Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T15:38:19.905Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Criminal Violence and Democratization in Central America: The Survival of the Violent State

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

José Miguel Cruz
José Miguel Cruz*
Affiliation:
Department of Politics and International Relations, Center for the Administration of Justice at Florida International University.jomcruz@fiu.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Why does Nicaragua have less violent crime than Guatemala, El Salvador, and Honduras? All these countries underwent political transitions in the 1990s. Many explanations point to the legacies of war, socioeconomic underdevelopment, and neoliberal structural reforms. However, these arguments do not fully explain why, despite economic reforms conducted throughout the region, war-less Honduras and wealthier Guatemala and El Salvador have much more crime than Nicaragua. This article argues that public security reforms carried out during the political transitions shaped the ability of the new regimes to control the violence produced by their own institutions and collaborators. In the analysis of the crisis of public security, it is important to bring the state back. The survival of violent entrepreneurs in the new security apparatus and their relationship with new governing elites foster the conditions for the escalation of violence in northern Central America.

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 53 , Issue 4 , Winter 2011 , pp. 1 - 33
Copyright
Copyright © University of Miami 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alvarenga, Patricia. 1996. Cultura y ética de la violencia: El Salvador, 1980–1932. San José : EDUCA.Google Scholar
Amaya, Edgardo Alberto. 2006. Security Policies in El Salvador, 1992–2002. In Public Security and Police Reform in the Americas, ed. Bailey, John and Dammert, Lucia. Pittsburgh : University of Pittsburgh Press. 132–47.Google Scholar
Americas Barometer. 2010. Database. http://lapop.ccp.ucr.ac.cr/Lapop_English.html.Google Scholar
Amnesty International. 19912009. Amnesty International Annual Reports. London : AI.Google Scholar
Amnesty International. 2003. Honduras: Zero Tolerance for … Impunity: Extrajudicial Executions of Children and Youths Since 1998. London : AI.Google Scholar
Arana, Ana. 2005. How the Street Gangs Took Central America. Foreign Affairs 84, 3: 98–110.Google Scholar
Baires, Sonia. 2003. Barrios cerrados como nueva forma de segregación y fragmentación urbana. Paper presented at the 24th International Congress of the Latin American Studies Association, Dallas, March 27–28.Google Scholar
Barnes, Nielan. 2007. A Comparative Analysis of Transnational Youth Gangs in Central America, Mexico, and the United States. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, New York, August 10.Google Scholar
Beltrán, Adriana. 2007. The Captive State, Organized Crime, and Human Rights in Latin America. In WOLA Special Report. Washington , DC : Washington Organization on Latin America, October. 1–27.Google Scholar
Beltrán, Adriana. 2009. Protect and Serve? The Status of Police Reform in Central America. Report. Washington , DC : WOLA.Google Scholar
Benson, Peter, Fischer, Edward F., and Thomas, Kedron. 2008. Neoliberalism, Accusation, and the Sociopolitical Context of Guatemala's New Violence. Latin American Perspectives 35, 5: 36–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Booth, John A., Wade, Christine J., and Walker, Thomas W.. 2010. Understanding Central America: Global Forces, Rebellion, and Change. 5th ed. Boulder : Westview Press.Google Scholar
Boraz, Steven C., and Bruneau, Thomas C.. 2006. Are the Maras Overwhelming Governments in Central America? Military Review 86, 6: 36–40.Google Scholar
Borjas, María Luisa. 2011. Former Commisioner of Police. Author interview. Tegucigalpa, August 12.Google Scholar
Cajina, Roberto J. 1996. Transición política y reconversión militar en Nicaragua, 1990–1995. Managua : CRIES.Google Scholar
