Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-ttngx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-26T11:46:52.961Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Mass-Casualty, Terrorist Bombings: Epidemiological Outcomes, Resource Utilization, and Time Course of Emergency Needs (Part I)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 June 2012

Jeffrey L. Arnold*
Affiliation:
Yale New Haven Center for Emergency and Terrorism Preparedness, New Haven, Connecticut, USA
Ming-Che Tsai
Affiliation:
Department of Emergency and Trauma Service, National Cheng-Kung University Hospital, Tainan, Taiwan, Republic of, China
Pinchas Halpern
Affiliation:
Department of Emergency Medicine, Tel-Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, Tel-Aviv, Israel
Howard Smithline
Affiliation:
Department of Emergency Medicine, Tufts University School of Medicine, Baystate Medical Center, Springfield, MA, USA
Edita Stok
Affiliation:
Ministry of Health, Ljubljana, Slovenia
Gurkan Ersoy
Affiliation:
Department of Emergency Medicine, Dokuz Eylul University Medical Center, Izmir, Turkey
*
Medical Director, Yale New Haven Center for Terrorism and Emergency Preparedness, 1 Church Street, 5th Floor, New Haven, CT 06510 USA, E-mail: jeffrey.arnold@yale.edu

Abstract

Introduction:

This article characterizes the epidemiological outcomes, resource utilization, and time course of emergency needs in mass-casualty, terrorist bombings producing 30 or more casualties.

Methods:

Eligible bombings were identified using a MEDLINE search of articles published between 1996 and October 2002 and a manual search of published references. Mortality, injury frequency, injury severity, emergency department (ED) utilization, hospital admission, and time interval data were abstracted and relevant rates were determined for each bombing. Median values for the rates and the inter-quartile ranges (IQR) were determined for bombing subgroups associated with: (1) vehicle delivery; (2) terrorist suicide; (3) confined-space setting; (4) open-air setting; (5) structural collapse sequela; and (6) structural fire sequela.

Results:

Inclusion criteria were met by 44 mass-casualty, terrorist bombings reported in 61 articles. Median values for the immediate mortality rates and IQRs were: vehicle-delivery, 4% (1–25%); terrorist-suicide, 19% (7–44%); confined-space 4% (1–11%); open-air, 1% (0–5%); structural-collapse, 18% (5–26%); structural fire 17% (1–17%); and overall, 3% (1–14%). A biphasic pattern of mortality and unique patterns of injury frequency were noted in all subgroups. Median values for the hospital admission rates and IQRs were: vehicle-delivery, 19% (14–50%); terrorist-suicide, 58% (38–77%); confined-space, 52% (36–71%); open-air, 13% (11–27%); structural-collapse, 41% (23–74%); structural-fire, 34% (25–44%); and overall, 34% (14–53%). The shortest reported time interval from detonation to the arrival of the first patient at an ED was five minutes. The shortest reported time interval from detonation to the arrival of the last patient at an ED was 15 minutes. The longest reported time interval from detonation to extrication of a live victim from a structural collapse was 36 hours.

Conclusion:

Epidemiological outcomes and resource utilization in mass-casualty, terrorist bombings vary with the characteristics of the event.

