Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-t5pn6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T06:52:55.764Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Exalted Column, the Hejaz Railway and imperial legitimation in late Ottoman Haifa

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 October 2014

MICHAEL TALBOT
MICHAEL TALBOT*
Affiliation:
Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne, 17 rue de la Sorbonne, Paris, 75005, France
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

This article examines the political and social tensions of late Ottoman Haifa through the history of the Hejaz Railway and a particular monument, the ‘Exalted Column’ (Sütūn-u ʿĀlī), a monument erected in 1903 to commemorate the beginning of Ottoman construction on the Haifa railway branch. By first establishing the use of railways and railway architecture as a means of exerting state power in a comparative and local perspective, the railway structures in Haifa are analysed in the context of that city's other monumental buildings. This then leads to a discussion of the Sütūn-u ʿĀlī as a celebration of Ottoman authority and modernity, and of the developing Ottoman–German alliance. The symbolism of the column's iconography is shown to reflect a variety of problems that the Ottoman state faced in Haifa at the turn of the twentieth century.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 42 , Issue 2 , May 2015 , pp. 246 - 272
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ochsenwald, W., The Hijaz Railroad (Carlottesville, VA, 1980)Google Scholar; Tourret, R., Hedjaz Railway (Abingdon, 1989)Google Scholar; Gülsoy, U., Hicaz Demiryolu (The Hejaz Railway) (Istanbul, 1994)Google Scholar; Özyüksel, M., Hicaz Demiryolu (The Hejaz Railway) (Istanbul, 2000)Google Scholar; Nicholson, J., The Hejaz Railway (London, 2005)Google Scholar; Hülagü, M., The Hejaz Railway Based on British Sources (New York, 2010)Google Scholar; Mansour, J., Al-Khaṭṭ al-Ḥadīdī al-Ḥijāzī: Tārīkh wa-Taṭawwur Qiṭār Daraʿā-Ḥayfā (The Hejaz Railway: The History and Development of the Dara’a-Haifa Line) (Jerusalem, 2008)Google Scholar; Safran, Y. and Goren, T., ‘Ideas and plans to construct a railroad in northern Palestine in the late Ottoman Period’, Middle Eastern Studies, 46 (2010), 753–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Kreiser, K., ‘Public monuments in Turkey and Egypt, 1840–1916’, Muqarnas, 14 (1997), 103–17, at 110–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Bosworth, C.E., ‘Haifa’, in Bosworth, C.E. (ed.), Historic Cities of the Islamic World (Leiden, 2007), 149–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Carmel, A., Toldot Ḥeyfah bi-Yeme ha-Turkim (The History of Haifa in the Days of the Turks) (Haifa, 1969)Google Scholar; Seikaly, M., Ḥayfā al-ʿArabiyyah, 1918–1939: Al-Taṭawwur al-Ijtimāʿī wa-al-Iqtiṣādī (Arab Haifa, 1918–1939: Social and Economic Development) (Beirut, 1998), 25–62Google Scholar.

4 Yazbak, M., Haifa in the Late Ottoman Period, 1864–1914: A Muslim Town in Transition (Leiden, 1998), 112Google Scholar; Büssow, J., Hamidian Palestine: Politics and Society in the District of Jerusalem, 1872–1908 (Leiden, 2011), 441–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Agmon, I., Family and Court: Legal Culture and Modernity in Late Ottoman Palestine (Syracuse, NY, 2006), 18–20Google Scholar; Schattner, I., ‘Haifa: a study in the relation of city and coast’, Israel Exploration Journal, 4 (1954), 26–46Google Scholar. On the history of Acre in this period, see Philipp, T., Acre: The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian City, 1730–1831 (New York, 2001)Google Scholar; Schur, N., Toldot ʿAko (The History of Acre) (Tel Aviv, 1990), 273–306Google Scholar; Lurie, Y., ʿAko ʿIr ha-Ḥomot: Yehudim beyn ʿArvim, ʿArvim beyn Yehudim (Acre, the Walled City: Jews among Arabs, Arabs among Jews) (Tel Aviv, 2000), 94–101Google Scholar; Ghanayim, Z., Liwāʿ ʿAkkā fī ʿAhd al-Tanẓīmāt al-ʿUthmāniyyah, 1281–1337 AH / 1864–1918 CE (The District of Acre in the Ottoman Reform Period, 1281–1337 AH / 1864–1918 CE) (Beirut, 1999)Google Scholar.

