Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-18T05:56:37.082Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Identity as a Variable

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2006

Rawi Abdelal ,
Yoshiko M. Herrera ,
Alastair Iain Johnston  and
Rose McDermott
Rawi Abdelal
Affiliation:
Harvard Business School (E-mail: rabdelal@hbs.edu)
Yoshiko M. Herrera
Affiliation:
Government Department, Harvard University (E-mail: herrera@fas.harvard.edu)
Alastair Iain Johnston
Affiliation:
Government Department, Harvard University (E-mail: johnston@fas.harvard.edu)
Rose McDermott
Affiliation:
Political Science Department, University of California at Santa Barbara (E-mail: rmcdermott@polsci.ucsb.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

As scholarly interest in the concept of identity continues to grow, social identities are proving to be crucially important for understanding contemporary life. Despite—or perhaps because of—the sprawl of different treatments of identity in the social sciences, the concept has remained too analytically loose to be as useful a tool as the literature's early promise had suggested. We propose to solve this longstanding problem by developing the analytical rigor and methodological imagination that will make identity a more useful variable for the social sciences. This article offers more precision by defining collective identity as a social category that varies along two dimensions—content and contestation. Content describes the meaning of a collective identity. The content of social identities may take the form of four non-mutually-exclusive types: constitutive norms; social purposes; relational comparisons with other social categories; and cognitive models. Contestation refers to the degree of agreement within a group over the content of the shared category. Our conceptualization thus enables collective identities to be compared according to the agreement and disagreement about their meanings by the members of the group. The final section of the article looks at the methodology of identity scholarship. Addressing the wide array of methodological options on identity—including discourse analysis, surveys, and content analysis, as well as promising newer methods like experiments, agent-based modeling, and cognitive mapping—we hope to provide the kind of brush clearing that will enable the field to move forward methodologically as well.Rawi Abdelal is Associate Professor, Harvard Business School (rabdelal@hbs.edu). Yoshiko M. Herrera is Associate Professor, Government Department, Harvard University (herrera@fas.harvard.edu). Alastair Iain Johnston is Professor, Government Department, Harvard University (johnston@fas.harvard.edu). Rose McDermott is Associate Professor, Political Science Department, University of California at Santa Barbara (rmcdermott@polsci.ucsb.edu). Research for the paper was made possible by the generous support of the Weatherhead Initiative of the Weatherhead Center for International Affairs at Harvard University. We are grateful to those who commented on earlier versions of this paper: Peter Burke, Lars-Erik Cederman, Jeff Checkel,Michael Dawson, James Fearon, David Frank, Erin Jenne, Michael Jones-Correa, Cynthia Kaplan, Peter Katzenstein, Herb Kelman, Paul Kowert, David Laitin, Daniel Posner, Paul Sniderman, Werner Sollors, Jeff Strabone, Philip Stone, Ronald Suny, Charles Tilly, Mary Waters, and three anonymous reviewers. We would also like to thank participants of the 2004 Identity as a Variable conference, including Henry Brady, Kanchan Chandra, Jack Citrin, Neta Crawford, Jennifer Hochschild, Jacques Hymans, Ted Hopf, Cynthia Kaplan, Ulrich Krotz, Taeku Lee, Will Lowe, Jason Lyall, Kimberly Neuendorf, Roger Petersen, Kevin Quinn, David Rousseau, Rogers Smith, Donald Sylvan, Kim Williams, and Michael Young, for comments on this version.

Type
Research Article
Information
Perspectives on Politics , Volume 4 , Issue 4 , December 2006 , pp. 695 - 711
Copyright
2006 American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abdelal, Rawi. 2001. National Purpose in the World Economy: Post-Soviet States in Comparative Perspective. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Abdi, Reza. 2002. Interpersonal metadiscourse: An indicator of interaction and identity. Discourse Studies 4 (2): 139–45.Google Scholar
Adler, Emmanuel. 1992. The emergence of cooperation: National epistemic communities and the international evolution of the idea of nuclear arms control. International Organization 46 (1): 101–46.Google Scholar
Adler, Emmanuel, and Michael Barnett, eds. 1998. Security Communities. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ahuvia, Aaron. 2001. Well-being in cultures of choice: A Cross-cultural perspective. American Psychologist 56 (1): 77–8.Google Scholar
Anderson, Benedict. 1991. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, rev. ed. London: Verso.