Caldera, Hilda, and Landaverde, Gustavo. 2004. Comportamiento reciente del narcotráfico, el crimen organizado y maras en Honduras. In Proyecto n. 39109. Análisis político y escenarios prospectivos. Tegucigalpa : PNUD. http://www.hilda-caldera.rds.hn/doctos/inf_narco.doc. Accessed September 15, 2010.Google Scholar
Call, Charles T. 2003. Democratisation, War and State-Building: Constructing the Rule of Law in El Salvador. Journal of Latin American Studies 35, 4: 827–62.Google Scholar
Honduras, Casa Alianza. 2006. Informe de ejecuciones y muertes violentas de niños, niñas y jóvenes durante la administración del Presidente Ricardo Maduro, enero 2002–enero 2006. Tegucigalpa : Casa Alianza.Google Scholar
Castellanos, Julieta, and Salomón, Leticia. 2002. Honduras: reforma policial y seguridad ciudadana. Tegucigalpa : Foro Ciudadano.Google Scholar
Castillo, Beatriz. 2010. Inspectoría presentará cargos en caso de ex jefes policiales. Diario Co-Latino, February 2: 5.Google Scholar
Centro Nicaraguense de Derechos Humanos, Alianza de Centros de Mujeres, Red de Mujeres contra la Violencia, CODENI, and OMCT. 2008. Violaciones de los derechos humanos en Nicaragua. Informe presentado al Comité de Derechos Humanos. Managua : CENIDH.Google Scholar
Chinchilla, Laura. 2003. Experiences with Citizens’ Participation in Crime Prevention in Central America. In Crime and Violence in Latin America: Citizen Security, Democracy, and the State, ed. Frühling, Hugo, Tulchin, Joseph, and Golding, Heather. Baltimore : Johns Hopkins University Press. 205–32.Google Scholar
Comisión de Jefes y Jefas de Policía de Centroamérica y el Caribe. 2003. Estudio y evaluación de la actividad delictiva de las pandillas y/o maras. Panama : Comisión de Seguridad de Centroamérica.Google Scholar
Comisión de la Verdad. 1993. De la locura a la esperanza: la guerra de doce años en El Salvador. Informe de la Comisión de la Verdad para El Salvador. New York : United Nations.Google Scholar
Cruz, José Miguel. 1997. Los factores posibilitadores y las expresiones de la violencia en los noventa. Estudios Centroamericanos 52, 588: 977–92.Google Scholar
Cruz, José Miguel. 2007. Violence, Citizen Insecurity, and Elite Maneuvering in El Salvador. In Public Security and Police Reform in the Americas, ed. Bailey, John and Dammert, Lucia. Pittsburgh : University of Pittsburgh Press. 148–68.Google Scholar
Cruz, José Miguel. 2010a. Central American Maras: from Youth Gangs to Transnational Protection Rackets. Global Crime 11, 4: 379–98.Google Scholar
Cruz, José Miguel. 2010b. Police Misconduct and Democracy in Latin America. Americas-Barometer Insights 33: 1–5.Google Scholar
Cruz, José Miguel, de Castro, Rafael Fernández, and Santamaría, Gema. Forthcoming. Political Transition, Social Violence, and Gangs: Cases in Central America and Mexico. In In the Wake of War: Democratization and Internal Armed Conflict in Latin America, ed. Arnson, Cynthia. Washington , DC / Stanford : Woodrow Wilson Center Press/Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Cuadra, Elvira. 2002. Nuevas dimensiones de la seguridad ciudadana en Nicaragua. In Seguridad ciudadana, ¿euespejismo o realidad? ed. Carrión, F.. Quito : FLACSO and OPS/OMS.Google Scholar
Cuadra Lacayo, Joaquín. 2009. Retired general. Author interview. Managua, June.Google Scholar
Davis, Diane E. 2009. Non-State Armed Actors, New Imagined Communities, and the Shifting Patterns of Sovereignty and Insecurity in the Modern World. Contemporary Security Policy 30, 2: 221–45.Google Scholar
Diamond, Larry 2008. The Democratic Rollback: the Resurgence of the Predatory State. Foreign Affairs 87, 2: 36–48.Google Scholar
Dunkerley, James, and Sieder, Rachel. 1996. The Military: The Challenges of Transitions. In Central America: Fragile Transition, ed. Sieder, . London : Macmillan Press. 55–102.Google Scholar
The Economist. 2010. Reaching the Untouchables: Guatemala and Organised Crime. March 11.Google Scholar