5 Kark, R., ‘The rise and decline of coastal towns in Palestine’, in Gilbar, G. (ed.), Ottoman Palestine, 1800–1914 (Leiden, 1990), 69–90, at 76–80Google Scholar.

6 Pick, W.P., ‘Meissner Pasha and the construction of railways in Palestine and neighbouring countries’, in Gilbar, G. (ed.), Ottoman Palestine, 1800–1914 (Leiden, 1990), 179–218Google Scholar; Kayalı, H., Arabs and Young Turks: Ottomanism, Arabism and Islamism in the Ottoman Empire (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1997), 156–61Google Scholar.

7 Peters, R., ‘Attitudes towards modernisation in the Ottoman empire: a nineteenth-century pious text on steamships, factories and the telegraph’, Die Welt des Islams 26 (1986), 76–105Google Scholar.

8 Ibid., 94.

9 Ibid., 88.

10 Rogan, E., ‘Bringing the state back: the limits of Ottoman rule in Jordan, 1840–1910’, in Rogan, E. and Tell, T. (eds.), Village, Steppe and State: The Social Origins of Modern Jordan (London, 1994), 32–57, at 50Google Scholar; Toth, A.B., ‘Last battles of the Bedouin and the rise of modern states in Northern Arabia: 1850–1950’, in Chatty, D. (ed.), Nomadic Societies in the Middle East and North Africa: Entering the Twenty-First Century (Leiden, 2006), 49–77, at 59–63.Google Scholar

11 Landau, J.M., The Hejaz Railway and the Muslim Pilgrimage: A Case of Ottoman Political Propaganda (Detroit, 1971)Google Scholar; Norris, J., Land of Progress: Palestine in the Age of Colonial Development, 1905–1948 (Oxford, 2013), 33–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Başbakanlık Osmanlı Arşivleri (Prime Minister's Ottoman Archives, BOA), DH.MKT 2212/31, 10 Safer 1317 (19 Jun. 1899); BOA, BEO 3511/263267, 21 Safer 1327 (14 Mar. 1909).

13 ‘Ḥamīdiye Ḥicāz Demiryolu’ (‘The Hamidian Hejaz Railway’), Sālnāme-i Vilāyet-i Beyrūt (Yearbook of the Province of Beirut) (Beirut, 1326 (1908/09)), 54.

14 A. Mukhopadhyay, ‘Wheels of change? Impact of railways on colonial north Indian society, 1855–1920’, Ph.D. thesis, SOAS, University of London, 2013.

15 Kerr, I.J., ‘Representation and representations of the railways of colonial and post-colonial South Asia’, Modern Asian Studies, 37 (2003), 287–326, esp. 289–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Iqbal, I., ‘The railway in colonial India: between ideas and impacts’, in Srinivasan, R., Tiwari, M. and Silas, S. (eds.), Our Indian Railway: Themes in India's Railway History (New Delhi, 2006), 173–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ahuja, R., ‘The “bridge builders”: some notes on railways, pilgrimage and the British “civilizing mission” in colonial India’, in Fischer-Tiné, H. and Mann, M. (eds.), Colonialism as Civilizing Mission: Cultural Ideology in British India (London, 2004), 95–116Google Scholar; Makdisi, U., ‘Ottoman Orientalism’, American Historical Review, 107 (2002), 768–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Foster, M.D., ‘Haunting modernity: Tanuki, trains and transformation in Japan’, Asian Ethnology, 71 (2012), 3–29, at 10Google Scholar. See also Coaldrake, W.H., Architecture and Authority in Japan (London, 1996), 230–1Google Scholar.