Axelrod, Robert. 1976. Structure of Decision. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Axelrod, Robert. 1997a. Advancing the art of simulation in the social sciences.” In Simulating Social Phenomena, ed. Rosaria Conte, Rainer Hegselmann, and Pietro Terna. Berlin: Springer.
Axelrod, Robert. 1997b. The Complexity of Cooperation: Agent-Based Models of Competition and Collaboration. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Azzam, Maha. 1991. The Gulf crisis: Perceptions in the Muslim world. International Affairs 67 (3): 473–85.Google Scholar
Bailey, S.R.2002. The race construct and public opinion: Understanding Brazilian beliefs about racial inequality and their determinants. American Journal of Sociology 108 (2): 406–39.Google Scholar
Barnett, Michael. 1999. Culture, strategy, and foreign policy change: Israel's road to Oslo. European Journal of International Relations 5 (1): 5–36.Google Scholar
Bartelson, Jens. 1998. Second natures: Is the state identical with itself? European Journal of International Relations 4 (3): 295–326.Google Scholar
Bauer, Martin, and George Gaskell, eds. 2000. Qualitative Researching with Text, Image and Sound. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Bell, David. 2001. The Cult of the Nation in France. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Billig, Michael, and Henri Tajfel. 1973. Social categorization and similarity in intergroup behavior. European Journal of Social Psychology 3 (1): 27–52.Google Scholar
Brady, Henry E., and Cynthia S. Kaplan. 2000. Categorically wrong? Nominal versus graded measures of ethnic identity. Studies in Comparative International Development 35 (3): 56–91.Google Scholar
Brewer, Marilynn B., and W. Gardner. 1996. Who is this “we”? Levels of collective identity and self-representations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 71 (1): 83–93.Google Scholar
Briggs, Charles L.1986. Learning How to Ask: A Sociolinguistic Appraisal of the Role of the Interview in Social Science Research. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Brubaker, Rogers, and Frederick Cooper. 2000. Beyond “identity”. Theory and Society 29 (1): 1–47.Google Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers, Maria Loveman, and Peter Stamatov. 2004. Ethnicity as cognition. Theory and Society 33 (1): 31–64.Google Scholar
Burke, Peter J., and Judy C. Tully. 1977. The measurement of role identity. Social Forces 55 (4): 881–97.Google Scholar
Canning, Kathleen. 1996. Languages of Labor and Gender: Female Factory Work in Germany, 1850–1914. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Cederman, Lars-Erik. 1995. Competing identities: An ecological model of nationality formation. European Journal of International Relations 1 (September): 331–65.Google Scholar
Cederman, Lars-Erik. 1997. Emergent Actors in World Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Cederman, Lars-Erik. 2001. Agent-based modeling in political science. Political Methodologist 10 (Fall): 16–22.Google Scholar
Chan, S.F.2000. Formal logic and dialectical thinking are not incongruent. American Psychologist 55 (9): 1063–64.Google Scholar
Chandra, Kanchan, and David Laitin. 2002. “A Constructivist Framework for Thinking about Identity Change.” Stanford: LICEP 5 Conference, Stanford University, May 11.
Checkel, Jeff. 2001. Why comply? Social learning and European identity change. International Organization 55 (3): 553–88.Google Scholar
Citrin, Jack, Beth Reingold, and Donald P. Green. 1990. American identity and the politics of ethnic change. Journal of Politics 52 (4): 1124–54.Google Scholar
Citrin, Jack, Ernst B. Haas, Christopher Muste, and Beth Reingold. 1994. Is American nationalism changing? Implications for foreign policy. International Studies Quarterly 381 (1): 1–31.Google Scholar
Cox, Robert. 1986. Social forces, states, and world orders.” In Neorealism and Its Critics, ed. Robert Keohane. New York: Columbia University Press.
Denzau, Arthur T., and Douglass C. North. 1994. Shared mental models: Ideologies and institutions. Kyklos 47 (1): 3–31.Google Scholar
Diener, Ed, Shigehiro Oishi, and Richard E. Lucas. 2003. Personality, culture, and subjective well-being: Emotional and cognitive evaluations of life. Annual Review of Psychology 54: 403–25.Google Scholar
Eilders, Christiane, and Albrecht Lüter. 2000. Germany at war: Competing framing strategies in German public discourse. European Journal of Communication 15 (3): 415–28.Google Scholar
Fearon, James. 1999. “What Is Identity (As We Now Use the Word)?” Unpublished manuscript. Stanford University, Stanford, Calif., November 3.
