Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-mp689 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T11:41:41.458Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The power-trust cycle in global health: Trust as belonging in relations of dependency

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 July 2021

Emma-Louise Anderson Open the ORCID record for Emma-Louise Anderson [Opens in a new window] ,
Laura Considine  and
Amy S. Patterson Open the ORCID record for Amy S. Patterson [Opens in a new window]
Emma-Louise Anderson*
Affiliation:
School of Politics and International Studies (POLIS), University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom
Laura Considine
Affiliation:
School of Politics and International Studies (POLIS), University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom
Amy S. Patterson
Affiliation:
Department of Politics, University of the South, Tennessee, United States
*
*Corresponding author. Email: E.L.Anderson@leeds.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Trust between actors is vital to delivering positive health outcomes, while relationships of power determine health agendas, whose voices are heard and who benefits from global health initiatives. However, the relationship between trust and power has been neglected in the literatures on both international politics and global health. We examine this relationship through a study of relations between faith based organisations (FBO) and donors in Malawi and Zambia, drawing on 66 key informant interviews with actors central to delivering health care. From these two cases we develop an understanding of ‘trust as belonging’, which we define as the exercise of discretion accompanied by the expression of shared identities. Trust as belonging interacts with power in what we term the ‘power-trust cycle’, in which various forms of power undergird trust, and trust augments these forms of power. The power-trust cycle has a critical bearing on global health outcomes, affecting the space within which both local and international actors jockey to influence the ideologies that underpin global health, and the distribution of crucial resources. We illustrate how the power-trust cycle can work in both positive and negative ways to affect possible cooperation, with significant implications for collective responses to global health challenges.

Keywords

Global HealthHealth DiplomacyPowerTrustDependencyAfricaMalawiZambia
Type
Research Article
Information
Review of International Studies , Volume 47 , Issue 4 , October 2021 , pp. 422 - 442
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the British International Studies Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Patterson, Amy, Africa and Global Health Governance (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2018)Google Scholar; Richards, Paul, Mokuwa, Esther, Welmers, Pleun, Maat, Harro, and Beisel, Ulrike, ‘Trust, and distrust, of Ebola Treatment Centers’, PloS One, 14:12 (2019), e022451CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

2 Crane, Johanna, Scrambling for Africa: AIDS, Expertise and the Rise of American Health Science (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Graboyes, Melissa, The Experiment Must Continue (Athens, OH: Ohio University, 2015)Google Scholar.

3 Möllering, Guido, ‘Connecting trust and power’, Journal of Trust Research, 9:1 (2019), pp. 1–5 (p. 1)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; see Bachmann, Reinhard, ‘Trust, power and control in trans-organizational relations’, Organization Studies, 22:2 (2001), pp. 337–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gilson, Lucy, ‘Trust and the development of health care as a social institution’, Social Science and Medicine, 56 (2003), pp. 1453–68CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

4 Moon, Suerie, ‘Power in global governance’, Global Health, 15:74 (2019), p. 6Google ScholarPubMed; Sriram, Veena, Topp, Stephanie M., Schaaf, Marta, Mishra, Arima, Flores, Walter, Rajasulochana, Subramania Raju, and Scott, Kerry, ‘10 best resources on power in health policy and systems in low- and middle-income countries’, Health Policy and Planning, 33 (2018), pp. 611–21CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Shiffman, Jeremy, ‘Knowledge, moral claims and the exercise of power in global health’, International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 3:6 (2014), pp. 297–9CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

5 Pfeiffer, James, ‘International NGOs and primary health care in Mozambique’, Social Science & Medicine, 56:4 (2003), pp. 725–38 (pp. 735–6)CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

6 Anderson, Emma-Louise and Patterson, Amy, Dependent Agency in the Global Health Regime (Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave MacMillan, 2016)Google Scholar; Clapp, Jennifer, ‘Africa, NGOs, and the international toxic waste trade’, Journal of Environment and Development, 3:2 (1994), pp. 17–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Katz, Rebecca, Kornblet, Sarah, Arnold, Grace, Lief, Eric, and Fischer, Julie, ‘Defining health diplomacy’, Milbank Quarterly, 89:3 (2011), pp. 503–23CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Kickbusch, Iona, Silberschmidt, Gaudenz, and Buss, Paulo, Global Health Diplomacy (Geneva: WHO, 2008)Google Scholar; Kickbusch, Ilona and Kökény, Mihály, ‘Global health diplomacy’, Bulletin of the WHO, 91:3 (2013), p. 159Google ScholarPubMed.