Type
Original Research
Copyright
Copyright © World Association for Disaster and Emergency Medicine 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1.Terror Attack Database: International Policy Institute for Counter-Terrorism Web site. Available at: http://www.ict.org.il/. Accessed 22 January 2002.Google Scholar
2.Mahoney, LE, Reutershan, TP: Catastrophic disasters and the design of disaster medical care systems. Ann Emerg Med 1987; 16: 227233.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
3.Weiner, T: 1,800 Injured overwhelming Kenya Hospital. New York Times We b site. Available at http://www.nytimes.com. Accessed 09 August 1998.Google Scholar
4.Rignault, DP, Deligny, MC: The 1986 terrorist bombing experience in Paris. Ann Surg 1989; 209: 368373.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
5.Withers, JN: Personal protection during the bombing of the Victoria BOQ. Mil Med 1996; 131: 12851289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
6.Henderson, JV: Anatomy of a terrorist attack: The Cu Chi mess hall incident. Prehosp Disast Med 1986; 2: 6973.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
7.Rutherford, WH: Experience in the Accident and Emergency Department of the Royal Victoria Hospital with patients from civil disturbances in Belfast 1969–1972, with a review of disasters in the United Kingdom 1951–1971. Injury 4(3): 189199.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8.Kerr, AG, Byrne, JET: Blast injuries of the ear. BMJ 1975; 1: 559561.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
9.Kerr, AG, Byrne, JET: Concussive effects of bomb blast on the ear. J Laryng Otology 1975; 89: 131143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
10.Kerr, AG: Blast injuries to the ear. The Practitioner 1978; 221: 677682.Google ScholarPubMed
11.Kerr, AG: Trauma and the temporal bone. The effects of blast on the ear. J Laryng Otology 1980; 94: 107110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
12.McCaughey, W, Coppel, DL, Dundee, JW: Blast injuries to the lungs. A report of two cases. Anaesthesia 1973; 28: 29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
13.Walsh, RM, Pracy, JP, Huggon, AM, Gleeson, MJ: Bomb blast injuries to the ear: the London Bridge incident series. J Accid Emerg Med 1995; 12: 194198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
14.Caro, D, Irving, M: The Old Bailey bomb explosion. Lancet 1973; 1: 14331435.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
15.Cooper, GJ, Maynard, RL, Cross, NL, Hill, JF: Casualties from terrorist bombings. J Trauma 1983; 23: 955967.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
16.Hill, JF: Blast injury with particular reference to recent terrorist bombings incidents. Ann Roy Coll Surg Engl 1979; 61: 411.Google ScholarPubMed
17.Tucker, K, Lettin, A: The Tower of London bomb explosion. BMJ 1975; 3: 287290.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
18.Waterworth, TA, Carr, MJT: Report on injuries sustained by patients treated at the Birmingham General Hospital following the recent bomb explosions. BMJ 1975: 2: 2527.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
19.Frykberg, ER, Tepas, JJ: Terrorist bombings. Lessons learned from Belfast to Beirut. Ann Surg 1988; 208: 569576.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
20.Jacobs, LM, Ramp, JM, Breay, JM: An emergency medical system approach to disaster planning. J Trauma 1979; 19: 157162.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
21.Brismar, B, Bergenwald, L: The terrorist bomb explosion in Bologna, Italy, 1980: An analysis of the effects and injuries sustained. J Trauma 1982; 22: 216220.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
22.Frykberg, ER, Tepas, JJ, Alexander, RH: The 1983 Beirut Airport terrorist bombing. Injury patterns and implications for disaster management. Am Surg 1989; 55: 134141.Google ScholarPubMed
23.Scott, BA, Fletcher, JR, Pulliam, MW: The Beirut terrorist bombing. Neurosurgery 1986; 18: 107110.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
24.Slater, MS, Trunkey, DD: Terrorism in America. An evolving threat. Arch Surg 1997; 132: 10591066.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
25.Boehm, TM, James, JJ: The medical response to the La Belle Disco bombing in Berlin, 1986. Mil Med 1988; 153: 235238.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
26.Morrell, PAG, Naif, FE, Domenech, RP, et al: Burns caused by the terrorist bombing of the department store Hipercor in Barcelona. Part I. Burns 1990; 16: 423425.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
27.Jimenez-Hernandez, FH, Blasco, EL, Oliva, RL, Caicedo Caicedo, JC, Banuelos Roda, JA: Burns caused by the terrorist bombing of the department store Hipercor in Barcelona. Part 2. Burns 1990; 16: 426431.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
28.Cudennec, YF, Buffe, P, Poncet, JL: Otologic features and teachings of a bombing attempt. Mil Med 1995; 160(9): 467470.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
29.Brown, MG, Marshall. The Enniskillen bomb: A disaster plan. BMJ 1988; 297: 11131116.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
30.Curran, PS, Bell, AP, Murray, G: Psychological consequences of the Enniskellen bombing. Br J Psych 1990; 156: 479482.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
31.Katz, E, Ofek, B, Adler, J, et al: Primary blast injury after a bomb explosion in a civilian bus. Ann Surg 1989; 209: 484488.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
32.Johnstone, DJ, Evans, SC, Field, RE, Booth, SJ: The Victoria bomb: A report from the Westminster Hospital. Injury 1993; 24: 59.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
33.Maniscalco, PM: Terrorism hits home. Emerg Med Serv 1993; 22: 3132, 34–37,40–41.Google ScholarPubMed