Gavigan, Patrick. 2009. Organized Crime, Illicit Power Structures, and Guatemala's Threatened Peace Process. International Peacekeeping 16, 1: 62–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Godnick, William, Muggah, Robert, and Waszink, Camilla. 2002. Stray Bullets: The Impact of Small Arms Misuse in Central America. Occasional Paper no. 5. Geneva : Small Arms Survey.Google Scholar
Godoy, Angelina Snodgrass. 2006. Popular Injustice, Violence, Community, and Law in Latin America. Stanford : Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Haggard, Stephan, and Kaufman, Robert R.. 1997. The Political Economy of Democratic Transitions. Comparative Politics 9, 3: 263–83.Google Scholar
Hernández-Pico, Juan. 2002. The Armed Wings of the Hidden Powers in Action. Envío 249, April 2002. http://www.envio.org.ni/articulo/1572.Google Scholar
Holden, Robert H. 1996. Constructing the Limits of State Violence in Central America: towards a New Research Agenda. Journal of Latin American Studies 28, 2: 435–59.Google Scholar
Instituto de Derechos Humanos de la UCA (IDHUCA). 1997. Los derechos humanos en 1997. El Salvador Proceso 18, 788: 10–15.Google Scholar
International Human Rights Clinic. 2007. No Place to Hide: Gang, State, and Clandestine Violence in El Salvador. Report. Cambridge : Human Rights Program, Harvard Law School.Google Scholar
Joint Group for the Investigation of Illegal Armed Groups with Political Motivation in El Salvador. 1994. Report of the Joint Group for the Investigation of Illegal Armed Groups with Political Motivation in El Salvador. San Salvador : United Nations.Google Scholar
Jutersonke, Oliver, Muggah, Robert, and Rodgers, Dennis. 2009. Gangs, Urban Violence, and Security Interventions in Central America. Security Dialogue 40, 4–5: 373–97.Google Scholar
Karl, Terry Lynn. 1990. Dilemmas of Democratization in Latin America. Comparative Politics 23: 1–21.Google Scholar
Karl, Terry Lynn. 1995. The Hybrid Regimes of Central America. Journal of Democracy 6, 3: 72–86.Google Scholar
Karstedt, Susanne, and LaFree, Gary. 2006. Democracy, Crime, and Justice. Annals of the Academy of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 605: 6–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kincaid, Douglas, and Gamarra, Eduardo. 1996. Disorderly Democracy: Redefining Public Security in Latin America. In Latin America in the World Economy, ed. Korzeniewicz, Roberto P. and Smith, William C.. Wesport : Greenwood Press. 211–28.Google Scholar
Koonings, Kees. 2001. Armed Actors, Violence, and Democracy in Latin America in 1990s: Introductory Notes. Bulletin of Latin American Research 20, 4: 401–8.Google Scholar
Kruijt, Dirk. 2008. Guerrillas: War and Peace in Central America. New York : Zed Books.Google Scholar
LPG Datos. 2011. Homicidios en Centroamérica. ed. Gráfica, La Prensa. http://multimedia.laprensagrafica.com/pdf/2011/03/20110322-PDF-Informe-0311-Homicidios-en-Centroamerica.pdf.Google Scholar
Lungo, Mario, and Martel, Roxana. 2003. Ciudadania social y violencia en las ciudades centroamericanas. In Seguridad ciudadana: experiencias y desafíos, ed. Dammert, Lucia. Valparaíso : Programa URB-AL.Google Scholar
Mahoney, James. 2001. The Legacies of Liberalism: Path Dependence and Political Regimes in Central America. Baltimore : Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
McKinley, James C. 2007. In Guatemala, Officers’ Killings Echo Dirty War. New York times, March 5.Google Scholar
Meza, Víctor. 2004. Honduras: hacia una política integral de seguridad ciudadana. Tegucigalpa : CEDOH.Google Scholar
Moreno, Ismael. 2007. Insecurity, Criminality, Hidden Powers, and Visible Roots. Envío in English 312 (July). http://www.envio.org.ni/articulo/3607.Google Scholar
Moser, Caroline, and Winton, Ailsa. 2002. Violence in the Central American Region: Towards an Integrated Framework of Violence Reduction. Working Paper. London : Overseas Development Institute.Google Scholar
Neild, Rachel. 2002. Sustaining Reform: Democratic Policing in Central America. WOLA Briefing Series. Washington , DC : Washington Office on Latin America.Google Scholar
O'Donnell, Guillermo. 2004. Why the Rule of Law Matters. Journal of Democracy 15, 4: 32–46.Google Scholar
