No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
English Convents in Eighteenth-Century Travel Literature*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 January 2016
Extract
‘A Nun’s dress is a very becoming one’, wrote Cornelius Cayley in 1772. Similarly, Philip Thicknesse, witnessing the clothing ceremony at the English Augustinian convent in Paris, observed that the nun’s dress was ‘quite white, and no ways unbecoming … [it] did not render her in my eyes, a whit less proper for the affections of the world’. This tendency to objectify nuns by focusing on the mysterious and sexualized aspects of conventual life was a key feature of eighteenth-century British culture. Novels, poems and polemic dwelt on the theme of the forced vocation, culminating in the dramatic portrayals of immured nuns in the Gothic novels of the 1790s. The convent was portrayed as inherently despotic, its unnatural hierarchy and silent culture directly opposed to the sociability which, in Enlightenment thought, defined a civilized society. This despotic climate was one aspect of a culture of tyranny and constraint, which rendered nuns either innocent and victimized or complicit and immoral. Historians have noted that these stereotypes were remarkably similar to those applied to the Orient and have thus extended Said’s notion of ‘otherness’ - the self-affirmation of a dominant culture as a norm from which other cultures deviate – to apply not merely to oriental cultures but to those aspects of European culture deemed exotic. In so doing, they have challenged the notion that travel writing was an exact record of social experience and have initiated a more nuanced understanding of textual convention and authorial experience. For historians of eighteenth-century Britain this has led to an examination of the construction of anti-Catholicism within travel literature and its use as an ideology around which the Protestant nation could unite. Thus, Jeremy Black has noted that anti-Catholicism remained the ‘prime ideological stance in Britain’ and has claimed that encounters with Catholicism by British travellers in France ‘excited fear or unease … and, at times, humour or ridicule’. Likewise, Bryan Dolan and Christopher Hibbert have seen encounters with continental convents culminating in negative descriptions of rituals, relics and enclosed space.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2012
Footnotes
*
I am grateful to the Arts and Humanities Research Council for funding this research and to David Allan and Michael Questier for their comments.
References
1 Cayley, Cornelius, A Tour Through Holland, Flanders and Part of France in the year 1772 (Leeds, 1773), 56.Google Scholar
2 Thicknesse, Philip, Useful Hints to Those who make the tour of France in a Series of Letters Written from that Kingdom (London, 1768), 48.Google Scholar
3 See, e.g., Anon, ., The Cloisters Laid Open (London, 1770).Google Scholar
4 E.g. Lewis, Matthew, The Monk (London, 1790)Google Scholar; Radcliffe, Ann, The Mysteries of Udolpho (London, 1794).Google Scholar
5 Said, Edward, Orientalism (London, 1978)Google Scholar. For Said, Orientalism constituted a collection of false assumptions underlying Western attitudes towards the East. These assumptions were in direct contrast to the West’s view of itself. For instance, the notion that the East was feminine, irrational and weak contrasted with the West’s portrayal of itself as masculine, strong and rational. Chard, Chloe, Pleasure and Guilt on the Grand Tour (kManchester, 1998)Google Scholar, has extended this idea to Protestant portrayals of Catholic countries as irrational, idolatrous and autocratic.
6 Black, Jeremy, The Grand Tour in the Eighteenth Century (Gloucester, 1992)Google Scholar. This argument builds on that put forward by Colley, Linda, Britons: Forging the Nation, 1707–1837 (London, 1994).Google Scholar
7 Black, Jeremy, France and the Grand Tour (Basingstoke, 2003), 159–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8 Dolan, Brian, Ladies of the Grand Tour (London, 2001), 169–70 Google Scholar; Hibbert, Christopher, The Grand Tour (London, 1989), 121–32.Google Scholar
9 English convents had been founded in exile on the Continent at the beginning of the seventeenth century. There were twenty-one in France and Flanders.
