Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c4f8m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T02:28:18.179Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Giving Up On the Founding: The Separation of Church and State and the Writing of Establishment Clause History

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 February 2013

Christopher S. Grenda
Christopher S. Grenda*
Affiliation:
Bronx Community College of the City University of New York
*
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Christopher S. Grenda, 702 Firethorn Drive, Union, NJ 07083-5074. E-mail: csgmd1@aol.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Examination of the First Amendment's establishment clause in the post World War II period is unique in American constitutional interpretation because virtually all voices had agreed on one point, originalism. Few if any significant writers on the establishment clause had doubted the centrality of the founders' original intent for interpreting the clause's meaning. Yet this now has changed. Unlike their predecessors, leading advocates of church-state separation have now moved away from an original meaning interpretation of the establishment clause. Yet these separationists continue to try to ground their normative policy prescriptions in establishment clause mandates. They attempt this balancing act by employing narrative strategies of evolutionary processes in history. They do not simply track changes in constitutional doctrine, but characterize changes yielding greater separation between church and state through the nation's history as incipient in the Republic's founding, an originally inchoate church-state principle only fully formed through historical evolution. In the process, they sweep myriad separationist ideas into their progressively evolving narratives which have never been enunciated as law. Their accounts thus often reflect less an attempt to track historical developments in fundamental law than an attempt to construct fundamental law narratives. These attempts highlight persistent historical problems in the separationist endeavor that require attention if the evolutionary narratives of leading separationist are to shape the field of establishment clause history.

Type
Articles
Information
Politics and Religion , Volume 6 , Issue 2 , June 2013 , pp. 402 - 434
Copyright
Copyright © Religion and Politics Section of the American Political Science Association 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Abington School District v. Schempp. 1963. 374 U.S. 203.Google Scholar
Agostini v. Felton. 1997. 521 U.S. 203.Google Scholar
Bagley v. Raymond School Department. 1999. 728 A.2d 127.Google Scholar
Board of Education v. Allen. 1968. 391 US. 236.Google Scholar
Brown v. Board of Education. 1954. 347 U.S. 483.Google Scholar
Chamberlain v. Public Instruction Board. 1964. 377 U.S. 402.Google Scholar
Engel v. Vitale. 1962. 370 U.S. 421.Google Scholar
Everson v. Board of Education. 1947. 330 U.S. 1.Google Scholar
Grand Rapids School District v. Ball. 1985. 473 U.S. 373.Google Scholar
Griswold v. Connecticut. 1965. 381 U.S. 479.Google Scholar
Grutter v. Bollinger. 2003. 539 U.S. 306.Google Scholar
Jackson v. Benson. 1998. 218 Wis.2d 835, 578 N.W. 2d 602.Google Scholar
Kotterman v. Killian. 1999. 193 Ariz. 273, 972 P.2d 606.Google Scholar
Lee v. Weisman. 1992. 505 U.S. 577.Google Scholar
Lemon v. Kurtzman. 1971. 403 U.S. 602.Google Scholar
Meek v. Pittenger. 1975. 421 U.S. 349.Google Scholar
Mitchell v. Helms. 2000. 530 U.S. 793.Google Scholar
McCreary County v. ACLU of Kentucky. 2005. 545 U.S. 844.Google Scholar
Van Orden v. Perry. 2005. 545 U.S. 677.Google Scholar
Wallace v. Jaffree.1985. 472 U.S. 38.Google Scholar
West Coast Hotel v. Parrish. 1937. 300 U.S. 379.Google Scholar
Wolman v. Walter. 1977. 433 U.S. 229.Google Scholar
Zelman v. Simmons-Harris. 2002. 536 U.S. 639.Google Scholar
Alley, Robert S. ed. 1985. James Madison on Religious Liberty. Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
Antieau, Charles J., Downey, Arthur T., and Roberts, Edward C.. 1964. Freedom from Federal Establishment: Formation and Early History of the First Amendment Religion Clauses. Milwaukee, WI: Bruce Publishing Co.Google Scholar
Antieau, Chester James, Carroll, Phillip Mark, and Burke, Thomas Carroll. 1965. Religion Under the State Constitutions. Brooklyn, NY: Central Book Company.Google Scholar
Appleby, Joyce. 1984. Capitalism and a New Social Order: The Republican Vision of the 1790s. New York, NY: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Appleby, Joyce. 1992. Liberalism and Republicanism in the Historical Imagination. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Audi, Robert. 1989. “The Separation of Church and State and the Obligations of Citizenship.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 3:259–96.Google Scholar
