Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2014
  • Online publication date: August 2014

6 - New penitential territories: the tenth and eleventh centuries

Summary

In the Carolingian Church penance had become a regular feature of the life of the clergy and the laity. As a consequence many penitential books were composed to assist priests in their task of hearing confession. Such penitential manuals had been copied in large quantities and were available in the small collections of books of country churches. After this blossoming of penitential literature, which was characterized by a production of new texts, distributing these texts by copying them and discussing their models and functions, the tenth and eleventh centuries form a contrast. In the northern Frankish regions, the centre of production and discussions of penitential texts during the Carolingian era, we no longer see a thriving production of new penitential texts. This decrease fits in with a more general decline in the production of texts and manuscripts that has been observed for this period. This decline can partly be explained by the extensive production of texts and manuscripts in the preceding era, which seems to have met many demands. Given the fact that parchment manuscripts are durable products, the Carolingian copies probably remained in use in the following centuries. A well-stocked parish bookshelf did not need instant renewal. The conservative nature of the tenth- and eleventh-century liturgical developments did not create a need for new texts, as is shown, for instance, by the fact that earlier penitential handbooks continued to be reproduced. The penitentials attributed to Bede and Egbert, for example, were copied at least eighteen times in this period.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Leonardi, C., ‘Intellectual life’, in Reuter, T. (ed.), The New Cambridge Medieval History, vol. : c. 900–c. 1024 (Cambridge 1999), pp. 186–211, at p. 186.
Regino of Prüm, Libri duo de synodalibus causis et disciplinis ecclesiasticis, Praefatio, ed. Wasserschleben, H., Reginonis libri duo de synodalibus causis et disciplinis ecclesiasticis (Leipzig 1840), p. 1
Somerville, R. and Brasington, B., Prefaces to Canon Law Books in Latin Christianity. Selected Translations, 500–1245 (New Haven / London 1998), pp. 92–4.
Hartmann, W., Kirche und Kirchenrecht um 900. Die Bedeutung de spätkarolingischen Zeit für Tradition und Innovation im kirchlichen Recht, Schriften der MGH 58 (Hanover 2008), pp. 149–62.
Siems, H., ‘In ordine posuimus: Begrifflichkeit und Rechtsanwendung in Reginos Sendhandbuch’, in Hartmann, W. (ed.), Recht und Gericht in Kirche und Welt um 900, Schriften des Historischen Kollegs. Kolloquien 69 (Munich 2007), pp. 67–90, at p. 73.
Hartmann, W., ‘Die Capita incerta im Sendhandbuch Reginos von Prüm’, in Münsch, O. and Zotz, T. (eds.), Scientia veritatis. Festschrift für Hubert Mordek zum 65. Geburtstag (Ostfildern 2004), pp. 207–26.
McKitterick, R., Charlemagne. The Formation of a European Identity (Cambridge 2008), pp. 256–66.
Schieffer, R., ‘Zur Entstehung des Sendgerichts im 9. Jahrhundert’, in Müller, W. P. and Sommar, M. E. (eds.), Medieval Church Law and the Origins of the Western Legal Tradition. A Tribute to Kenneth Pennington (Washington DC 2006), pp. 50–6
Hartmann, W., ‘Probleme des geistlichen Gerichts im 10. und 11. Jahrhunderts: Bischöfe und Synoden als Richter im ostfränkisch-deutschen Reich’, in La Giustizia nell’alto medioevo (secoli IX–XI), Settimana di Studio 44 (Spoleto 1997), pp. 631–72.
Rau, R., Briefe des Bonifatius. Willibalds Leben des Bonifatius. Nebst einigen zeitgenössischen Dokumenten, Ausgewählte Quellen zur deutschen Geschichte des Mittelalters. Freiherr vom Stein-Gedächtnisausgabe 4b (Darmstadt 1968), pp. 378–80 and 386.
Waitz, G., in Lebensbeschreibungen einiger Bischöfe des 10.–12. Jahrhunderts, tr. Kallfelz, Hatto, Ausgewählte Quellen 22 (second edition, Darmstadt 1986), pp. 78–80
Koeniger, A., Die Sendgerichte in Deutschland (Munich 1907), pp. 191–4
Davis, A., The Holy Bureaucrat. Eudes Rigaud and Religious Reform in Thirteenth-Century Normandy (Ithaca / London 2006), pp. 111–12.