Oficina de Derechos Humanos del Arzobispado de Guatemala (ODHAG). 1998. Guatemala: nunca más. Donostia : Tercera Prensa.Google Scholar
Orozco, Roberto. 2009. Policía Nacional: ¿Una institucionalidad manoseada? Mirador de Seguridad. Revista del Instituto de Estudios Estratégicos y Políticas Públicas (February): 15–22.Google Scholar
Betancourt, Orozco, José, Roberto. 2007. Una visión exploratoria sobre la situación de seguridad en las costa caribe de Nicaragua. Managua : IEEPP.Google Scholar
Peacock, Susan C., and Beltrán, Adriana. 2003. Hidden Powers: Illegal Armed Groups on Post-Conflict Guatemala and the Forces Behind Them. WOLA Special Report. Washington , DC : Washington Office on Latin America.Google Scholar
Restrepo, Perea, Mario, Carlos. 2008. El frío del miedo. Violencia y cultura en México. Revista CIDOB d'Afers Internacionals 81: 17–43.Google Scholar
Programa de las Naciones Unidas para el Desarrollo (PNUD). 2005. Venciendo el temor: (in)seguridad ciudadana y desarrollo humano en Costa Rica. San José : PNUD Costa Rica.Google Scholar
Programa de las Naciones Unidas para el Desarrollo (PNUD). 2009. Informe sobre desarrollo humano para América Central 2009–2010. San José : PNUD.Google Scholar
Programa Estado de la Región, Costa Rica. 2008. Estado de la región en desarrollo humano sostenible: un informe desde Centroamérica y para Centroamérica. San José : Estado de la Nación.Google Scholar
Raudales, Magda. 2006. Honduras. In La cara de la violencia urbana en América Central, ed. Chavarría, Eugenia Zamora and Espinoza, Ana Yancy. San José : Fundación Arias para la Paz y el Progreso Humano. 201–43.Google Scholar
Rocha, José Luis. 2006. A Region Torn Apart: The Dynamics of Migration in Central America. San José : Lara Segura Editores.Google Scholar
Rocha, José Luis. 2007. Lanzando piedras, fumando piedras. Evolución de las pandillas en Nicaragua 1997–2006. Managua : UCA Publicaciones.Google Scholar
Rocha, José Luis, and Rodgers, Dennis. 2008. Bróderes descobijados y vagos alucinados. Una década con las pandillas nicaraguenses. Managua : Revista Envío.Google Scholar
Gómez, Rocha, Luis, José. 2007. Mapping the Labyrinth from within: the Political Economy of Nicaraguan Youth Policy concerning Violence. Bulletin of Latin American Research 26, 4: 533–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rodgers, Dennis. 2006a. Living in the Shadow of Death: Gangs, Violence, and Social Order in Nicaragua, 1996–2002. Journal of Latin American Studies 38: 267–92.Google Scholar
Rodgers, Dennis. 2006b. The State as a Gang: Conceptualizing the Governmentality of Violence in Contemporary Nicaragua. Critique of Anthropology 26, 6: 315–30.Google Scholar
Rodgers, Dennis. 2009. Slum Wars of the 21st Century: Gangs, Mano Dura, and the New Urban Geography of Conflict in Central America. Development and Change 40, 5: 949–76.Google Scholar
Rose, Richard, and Shin, Doh Chull. 2001. Democratization Backwards: the Problem of Third Wave Democracies. British Journal of Political Science 31: 331–54.Google Scholar
Rosenberg, Mark B. 1988. Narcos y Políticos: the Politics of Drug Trafficking in Honduras. Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs 30, 2–3: 143–65.Google Scholar
Ruhl, Mark J. 2000. Honduras: Militarism and Democratization in Troubled Waters. In Repression, Resistance, and Democratic Transitions in Central America, ed. Walker, Thomas and Armony, Ariel. Wilmington : Scholarly Resources. 47–66.Google Scholar
Salinas Maldonado, Carlos. 2010. Policía Nacional celebra 31 aniversario bajo señales confusas en su relación con el ejecutivo: jefatura de granera entra a la recta final. Confidencial Digital, September 5.Google Scholar
Samayoa, Claudia V. 2007. Las ejecuciones extrajudiciales de jóvenes estigmatizados. Guatemala : La Otra Mitá.Google Scholar
Schirmer, Jennifer. 1998. The Guatemalan Military Project: A Violence Called Democracy. Philadelphia : University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
