Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Print publication year: 2009
  • Online publication date: January 2010

49 - Appropriateness of intensive care application

from Section 6 - Assessing outcome of the brain-injured infant



Ethical questions in medicine revolve around three core topics: what needs to be decided, on what basis, and by whom. These matters are not unique to the perinatal period, nor to patients with brain injury, but both of those circumstances may have ethical implications in the decision-making process, and in combination they raise questions that are unique. Because these situations touch so many critical aspects of human existence – birth, death, personhood, parenthood, etc. – it is not surprising that ethical matters related to the perinatal period have garnered a disproportionate amount of attention in the public discourses on medical ethics, nor that brain integrity lies at the core of so many of the contentious cases. The philosophical underpinnings of medical ethics have been reviewed exhaustively in many other venues, so this discussion will focus on aspects that are unique to or uniquely framed by brain injury or dysfunction in the perinatal period.

What is to be decided?

In the lay literature, ethical dilemmas are often framed as “life-or-death” decisions, with the implication that death or survival are options to be freely selected by patients, family members, or care providers, and that the ultimate outcome is within their control. In reality, that is rarely the case. In the case of a patient whose vital signs are rapidly failing despite full application of intensive care measures, this fact is obvious and there is no (or at most a very short-lived) ethical problem.

In the matter of baby K. In: LEXIS, US App. 4th Cir., 1994.
Greenhouse, L. Court order to treat baby with partial brain prompts debate on costs and ethics. New York Times 1994 February 20; Sect. 20.
Kolata, G. Battle over a baby's future raises hard ethical issues. New York Times 1994 December 27; Sect. A1.
Hintz, SR, Kendrick, , Stoll, BJ, et al. Neurodevelopmental and growth outcomes of extremely low birth weight infants after necrotizing enterocolitis. Pediatrics 2005; 115: 696–703.
Cirak, B, Wang, P, Avellino, AM. Implications of a neurosurgical intervention in a patient with a surgically repaired hypoplastic left heart syndrome. Pediatr Neurosurg 2007; 43: 488–91.
Tabbutt, S, Nord, AS, Jarvik, GP, et al. Neurodevelopmental outcomes after staged palliation for hypoplastic left heart syndrome. Pediatrics 2008; 121: 476–83.
Davis, D, Davis, S, Cotman, K, et al. Feeding difficulties and growth delay in children with hypoplastic left heart syndrome versus d-transposition of the great arteries. Pediatr Cardiol 2008; 29: 328–33.
Schultz, AH, Wernovsky, G. Late outcomes in patients with surgically treated congenital heart disease. Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg Pediatr Card Surg Annu 2005: 145–56.
Kon, AA, Ackerson, L, Lo, B. How pediatricians counsel parents when no “best-choice” management exists: lessons to be learned from hypoplastic left heart syndrome. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2004; 158: 436–41.
Eicher, DJ, Wagner, CL, Katikaneni, LP, et al. Moderate hypothermia in neonatal encephalopathy: efficacy outcomes. Pediatr Neurol 2005; 32: 11–17.
Gluckman, PD, Wyatt, JS, Azzopardi, D, et al. Selective head cooling with mild systemic hypothermia after neonatal encephalopathy: multicentre randomised trial. Lancet 2005; 365: 663–70.
Shankaran, S, Laptook, AR, Ehrenkranz, RA, et al. Whole-body hypothermia for neonates with hypoxic–ischemic encephalopathy. N Engl J Med 2005; 353: 1574–84.
Whitelaw, A. Death as an option in neonatal intensive care. Lancet 1986; 2: 328–31.
Isaacs, D. Brain death. J Paediatr Child Health 2003; 39: 224–5.
,American Academy of Pediatrics Task Force on Brain Death in Children. Guidelines for the determination of brain death in children. Pediatrics 1987; 80: 298–300.
Volpe, JJ. Brain death determination in the newborn. Pediatrics 1987; 80: 293–7.
Ashwal, S. Brain death in the newborn: current perspectives. Clin Perinatol 1997; 24: 859–82.
Stahlman, M. Withholding and withdrawing therapy and actively hastening death. In Goldworth, A, Silverman, W, Stevenson, DK, et al., eds., Ethics and Perinatology. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 1995: 162–71.
Moseley, KL, Silveira, MJ, Goold, SD. Futility in evolution. Clin Geriatr Med 2005; 21: 211–22, x.