8 Lipsky, Alyson, ‘Evaluating the strength of faith’, Public Administration and Development, 31:1 (2011), pp. 25–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Patterson, Amy, The Church and AIDS in Africa (Boulder, CO: First Forum Press, 2011)Google Scholar.

10 Barnett, Michael and Duvall, Raymond, ‘Power in international politics’, International Organization, 59:1 (2005), pp. 39–75 (p. 41)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Ibid., p. 42.

12 Andrews, Matt, Pritchett, Lant, and Woolcock, Michael, Building State Capability (London, UK: Oxford University Press, 2017), p. 288CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Gore, Radhika and Parker, Richard, ‘Analysing power and politics in health policies and systems’, Global Public Health, 14 (2019), pp. 481–8CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Scott, James, Weapons of the Weak (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1985)Google Scholar.

14 Exceptions include Michel, Torsten, ‘Time to get emotional’, European Journal of International Relations, 19:4 (2012), pp. 869–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Fierke, Karen, ‘Terrorism and trust in Northern Ireland’, Critical Studies on Terrorism, 2:3 (2009), pp. 497–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Considine, Laura, ‘Back to the rough ground!’ A grammatical approach to trust and international relations’, Millennium, 40:4 (2015), pp. 109–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Booth, Ken and Wheeler, Nicholas, The Security Dilemma (Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008), p. 231Google Scholar. See also Keating, Vincent and Ruzicka, Jan, ‘Trusting relationships in international politics’, Review of International Studies, 40:4 (2014), p. 755CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rathbun, Brian, Trust in International Cooperation (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2012), p. 6Google Scholar.

16 Michel, ‘Time to get emotional’, p. 884.

17 Rathbun, Brian, ‘It takes all types: Social psychology, trust, and the international relations paradigm in our minds’, International Theory, 1:3 (2009), pp. 345–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Luhman, Niklas, Trust and Power (New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons, 1979)Google Scholar.

19 Torsten Michel, ‘Trust, rationality and vulnerability in international relations’, in Amanda Beattie and Kate Schick (eds), The Vulnerable Subject (London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013), pp. 86–109 (p. 98).

20 Brian Rathbun, ‘Before hegemony: Generalized trust and the creation and design of international security organizations’, International Organization, 65:2 (2011), pp. 243–73.

21 Booth and Wheeler, The Security Dilemma.

22 Jan Ruzicka and Vincent Keating, ‘Going global: Trust research and international relations’, Journal of Trust Research, 5 (2015), p. 3.

23 Andrew Kydd, ‘Trust building, trust breaking’, International Organization, 55:4 (2001), p. 810.

24 Nicholas Wheeler, ‘Beyond Waltz's nuclear world: More trust may be better’, International Relations, 23:3 (2009), pp. 428–45.

25 Booth and Wheeler, The Security Dilemma; Andrew Kydd, Trust and Mistrust in International Relations (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2005); Nicholas Wheeler, ‘Investigating diplomatic transformations’, International Affairs, 89:2 (2013), pp. 477–96.

26 Aaron Hoffman, ‘A conceptualization of trust in international relations’, European Journal of International Relations, 8:3 (2002), pp. 375–401.

27 Vincent Keating and Jan Ruzicka, ‘Trusting relationships in international politics’, Review of International Studies, 40:4 (2014), pp. 753–70.

28 Cynthia Hardy, Nelson Phillips, and Thomas Lawrence, ‘Distinguishing trust and power in inter-organizational relations’, in Christel Lane and Reinhard Bachmann (eds), Trust Within and Between Organizations (Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 1998), pp. 64–87; Bachmann, ‘Trust, power and control’.

29 Michel, ‘Time to get emotional’.

30 Kydd, Trust and Mistrust; Andrew Kydd, ‘Trust, reassurance, and cooperation’, International Organization, 54:2 (2002), pp. 325–57.

31 Booth and Wheeler, The Security Dilemma.

32 Hoffman, ‘A conceptualization of trust’, p. 381.

33 See Bernd Lahno, ‘On the emotional character of trust’, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, 4:2 (2001), pp. 171–89; Nicholas Wheeler, Trusting Enemies (Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2018); Jonathan Mercer, ‘Rationality and psychology in international relations’, International Organization, 59:1 (2005), pp. 77–106; Michel, ‘Trust, rationality and vulnerability’; Eric Uslaner, The Moral Foundations of Trust (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2002).