Feng, Chongyi. 1999. Seeking lost codes in the wilderness: The search for a Hainanese culture. China Quarterly 160: 1036–56.Google Scholar
Fierke, Karin. 1996. Multiple identities, interfacing games. European Journal of International Relations 2 (4): 467–98.Google Scholar
Fierke, Karin. 2004. World or worlds? The analysis of content and discourse.” Qualitative Methods: Newsletter of the American Political Science Association Organized Section on Qualitative Methods 2 (1): 36–9.Google Scholar
Fink, A., ed. 2003. The Survey Kit, 2d ed. 10 vol. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Fiske, Susan, and Shelley Taylor. 1991. Social Cognition, 2d ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Furia, Peter. 2002. “National Identity and Its Impact on International Politics.” Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Boston, August 29–September 1.
Goldstein, Judith, and Robert O. Keohane, ed. 1993. Ideas and Foreign Policy: Beliefs, Institutions, and Political Change. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Goodman, B.2000. Improvisation on a semi-colonial theme, or, how to read a celebration of transnational urban community. Journal of Asian Studies 59 (4): 921–22.Google Scholar
Goodman, David S.G.2002. Structuring local identity: Nation, province and county in Shanxi during the 1990s. China Quarterly 172: 837–62.Google Scholar
Gudykunst, W.1989. Culture and intergroup processes. In The Cross Cultural Challenge to Social Psychology, ed. M.H. Bond. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE Publications.
Gurung, R.A.R.2003. Comparing cultural and individual learning tendencies. American Psychologist 58 (2): 145–46.Google Scholar
Gutmann, Amy. 2003. Identity in Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Hardy, Cynthia, Bill Harley, and Nelson Phillips. 2004. Discourse analysis and content analysis: Two solitudes? Qualitative Methods: Newsletter of the American Political Science Association Organized Section on Qualitative Methods 2 (1): 19–22.Google Scholar
Herrera, Yoshiko M.2005. Imagined Economies: The Sources of Russian Regionalism. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Herrera, Yoshiko M., and Bear F. Braumoeller. 2004. Symposium: Discourse and content analysis. Qualitative Methods: Newsletter of the American Political Science Association Organized Section on Qualitative Methods 2(1): 15–18.Google Scholar
Ho, D.Y.F.2000. Dialectical thinking: Neither Eastern nor Western. American Psychologist 55 (9): 1064–65.Google Scholar
Holstein, J., and J. Gubrium, eds. 2003. Inside Interviewing: New Lenses, New Concerns. London: SAGE Publications.
Hooper, Michael. 1976. The structure and measurement of social identity. Public Opinion Quarterly 40 (2): 154–64.Google Scholar
Hopf, Ted. 2004. Discourse and content analysis: Some fundamental incompatibilities. Qualitative Methods: Newsletter of the American Political Science Association Organized Section on Qualitative Methods 2 (1): 31–3.Google Scholar
Hopf, Ted. 2002. Social Construction of International Politics: Identities and Foreign Policies. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Horowitz, Donald. 1985. Ethnic Groups in Conflict. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Horowitz, Michael. 2002. “Research Report on the Use of Identity Concepts in International Relations.” Cambridge: Weatherhead Center for International Affairs and the Harvard Identity Project, July. Available at: http://www.wcfia.harvard.edu/misc/initiative/identity/publications/horowitz1.pdf
Huntington, Samuel P.2004. Who Are We? The Challenges to America's National Identity. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Jepperson, Ronald, Alexander Wendt, and Peter J. Katzenstein. 1996. Norms, identity, and culture in national security. In The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics, ed. Peter J. Katzenstein. New York: Columbia University Press.
Katzenstein, Peter J.1996. Cultural Norms and National Security: Police and Military in Postwar Japan. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Kelman, Herbert C.1969. Patterns of personal involvement in the national system: A social-psychological analysis of political legitimacy. In International Politics and Foreign Policy: A Reader in Research and Theory, rev. ed., J.N. Rosenau, ed. Princeton: Free Press.
