Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2011
  • Online publication date: November 2011

22 - On optimal decision making in brains and social insect colonies

from Part III - Action selection in social contexts

Summary

Summary

The problem of how to compromise between speed and accuracy in decision making faces organisms at many levels of biological complexity. Striking parallels are evident between decision making in primate brains and collective decision making in social insect colonies: in both systems separate populations accumulate evidence for alternative choices, when one population reaches a threshold a decision is made for the corresponding alternative, and this threshold may be varied to compromise between the speed and accuracy of decision making. In primate decision making simple models of these processes have been shown, under certain parameterisations, to implement the statistically optimal procedure that minimises decision time for any given error rate. In this chapter, we adapt these same analysis techniques and apply them to new models of collective decision making in social insect colonies. We show that social insect colonies may also be able to achieve statistically optimal collective decision making in a very similar way to primate brains, via direct competition between evidence-accumulating populations. This optimality result makes testable predictions for how collective decision making in social insects should be organised. Our approach also represents the first attempt to identify a common theoretical framework for the study of decision making in diverse biological systems.

Introduction

Animals constantly make decisions. Habitat selection, mate selection, and foraging require investigation of, and choice between, alternatives that may determine an animal's reproductive success. For example, many animals invest considerable time and energy in finding a safe home (Franks et al., 2002; Hansell, 1984; Hazlett, 1981; Seeley, 1982). Similarly an animal may frequently have to deal with ambiguous sensory information in deciding whether a predator is present or not (Trimmer et al., 2008).