34 Nicholas Rengger, ‘The ethics of trust in world politics’, International Affairs, 73:3 (1997), p. 472. Rengger develops this definition from Annette Baier. Rengger uses ‘discretionary power’, which we amend here to avoid confusion with our uses of power.

35 Ibid., p. 472; Michel, ‘Trust, rationality and vulnerability’, p. 93.

36 Hoffman, ‘A conceptualization of trust’.

37 Clara Weinhardt, ‘Relational trust in international cooperation’, Journal of Trust Research, 5:1 (2015), p. 32.

38 Hoffman, ‘A conceptualization of trust’, p. 384.

39 Mercer, ‘Rationality and psychology'; Uslaner, The Moral Foundations of Trust; J. David Lewis and Andrew Weigert, ‘Trust as a social reality’, Social Forces, 63 (1985), pp. 967–85.

40 Robert F. Hurley, Decision to Trust (San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 2011), p. 57.

41 Dorothea Hillhorst, The Real World of NGOs (London, UK: ZED, 2003), p. 31.

42 Weinhardt, ‘Relational trust’, p. 32.

43 Ibid., p. 34.

44 Nicholas Wheeler, ‘To put oneself into the other fellow's place’, International Relations, 22:1 (2008), pp. 493–509; also Wheeler, Trusting Enemies.

45 Rengger, ‘The ethics of trust’, p. 481.

46 Sriram et al., ‘10 best resources on power’, p. 612; David McCoy and Guddi Singh, ‘A spanner in the works? Anti-politics in global health policy’, International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 3:3 (2015), pp. 151–3.

47 Kabir Sheikh, Lucy Gilson, Irene Akua Agyepong, Kara Hanson, Freddie Ssengooba, and Sara Bennett, ‘Building the field of health policy and systems research’, PLoS Med, 8:8 (2011), e1001073.

48 Pfeiffer, ‘International NGOs and primary health care’, p. 735; Craig Janes, and Kitty Corbett, ‘Anthropology and global health’, Annual Review of Anthropology, 38 (2009), pp. 167–83; Katerini Storeng, and Arima Mishra, ‘Politics and practices of global health’, Global Public Health, 9:8 (2014), pp. 858–64; James Pfeiffer and Mimi Nichter, ‘What can critical medical anthropology contribute to global health?’, Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 22:4 (2008), pp. 410–15.

49 Moon, ‘Power in global governance’, p. 8.

50 Barnett and Duvall, ‘Power in international politics’.

51 See Rita Jalali, ‘Financing empowerment?’, Sociology Compass, 7:1 (2013), pp. 55–73.

52 Stephen Ellis, Season of Rains (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2011), pp. 6, 33.

53 James Scott, Domination and the Arts of Resistance (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1990), p. 9.

54 Ibid.; Anderson and Patterson, Dependent Agency.

55 Barnett and Duvall, ‘Power in international politics’, p. 43.

56 Stephen Lukes, Power: A Radical View (London, UK: Macmillan, 1974), p. 24; Barnett and Duvall, ‘Power in international politics’, pp. 55–6.

57 Moon, ‘Power in global governance’, p. 6; Kent Buse and Sarah Hawkes, ‘Health post 2015’, Lancet, 383 (2014), pp. 678–9.

58 Moon, ‘Power in global governance’, p. 6.

59 Emma-Louise Anderson, ‘African health diplomacy’, International Relations, 32:2 (2018), pp. 194–217; Graham Harrison, ‘Post-conditionality politics and administrative reform’, Development and Change, 32:4 (2001), pp. 657–79.

60 Martin Carstensen and Vivien Schmidt, ‘Power through, over and in ideas’, Journal of European Public Policy, 23:3 (2016), pp. 318–37 (pp. 320–1).

61 Eduard Grebe, ‘The Treatment Action Campaign's struggle for AIDS treatment in South Africa’, Journal of Southern African Studies, 37:4 (2011), pp. 849–68.

62 Rita Abrahamsen, ‘The power of partnerships in global governance’, Third World Quarterly, 25:8 (2004), pp. 1453–67 (p. 1459).

63 Ibid., p. 1462.

64 Barnett and Duvall, ‘Power in international politics’, p. 55.

65 Simon Rushton and Owain Williams, ‘Frames, paradigms and power’, Global Society, 26:2 (2012), pp. 147–67; Lisa Forman, ‘The ghost is the machine’, International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 5:3 (2015), pp. 197–9.