Audi, Robert. 1991. “Religious Commitment and Secular Reason: A Reply to Professor Weithman.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 1:66–76.Google Scholar
Audi, Robert. 2000. “The Place of Religious Argument in a Free and Democratic Society.” In Law and Religion: A Critical Anthology, ed. Feldman, Stephen M.New York: New York University Press, 69–88.Google Scholar
Audi, Robert. 1997. “The State, the Church, and the Citizen.” In Religion and Contemporary Liberalism, ed. Weithman, Paul J.. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 38–75.Google Scholar
Banning, Lance. 1978. The Jeffersonian Persuasion: Evolution of a Party Ideology. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Berkowitz, Peter. 1999. Virtue and the Making of Modern Liberalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Carter, Stephen L. 2001. “Liberal Hegemony and Religious Resistance: An Essay on Legal Theory.” In Christian Perspectives on Legal Thought, eds. McConnell, Michael W., Cochran, Robert F. Jr., and Carmella, Angela C.. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Cord, Robert L. 1982. Separation of Church and State: Historical Fact and Current Fiction. New York, NY: Lambeth Press.Google Scholar
Coleman, John A. 1997. “Deprivatizing Religion and Revitalizing Citizenship.” In Religion and Contemporary Liberalism, ed. Weithman, Paul J.Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 264–290.Google Scholar
Davis, Derek H. 1991. Original Intent: Chief Justice Rehnquist and the Course of American Church-State Relations. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
Davis, Derek H. 1998. “Equal Treatment: A Christian Separationist Perspective.” In Equal Treatment of Religion in a Pluralistic Society, eds. Monsma, Stephen V., and Soper, J. Christopher. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans Publishing, 157.Google Scholar
Davis, Derek H. 2000. Religion and the Continental Congress, 1774–1789: Contributions to Original Intent. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Drakeman, Donald L. 2010. Church, State, and Original Intent. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Dreisbach, Daniel L. 1990. “Thomas Jefferson and Bills Number 82–86 of the Revision of the Laws of Virginia, 1776–1786: New Light on the Jeffersonian Model of Church-State Relations.” North Carolina Law Review 69:159–211.Google Scholar
Dreisbach, Daniel L. 1991. “A New Perspective on Jefferson's Views on Church-State Relations: The Virginia Statute for Establishing Religious Freedom in Its Legislative Context.” American Journal of Legal History 35:172–204.Google Scholar
Dreisbach, Daniel L. 1997. “Everson and the Command of History: The Supreme Court, Lessons of History, and Church-State Debate in America.” In Everson Revisited: Religion, Education, and Law at the Crossroads. New York, NY: Rowman & Littlefield, 23–57.Google Scholar
Dreisbach, Daniel L. 2000. “Religion and Legal Reforms in Revolutionary Virginia: A Reexamination of Jefferson's Views on Religious Freedom and Church-State Separation.” In Religion and Political Culture in Jefferson's Virginia, eds. Sheldon, Garrett W., and Dreisbach, Daniel L.. New York, NY: Rowman & Littlefield, 189–218.Google Scholar
Dreisbach, Daniel L. 2002. Thomas Jefferson and the Wall of Separation between Church and State. New York, NY: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Estep, William R. 1990. Revolution within the Revolution: The First Amendment in Historical Context, 1612–1789. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.Google Scholar
Feldman, Stephen M. 1997. Please Don't Wish Me a Merry Christmas: A Critical History of the Separation of Church and State. New York, NY: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Grant, Ruth W. 1987. John Locke's Liberalism. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Green, Steven K. 2004. “‘Blaming Blaine’: Understanding the Blaine Amendment and the No-Funding Principle.” First Amendment Law Review 2:107–151.Google Scholar
Green, Steven K. 2010. The Second Disestablishment: Church and State in Nineteenth Century America. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Green, Steven K. 2012. The Bible, the School, and the Constitution: The Clash that Shaped Modern Church-State Doctrine. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Grenda, Christopher S. 2006. “Thinking Historically about Diversity: Religion, the Enlightenment, and the Construction of Civic Culture in Early America.” Journal of Church and State 3:567–600.Google Scholar
Haakonssen, Knud. 1996. Natural Law and Moral Philosophy: From Grotius to the Scottish Enlightenment. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hamburger, Philip. 2002. Separation of Church and State. Cambridge, NY: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Hollenbach, David. 1997. “Politically Active Churches: Some Empirical Prolegomena to a Normative Approach.” In Religion and Contemporary Liberalism, ed. Weithman, Paul J.Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 291–306.Google Scholar