Fouracre, P. and Ganz, D. (eds.), Frankland. The Franks and the World of the Early Middle Ages. Essays in Honour of Dame Jinty Nelson (Manchester 2008), pp. 209–41.
van Rhijn, C., ‘Priests and the Carolingian reforms: the bottlenecks of local correctio’, in Corradini, R., Meens, R., Pössel, C. and Shaw, P. (eds.), Texts and Identities in the Early Middle Ages, Forschungen zur Geschichte des Mittelalters 12 (Vienna 2006), pp. 219–37.
Meens, R., ‘Die Bußbücher und das Recht im 9. und 10. Jahrhundert. Kontinuität und Wandel’, in Hartmann, W. (ed.), Recht und Gericht in Kirche und Welt um 900 (Munich 2007), pp. 217–33, at p. 228.
Fowler-Magerl, L., Clavis canonum. Selected Canon Law Collections Before 1140. Access with Data Processing, MGH Hilfsmittel 21 (Hanover 2005), p. 90.
Austin, G., Shaping Church Law Around the Year 1000. The Decretum of Burchard of Worms (Farnham 2009), p. 20
Hoffmann, H. and Pokorny, R., Das Dekret des Bisschofs Burchard von Worms. Textstufen – Frühe Verbreitung – Vorlagen, MGH Hilfsmittel 12 (Munich 1991), pp. 12–13.
Huisman, G., Catalogus van de middeleeuwse handschriften in de Universiteitsbibliotheek Nijmegen (Leuven 1997), pp. 77–82.
Reynolds, R., ‘Penitentials in south and central Italian canon law manuscripts of the tenth and eleventh centuries’, Early Medieval Europe 14 (2006), pp. 65–84, at pp. 82–3
Rolker, C., Canon Law and the Letters of Ivo of Chartres (Cambridge 2010), pp. 68–9
Fransen, G. and Kölzer, T. (eds.), Burchard von Worms: Decretorum libri XX (Aalen 1992).
Mostert, M., ‘What happened to literacy in the Middle Ages? Scriptural evidence for the history of the western literate mentality’, Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis 108 (1995), pp. 323–5.
Austin, G., ‘Jurisprudence in the service of pastoral care. The Decretum of Burchard of Worms’, Speculum 79 (2004), pp. 929–59, at p. 932
Körntgen, L., ‘Canon law and the practice of penance: Burchard of Worms’s penitential’, Early Medieval Europe 14 (2006), pp. 103–17, at p. 106.
McNeill, J. T. and Gamer, H., Medieval Handbooks of Penance. A Translation of the Principal ‘Libri Poenitentiales’ and Selections from Related Documents (New York 1938, repr. 1990), p. 341.
Künzel, R., ‘Paganisme, syncrétisme et culture religieuse populaire au Haut Moyen Age’, Annales ESC 47 (1992), pp. 1055–69
Ekkehard IV of St Gallen, Casus Sancti Galli, c. 30, ed. Haefele, H., AQ 10 (Darmstadt 1980), pp. 70–2
de Jong, M., ‘Pollution, penance and sanctity: Ekkehard’s Life of Iso of St. Gall’, in Hill, J. and Swan, Mary (eds.), The Community, the Family and the Saint. Patterns of Power in Early Medieval Europe (Turnhout 1998), pp. 145–58
Hamilton, S., ‘The unique favour of penance: the Church and the people c. 800 – c. 1100’, in Linehan, P. and Nelson, J. (eds.), The Medieval World (London and New York 2001), pp. 229–45.
Kerff, F., ‘Libri paenitentiales und kirchliche Strafgerichtsbarkeit bis zum Decretum Gratiani. Ein Diskussionsvorschlag’, ZRG Kan. Abt. 75 (1989), pp. 23–57, at p. 36.
Palazzo, E., Le Moyen Age. Des origines au XIIIe siècle, Histoire des livres liturgiques (Paris 1993), pp. 210–15.
Rasmussen, N. K., Les pontificaux du haut Moyen Age. Genèse du livre de l’évêque. Texte mise au point par Marcel Haverals, Spicilegium Sacrum Lovaniense, Études et documents 49 (Leuven 1998).
Vogel, C. and Elze, R., Le Pontifical Romano-Germanique du dixième siècle, 3 vols., Studi e Testi 226, 227 and 269 (Vatican City 1963–72), vol. ii, pp. 14–23, 59–67 and 234–45.