66 James Ferguson, ‘The uses of neoliberalism’, Antipode, 41 (2010), pp. 166–84 (p. 173).

67 Séverine Autesserre, Peaceland (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2014).

68 Arturo Escobar, Encountering Development (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1995); Andrea Cornwall and Karen Brock, ‘What do buzzwords do for development policy?’, Third World Quarterly, 26:7 (2005), pp. 1043–60.

69 Moon, ‘Power in global governance’, p. 6.

70 Ferguson, ‘The uses of neoliberalism’, p. 173.

71 John Meyer, John Boli, George Thomas, and Francisco Ramirez, ‘World society and the nation-state’, American Journal of Sociology, 103:1 (1997), pp. 144–81.

72 Anderson, ‘Shadow diplomacy’; Anderson and Patterson, Dependent Agency; Jeremy Shiffman, ‘Agency, structure and the power of global health networks’, International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 7:10 (2018), pp. 79–84; Scott, Weapons of the Weak.

73 Bornstein, Erica, The Spirit of Development (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2005), p. 2Google Scholar.

74 Canaan, Ram, The Newer Deal (New York, NY: Columbia University Press, 1999), p. 300Google Scholar.

75 Stephen Ellis and Gerrie Ter Haar, ‘Religion and politics in sub-Saharan Africa’, Journal of Modern African Studies, 36:2 (1998), pp. 175–201 (p. 195).

76 Moon, ‘Power in global governance’, p. 6; Shiffman, ‘Knowledge, moral claims and the exercise of power’; Kelley Lee, ‘Revealing power in truth’, International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 4:4 (2015), pp. 257–9.

77 Haas, Peter, ‘Epistemic communities and international policy coordination’, International Organization, 46:1 (1992), pp. 1–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

78 Grépin, Karen, ‘Power and priorities’, International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 4:5 (2015), pp. 321–2CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Rushton, Simon, ‘The politics of researching global health politics’, International Health Policy and Management, 4:5 (2015), pp. 311–14CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

79 Youde, Jeremy, AIDS, South Africa, and the Politics of Knowledge (London, UK: Routledge, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

80 Moon, ‘Power in global governance’, p. 6.

81 Rushton, ‘The politics of researching’.

82 Patterson, Church and AIDS in Africa; Jeffrey Haynes, Religion and Development (Basingstoke, UK: Springer, 2007).

83 Shiffman, ‘Knowledge, moral claims and the exercise of power’.

84 Moon, ‘Power in global governance’, p. 6.

85 Ibid., pp. 6–7; Pierre Bourdieu, ‘The forms of capital’, Mark Granovetter and Richard Swedberg (eds), The Sociology of Economic Life (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 2018); Johanna Hanefeld and Gill Walt, ‘Knowledge and networks’, International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 4:2 (2015), pp. 119–21.

86 CHAZ, ‘About Us’ (2018), available at: {http://www.chaz.org.zm/about-chaz}; CHAM, ‘Our Impact’ (2017), available at: {http://www.cham.org.mw/our-impact.html}.

87 Susan Watkins and Ann Swidler, ‘Working misunderstandings’, Population and Development Review, 38:Suppl. (2013), pp. 197–208 (p. 199).

88 Government of Malawi, ‘Health Sector Resource Mapping’, FY2017/18-2019/20 (2020), p. 15, available at: {http://www.health.gov.mw/index.php/reports?download=54:resource-mapping-round-5}.

89 Health Policy Project, ‘Health Financing Profile: Zambia’ (May 2016), available at: {https://www.healthpolicyproject.com/pubs/7887/Zambia_HFP.pdf}.

90 CHAM, ‘Annual Report’ (2015), p. 48, available at:

{http://www.cham.org.mw/uploads/7/3/0/8/73088105/annual_report_final_2015_opt.pdf}; Christopher Simoonga and Karen Sichinga, ‘Zambian Case Study: Key Lessons on PPP between CHAZ and MoH’, presentation in Washington, DC (7–9 July 2015), available at: {https://slideplayer.com/slide/11775667}.