18 Fahmy, A., ‘Between mystical and military: the architecture of the Hejaz Railway (1900–1918)’, in Kafescioğlu, Ç. and Thys-Şenocak, L. (eds.), Aptullah Kuran için Yazılar: Essays in Honour of Aptullah Kuran (İstanbul, 1999), 367–77, esp. 371–4Google Scholar. For an example, at Ma’an, see Servet-i Fünūn (Treasure of Knowledge), 2 Teşrin-i evvel 1321 (15 Jan. 1905), 4.

19 Burns, R., Damascus: A History (Abingdon, 2005), 258–9Google Scholar; Kuiper, K., Islamic Art, Literature and Culture (New York, 2010), 214Google Scholar.

20 Weber, S., Damascus: Modernity and Urban Transformation, 2 vols. (Aarhus, 2009), vol. I, 103–12Google Scholar.

21 Watenpaugh, H.Z., The Image of an Ottoman City: Imperial Architecture and Urban Experience in Aleppo in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries (Leiden, 2004), 41–3Google Scholar; van Leeuwen, R., Waqfs and Urban Structures: The Case of Ottoman Damascus (Leiden, 1999), especially 118–50, 178–202Google Scholar; Gerber, H., ‘The public sphere and civil society in the Ottoman empire’, in Hoexter, M., Eisenstadt, S.N. and Levtzion, N. (eds.), The Public Sphere in Muslim Societies (New York, 2002), 65–82, at 75–7Google Scholar.

22 Kana’an, R., ‘Waqf, architecture, and political self-fashioning: the construction of the Great Mosque of Jaffa by Muhammad Aga Abu Nabbut’, Muqarnas, 16 (2001), 120–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 Lemire, V., Le soif de Jérusalem: essai d’hydrohistoire (1840–1948) (Paris, 2011), 27–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Büssow, Hamidian Palestine, 496.

25 BOA, A.}AMD 29/26, 24 Rebiülevvel 1267 (27 Jan. 1851); BOA, A.}MKT.MHM 149/84. 20 Cemaziyelevvel 1275 (26 Dec. 1858); von Mülinen, E. Graf, Beiträge zur Kenntnis des Karmel (Contributions to the Knowledge of Carmel) (Leipzig, 1908), 283Google Scholar; Michael Talbot, ‘The lights of Ahmad: Al-Anwar (al-Jazzar) Mosque in Acre’, Stanbouline (2014), www.stanbouline.com.

26 Brummett, P., Image and Imperialism in the Ottoman Revolutionary Press, 1908–1911 (New York, 2000), 313Google Scholar.

27 Hansen, J., Fin de siècle Beirut: The Making of an Ottoman Provincial Capital (Oxford, 2005), 247Google Scholar.

28 Ibid., 243–7.

29 ‘Be-ʾErets ha- Ḳodesh’ (‘In the Holy Land’), Ha-Melits, 18 Sep. 1900, 3.

30 Acun, H., Anadolu Saat Kuleleri (Anatolian Clock Towers) (Ankara, 1994), 19–20Google Scholar.

31 Translated by the author. The inscription reads in full: ‘In celebration of this felicitous year of the completion of five-and-twenty [years], commemorating it with the sincere words: long live our sultan Abdülhamid. Year 1316 AH.’

32 Kushner, D., ‘The Haifa Damascus Railway: the British phase, 1890–1902’, in Farah, Caesar (ed.), Decision Making and Change in the Ottoman Empire (Kirksville, 1993), 193–213Google Scholar.

33 The Syria Ottoman Railway Company, Acre-Haifa-The Hauran-Damascus: Official Report of the Inauguration, 12 December 1892 (Beirut, 1892), 9.

34 Ibid., 11.

35 Çelik, Z., Empire, Architecture, and the City: French–Ottoman Encounters, 1830–1914 (London, 2008), 42Google Scholar.

36 Clipping from Servet-i Fünūn, 28 Teşrin-i Sânî 1318 (11 Dec. 1902), in The National Archives (TNA), FO 78/5452, fol. 148.