Vogel, C., ‘Les rites de la pénitence publique aux Xe et XIe siècle’, in Gallais, P. and Riou, Y.-J. (eds.), Mélanges René Crozet (Poitiers 1966), vol. i, pp. 137–44.
Palazzo, E., Les sacramentaires de Fulda. Étude sur l’iconographie et la liturgie à l’époque ottonienne, Liturgiewissenschaftliche Quellen und Forschungen 77 (Aschendorff, Münster 1994), p. 98.
Lapidge, M., The Anglo-Saxon Library (Oxford 2006), pp. 44–5.
Smyth, A. P., ‘The effect of the Scandinavian raiders on the English and Irish churches: a preliminary reassessment’, in Smith, B., Britain and Ireland 900–1300. Insular Reponses to Medieval European Change (Cambridge 1999), pp. 1–38.
Cubitt, C., ‘Bishops, priests and penance in late Anglo-Saxon England’, Early Medieval Europe 14 (2006), pp. 41–63, at pp. 44–8.
Liebermann, F., Die Gesetze der Angelsachsen I: Text und Überlieferung (Halle 1903, repr. Aalen 1960), pp. 26–89, at pp. 48–9.
Whitelock, D., Brett, M. and Brooke, C., Councils and Synods with Other Documents Relating to the English Church (Oxford 1981), vol. i, 1, pp. 6–12.
Nelson, J., ‘“… sicut olim gens Francorum …”: Fulk’s letter to Alfred revisited’, in Roberts, J., Nelson, J. and Godden, M. (eds.), Alfred the Wise. Studies in Honour of Janet Bately on the Occasion of her Sixty-Fifth Birthday (Cambridge 1997), pp. 135–44
Vanderputten, S., ‘Canterbury and Flanders in the late tenth century’, Anglo-Saxon England 35 (2006), pp. 219–44.
Rusche, P., ‘St Augustine’s Abbey and the tradition of penance in early tenth-century England’, Anglia 120 (2002), pp. 159–83.
Ker, N., Catalogue of Manuscripts Containing Anglo-Saxon (Oxford 1957), p. 360.
Gneuss, H., Handlist of Anglo-Saxon Manuscripts. A List of Manuscripts and Manuscript Fragments Written or Owned in England up to 1100, Medieval and Renaissance Texts and Studies 241 (Tempe, Arizona 2001), nr. 565, p. 93.
Ambrose, S., ‘The codicology and palaeography of London, BL, Royal 5 E. XIII and its abridgment of the Collectio Canonum Hibernensis’, Codices Manuscripti 54/55(2006), pp. 1–26
Gameson, R., ‘The origin of the Exeter Book of Old English poetry’, Anglo-Saxon England 25 (1995), pp. 135–85, at pp. 172–77.
Delen, K., Gaastra, A., Saan, M. and Schaap, B., ‘The Paenitentiale Cantabrigiense. A witness of the Carolingian contribution to the tenth-century reforms in England’, Sacris Erudiri 41 (2002), pp. 341–73.
Townend, M. (ed.), Wulfstan, Archbishop of York. The Proceedings of the Second Alcuin Conference (Turnhout 2004)
Wormald, P., ‘Archbishop Wulfstan and the holiness of society’, in Wormald, , Legal Culture in the Early Medieval West. Law as Text, Image and Experience (London / Rio Grande 1999), pp. 225–51, at pp. 239–40
Wormald, P., The Making of English Law. King Alfred to the Twelfth Century, vol. : Legislation and its Limits (Oxford 1999), p. 218.
Heyworth, M., ‘The “Late Old English Handbook for the use of a Confessor”: authorship and connections’, Notes and Queries 54 (2007), pp. 218–22
Morris, R., The Blickling Homilies with a Translation and Index of Words together with the Blickling Glosses, Early English Texts Society 58, 63, 73 (reprinted in one volume, London 1967), pp. 42–3
Hamilton, S., ‘Rites for public penance in Late Anglo-Saxon England’, in Gittos, H. and Bedingfield, M. B. (eds.), The Liturgy of the Late Anglo-Saxon Church, Henry Bradshaw Society Subsidia 5 (London 2005), pp. 65–103
Bedingfield, M., ‘Public penance in Anglo-Saxon England’, Anglo-Saxon England 31 (2002), pp. 223–55
Vives, J., Concilios visigóticos e hispano-romanos (Madrid / Barcelona 1963), p. 128.