References
Beekman, MFathke, RSeeley, T 2006 How does an informed minority of scouts guide a honeybee swarm as it flies to its new homeAnim. Behav. 71 161
Bogacz, RBrown, EMoehlis, JHolmes, PCohen, J. D 2006 The physics of optimal decision making: a formal analysis of models of performance in two-alternative forced choice tasksPsychol. Rev. 113 700
Bogacz, RGurney, K 2007 The basal ganglia and cortex implement optimal decision making between alternative actionsNeural Comput. 19 442
Bogacz, RUsher, MZhang, JMcClelland, J. L 2007 Extending a biologically inspired model of choice: multi-alternatives, nonlinearity and value-based multidimensional choicePhil. Trans. Roy. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 362 1655
Britten, K. HShadlen, M. NNewsome, W. TMovshon, J. A 1993 Responses of neurons in macaque mt to stochastic motion signalsVis. Neurosci. 10 1157
Britton, N. FFranks, N. RPratt, S. CSeeley, T. D 2002 Deciding on a new home: how do honeybees agreeProc. Soc. Roy. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 269 1383
Chittka, LDyer, A. GBock, FDornhaus, A 2003 Bees trade off foraging speed for accuracyNature 424 388
Couzin, I. DKrause, JFranks, N. RLevin, S. A 2005 Effective leadership and decision-making in animal groups on the moveNature 433 513
Dornhaus, AFranks, N 2006 Colony size affects collective decision-making in the ant Insectes Sociaux 53 420
Dornhaus, AFranks, N. RHawkins, R. MShere, H. N. S 2004 Ants move to improve: colonies of emigrate whenever they find a superior nest siteAnim. Behav. 67 959
Edwards, W 1965 Optimal strategies for seeking information: models for statistics, choice reaction times, and human information processingJ. Math. Psychol. 2 312
Franks, N. RRichardson, T 2006 Teaching in tandem-running antsNature 439 153
Franks, NDornhaus, ABest, CJones, E 2006 Decision making by small and large house-hunting ant colonies: one size fits allAnim. Behav. 72 611
Franks, N. RDornhaus, AFitzsimmons, J. PStevens, M 2003 Speed versus accuracy in collective decision makingProc. Soc. Roy. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 270 2457
Franks, N. RDornhaus, AHitchcock, G 2007 Avoidance of conspecific colonies during nest choice by antsAnim. Behav. 73 525
Franks, N. RDornhaus, AMetherell, B. G 2006 Not everything that counts can be counted: ants use multiple metrics for a single nestsProc. Soc. Roy. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 273 165
Franks, N. RHooper, JWebb, CDornhaus, A 2005 Tomb evaders: house-hunting hygiene in antsBiol. Lett. 1 190
Franks, N. RHooper, J. WGumn, M 2007 181
Franks, N. RMallon, E. BBray, H. EHamilton, M. JMischler, T. C 2003 Strategies for choosing between alternatives with different attributes: exemplified by house-hunting antsAnim. Behav. 65 215
Franks, N. RPratt, S. CMallon, E. BBritton, N. FSumpter, D. J. T 2002 Information flow, opinion polling and collective intelligence in house-hunting social insectsProc. Soc. Roy. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 357 1567
Giurfa, MZhang, SJenett, AMenzel, RSrinivasan, M. V 2001 The concepts of ‘sameness’ and ‘difference’ in an insectNature 410 930
Hanks, T. DDitterich, JShadlen, M. N 2006 Microstimulation of macaque area lip affects decision-making in a motion discrimination taskNature Neurosci. 9 682
Hansell, M. H 1984 Animal Architecture and Building BehaviourLondonLongman
Hazlett, B. A 1981 The behavioral ecology of hermit crabsAnn. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 12 1
Hofstadter, D. R 1979 Gödel Escher Bach: An Eternal Golden BraidNew YorkBasic Books
Huk, A. CShadlen, M. N 2005 Neural activity in macaque parietal cortex reflects temporal integration of visual motion signals during perceptual decision makingJ. Neurosci. 25 10420
Koch, C 1999 Biophysics of Computation: Information Processing in Single NeuronsNew York:Oxford University Press
Lindauer, M 1955 Schwarmbienen auf wohnungssucheJ. Comp. Physiol. A: Sens. Neural Behav. Physiol. 37 263
Mallon, E. BFranks, N. R 2000 Ants estimate area using Buffon's needleProc. Soc. Roy. Soc. B. Biol. Sci. 267 765
Mallon, E. BPratt, S. CFranks, N. R 2001 Individual and collective decision-making during nest site selection by the ant Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 50 352
Marshall, J. A. RBogacz, RDornhaus, A 2009
Marshall, J. A. RDornhaus, AFranks, N. RKovacs, T 2006 Noise, cost and speed-accuracy trade-offs: decision-making in a decentralized systemJ. Roy. Soc. Interface 3 243
Marshall, J. A. RFranks, N. R 2009 Colony-level cognitionCurr. Biol. 19 R395
Möglich, M 1978 Social organization of nest emigration in (Hym., Form.)Insectes Sociaux 25 205
Möglich, MHölldobler, B 1974 Social carrying behavior and division of labor during nest moving in antsPsyche 81 219
Myerscough, M. R 2003 Dancing for a decision: a matrix model for nestsite choice by honeybeesProc. Soc. Roy. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 270 577