10 Claydon, Tony, Europe and the Making of England, 1660–1760 (Cambridge, 2007), 62.Google Scholar
11 Ibid. 18–20.
12 Pratt, Mary Louise, Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation (New York, 1992)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Morin, Karin M. and Gueske, Jeanne K., ‘Strategies of Representation, Relationship and Resistance: British Women Travellers and Mormon Plural Wives’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers 88 (1998), 436–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
13 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 2.Google Scholar
14 Cayley, , Tour, iii–iv.Google Scholar
15 Shaw, Joseph, Letters to a Nobleman from a Gentleman Travelling thro’ Holland, Flanders and France (London, 1709), xiii Google Scholar; Stephens, Sacheverell, Miscellaneous Remarks made on the Spot in a Late Seven Years Tour through France, Italy, Germany and Holland (London, 1756).Google Scholar
16 Ayscough, George Edward, Letters from an Officer in the Guards to his friend in England: Containing some Account of France and Italy (London, 1778), 2.Google Scholar
17 Anon, ., A Tour Through Part of France and Flanders (London, 1768), vii.Google Scholar
18 A. R., Travels into France and Italy in a series of Letters to a Lady (London, 1771), 2.Google Scholar
19 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 73 (Letter VII).Google Scholar
20 Ibid. 95 (Letter VIII).
21 Ayscough, , Letters from an Officer, 5–10.Google Scholar
22 Cayley, , Tour, 13.Google Scholar
23 Stevens, , Miscellaneous Remarks, 6.Google Scholar
24 Shaw, , Letters to a Nobleman, xiii.Google Scholar
25 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 6–9 Google Scholar; A. R., Letters to a Lady, 44–8.Google Scholar
26 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 52.Google Scholar
27 Ibid.
28 A. R., Letters to a Lady, 21.Google Scholar
29 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 12–16.Google Scholar
30 Cayley, , Tour, 22 Google Scholar; Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, xxix.Google Scholar
31 Ayscough, , Letters from an Officer, 39.Google Scholar
32 Cayley, , Tour, 29.Google Scholar
33 A. R., Letters to a Lady, 125.Google Scholar
34 Stevens, , Miscellaneous Remarks, 17–19.Google Scholar
35 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 32–9.Google Scholar
36 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 118.Google Scholar
37 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 38.Google Scholar
38 Ibid. 121.
39 Ibid. 122–8.
40 Cayley, , Tour, 51–4.Google Scholar
41 Ibid. 54.
42 Stevens, , Miscellaneous Remarks, 321.Google Scholar
43 Ayscough, , Letters from an Officer, 212.Google Scholar
44 A. R., Letters to a Lady, 109.Google Scholar
45 The English convents in exile referred to themselves as English subjects but their membership was composed of English, Welsh and Irish women. Scottish women seem to have joined French convents.
46 Ibid. 110.
47 Anon, ., Tour Tltrough Part of France and Flanders, 32–3 Google Scholar; Stevens, , Miscellaneous Remarks, 318.Google Scholar
48 Shaw, , Letters to a Nobleman, vii, 75 Google Scholar; Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 102.Google Scholar
49 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 21.Google Scholar
50 Winchester, Hampshire Record Office, MS Banbury, 1M44/110/81: Letter of William Knollis to Mary Knollis, 20–23 January 1794.
51 Ayscough, , Letters from an Officer, 9 Google Scholar; Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 49.Google Scholar
52 Ayscough, , Letters from an Officer, 9.Google Scholar
53 Anon, , Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 7.Google Scholar
54 Ibid. 21.
55 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, xvii.Google Scholar
56 Ibid.
57 Shaw, , Letters to a Nobleman, xviii.Google Scholar
58 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 5 Google Scholar; Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 17.Google Scholar
59 A. R., Letters to a Lady, 4.Google Scholar
60 Anon, ., Tour Through Part of France and Flanders, 16.Google Scholar
61 Ibid. 9–10.
62 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 125.Google Scholar
63 Ibid. 31.
64 Ibid. 12.
65 A. R., Letters to a Lady, 17–19.Google Scholar
66 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 18–22.Google Scholar
67 Shaw, , Letters to a Nobleman, xiv.Google Scholar
68 Knox, Vicesimus, On the Manner of Writing Voyages and Travels (London, 1778), 432–8.Google Scholar
69 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 122 Google Scholar; Shaw, , Letters to a Nobleman, 229.Google Scholar
70 Cayley, , Tour, 1–10.Google Scholar
71 Ibid. 99–100.
72 A. R., Letters to a Lady, 71–3.Google Scholar
73 Stevens, , Miscellaneous Remarks, 6.Google Scholar
74 Thicknesse, , Useful Hints, 161–2.Google Scholar
75 Ward, B., The Dawn of the Catholic Revival in England 1781–1803, 2 vols (London, 1909), 2: 165 Google Scholar; Matthew, D., Catholicism in England 1535–1935: Portrait of a Minority; its Culture and Tradition (London, 1936), 101–10 Google Scholar; Ryan, R., The Romantic Reformations: Religion and Politics in English Literature (Cambridge, 1997), 23.Google Scholar