91 See Anne Mills, ‘Health policy and systems research’, Health Policy and Planning, 27:1 (2011), pp. 1–7 (p. 6).

92 Friederike Welter and Alex Nadezhda, ‘Researching trust in different cultures’, in Fergus Lyon, Guido Möllering, and Mark Saunders (eds), Handbook of Research Methods on Trust (Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2015), pp. 75–85 (p. 81).

93 Mark Saunders, ‘Using mixed methods’, in Lyon, Möllering, and Saunders (eds), Handbook of Research Methods on Trust, pp. 134–44 (p. 135).

94 The authors’ home institutions provided ethical clearance.

95 In 2011, 81 per cent of CHAZ's annual income came from donors and in 2018, 90 per cent. CHAZ, ‘2018 Annual Report’ (2018), p. 36, available at: {https://www.chaz.org.zm/download/annual-report-2018/?wpdmdl=1870&refresh=5d74f70d32a4b1567946509}; CHAZ, ‘2011 Annual Report’ (2011), p. 6, available at: {https://www.chaz.org.zm/download/annual-report-2011/?wpdmdl=822&refresh=5f0ce8d7e8fe41594681559}.

96 ‘A discussion with Karen Sichinga, Executive Director of Churches Health Association of Zambia’, interview published online, Berkley Center for Religion, Peace and World Affairs, Georgetown University, Washington, DC (14 February 2014), available at: {https://berkleycenter.georgetown.edu/interviews/a-discussion-with-karen-sichinga-executive-director-churches-health-association-of-zambia}.

97 CRS and AIDSRelief, ‘The AIDSRelief Zambia Partnership: Transitioning to the Churches Health Association of Zambia’ (2012), available at: {https://www.crs.org/sites/default/files/tools-research/aidsrelief-zambia-partnership-transitioning-churches-health-association-zambia.pdf}.

98 CHAZ, ‘2018 Annual Report’, p. 36; CHAZ, ‘2011 Annual Report’, p. 6; CHAZ, ‘2013 Annual Report’ (2013), p. 35, available at: {https://www.chaz.org.zm/download/annual-report-2013/?wpdmdl=825&refresh=5f0cea676ab8d1594681959}.

99 CHAZ, ‘2018 Annual Report’, p. 11.

100 Global Fund, ‘Partner Investments’, dataset (2019), available at: {https://data.theglobalfund.org/partners/ZMB}.

101 CHAZ, ‘Strategic Plan 2017–2021’ (2017), available at: {https://www.chaz.org.zm/download/chaz-strategic-plan-2017-2021/?wpdmdl=805&refresh=5f0ca20d4fb531594663437}.

102 In 2015, 97 per cent of CHAM's operating budget came from donors. CHAM, ‘Annual Report’ (2015), p. 547.

103 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

104 CHAM, ‘Strategic Plan 2015–2019’ (2015), p. 6, available at: {http://www.cham.org.mw/uploads/7/3/0/8/73088105/cham_strategic_plan_7-2-15__1___1_.pdf}; Authors’ interview with CHAM official.

105 Bayart, Jean-François, ‘Africa in the world’, trans. Stephen Ellis, African Affairs, 99:395 (2000), pp. 217–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

106 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

107 Möllering, Guido, Trust: Reason, Routine, Reflexivity (Oxford, UK: Elsevier, 2006)Google Scholar.

108 Rengger, ‘Ethics of trust’, p. 481.

109 Ferguson, James, Global Shadows (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2010)Google Scholar.

110 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

111 Authors’ interview with Expanded Church Response official, Lusaka, 17 August 2007; Authors’ interview with Christian Council of Zambia official, Lusaka, 25 February 2011.

112 Patterson, Church and AIDS in Africa.

113 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

114 Authors’ interview with CHAZ official, Lusaka, 16 August 2007.

115 Government of Malawi, ‘Health Sector Strategic Plan (2011–2016)’, p. 30, available at: {https://www.health.gov.mw/index.php/policies-strategies?download=14:malawi-health-sector-strategic-plan-2011-2016}.

116 CHAM, ‘Strategic Plan 2015–2019’, p. 7.

117 CHAM-CDC, ‘HIV/AIDS Project 2015–2019’, available at: {http://www.cham.org.mw/cham-cdc-hivaids-partnership.html}.

118 CHAZ, ‘2017–2021 Strategic Plan’.

119 Patrick Kyalo and Doris Mwarey, ‘Looking Back and Encouraged to Press on for the Health Workforce in Africa’ (13 April 2015), available at: {https://imaworldhealth.org/looking-back-and-encouraged-to-press-on-for-the-health-workforce-in-africa}.