Neyman, JPearson, E 1993 On the problem of the most efficient tests of statistical hypothesesPhil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 231 289
Nieh, J. C 1993 The stop signal of honey bees: reconsidering its messageBehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 33 51
Parker, G. AMaynard Smith, J 1990 Optimality theory in evolutionary biologyNature 348 27
Passino, KSeeley, T 2006 Modeling and analysis of nest-site selection by honeybee swarms: the speed and accuracy trade-offBehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 59 427
Passino, K. MSeeley, T. DVisscher, P. K 2008 Swarm cognition in honeybeesBehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 62 401
Planqué, RDechaume-Moncharmont, F. XFranks, N. RKovacs, TMarshall, J. A. R 2007 Why do house-hunting ants recruit in both directionsNaturwissenschaffen 94 911
Pratt, S. C 2008 Efficiency and regulation of recruitment during colony emigration by the ant Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 62 1369
Pratt, S. CMallon, E. BSumpter, D. J. TFranks, N. R 2002 Quorum sensing, recruitment, and collective decision-making during colony emigration by the ant Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 52 117
Pratt, S. CSumpter, D. J. T 2006 A tunable algorithm for collective decision-makingProc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 103 15906
Pratt, S. CSumpter, D. J. TMallon, E. BFranks, N. R 2005 An agent-based model of collective nest choice by the ant Anim. Behav. 70 1023
Ratcliff, R 1978 A theory of memory retrievalPsychol. Rev. 85 59
Ratcliff, RCherian, ASegraves, M. A 2003 A comparison of macaque behavior and superior colliculus neuronal activity to predictions from models of two choice decisionsJ. Neurophysiol. 90 1392
Ratcliff, RSmith, P. L 2004 A comparison of sequential sampling models for two-choice reaction timePsychol. Rev. 111 333
Richardson, TSleeman, PMcNamara, JHouston, A. IFranks, N. R 2007 Teaching with evaluation in antsCurr. Biol. 17 1520
Robinson, E. J. H.Franks, N. R.Ellis, SOkuda, SMarshall, J. A. R 2011 A simple threshold rule is sufficient to explain sophisticated collective decision makingPloS One 6
Robinson, E. J. H.Smith, F. D.Sullivan, K. M. EFranks, N. R 2009 2635
Roitman, J. DShadlen, M. N 2002 Response of neurons in the lateral intraparietal area during a combined visual discrimination reaction time taskJ. Neurosci. 22 9475
Schall, J. D 2001 Neural basis of deciding choosing and actingNat. Rev. Neurosci. 2 33
Seeley, T 1995 The Wisdom of the Hive: The Social Physiology of Honey Bee ColoniesCambridge, MAHarvard University Press
Seeley, T. D 1982 How honeybees find a homeSci. Amer. 247 158
Seeley, T. D 2003 Consensus building during nest-site selection in honey bee swarms: the expiration of dissentBehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 53 417
Seeley, T. DBuhrman, S. C 1999 Group decision making in swarms of honey beesBehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 45 19
Seeley, T. DBuhrman, S. C 2001 Nest-site selection in honey bees: how well do swarms implement the ‘best-of-N’ decision ruleBehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 49 416
Seeley, T. DVisscher, P. K 2004 Group decision making in nest-site selection by honey beesApidologie 35 101
Seeley, T. DVisscher, P. K 2004 Quorum sensing during nest-site selection by honeybee swarmsBehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 56 594
Shadlen, M. NNewsome, W. T 2001 Neural basis of a perceptual decision in the parietal cortex (area lip) of the rhesus monkeyJ. Neurophysiol. 86 1916
Stone, M 1960 Models for choice reaction timePsychometrika 25 251
Trimmer, P. CBogacz, RHouston, A. I 2008 Mammalian choices: combining fast-but-inaccurate and slow-but-accurate decision-making systemsProc. Soc. Roy. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 275 2353
Trimmer, P. CHouston, A. IMarshall, J. A. R 2011 Decision-making under uncertainty: biases and BayesiansAnim. Cogn.
Usher, MMcClelland, J. L 2001 The time course of perceptual choice: the leaky, competing accumulator modelPsychol. Rev. 108 550
Veeravalli, V. VBaum, C. W 1995 Asymptotic efficiency of a sequential multihypothesis testIEEE Trans. Inf. Theor. 41 1994
Visscher, P. K 2007 Group decision making in nest-site selection among social insectsAnn. Rev. Entomol. 52 255
Visscher, P. KCamazine, S 1999 Collective decisions and cognition in honeybeesNature 397 400
Visscher, P. KCamazine, S 1999 The mystery of swarming honeybees: from individual behaviours to collective decisionsInformation Processing in Social InsectsDetrain, CDeneubourg, J. LPasteels, J. MSwitzerlandBirkhäuser355
von Frisch, K 1967 The Dance Language and Orientation of BeesCambridge, MABelknap Press
Wald, AWolfowitz, J 1948 Optimum character of the sequential probability ratio testAnn. Math. Stat. 19 326
Marshall, J. A. RBogacz, RDornhaus, APlanqué, RKovacs, TFranks, N. R 2009