37 Servet-i Fünūn, 28 Teşrin-i Sânî 1318 (11 Dec. 1902), in TNA, FO, 78/5452, fol. 148.

38 Servet-i Fünūn, 1 Mayıs 1319 (14 May 1903), front page.

39 Ibid., 65.

40 Matthews, M., The Civilizing Machine: A Cultural History of Mexican Railroads, 1876–1910 (Lincoln, NE, 2014), 103–42Google Scholar; Illustrated London News, no. 1911, 11 Mar. 1876, 261; Garlick, H., The Final Curtain: State Funerals and the Theatre of Power (Atlanta, 1999), 131–67Google Scholar.

41 Wolmar, C., To the Edge of the World: The Story of the Trans-Siberian Express (London, 2013), 3Google Scholar.

42 Norris, Land of Progress, 52.

43 ‘Deutsche Eisenbahntechnik in der Türkei’ (‘German railway technology in Turkey’), Die Welt der Technik, 75 (1913), 1–2.

44 For instance Norris, Land of Progress, 2, 52; Cotterell, P., The Railways of Palestine and Israel (Abingdon, 1984), 12, Plate 12Google Scholar.

45 Servet-i Fünūn, 2 Teşrin-i evvel 1321 (15 Jan. 1905), 1; ‘Ḥamīdiye Ḥicāz Demiryolu’, 54.

46 Ibid.

47 ‘Yerushalayim’ (‘Jerusalem’), Ḥavatselet (Lilly), 4 Iyyar 5663 (1 May 1903), 1.

48 Consular Reports: Commerce, Manufactures, etc, 72:274 (Washington, 1903), 467.

49 See for instance Cotterell, Railways, 11, Plate 11.

50 Kreiser only noted an inscription in Ottoman Turkish. However, that translation seems to be based on the Arabic inscription. Kreiser, ‘Public monuments’, 110.

51 Translated by the author from the Arabic inscription on the Sütūn-u ʿĀlī.

52 Translated by the author from the Ottoman Turkish inscription on the Sütūn-u ʿĀlī.

53 Sālnāme-i Vilāyet-i Sūriye (Yearbook of the Province of Syria), vol. 11 (Damascus, 1296 (1878/89)), 93; Sālnāme-i Vilāyet-i Sūriye, vol. 12 (Damascus, 1297 (1879/80)), 194; Sālnāme-i Devlet-i ʿAliye-i ʿOsmāniye (Yearbook of the Sublime Ottoman State), vol. 46 (Istanbul, 1308 (1890/91)), 497; Sālnāme-i Devlet-i ʿAliye-i ʿOsmāniye, vol. 47 (Istanbul, 1309 (1891/92)), 524.

54 Syria Ottoman Railway Company, 9.

55 BOA, MV 7/36, 14 Rebiülahir 1303 (20 Jan. 1886); BOA, İ.MMS 82/3525, 19 Rebiülahir 1303 (25 Jan. 1886); BOA, ŞD 507/2, 4 Muharrem 1305 (22 Sep. 1887); BOA, Y.PRK.TNF 3/29, 20 Şaban 1309 (20 Mar. 1892); BOA, Y.A.HUS 257/104, 21 Şaban 1309 (21 Mar. 1892).

56 BOA, Y.MTV 61/82, 25 Ramazan 1309 (23 Apr. 1892).

57 Moscrop, J.J., Measuring Jerusalem: The Palestine Exploration Fund and British Interests in the Holy Land (London, 2000), 150–3Google Scholar.