Kelman, Herbert C.1997. Negotiating national identity and self-determination in ethnic conflicts. Negotiation Journal 13 (4): 327–40.Google Scholar
Kelman, Herbert C.1999. The interdependence of Israeli and Palestinian national identities. Journal of Social Issues 55 (3): 581–600.Google Scholar
Kelman, Herbert C.2001. The role of national identity in conflict resolutions. In Social Identity, Intergroup Conflict, and Conflict Reduction, ed. Ashmoreet al.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kier, Elizabeth. 1997. Imagining War: French and British Military Doctrine between the Wars. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Klandermans, Bert. 1997. The Social Psychology of Protest. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
Klotz, Audie. 1995a. Norms in International Relations: The Struggle against Apartheid. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Klotz, Audie. 1995b. Norms reconstituting interests: Global racial equality and U.S. sanctions against South Africa. International Organization 49 (3): 451–78.Google Scholar
Laitin, David. 1998. Identity in Formation. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Laitin, David. 2002. Culture and national identity: “The East” and European integration. West European Politics 25 (2): 56–80.Google Scholar
Lee, Yueh-Ting. 2000. What is missing in Chinese–Western dialectical reasoning? American Psychologist 55 (9): 1065–67.Google Scholar
Li, Jin. 2003. The core of Confucian learning. American Psychologist 58 (2): 146–47.Google Scholar
Lowe, Will. 2004. Content analysis and its place in the methodological scheme of things. Qualitative Methods: Newsletter of the American Political Science Association Organized Section on Qualitative Methods 2 (1): 25–7.Google Scholar
Lowe, Will. 2002. “Software for Content Analysis—A Review.” Cambridge: Weatherhead Center for International Affairs and the Harvard Identity Project, June. Online at: http://www.wcfia.harvard.edu/misc/initiative/identity/
Lustick, Ian S.2002. PS-I: A user-friendly agent-based modeling platform for testing theories of political identity and political stability. Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulations 5 (3). Online journal available at: http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac.uk/5/3/7.html.Google Scholar
Lustick, Ian S., Dan Miodownik, and Roy J. Eidelson. 2004. Secessionism in multicultural states: Does sharing power prevent or encourage it? American Political Science Review 98 (2): 209–30.Google Scholar
March, James G., and Johan P. Olsen. 1989. Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics. New York: Free Press.
Mar-Molinero, Clare. 2000. Politics of Language in the Spanish-Speaking World. London: Routledge.
McCracken, Grant. 1988. Qualitative Research Methods, Vol. 13: The Long Interview. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE Publications.
Mearsheimer, John J.1990. Back to the future: Instability in Europe after the Cold War. International Security 15 (1): 5–56.Google Scholar
Monroe, Kristen Renwick, James Hankin, and Renée Bukovchik van Vechten. 2000. The psychological foundations of identity politics. Annual Review of Political Science 3: 419–47.Google Scholar
Neuendorf, Kimberly. 2002. The Content Analysis Guidebook. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Neuendorf, Kimberly. 2004. Content analysis: A contrast and complement to discourse analysis. Qualitative Methods: Newsletter of the American Political Science Association Organized Section on Qualitative Methods 2 (1): 33–6.Google Scholar
Neumann, Iver B.1999. Uses of the Other: “The East” in European Identity Formation. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Nisbett, Richard, and Dov Cohen. 1996. The Culture of Honor: The Psychology of Violence in the American South. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Osgood, Charles, Percy H. Tannenbaum, and George J. Suci. 1990. The Measurement of Meaning. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.
Peng, Kaiping, and R.E. Nisbett. 1999. Culture, dialectics, and reasoning about contradiction. American Psychologist 54 (9): 741–54.Google Scholar
Peng, Kaiping, and R.E. Nisbett. 2000. Dialectical responses to questions about dialectical thinking. American Psychologist 55 (9): 1067–68.Google Scholar
Phillips, Nelson, and Cynthia Hardy. 2002. Discourse Analysis: Investigating Processes of Social Construction. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Popping, Roel. 2000. Computer-Assisted Text Analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Price, Richard, and Nina Tannenwald. 1996. Norms and Deterrence: The Nuclear and Chemical Weapons Taboos. In The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics, ed. Peter J. Katzenstein. New York: Columbia University Press.