Bezler, F., Les Pénitentiels Espagnols. Contribution à l’étude de la civilisation de l’Espagne chrétienne du haut Moyen Âge, Spanische Forschungen der Görresgesellschaft, 2. Reihe, Bd. 30 (Münster 1994), pp. xxiv–xxv.
Löfstedt, B., ‘Sprachliches zu den spanischen Bussbüchern’, Archivum Latinitatis Medii Aevi. Bulletin du Cange 60 (2002), pp. 261–2
Reynolds, R., ‘Rites and signs of conciliar decisions in the early Middle Ages’, in Segni e riti nella chiesa altomedievale occidentale, Settimane di Studio 33 (Spoleto 1987), pp. 225–44.
Eberhardt, O., Via Regia. Der Fürstenspiegel Smaragds von St. Mihiel und seine literarische Gattung, Münstersche Mittelalter-Schriften 28 (Munich 1977), pp. 96–7.
Martin Duque, A. J., ‘Sancho III el Mayor de Navarra, entre la leyenda y la historia’, in Ante el milenario del reinado de Sancho el Mayor. Un rey Navarro para España y Europa, XXX Semana de Estudios Medievales, Estella (Pamplona 2004), pp. 19–42, at p. 34
Andrade, J., ‘Textos penitenciales y penitencia en el Noroeste de la peninsula Ibérica’, in Herren, M. W., McDonough, C. J. and Arthur, R. (eds.), Latin Culture in the Eleventh Century. Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Medieval Latin Studies. Cambridge, September 9–12–1998 (Turnhout 2002), pp. 29–38.
Noble, T., ‘The Christian church as an institution’, in Noble, T. F. X. and Smith, J. M. H. (eds.), The Cambridge History of Christianity, vol. : Early Medieval Christianities c. 600–c. 1100 (Cambridge 2008), pp. 249–74, at pp. 253–4
Hitchcock, R., Mozarabs in Medieval and Early Modern Spain. Identities and Influences (Aldershot 2008):
Boylan, A., ‘The library at Santo Domingo de Silos and its catalogues (XIth–XVIIIth centuries)’, Revue Mabillon 64 (1992), pp. 59–102, at p. 61
Diaz y Diaz, M., ‘El escriptorio de Silos’, Revista de Musicologia 15 (1992), pp. 389–401
Collins, R., ‘Continuity and loss in medieval Spanish culture: the evidence of MS, Silos, Archivo Monástico 4’, in Collins, R. and Goodman, A. (eds.), Medieval Spain. Culture, Conflict, and Coexistence. Studies in Honour of Angus MacKay (Basingstoke / New York 2002), pp. 1–22, at pp. 3–5.
Wright, R., ‘In what language are the glosses of San Millán and Silos?’, in Wright, , A Sociophilological Study of Late Latin, Utrecht Studies in Medieval Literacy 10 (Turnhout 2002), pp. 232–42 at p. 241, n. 23.
Bezler, F., ‘Chronologie relative des Pénitentiels d’Albelda et de Silos’, Sacris Erudiri 23 (1991), pp. 163–9.
Faulhaber, C., Medieval Manuscripts in the Library of the Hispanic Society of America (New York 1983), p. 134
Pokorny, R. and Stratmann, M., Capitula Episcoporum II, MGH Cap. Ep. II (Hanover 1995), pp. 169–70
Meens, R., ‘The oldest Manuscript witness of the Collectio canonum Hibernensis’, Peritia 14 (2000), pp. 1–19.
Reynolds, R., ‘A Visigothic-script folio of a Carolingian collection of canon law’, Mediaeval Studies 58 (1996), pp. 321–5, at p. 321.
de Martel, G., ‘Les textes pénitentiels du ms. Lisbonne 232’, Sacris Erudiri 27 (1984), pp. 443–60.
Weigle, F., Die Briefe des Bischofs Rather von Verona, MGH, Briefe der deutschen Kaiserzeit I (Weimar 1949), pp. 133–7.
Wemple, S., ‘The canonical resources of Atto of Vercelli (926–960)’, Traditio 26 (1970), pp. 335–50
Gaastra, A., ‘Between liturgy and canon law. A study of books of confession and penance in eleventh- and twelfth-century Italy’ (Dissertation, University of Utrecht, 2007), p. 10.