34.Quenemoen, LE, Davis, YM, Malilay, J, et al: The World Trade Center bombing: injury prevention strategies for high-rise building fires. Disasters 1996; 20: 125132.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
35.Biancolini, CA, Del Bosco, CG, Jorge, MA: Argentine Jewish community institution bomb explosion. J Trauma 1999; 47: 728732.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
36.Stein, M, Hirshberg, A: Medical consequences of terrorism. Surg Clin North Am 1999; 79: 15371552.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
37.Hogan, DE, Waeckerle, JF, Dire, DJ, Lillibridge, SR: Emergency department impact of the Oklahoma City terrorist bombing. Ann Emerg Med 1999; 34: 160167.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
38.Mallonee, S, Shariat, S, Stennies, G, et al: Physical injuries and fatalities resulting from the Oklahoma City bombing. JAMA 1996; 276(5): 382387.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
39.Maningas, PA, Robison, M, Mallonee, S: The EMS response to the Oklahoma City bombing. Prehosp Disast Med 1997; 12: 8085.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
40.Mines, M, Thach, A, Mallonee, S, et al: Ocular injuries sustained by survivors of the Oklahoma City bombing. Ophthalmology 2000; 107: 837843.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
41.North, CS, Nixon, SJ, Shariat, , et al: Psychiatric disorders among survivors of the Oklahoma City bombing. JAMA 1999; 282: 755762.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
42.Paran, H, Neufeld, D, Shwartz, I, et al: Perforation of the terminal ileum induced by blast injury: Delayed diagnosis or delayed perforation? J Trauma 1996; 40: 472475.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
43.Applewhite, L: Coping with terrorism: The OPM-SANG experience. Mil Med 1997; 162: 240242.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
44.Leibovici, D, Gofrit, ON, Stein, M, et al: Blast injuries–Bus versus open-air bombings: A comparative study of injuries in survivors of open-air versus confined-space explosions. J Trauma 1996; 41: 10301035.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
45.Batho, S, Russell, L, Williams, G: Crisis management to controlled recovery: The emergency planning response to the bombing of Manchester City Centre. Disasters 1999; 23(3): 217233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
46.Carley, SD, Mackway-Jones, K: The casualty profile from the Manchester bombing 1996: A proposal for the construction and dissemination of casualty profiles from major incidents. J Accid Emerg Med 1997; 14: 7680.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
47.Feliciano, DV, Anderson, GV, Rozycki, GS, et al: Management of casualties from the bombing at the Centennial Olympics. Am J Surg 1998; 176: 538543.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
48.Budd, F: Helping the helpers after the bombing in Dhahran: Critical incident stress services for an air rescue squadron. Mil Med 1997; 162: 515520.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
49.Gunby, P: Military medicine responds to terrorism. JAMA 1996; 276: 265.Google ScholarPubMed
50.Thach, AB, Ward, TP, Hollifield, RD, et al: Eye injuries in a terrorist bombing. Dhahran, Saudi Arabia, 25 June, 1996. Ophthalmology 2000; 107: 844847.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
51.Vassallo, DJ, Taylor, JC, Aldington, DJ, Finnegan, AP.Shattered illusions – The Thiepval Barracks bombing, 07 October 1996. J R Med Corps 1997; 143: 511.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
52.Alexander, DA: Nairobi terrorist bombing: The personal experience of a mental health adviser. Int J Emerg Mental Health 2001; 3(4): 249257.Google ScholarPubMed
53.Macintyre, AG, Weir, S, Barbera, JA: The international search and rescue response to the US Embassy bombing in Kenya: The medical team experience. Prehosp Disast Med 1999; 14: 215221.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
54.Odhiambo, WA, Guthua, SW, Macigo, FG, Akama, MK: Maxillofacial injuries caused by terrorist bomb attack in Nairobi, Kenya. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2002; 31: 374377.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
55.Williams, KN, Squires, S: Experience of a major incident alert at two hospitals: “The Soho Bomb”. Br J Anaesth 2000; 85: 322324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
56.Asaeda, G: The day that the START triage system came to a stop: Observations from the World Trade Center disaster. Acad Emerg Med 2002; 9: 255256.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
57.Centers for Disease Control: New York City Department of Health response to the terrorist attack, September 11, 2001. MMWR 2001; 50: 821822.Google Scholar
58.Centers for Disease Control: Rapid assessment of injuries among survivors of the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center — New York City, September 2001. MMWR 2002; 51: 15.Google Scholar
59.Centers for Disease Control: Deaths in World Trade Center Terrorist Attacks – New York City, 2001. MMWR 2002; 51 (Special issue): 16–18.Google Scholar
60.Galea, S, Ahern, J, Resnick, H, et al: Psychological sequelae of the September 11 terrorist attacks in New York City. N Engl J Med 2002; 346: 982987.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
61.Jacobson, S: Recollections of September 11, 2001. Acad Emerg Med 2002; 9: 216.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
62.Menlove, S: Reflections. September 11, 2001 — What we learned. Acad Emerg Med 2002; 9: 217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
63.Nierenberg, R: Reflections. September 11, 2001 — What we learned. Acad Emerg Med 2002; 9: 217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