120 For a critique, see Amy Barnes, Garrett Brown, and Sophie Harman, Global Politics of Health Reform in Africa (Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 2015); Anderson, ‘African health diplomacy’, pp. 199–200.

121 Brass, Jennifer, Allies or Adversaries: NGOs and the State in Africa (London, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

122 Authors’ interviews with: NAC official, Lusaka, 12 August 2007; international donor, Lusaka, 23 February 2011; DfID official, Lusaka, 15 August 2007; US Embassy official, Lusaka, 13 August 2007; international FBO official, Lusaka, 31 March 2011; CHAZ official, Lusaka, 13 April 2009. Simoonga and Sichinga, ‘Zambian Case Study’; CHAZ, ‘2018 Annual Report’.

123 Authors’ interview with US embassy official, Lusaka, 13 August 2007.

124 CHAZ, ‘2013 Annual Report’.

125 Amy Patterson, ‘Christianity and democracy’, in Gabrielle Lynch and Peter VonDoepp (eds), The Routledge Handbook of Democratization in Africa (London, UK: Routledge, 2019), pp. 275–87.

126 CHAZ, ‘Strategic Plan 2017–2021’.

127 Ferguson, James, The Anti-Politics Machine (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1990)Google Scholar.

128 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

129 Authors’ interview with independent consultant on health and development, Lilongwe, 29 June 2014.

130 Authors’ interview with independent consultant on health and development, Lilongwe, 29 June 2014. See Chimwemwe Mangazi, ‘CHAM medics to go on strike’, Capital Radio Malawi (2 January 2015); Pot, Hanneke, de Kok, Bregje, and Finyiza, Gertrude, ‘When things fall apart’, Reproductive Health Matters, 26:54 (2018), pp. 126–36 (p. 129)CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

131 Authors’ interview with independent consultant on health and development, Lilongwe, 29 June 2014.

132 VonDoepp, Peter, ‘Resisting democratic backsliding’, African Studies Review, 63:4 (2019), pp. 1–25Google Scholar.

133 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

134 Ibid.; CHAM, ‘Strategic Plan 2015–2019’, p. 6.

135 CHAM, ‘Strategic Plan 2015–2019’, p. 9.

136 Ibid., pp. 91, 96.

137 Ibid., p. v.

138 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

139 CHAZ, ‘2018 Annual Report’, pp. 7, 9.

140 CHAZ, ‘2017 Annual Report’, pp. 9, 17.

141 Authors' interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

142 Norad, ‘Report 4/2017 Country Evaluation Brief: Malawi’, Chr. Michelsen Institute, Oslo (June 2017), p. 12, available at: {https://norad.no/globalassets/publikasjoner/publikasjoner-2017/evaluering/4.17-country-evaluation-brief_malawi.pdf}; ‘Cashgate- Malawi's murky tale of shooting and corruption’, BBC News (27 January 2014), available at: {https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-25912652}; Authors’ interview with donor official, Lilongwe, 26 June 2014; Radha Adhikari, Jeevan Raj Sharma, Pam Smith, and Address Malata, ‘Foreign aid, Cashgate and trusting relationships amongst stakeholders’, Health Policy and Planning, 34:3 (2019), pp. 197–206 (pp. 200–02).

143 Authors' interviews with: international donors, Lilongwe, 26 June 2014, 4 July 2014, 9 July 2014; technical advisor with MoH-M, Lilongwe, 26 June 2014; technical advisor with MoF, Lilongwe, 27 June 2014.

144 Tambulasi, Richard, ‘When public services contracts are poorly managed’, International Public Management Review, 15:1 (2014), pp. 83–99Google Scholar (pp. 83–4); Adhikari et al., ‘Foreign aid, Cashgate and trusting relationships’.

145 Authors’ interview with international donor, Lusaka, 23 February 2011.

146 Anderson and Patterson, Dependent Agency, pp. 45–6.

147 CHAZ, ‘2017 Annual Report’, p. 7.

148 See Hofer, Katharina, ‘The role of evangelical NGOs in international development’, Afrika Spectrum, 38:3 (2003), pp. 375–98Google Scholar.

