Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 2
  • Print publication year: 2011
  • Online publication date: September 2011

9 - Pension funds as owners and as financial intermediaries

from Part II - New interests, new shareholder constellations, new landscapes


Acting like owners?

In the spring of 2007, a venerable Canadian corporation, Bell Canada Enterprises (BCE), became an acquisition target, and an acquisition agreement was subsequently signed. Until the deal was unwound on a technical valuation clause, it was the biggest proposed leveraged buyout in Canadian history: it was big news. Some of the features of this transaction were the size and nature of the target (formerly a regulated monopoly) and the identity of the primary purchaser, Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan (OTPP, an occupational pension plan for elementary and secondary school teachers). It might not have attracted much more attention – pension funds had been purchasing and controlling companies in Canada for a decade or more – but then in August 2007, about two months after the deal was made, the Canadian and then global credit markets seized up, and the General Financial Crisis (GFC), as it has come to be known, ensued. About a year later, the deal was unwound, but only after the bondholders of BCE visited the Supreme Court of Canada complaining of their treatment through the whole process.

Forgotten now are some of the more curious local aspects of this deal: OTPP (or any other pension fund) was prohibited from owning BCE – at least on paper – by Ontario pension legislation. The CEO of OTPP, a public sector union pension plan, publicly mused that it may restructure BCE, which implied tackling the unionized BCE employees. Indeed, it was said anecdotally that OTPP had a policy of not investing in businesses that sponsored defined benefit pension schemes – of which OTPP was one of the biggest in Canada. Contrary to past practice, in this deal, a major Canadian pension fund sought to own a local business, instead of purchasing, say, privatized UK utilities, far from the concerns of local pensioners.

Beebower, G.L.Bergstrom, G.L.A performance analysis of pension and profit-sharing portfolios: 1966 1977 33 Financial Analysts Journal31
Christopherson, J.A.Ferson, W.E.Glassman, D.A.Conditioning manager alphas on economic information: another look at the persistence of performance 1998 11 Review of Financial Studies111
Busse, J.Goyal, A.Wahal, S.Performance persistence in institutional investment management 2010 65 The Journal of Finance765
Lakonishok, J.Schleifer, A.Vishny, R.W.The structure and performance of the money management industry 1992 Brookings Papers on Economic Activity: Macroeconomics339
Ferson, W.Khang, K.Conditional performance measurement using portfolio weights: evidence for pension funds 2002 65 Journal of Financial Economics249
Wermers, R.Mutual fund performance: an empirical decomposition into stock-picking talent, style, transactions costs, and expenses 2000 55 The Journal of Finance1655
Berle, A.Power Without Property: A New Development in American Political EconomyNew YorkHarcourt Brace & Co. 1959
Druker, P.The Unseen Revolution: How Pension Fund Socialism Came to AmericaNew YorkHarper & Row 1976
Ambachtsheer, K.Pension Revolution: A Solution to the Pension CrisisTorontoJohn Wiley & Sons 2007
Davis, R.Democratizing Pension Funds: Corporate Governance and AccountabilityVancouverUBC Press 2006
Clark, G.Pension fund governance: expertise and organizational form 2004 3 Journal of Pension Economics and Finance233
Zanglbein, J.Public pension funds: the need for federal regulation of trustee investment decisions 1985 4 Yale Law & Policy Review188
Fogdall, S.Exclusive union control of pension funds: Taft-Hartley 2001 4 University of Pennsylvania Journal of Labor and Employment Law215
Nobles, R.Conflicts of interest in trustees 1985 14 The Industrial Law Journal1
Davis, E.P.Pension Funds, Retirement Income Security and Capital Markets: An International PerspectiveOxfordOxford University Press 1995
Richardson, B.Do the fiduciary duties of pension funds hinder socially responsible investment? 2007 22 Banking & Finance Law Review145
Hendry, J.Sanderson, P.Barker, R.Roberts, J.Responsible ownership, shareholder value and the new shareholder activism 2007 11:3 Competition and Change223
Coffee, J.Reforming the securities class action: an essay on deterrence and its implementation 2006 106 Columbia Law Review1572
Cox, J.Thomas, R.Does the plaintiff matter? An empirical analysis of lead plaintiffs in securities class actions 2006 106 Columbia Law Review1587
Smith, D.Ethical investing by union pension funds 2006 44:1 Canadian Business Law Journal158
Zanglein, J.High performance investing: harnessing the power of pension funds to promote economic growth and workplace integrity 1995 11 The Labor Lawyer59
Weitz, H.The Pension Promise, The Past and Future of Canada’s Private Pension SystemScarborough, OntarioCarswell 1992
Economic Council of CanadaOne in Three: Pensions for Canadians to 2030OttawaECC 1984
Gillese, E.Pension plans and the law of trusts 1996 Canadian Bar Review75
Bader, L.Gold, J.Perspectives: the case against stock in public pension funds 2007 63 Financial Analysts Journal55
Faccio, M.Lasfer, M.Do occupational pension funds monitor companies in which they hold large stakes? 2000 6 Journal of Corporate Finance71
Clarke, G.Best practice pension fund governance 2008 9 Journal of Asset Management2
Partnoy, F.Bookstaber, R.Infectious Greed: How Deceit and Risk Corrupted the Financial MarketsNew YorkTimes Books 2003
MacIntosh, J.Cumming, D.Crowding out private equity: Canadian evidence 2006 21 Journal of Business Venturing569
Stanford, J.Paper BoomTorontoJ. Lorimer & Co. 1999
Konings, M.Engelen, E.Morgan, G.Crouch, ColinPedersen, Ove KaiWhitley, RichardThe Oxford Handbook of Comparative Institutional AnalysisOxfordOxford University Press 2010
Bratton, W.Hedge funds and governance targets 2007 95 Georgetown Law Journal1375
Partnoy, F.Brav, A.Jiang, W.Thomas, R.Hedge fund activism, corporate governance, and firm performance 2008 63 Journal of Finance1729
Duzer, A. VanThe Law of Partnerships and CorporationsTorontoIrwin 2003
O’Sullivan, M.The expansion of the U.S. stock market, 1885 2007 8:3 Enterprise and Society489
Cumming, D.Private equity, leverage buyouts and governance 2007 13:4 Journal of Corporate Finance439
Strine, L.Toward common sense and common ground? Reflections on the shared interests of managers and labor in a more rational system of corporate governance 2007 Journal of Corporation Law