OTHER APPROACHES

A wide variety of formal methods have been proposed for the specification and development of real-time systems, based upon process algebras, temporal logics, and timed programming languages. Although much research has been carried out, a consensus has yet to emerge concerning the applicability of the various formalisms to different types of system. A successful development method is likely to involve some combination of the features mentioned above. A notation that is well-suited to requirements capture is unlikely to be an efficient programming language, and vice versa.

Quantitative Temporal Logics

Hooman and Widom (1989) present a compositional proof system relating an occam-like language to a quantitative temporal logic, similar to the one developed by Koymans and de Roever (1983). Although the system description language is somewhat limited, it is clear that quantitative temporal logics are useful assertion languages; Jackson (1990) shows how such a logic may be employed as a specification language for timed CSP. It would be interesting to see the proof system applied in the development of a large, complex system.

Shasha et al. (1983) use a quantitative temporal logic to prove the correctness of a carrier-sense broadcast protocol, similar to the one described in chapter seven. By assuming a simplified version of the service provided by the physical layer, and an internal specification of the data link layer, the authors are able to establish that certain desirable properties hold of the network.