64.Pesola, GR, Dujar, A, Wilson, S: Emergency preparedness: The World Trade Center and Singapore Airline disasters. Acad Emerg Med 2002; 9: 220222.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
65.Abenhaim, L, Dab, W, Salmi, LR: Study of civilian victims of terrorist attacks (France 1982–1987). J Clin Epidemiol 1992; 45: 103109.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
66.Adler, J, Golan, E, Golan, J, et al: Terrorist bombing experience during 1975–79. Casualties admitted to the Shaare Zedek Medical Center. Isr J Med Sci 1983; 19(2): 189193.Google Scholar
67.Cairns, E, Lewis, CA: Collective memories, political violence and mental health in Northern Ireland. Br J Psychol 1999; 90: 2533.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
68.Caseby, NG, Porter, MF: Blast injuries to the lungs. Clinical presentation, management and course. Injury 1976; 8: 112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
69.Clark, MA: The pathology of terrorism. Foresnic Path 1998; 18: 99114.Google ScholarPubMed
70.Coppel, DL: Blast injuries of the lungs. Br J Surg 1976; 63: 735737.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
71.Feigenberg, Z: Multi-casualty incidents caused by terrorist bombing explosions — Treated by the Magen David Adom in Israel. Prehosp Disast Med 1999; 14(Suppl 1): S36. Abstract.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
72.Finnegan, AP, Cumming, PA, Piper, ME: Critical incident stress debriefing following the terrorist bombing at army headquarters Northern Ireland. J R Army Med Corps 1998; 144: 510.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
73.Gray, RC, Coppel, DL: Intensive care of patients with bomb blast and gunshot injuries. BMJ 1975; 1: 502504.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
74.Hadden, WA, Rutherford, WH, Merrett, JD: The injuries of terrorist bombing. A study of 1532 consecutive patients. Br J Surg 1978; 65: 525.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
75.Hodgetts, TJ: Lessons from the Musgrave Park Hospital bombing. Injury 1993; 24: 219221.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
76.Hull, JB, Bowyer, GW, Cooper, GJ, Crane, J: Pattern of injury in those dying from traumatic amputation caused by bomb blast. Br J Surg 1994; 81(8): 11321135.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
77.Karmy-Jones, R, Kissinger, D, Golocovsky, M, et al: Bomb-related injuries. Mil Med 1994; 159: 536539.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
78.Kennedy, TL, Johnston, GW: Civilian bombing injuries. BMJ 1975; 1: 382383.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
79.Leibovici, D, Gofrit, ON, Shapira, SC: Eardrum perforation in explosion survivors: Is it a marker of pulmonary blast injury? Ann Emerg Med 1999; 34: 168172.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
80.Lyons, HA: Terrorists’ bombing and the psychological sequelae. J Irish Med Assoc 1974; 67: 1519.Google ScholarPubMed
81.Lynn, M, Farkash, U, Maor, R, Eldad, A: Epidemiological and medical aspects of terrorism. Prehosp Disast Med 1999; 14(Suppl): S61. Abstract.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
82.Marshall, T: A pathologist's view of terrorist violence. Forensic Sci Int 1988; 36: 5767.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
83.Pizov, R, Oppenheim-Eden, A, Matot, I, et al: Blast lung injury from an explosion on a civilian bus. Chest 1999; 115: 165172.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
84.Pyper, PC, Graham, WJ: Analysis of terrorist injuries treated at Craigavon Area Hospital, Northern Ireland, 1972–1980. Injury 1983; 14: 332338.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
85.Rosenberg, B, Sternberg, N, Zagher, U, et al: Burns due to terroristic attacks on civilian populations from 1975 to 1979. Burns Incl Therm Inj 1982; 9: 2123.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
86.Uretzky, G, Cotev, S: The use of continuous positive pressure in blast injuries of the chest. Crit Care Med 1980; 8: 486489.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
87.Subcommittee on Advanced Trauma Life Support for the American College of Surgeons Committee on Trauma: Advanced Trauma Life Support Course for Physicians. 5th ed.Chicago, IL: American College of Surgeons; 1995.Google Scholar
88.Watoh, Y, Okada, S: Relationship between mortality and building collapse patterns. Prehosp Disast Med 2001; 16: S82. Abstract.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
89.Boffard, K, MacFarlane, C: Urban bomb blast injuries: Patterns of injury and treatment. Surg Annu 1993; 25(Pt 1): 2947.Google ScholarPubMed
90.De Candole, CA: Blast injury. Can Med Ass J 1967; 96: 207214.Google ScholarPubMed
91.Gans, L, Kennedy, T: Management of unique clinical entities in disaster medicine. Emerg Med Clin North Am 1996; 14: 301326.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
92.Huller, T, Bazini, Y: Blast injuries of the chest and abdomen. Arch Surg 1970; 100: 2430.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
93.Kennedy, TL, Johnston, GW: Civilian bombing injuries. BMJ 1975; 1: 382383.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
94.Mellor, SG: The pathogenesis of blast injury and its management. Br J Hosp Med 1988; 39: 536539.Google ScholarPubMed
95.Stapczynski, JS: Blast injuries. Ann Emerg Med 1982; 11: 687694.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
96.Wightman, JM, Gladish, SL: Explosions and blast injuries. Ann Emerg Med 2001; 37: 664678.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
97. Nation team: Alive from blast tomb. Daily Nation on the Web We b site. Available at www.nationaudio.com. Accessed 29 January 2002.Google Scholar