Horowitz, Helen Lefkowitz. 2002. Rereading Sex: Battles over Sexual Knowledge and Suppression in Nineteenth-Century America. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.Google Scholar
Jacoby, Susan. 2004. Freethinkers: A History of American Secularism. New York, NY: Metropolitan Books.Google Scholar
Keller, Morton. 2009. America's Three Regimes: A New Political History. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2009.Google Scholar
Kramnick, Issac, and Moore, R. Laurence. 1996. The Godless Constitution: The Case Against Religious Correctness. New York, NY: W.W. Norton.Google Scholar
Laycock, Douglas. 1986. “‘Nonpreferential’ Aid to Religion: A False Claim about Original Intent.” William and Mary Law Review 5:875–923.Google Scholar
Levy, Lawrence W. [1986] 1994. The Establishment Clause: Religion and the First Amendment. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Locke, John. 1979. An Essay concerning Human Understanding, ed. Nidditch, Peter H.Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Lowi, Theodore J. 1979. The End of Liberalism: The Second Republic of the United States. New York, NY: W.W. Norton.Google Scholar
Maier, Pauline. 1997. American Scripture: Making the Declaration of Independence. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.Google Scholar
Malbin, Michael J. 1978. Religion and Politics: The Intentions of the Authors of the First Amendment. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.Google Scholar
Monsma, Stephen V., and Soper, J. Christopher, eds. 1998. Equal Treatment of Religion in a Pluralistic Society. Grand Rapids, MI.: Eerdmans Publishing.Google Scholar
Muñoz, Vincent Phillip. 2009. God and the Founders: Madison, Washington, and Jefferson. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
McCoy, Drew. 1982. The Elusive Republic: Political Economy in Jeffersonian America. New York, NY: W.W. Norton.Google Scholar
McGarvie, Mark D. 2004. One Nation Under Law: America's Early National Struggles to Separate Church and State. DeKalb: Ill: Northern Illinois University Press.Google Scholar
Noonan, John T. 1998. The Lustre of Our Country: The American Experience of Religious Freedom. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
O'Neill, Jonathan. 2005. Originalism in American Law and Politics: A Constitutional History. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Pangle, Thomas L. 1988. The Spirit of Modern Republicanism: The Moral Vision of the American Founders and the Philosophy of Locke. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Pfeffer, Leo. 1953. Church, State, and Freedom. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
Powell, Jefferson H. 1990. “The Original Understanding of Original Intent.” In Interpreting the Constitution: The Debate Over Original Intent, ed. Rakove, Jack N.Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press, 53–115.Google Scholar
Quinn, Philip L. 1997. “Political Liberalisms and Their Exclusions of the Religious.” In Religion and Contemporary Liberalism, ed. Weithman, Paul J.. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 138–161.Google Scholar
Rawls, John. 1985. “Justice as Fairness: Political not Metaphysical.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 3:223–249.Google Scholar
Rawls, John. 1993. Political Liberalism. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Sehat, David. 2011. The Myth of American Religious Freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Smith, Steven D. 1995. Foreordained Failure: The Quest for a Constitutional Principle of Religious Freedom. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Underwood, James Lowell. 1992. The Constitution of South Carolina, Volume III: Church and State, Morality and Free Expression. Columbus, SC: University of South Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Underwood, James Lowell, and Burke, W. Lewis, eds. 2006. The Dawn of Religious Freedom in South Carolina. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Weithman, Paul J. 1991. “The Separation of Church and State: Some Questions for Professor Audi.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 1:52–65.Google Scholar
Wolterstorff, Nicholas. 1997. “Why We Should Reject What Liberalism Tells Us about Speaking and Acting in Public for Religious Reasons.” In Religion and Contemporary Liberalism, ed. Weithman, Paul J.Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 162–181.Google Scholar
Wood, Gordon S. 1992. The Radicalism of the American Revolution. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.Google Scholar
Wood, Gordon S. 2009. Empire of Liberty: A History of the Early Republic, 1789–1815. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Wood, James E. Jr., ed. 1985. Religion and the State: Essays in Honor of Leo Pfeffer. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press.Google Scholar