Prizel, Ilya. 1998. National Identity and Foreign Policy: Nationalism and Leadership in Poland, Russia, and Ukraine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Reus-Smit, Christian. 1999. The Moral Purpose of the State. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Risse, Thomas, Daniela Engelmann-Martin, Hans-Joachim Knopf, and Klaus Roscher. 1999. To Euro or not to Euro? The EMU and identity politics in the European Union. European Journal of International Relations 5 (2): 147–87.Google Scholar
Risse-Kappen, Thomas. 1996. Collective identity in a democratic community: The case of NATO. In The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics, ed. Peter Katzenstein. New York: Columbia University Press.
Rubin, Herbert J., and Irene S. Rubin1995. Qualitative Interviewing: The Art of Hearing Data. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications,
Ruggie, John Gerard. 1998a. Interests, identity, and American foreign policy. In Constructing the World Polity, ed. John G. Ruggie. New York: Routledge.
Ruggie, John Gerard. 1998b. What makes the world hang together? Neo-utilitarianism and the social constructivist challenge. In Constructing the World Polity, ed. John G. Ruggie. New York: Routledge.
Shabad, Goldie, and Kazimierz M. Slomczynski. 1999. Political identities in the initial phase of systemic transformation in Poland: A test of the tabula rasa hypothesis. Comparative Political Studies 32 (6): 690–723.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony D.1992. National identity and the idea of European Unity. International Affairs 68 (1): 55–76.Google Scholar
Smith, Rogers. 2003. Stories of Peoplehood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Smith, Rogers. 2004. Identities, interests, and the future of political science. Perspectives on Politics 2 (2): 301–12.Google Scholar
Smith, Tom W., and Lars Jarkko. 2001. National Pride in Cross-National Perspective. Chicago, IL: National Opinion Research Center and the University of Chicago.
Sniderman, Paul M., Louk Hagendoorn, and Markus Prior. 2004. Predisposing factors and situational triggers: Exclusionary reactions to immigrant minorities. American Political Science Review 98 (1): 35–49.Google Scholar
Sylvan, Donald A.2004. “Measuring Identity in the Study of Israeli-Palestinian Relations.” Harvard Identity Conference, Weatherhead Center for International Affairs, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass., December 9–11.
Tajfel, Henri. 1970. Experiments in intergroup discrimination. Scientific American 223 (5): 96–102.Google Scholar
Tajfel, Henri. 1981. Human Groups and Social Categories: Studies in Social Psychology. London: Cambridge University Press.
Tajfel, Henri. 1982. Social psychology of intergroup relations. Annual Review of Psychology 33 (1): 1–39.Google Scholar
Taylor, Shelley.E., Letitia A. Peplau, and David O. Sears. 1997. Social Psychology, 9th ed. Princeton, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Titscher, Stefan, Michael Meyer, Ruth Wodak, and Eva Vetter. 2000. Methods of Text and Discourse Analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Tronvoll, Kjetil. 1998. The process of nation-building in post-war Eritrea: Created from below or directed from above? Journal of Modern African Studies 36 (3): 461–82.Google Scholar
Turner, John C.1985. Social categorization and the self-concept: A social cognitive theory of group behavior. In Advances in Group Processes, vol. 2, ed. E.J. Lawler. Greenwich CT: JAI Press.
Turner, John C., M.A. Hogg, P.J. Oakes, S.D. Reicher, and M.S. Wetherell. 1987. Rediscovering the Social Group: A Self-Categorization Theory. New York: Blackwell.
Turner, John C., R.J. Brown, and H. Tajfel. 1979. Social comparison and group interest in in-group favoritism. European Journal of Social Psychology 9 (2): 187–204.Google Scholar
Valenzuela, J. Samuel, and Timothy R. Scully. 1997. Electoral choices and the party system in Chile: Continuities and changes at the recovery of democracy. Comparative Politics 29 (4): 511–27.Google Scholar
Weldes, Jutta, Mark Laffey, Hugh Gusterson, and Raymond Duvall, eds. 1999. Cultures of Insecurity: States, Communities, and the Production of Danger. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Wendt, Alexander. 1994. Collective identity formation and the international state. American Political Science Review 88 (2): 384–96.Google Scholar
Wendt, Alexander. 1999. Social Theory of International Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wodak, Ruth, and Michael Meyer. 2001. Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis. London: Sage Publications.
Yashar, Deborah J.1998. Contesting citizenship: Indigenous movements and democracy in Latin America. Comparative Politics 31 (1): 23–42.Google Scholar