Democracy and Excellence: Concord or Conflict?, Joseph
Romance and Neil Reimer, eds., Westport CN: Praeger, 2005, 166,
pp. xiv.
This volume is the product of a question, asked by Neal Reimer, about
the relationship between democracy and excellence. Reimer provides
background for this relationship in the first chapter, noting that it can
be framed as government by the people versus standards of the good, true
and beautiful. Conflict can arise between the two ideas because democracy
prioritizes equality of citizens—but excellence depends upon the
recognition of differentiating merit. While democracy provides citizens
freedom from a limiting class structure, the lack of structure
can make citizens indifferent to pursuing a noble vision of the state.
Reimer argues, however, that there is a fundamental harmony between
democracy and excellence and that examples of excellence in democratic
societies (such as the United States) are many. It is possible and likely
that democratic societies will attain excellence in practice.