149 Authors’ interview with international FBO official, Lusaka, 21 May 2011.

150 Authors’ interview with CHAZ official, Lusaka, 16 August 2007.

151 CHAM, ‘Annual Report’, p. 48.

152 Mwai Makoka, ‘Strengthening PPPs and Interfaith Partnerships for UHC’, presentation at ACHAP 7th Biennial Conference, Nairobi (25 February 2015), available at: {https://www.slideshare.net/achapkenya/malawi-experience-by-dr-makoka-cham}; CHAM, ‘Strategic Plan 2015–2019’, pp. xv, 5.

153 Authors' interviews with: US PEPFAR program official, Lusaka, 13 August 2007; international FBO official, Lusaka, 17 March 2011.

154 ‘A discussion with Karen Sichinga’, interview available online.

155 Authors’ interview with World Vision official, Lusaka, 15 August 2007; authors’ observation, donor meeting, Lusaka, 11 February 2011.

156 David Lewis and David Mosse, Development Brokers and Translators (West Hartford, CT: Kumarian, 2006).

157 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

158 Authors’ interviews with: CHAZ official, Lusaka, 16 August 2007, 13 April 2009; World Vision official, Lusaka, 15 August 2007. See also Patterson, African Church and the AIDS Crisis.

159 Authors’ interview with CHAZ physician, Lusaka, 8 April 2009.

160 Authors’ informal discussions with CHAZ-facility clients, Lusaka, February 2011.

161 Lewis and Mosse, Development Brokers and Translators.

162 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

163 Authors’ interview with CHAZ official, Lusaka, 13 April 2009.

164 Authors’ interview with Reformed Church official, Lusaka, 31 March 2011.

165 Pot, Hanneke, ‘Public servants as development brokers’, Forum for Development Studies, 46:1 (2019), pp. 23–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

166 Authors’ interviews with: programme managers – major international donor, Lilongwe, 6 June, 4, 9, 10 July 2014; health advisor – major international donor, Lilongwe, 7 July, 2014; CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014; civil servant – MoH, Lilongwe, 3, 27 June 2014.

167 Makoka, ‘Strengthening PPPs and Interfaith Partnerships for UHC’.

168 Authors’ interviews with: programme managers – major international donor, Lilongwe, 6 June, 4, 9, 10 July 2014; health advisor – major international donor, Lilongwe, 7 July 2014. Anderson, ‘Shadow diplomacy’.

169 Mawdsley, Emma, Townsend, Janet, and Porter, Gina, ‘Trust, accountability and face-to-face interaction in North-South NGO relations’, Development in Practice, 15:1 (2005), pp. 77–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

170 Authors’ interviews with: international FBOs, Washington DC, 18 March, 11 April 2005; Zambian FBOs, Lusaka, 14, 17 August 2007; Ecumenical church leader, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 24 June 2010; (via telephone) Zambian FBO official, Ndola, 24 October 2008; (via telephone) ecumenical church leader, Lusaka, 10 November 2008; authors’ informal discussions with FBO representatives, Lusaka, Washington, DC, Wheaton, Illinois, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 18 March 2005; 9–15 August 2007; 9 November 2008; 13 March 2011; 16 June 2014.

171 Authors’ interview with CHAZ board member, Lusaka, 13 June 2014.

172 Epstein, Helen, The Invisible Cure (New York, NY: Picador, 2008)Google ScholarPubMed; Boyd, Lydia, Preaching Prevention (Athens, OH: Ohio University Press, 2015)Google Scholar.

173 CHAZ, ‘2018 Annual Report’, p. 9.

174 Ibid.

175 Authors’ interview with CHAZ official, Lusaka, 16 August 2007.

176 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014; CHAM, ‘Strategic Plan 2015–2019’.

177 The only civil society organisations to receive grants were FBO World Vision International and NGO ActionAid International Global Fund, ‘Partner Investments’, dataset (2019), available at: {https://data.theglobalfund.org/partners/MWI}.

178 Authors’ interview with CHAM official, Lilongwe, 3 July 2014.

179 Head, Naomi, ‘Costly encounters of the empathic kind’, International Theory, 8:1 (2016), pp. 171–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Wheeler, ‘To put oneself into the other fellow's place’.

180 See Pfeiffer, ‘International NGOs and primary health care’.

181 Pfeiffer, ‘International NGOs and primary health care’, p. 736.

182 Andrews, Pritchett, and Woolcock, Building State Capability, p. 288.

183 Keating, Vincent and Thrandardottir, Erla, ‘NGOs, trust, and the accountability agenda’, The British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 19:1 (2017), pp. 134–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.