Schlichte, Klaus. 2009. With the State against the State? the Formation of Armed Groups. Contemporary Security Policy 30, 2: 246–64.Google Scholar
Sieder, Rachel. 2001. War, Peace, and Memory Politics in Central America. In The Politics of Memory: Transitional Justice in Democratization Societies, ed. de Brito, Alexandra Barahona, González-Enríquez, Carmen, and Aguilar, Paloma. Oxford : Oxford University Press. 161–89.Google Scholar
Spalding, Rose J. 1999. From Low Intensity War to Low Intensity Peace: The Nicaraguan Peace Process. In Comparative Peace Processes in Latin America, ed. Arnson, Cynthia. Washington , DC : Woodrow Wilson Center Press. 31–64.Google Scholar
Spence, Jack. 2004. War and Peace in Central America: Comparing Transitions Toward Democracy and Social Equity in Guatemala, El Salvador, and Nicaragua. Brookline : Hemisphere Initiatives.Google Scholar
Stanley, William. 1993. Risking Failure: The Problems and Promise of the New Civilian Police in El Salvador. Washington , DC : Washington Office on Latin America/Hemisphere Initiatives.Google Scholar
Stanley, William. 1996. The Protection Racket State: Elite Politics, Military Extortion, and Civil War in El Salvador. Philadelphia : Temple University Press.Google Scholar
Stepan, Alfred. 1988. Rethinking Military Politics: Brazil and the Southern Cone. Princeton : Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tilly, Charles. 2003. The Politics of Collective Violence. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Torres Rivas, Edelberto. 2001. Foundations: Central America. In Democracy in Latin America: (Re)Constructing Political Society, ed. Garretón, Miguel Antonio and Newman, Edward. New York : United Nations University Press. 99–125.Google Scholar
del Arzobispado, Tutela Legal. 2007. La violencia homicida y otros patrones de grave afectación a los derechos humanos en El Salvador 2006. San Salvador : Comisión Arquidiocesana de Justicia y Paz.Google Scholar
Ungar, Mark. 2007. The Privatization of Citizen Security in Latin America: from Elite Guards to Neighborhood Vigilantes. Social Justice 34, 3–4: 20–34.Google Scholar
Ungar, Mark. 2009. Policing Youth in Latin America. In Youth Violence in Latin America: Gangs and Juvenile Justice in Perspective, ed. Jones, Gareth and Rodgers, Dennis. New York : Palgrave Macmillan. 201–24.Google Scholar
United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC). 2009. Annual Report of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and Reports of the Office of the High Commissioner and the Secretary-General. New York : United Nations Publications.Google Scholar
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC). 2007. Crime and Development in Central America: Caught in the Crossfire. New York : United Nations Publications.Google Scholar
U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID). 2006. Central America and Mexico Gang Assessment. Washington , DC : USAID Bureau for Latin American and Caribbean Affairs.Google Scholar
U.S. Department of State. 2008. Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2007. Washington , DC : Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor.Google Scholar
Vivas Lugo, René. 2009. La sobrevivencia como reto institucional. Mirador de Seguridad. Revista del Instituto de Estudios Estratégicos y Políticas Públicas (February): 27–30.Google Scholar
Williams, Philip J. 1994. Dual Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Popular and Electoral Democracy in Nicaragua. Comparative Politics 26, 2: 169–85.Google Scholar
Wood, Elisabeth Jean. 2005. Challenges to Political Democracy in El Salvador. In The Third Wave of Democratization in Latin America: Advances and Setbacks, ed. Hagopian, Frances and Mainwaring, Scott. New York : Cambridge University Press. 179–201.Google Scholar
Yashar, Deborah. 1999. Democracy, Indigenous Movements, and the Postliberal Challenge in Latin America. World Politics 52, 1: 76–104.Google Scholar
Zinecker, Heidrun. 2007. From Exodus to Exitus: Causes of Postwar Violence in El Salvador. PRIF Reports. Frankfurt : Peace Research Institute.Google Scholar