Morreim, EH. Profoundly diminished life: the casualties of coercion. Hastings Cent Rep 1994; 24: 33–42.
Sirico, RA. An unjust sacrifice. New York Times 2000 September 28; Sect. A31.
Dworkin, R. Life's Dominion: an Argument About Abortion, Euthanasia, and Individual Freedom. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf, 1993.
Wallis, C. The stormy legacy of Baby Doe. Time 1983 September 26.
Stevenson, DK, Ariagno, RL, Kutner, JS, et al. The “Baby Doe” rule. JAMA 1986; 255: 1909–12.
Greely, HT. Baby Doe and beyond: the past and future of government regulations in the United States. In Goldworth, A, Silverman, W, Stevenson, DK, et al., eds., Ethics and Perinatology. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 1995: 296–306.
Capron, AM. In re Helga Wanglie. Hastings Cent Rep 1991; 21: 26–8.
,League of Nations. Geneva Declaration of the Rights of the Child of 1924, adopted September 26, 1924. League of Nations OJ 1924; Spec. Supp. 21: 43.
United Nations. Declaration of the Rights of the Child, proclaimed by General Assembly resolution 1386 (XIV) of 20 November 1959.
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Behavioral Research. Deciding to Forgo Life-Sustaining Treatment. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office, 1983.
,American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Bioethics. Treatment of critically ill newborns. Pediatrics 1983; 72: 565–6.
Catlin, AJ, Stevenson, DK. Physicians' neonatal resuscitation of extremely low-birth-weight preterm infants. Image J Nurs Sch 1999; 31: 269–75.
Saigal, S, Stoskopf, B, Pinelli, J, et al. Self-perceived health-related quality of life of former extremely low birth weight infants at young adulthood. Pediatrics 2006; 118: 1140–8.
Stevenson, DK, Young, EWD. Introduction: a thematic overview. In Goldworth, A, Silverman, W, Stevenson, DK, et al., eds., Ethics and Perinatology. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 1995: 6.
,American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Fetus and Newborn. Noninitiation or withdrawal of intensive care for high-risk newborns. Pediatrics 2007; 119: 401–3.
Hardwig, J. What about the family?Hastings Cent Rep 1990; 20: 5–10.
Blustein, J. The family in medical decision making. Hastings Cent Rep 1993; 23: 6–13.
Fasouliotis, SJ, Schenker, JG. Maternal–fetal conflict. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 2000; 89: 101–7.
Nelson, LJ, Milliken, N. Compelled medical treatment of pregnant women: life, liberty, and law in conflict. JAMA 1988; 259: 1060–6.
Hume, D. Treatise of Human Nature. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1888.
Harris, J. What is the good of health care?Bioethics 1996; 10: 269–91.
Meadow, W, Lantos, JD, Mokalla, M, et al. Distributive justice across generations: epidemiology of ICU care for the very young and the very old. Clin Perinatol 1996; 23: 597–608.
Cutler, DM, Meara, E. The technology of birth: is it worth it?Forum Health Econ Policy 2000; 3: Article 3.
Antommaria, AM. “Who should survive?: one of the choices on our conscience”: mental retardation and the history of contemporary bioethics. Kennedy Inst Ethics J 2006; 16: 205–24.
Robertson, JA. Involuntary euthanasia of defective newborns: a legal analysis. Stanford Law Review 1975; 27: 213–69.
Who Should Survive? One of the Choices on Our Conscience. [Film]. Joseph, P. Kennedy Jr. Foundation, distributor, 1971.
McGehan, F. Hopkins was wrong to let infant die in '63 case, symposium decides. Baltimore Sun 1971 October 17; Sect. 20, 16.
Todres, ID, Krane, D, Howell, MC, et al. Pediatricians' attitudes affecting decision-making in defective newborns. Pediatrics 1977; 60: 197–201.
Shaw, A, Randolph, JG, Manard, B. Ethical issues in pediatric surgery: a national survey of pediatricians and pediatric surgeons. Pediatrics 1977; 60: 588–99.
Furrow, BR. Baby, K: a legal and ethical viewpoint. ASMLE Briefings 1994 (10): 1, 5.
Moreno, S. Case puts Texas futile-treatment law under a microscope. Washington Post 2007 April 11.
,Texas Futile Care Law. Texas Health & Safety Code. 1999: Chapter 166, Section 46.
Truog, RD. Tackling medical futility in Texas. N Engl J Med 2007; 357: 1–3.
Fine, RL, Mayo, TW. Resolution of futility by due process: early experience with the Texas Advance Directives Act. Ann Intern Med 2003; 138: 743–6.
Hackler, JC, Hiller, FC. Family consent to orders not resuscitate: reconsidering hospital policy. JAMA 1990; 264: 1281–3.
Rhoden, NK. Litigating life and death. Harv Law Rev 1988; 102: 375–446.
Coar, T. The Aphorisms of Hippocrates. London: Valpy, 1882.