Heiser, L., Die Responsa ad consulta Bulgarorum des Papstes Nikolaus (858–867) (Trier 1979), p. 37.
Airlie, S., ‘Private bodies and the body politic in the divorce case of Lothar II’, Past and Present 161 (1998), pp. 3–38
Heidecker, K., The Divorce of Lothar II. Christian Marriage and Political Power in the Carolingian World (Ithaca 2010)
Staubach, N., Das Herrscherbild Karls des Kahlen (Münster 1981), pp. 153–61.
Körntgen, L., ‘Ein italienisches Bußbuch und seine fränkische Quellen. Das anonyme Paenitentiale der Handschrift Vatikan, Arch. S. Pietro H 58’, in Mordek, H. (ed.), Aus Archiven und Bibliotheken. Festschrift für Raymund Kottje zum 65. Geburtstag (Frankfurt a.M. / Bern / etc., 1992), pp. 189–205.
Salmon, P., ‘Un “Libellus Officialis” du XIe siècle’, Revue Bénédictine 87 (1977), pp. 257–88
Hamilton, S., ‘The Rituale: the evolution of a new liturgical book’, in Swanson, R. (ed.), The Church and the Book, Studies in Church History 38 (Woodbridge 2004), pp. 74–86.
Reynolds, R., ‘The South-Italian canon law Collection in Five Books and its derivatives: new evidence on its origins, diffusion and use’, Mediaeval Studies 52 (1990), pp. 278–95.
Gaastra, A., ‘Penance and the law: the penitential canons of the Collection in Nine Books’, Early Medieval Europe 14 (2006), pp. 85–102.
Cowdrey, H., The Age of Abbot Desiderius. Montecassino, the Papacy, and the Normans in the Eleventh and Early Twelfth Centuries (Oxford 1983), pp. 43–4
Newton, F., The Scriptorium and Library at Monte Cassino (Cambridge 1999), p. 273, n. 126.
Reynolds, R., ‘The transmission of the Hibernensis in Italy: tenth to twelfth century’, Peritia 14 (2000), pp. 20–50.
Gyug, R., ‘The list of authorities in the illustrations of the Collection in Five Books (Ms. Vat. lat. 1339)’, in Cushing, K. and Gyug, R. (eds.), Ritual, Text and Law. Studies in Medieval Canon Law and Liturgy Presented to Roger E. Reynolds (London 2004), pp. 241–54.
Althoff, G., ‘Das Privileg der deditio. Formen gütlicher Konfliktbeendung in der mittelalterlichen Adelsgesellschaft’, in Althoff, , Spielregeln der Politik im Mittelalter. Kommunikation in Frieden und Fehde (Darmstadt 1997), pp. 99–125.
Becher, M., ‘Cum lacrimis et gemitu. Vom Weinen der Sieger und der Besiegten im frühen und hohen Mittelalter’, in Althoff, G. (ed.), Formen und Funktionen öffentlicher Kommunikation im Mittelalter, Vorträge und Forschungen. Konstanzer Arbeitskreis für Mittelalterliche Geschichte 51 (Stuttgart 2001), pp. 25–52.
Trillmich, W., Thietmar von Merseburg, Chronik, Ausgewählte Quellen zur deutschen Geschichte des Mittelalters 9 (Darmstadt 1985), pp. 244 and 256–8
Meens, R., ‘Kirchliche Buße und Konfliktbewältigung. Thietmar von Merseburg näher betrachtet’, Frühmittelalterliche Studien 41 (2007), pp. 317–30.
Barrow, J., ‘Demonstrative behaviour and political communication in later Anglo-Saxon England’, Anglo-Saxon England 36 (2007), pp. 127–50.
Caspar, E., Das Register Gregors VII, MGH Epistolae selectae 2.1 (Berlin 1920), p. 312.
Robinson, I. S., Henry IV of Germany 1056–1106 (Cambridge 1999), pp. 161–4
Althoff, G., Heinrich IV (Darmstadt 2006), pp. 150–60
Weinfurter, S., Canossa. Der Entzauberung der Welt (Munich 2006)
Reuter, T., ‘Contextualising Canossa: excommunication, penance, surrender, reconciliation’, in Reuter, T., Medieval Polities and Modern Mentalities (Cambridge 2006), pp. 147–66
Fried, J., ‘Der Pakt von Canossa. Schritte zur Wirklichkeit durch Erinnerungsanalyse’, in Hartmann, W. and Herbers, K. (eds.), Die Faszination der Papstgeschichte. Neue Zugänge zum frühen und hohen Mittelalter (Cologne / Weimar/ Vienna 2008), pp. 133–97.