58 BOA, İ.HUS 65/1316/S-26, 9 Safer 1316 (29 Jun. 1898); BOA, BEO 1151/86299, 14 Safer 1316 (4 Jul. 1898).

59 For an overview of Templer history in Palestine, see Carmel, A., Hityashvut ha-Germanim be-ʾErets Yiśraʾel be-Shilihé ha-Teḳufah ha-ʿOt’omanit: Beʿayoteyah ha-Medinyiot ha-Miḳomiyot ṿe-ha-Beyn-Leʾumiyot (German Settlement in the Land of Israel in the Late Ottoman Period: Political, Local, and International Issues) (Haifa, 1990)Google Scholar; Ben-’Artsi, Y., Mi-Germanyah le-ʾErets ha-Ḳodesh: Hityashvut ha-Ṭemplerim be-ʾErets Yiśraʾel (From Germany to the Holy Land: The Settlement of the Templers in the Land of Israel) (Jerusalem, 1996)Google Scholar; Yazbak, M., ‘Templars as proto-Zionists? The “German Colony” in late Ottoman Haifa’, Journal of Palestine Studies, 28 (1999), 40–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 BOA, MKT 2052/88, 30 Receb 1310 (17 Feb. 1893).

61 Shaw, W., Possessors and Possessed: Museums, Archaeology, and the Visualization of History in the Late Ottoman Empire (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 2003), 51Google Scholar.

62 BOA, DH.MKT 1351/37, 6 Ramazan 1303 (9 Jun. 1886); BOA, ŞD 2275/34, 22 Cemaziyelevvel 1304 (16 Feb. 1887); BOA, DH.MKT 1557/87, 18 Safer 1306 (24 Oct. 1888); BOA, DH.MKT 1797/128, 25 Cemaziyelevvel 1308 (7 Jan. 1891); BOA, MV 66/52, 23 Zilhicce 1308 (30 Jul. 1891); BOA, Y.MTV 53/24, 6 Muharrem 1309 (11 Aug. 1891); BOA, Y.PRK.AZJ 27/39, 2 Safer 1311 (14 Aug. 1893); BOA, İ.HUS 15/1311/S-030, 5 Safer 1311 (17 Aug. 1893).

63 BOA, DH.MKT 2055/57, 7 Şaban 1310 (24 Feb. 1893); BOA, MV 74/109, 3 Şevval 1310 (20 Apr. 1893).

64 BOA, İ.DH 1372/1317, 20 Şevval 1317 (20 Feb. 1900); BOA, BEO 1449/108603, 28 Şevval 1317 (28 Feb. 1900).

65 The 2–4–0 model never saw service on the Hejaz Railway. Cotterell, Railways, 12.

66 Büssow estimates that 10–30% of the school-age population had a basic level of literacy: Büssow, Hamidian Palestine, 460. See also Somel, S.A., The Modernisation of Public Education in the Ottoman Empire, 1839–1908: Islamization, Autocracy and Discipline (Leiden, 2001)Google Scholar.

67 See Fortna, B., Imperial Classroom: Islam, the State and Education in the Late Ottoman Empire (Oxford, 2002)Google Scholar.

68 Sālnāme-i Neẓāret-i Maʿārif-i ʿUmūmiye, 4 (Istanbul 1319 (1901/02)), 508–9.

69 Ibid. The villages listed are: Ijzim, Kafr Lām, Qisāriyyah, ʿArʿarah, ʿAyn Ghazāl, Jabaʿa, Balad al-Shaykh, Furaydis, al-Rihāniyyah, Umm al-Zīnāt, al-Kafrayn, ʿAyn Ḥawḍ, ʿAtlīt, al-Ṭanṭūrah, Buraykah, Bāqah al-Sharqiyah, Dāliyat al-Karmal and ʿIsifiyyā.

70 Ibid., 488–90. The provincial average is taken from the male and non-military rüşdiye schools in the districts of Saida, Sour, Haifa, Nazareth, Safed, Tiberias, Jenin, Jableh, Marqab and Sahyoun.

71 Ibid., 487.

72 Ibid., 475–6, 492–3.

73 Ibid., 494–5.

74 On population, see Yazbak, Haifa in the Late Ottoman Period, 89–111; McCarthy, J., ‘The population of Ottoman Syria and Iraq, 1878–1914’, Asian and African Studies, 15 (1981), 3–44Google Scholar; McCarthy, J., Population History of the Middle East and Balkans (Istanbul, 2002), 172–210.Google Scholar