Historico Directo” (Direct Historical Approach o dha) como un discurso que fomentó el legado del MBP. Aunque esa identificación es correcta, la disertación es demasiado limitada en dos maneras. Primero, el uso de dha para determinar etnicidad era más limitado de lo que se reconoce. Segundo, y más importante, el registro profundo documental y etnográfico de la cultura Plains Village se convirtió en una fuente de uso frecuente para producir analogías específicas para leer el registro arqueológico. La teoría se hizo irrelevante. Algunas de las abundantes inexactitudes producidas por eso están siendo corregidas solo recientemente.



Hide All
Bell, Earl H., and Cape, Robert E. 1936 The Rock Shelters of Western Nebraska in the Vicinity of Dalton, Nebraska. In Chapters in Nebraska Archaeology, edited by Earl H. Bell, pp. 357399. The University of Nebraska. Lincoln.
Gilder, Robert F. 1907 Archeology of the Ponca Creek District, Eastern Nebraska. American Anthropologist 9:702719.
Lehmer, Donald J. 1954 Archaeological Investigations in the Oahe Dam Area, South Dakota, 1950–1951. Bulletin 158. Bureau of American Ethnology, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.
Lehmer, Donald J. 1963 The Plains Bison Hunt—Prehistoric and Historic. Plains Anthropologist 8(22):211217.
Lehmer, Donald J. 1971 Introduction to Middle Missouri Archeology. Anthropological Papers No. 1. National Park Service, Washington, D.C.
Lyman, R. Lee, and O’Brien, Michael J. 2001 The Direct Historical Approach, Analogical Reasoning, and Theory in Americanist Archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 8:303342.
Lyman, R. Lee, O’Brien, Michael J., and Dunnell, Robert C. 1997 The Rise and Fall of Culture History. Plenum, New York.
Mitchell, Mark 2006 Research Traditions, Public Policy, and the Underdevelopment of Theory in Plains Archaeology: Tracing the Legacy of the Missouri Basin Project. American Antiquity 71:381396.
Roper, Donna C., and Pauls, Elizabeth P. 2005 What, Where, and When Is an Earthlodge? In Plains Earthlodges: Ethnographic and Archaeological Perspectives, edited by Donna C. Roper and Elizabeth P. Pauls. pp. 131. University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.
South, Stanley 1977 Method and Theory in Historical Archaeology. Academic Press, New York.
Sterns, Fred H. 1914 Ancient Lodge Sites on the Missouri in Nebraska. American Anthropologist 16:135137.
Strong, William Duncan 1932 An Archeological Reconnaissance in the Missouri Valley. In Explorations and Field-Work of the Smithsonian Institution in 1931, pp. 151158. Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.
Strong, William Duncan 1935 An Introduction to Nebraska Archeology. Miscellaneous Collections 93(10). Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.
Trigger, Bruce G. 2006 A History of Archaeological Thought. 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
Wedel, Waldo R. 1934 Contributions to the Archaeology of the Upper Republican Valley, Nebraska. Nebraska History Magazine 15:132209.
Wedel, Waldo R. 1938 The Direct-Historical Approach in Pawnee Archeology. Miscellaneous Collections 97(7). Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.
Wedel, Waldo R. 1940 Culture Sequence in the Central Plains. In Essays in Historical Anthropology of North America, pp. 291352. Miscellaneous Collections 100. Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.
Wedel, Waldo R. 1942 Archeological Remains in Central Kansas and Their Possible Bearing on the Location of Quivira. Miscellaneous Collections 101(7). Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.
Will, George F. 1924 Archaeology of the Missouri Valley. Anthropological Papers Vol. 22, Pt. 6. American Museum of Natural History, New York.
Willey, Gordon R., and Sabloff, Jeremy A. 1993 A History of American Archaeology. 3rd ed. W.H. Freeman and Company, New York.
Wobst, H. Martin 1978 The Archaeo-Ethnology of Hunter-Gatherers or the Tyranny of the Ethnographic Record in Archaeology. American Antiquity 43:303309.

The Effect of the Direct Historical Approach on the Development of Theory in Plains Archaeology: A Comment on Mitchell's Analysis of the MBP Legacy

  • Donna C. Roper (a1)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed