Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2015
  • Online publication date: February 2015

11 - Gambling and Financial Services (Other than Insurance)

Summary

General Introduction

There are a group of services that pose particular problems under a credit-invoice VAT imposed on taxable transactions. They are gambling, transactions involving financial products that are priced to include implicit fees, and insurance (a particular kind of financial service). In all three cases, the value added by the service provider should be subject to a broad-based VAT, at least to the extent that it represents personal consumption expenditures. When early transaction-based, credit-invoice VATs were introduced in Europe and elsewhere, these kinds of services were difficult to include in the tax base because the credit-invoice VAT is based on charging tax on the consideration received by the supplier. For most financial services, the consideration is not explicitly stated. Moreover, financial services accounted for a much smaller percentage of personal consumption included in the VAT base than they do today.

Accordingly, it is not surprising that the default rule in early adopters of VAT was to exempt these services. Recently, some countries have been bringing gambling, more financial services, and casualty insurance into the VAT base. Many problems remain.

Gambling, Lotteries, and Other Games of Chance

In a typical transaction involving goods or services, a registered person remits to the government the difference between the tax on the price charged the customer and the tax on business inputs (such as inventory and supplies) used in making these sales. In a gambling transaction, whether a table game, a gaming machine, or a lottery, the gambler pays for the service (the chance to win) up front, and the value added cannot be calculated precisely until after winners are determined and winnings are paid out.

Zee, Howell H., ed., Taxing the Financial Sector: Concepts, Issues, and Practices (IMF 2004)
Schenk, A. & Zee, H., “Treating Financial Services under a Value-Added Tax: Conceptual Issues and Country Practices,” 22 Tax Notes Int’l3309 (June 25, 2001)
Poddar, S. & English, M., “Taxation of Financial Services under a Value-Added Tax: Applying the Cash-Flow Approach,” 50 National Tax Journal89 (Mar. 1997)
Schenk, A., “Taxation of Financial Services under a Value Added Tax: A Critique of the Treatment Abroad and the Proposals in the United States,” 9 Tax Notes Int’l823 (1994)
Neubig, T. & Adrion, H., “Value Added Taxes and Other Consumption Taxes: Issues for Insurance Companies,” 61 Tax Notes1001 (1993)
Schenk, A. & Oldman, O., principal draftsmen, “Analysis of Tax Treatment of Financial Services under a Consumption-Style VAT: Report of American Bar Association Section of Taxation, Value Added Tax Committee,” 44 Tax Law181 (1990)
Henderson, Y. [Kodrzycki], “Financial Intermediaries under Value-Added Tax,” New England Economic Review 37 (July–Aug., 1988)
Barham, V., Poddar, S. & Whalley, J., “The Tax Treatment of Insurance Under a Consumption Type, Destination Basis VAT,” 40 National Tax Journal171 (1987)
Hoffman, L., Poddar, S. & Whalley, J., “Taxation of Banking Services under a Consumption Type, Destination VAT,” 40 National Tax547 (1987)
Schenk, , “Taxation of Financial Services (including Insurance) under a U.S. Value-Added Tax63 Tax Law Review409 (2010)
Zee, H., “A New Approach to Taxing Financial Intermediation Services under a Value-Added Tax,” 58 National Tax Journal77, 78 (Mar. 2005)
Radecki, L., “Banks’ Payments-Driven Revenues,” 5 Economic Policy Review53 (July, 1999)
Jack, W., “The Treatment of Financial Services under a Broad-Based Consumption Tax,” 53 National Tax Journal841 (1999)
Grubert, H. & Mackie, J., “Must Financial Services Be Taxed under a Consumption Tax?53 National Tax Journal 23 (1999)
Auerbach, A. & Gordon, R., “Taxation of Financial Services under a VAT,” 92 American Economic Review 411 (2002)
Rousslang, D., “Should Financial Services Be Taxed under a Consumption Tax? Probably,” 55 National Tax Journal281 (June 2002)
Mason, P., “Solving the Issues of VAT and Financial Derivatives or It’s VAT Jim, but Not As We Know It?Derivatives & Financial Instruments 190 (July/Aug. 2000)
Schatan, R., “VAT on Banking Services: Mexico’s Experience,” 14 VAT Monitor 287 (July/Aug. 2003)
Owens, J., “The Move to VAT,” 2 Interfax45, 49 (1996)
Edgar, T., “Exempt Treatment of Financial Intermediation Services under a Value-Added Tax: Assessing the Significance of Recent Challenges to an Imperfect Status Quo,” 49 Canadian Tax Journal1133 (2001)
Nevelsteen, L. & Van Den Plas, R., “Undertakings of Collective Investment and VAT in the EU,” 14 VAT Monitor 456 (Nov./Dec. 2003)
Cnossen, , “VAT Treatment of Financial Services,” in International Studies in Taxation: Law and Economics – Liber Amicorum Mutén 91(Lindencrona, G., Lodin, S., and Wiman, B., eds., Kluwer 1999)
Stacey, P.Guarantees: Multiple Supplies, Different GST Treatments,” 15 VAT Monitor 398 (Nov./Dec. 2004)
Joseph, A., “Securitization – The Position of SPVs under Australian GST,” 16 VAT Monitor 109 (Mar./Apr. 2005)
Vaughan, M., “Exchange of Currency,” 13 VAT Monitor 363 (Sept. /Oct. 2002)
Zee, H., “VAT Treatment of Financial Services: A Primer on Conceptual Issues and Country Practices,” 34(10) Intertax458
Pallot, M. & White, D., “Improvements to the GST Treatment of Financial Services – The Proposed New Zealand Approach,” 13 VAT Monitor 481 (Nov./Dec. 2002)
Gliksberg, D., “Israel’s Value Added Tax Law,” VAT Monitor 2 (July 1992)
Oldman, O. & Schenk, A., “The Business Activities Tax: Have Senators Danforth & Boren Created a Better Value Added Tax?10 Tax Notes Int’l 55, 69–70 (Jan. 2, 1995)