Emerton, E. (tr.), The Correspondence of Pope Gregory VII. Selected Letters from the Registrum (New York 1932), pp. 111–12.
Cowdrey, H. E. J. (tr.), The Register of Pope Gregory VII, 1073–1085. An English Translation (Oxford 2002).
Weinfurter, S. in collaboration with Seibert, Hubertus (eds.), Die Salier und das Reich, vol. Gesellschaftlicher und ideengeschichtlicher Wandel im Reich der Salier (Sigmaringen 1991), pp. 297–325)
Goez, W., ‘Canossa als deditio?’, in Thumser, M. (ed.), Studien zur Geschichte des Mittelalters. Jürgen Petersohn zum 65. Geburtstag (Stuttgart 2000), pp. 92–9
Lampert of Hersfeld, Annales, s.a. 1077, ed. Holder-Egger, O., AQ 13 (4th edn Darmstadt 2011), pp. 410–12
Rau, R., Quellen zur karolingischen Reichsgeschichte III. AQ 7 (4th edn Darmstadt 2002), s.a. 868, p. 222
MacLean, S., History and Politics in Late Carolingian and Ottonian Europe. The Chronicle of Regino of Prüm and Adalbert of Magdeburg (Manchester / New York 2009), pp. 157–8.
Pérez de Urbel, J. and González Ruiz-Zorilla, A. (eds.), Historia Silense (Madrid 1959), pp. 208–9
Bishko, C. J., ‘The liturgical context of Ferdinand I’s last days’, Hispania Sacra. Revista de Historia Eclesiástica 17 (1964), pp. 47–59
Bishko, C. J., Spanish and Portuguese Monastic History 600–1300, Variorum Reprints (London 1984), no. VII).
Cowdrey, H., The Cluniacs and the Gregorian Reform (Oxford 1970), p. 128
Hamilton, S., ‘Penance in the age of the Gregorian Reform’, in Cooper, K. and Gregory, J. (eds.), Retribution, Repentance, and Reconciliation, Studies in Church History 40 (Woodbridge 2004), pp. 47–73, at p. 54.
Chiffoleau, J., La comptabilité de l'au-delà: Les hommes, la mort et la religion dans la région d'Avignon à la fin du moyen âge (Rome 1980)
Angenendt, A., Braucks, T. and Busch, R., ‘Gezählte Frömmigkeit’, Frühmittelalterliche Studien 29 (1995), pp. 1–71.
Angenendt, A., Grundformen der Frömmigkeit im Mittelalter (Munich 2004), pp. 98–9.
Cowdrey, H., ‘The spirituality of Gregory VII’, in Hogg, J. (ed.), The Mystical Tradition and the Carthusians (Salzburg 1995), vol. i, pp. 1–22
Cowdrey, H., Popes and Church Reform in the Eleventh Century (Aldershot 2000)).
Tyerman, C., God’s War. A New History of the Crusades (Cambridge MA, 2006), p. 72.
Constable, G., ‘Medieval charters as sources for the history of the crusades’, in Edbury, P. (ed.), Crusade and Settlement. Papers read at the First Conference of the Society for the Study of the Crusades and the Latin East Presented to R. C. Smail (Cardiff 1985), pp. 73–89
Bull, M., Knightly Piety and the Lay Response to the First Crusade. The Limousin and Gascony, c. 970–c. 1130 (Oxford 1993), pp. 157–91.
Brundage, J., ‘Prostitution, miscegenation and sexual purity in the First Crusade’, in Edbury, P. (ed.), Crusade and Settlement (Cardiff 1985), pp. 57–65.
Goetz, H.-W., ‘Die Chronik Thietmars von Merseburg als Ego-Dokument. Ein Bischof mit gespaltenem Selbstverständnis’, in McKitterick, R., van Renswoude, I. and Gillis, M. (eds.), Ego Trouble. Authors and Their Identities in the Early Middle Ages (Vienna 2009), pp. 259–70.