Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-cfpbc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T21:09:14.547Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

De Facto Demilitarization: Budget-Driven Downsizing in Latin America

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

Patrice Franko
Patrice Franko*
Affiliation:
Colby College (ME)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The international financial community has recently joined the arms control community in scrutinizing the relationship between military spending and economic growth. The Independent Group on Financial Flows to Developing Countries, headed by Helmut Schmidt, recommended (in Facing One World) that priority in financial assistance be given to countries that spend less than 2% of their gross domestic product (GDP) on security (The Economist, 1991a: 61). Robert McNamara, past president of the World Bank as well as a former US Secretary of Defense, supported this proposal in his speech before the World Bank Annual Conference on Development Economics (April 1991), recommending that military expenditures, as a percentage of GDP, be reduced by 50%. Nicole Ball, in Pressing for Peace: Can Aid Induce Reform?, argues cogently for conditioning international assistance on the initiation, or acceleration, of reforms in defense spending in the developing world (Ball, 1992).

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs , Volume 36 , Issue 1 , Spring 1994 , pp. 37 - 74
Copyright
Copyright © University of Miami 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ball, N. (1992) Pressing for Peace: Can Aid Induce Reform? Washington, DC: The Overseas Development Council.Google Scholar
Bitencourt, L. (1993) “Brazilian Strategic Leadership or Sunset?” Paper prepared for the Fourth Annual Workshop on “Latin American Security Issues: Values and Perspectives in Latin American-US Security Relations,” 23–25 May, Santa Fe, New Mexico.Google Scholar
Clarín, (1991) “Planos de Privatizatión.” (6 Maio).Google Scholar
Dorin, F., (1991) “Fuerzas Armadas: reestructuración y presupuesto.” Nuevo Proyecto 7–8.Google Scholar
(The) Economist (1991) “Let them eat guns.” (2 November): 6l. The Economic Intelligence Unit (Eiu) (1991) “Chile: A Country Report” (No. 4). London, England: EIU Ltd.Google Scholar
Fitch, J.S. (1993) draft paper entitled “The Decline of US Military Influence in Latin America.” [A revised version of this paper was published in the Summer 1993 issue (Vol.35, No.2) of the Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs.]Google Scholar
Fitch, J.S. (1989) “Military Professionalism, National Security and Democracy: Lessons from the Latin American Experience,” Pacific Focus IV, 2 (Fall): 99–147.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service - Latin America (FBIS-LAT) (1994a) “Workers Party Military Policy Outlined,” Folha de São Paulo, 31 January, in FBIS-LAT-94-022 (2 February): 6.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1994b) “Special Report on the Armed Forces,” Veja, 2 February, in FBIS-LAT-94-028 (10 February): 68–77.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1993a) “Secretariat Analyzes Reasons for Military ‘Dissatisfaction,'” O Estado de São Paulo, 30 May, in FBIS-LAT-93-104 (3 June): 7.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1993b) “Ex-Navy Minister ‘Frustrated’ About ‘Low’ Military Salaries,” O Estado de São Paulo, 19 May, in FBIS-LAT-93-097 (21 May): 22.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1993c) “Defense Minister Denies Armed Forces ‘Defenseless,'” reported on Buenos Aires TELAM, 21:10 GMT, 15 April, in FBIS-LAT-93-073 (19 April): 28.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1993d) “Army Offers to Help Implement Social Projects,” O Globo, 17 January, in FBIS-LAT-93-011 (19 January): 42.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1993e) Clarion, 14 December, in FBIS-LAT-93-241 (17 December): 3.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1993e) “Salary Hike for Military Employees,” Buenos Aires, NoticiasArgentinas,01:17GMT, 28 December, in FBIS-LAT-93-248 (29 December): 14.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1992a) “Guidelines issued for the Army High Command,” O Estado de São Paulo, 19 November, in FBIS-LAT-92-226, (23 November): 4.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1992b)“Army Minister on Proposed Defense Ministry,” Folha de São Paulo, 14 October, in FBIS-LAT-92-202 (19 October): 12.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1992c) “Policy Priorities of Military Ministers Viewed,” Gazeta Mercantil, 9 October, in FBIS-LAT-92-209 (28 October): 1,6.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1992d) “Priority Concerns of Armed Forces Discussed,” Brasilia Voz do Brazil Network, 2200 GMT, 9 July, in FBIS-LAT-92-133 GO July): 025.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1992e)“Army ‘Editorial’ Criticizes Unequal Salaries,” O Globo, 1 May, in FBIS-LAT-92-087 (5 May):27.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1992f)“Impact of Military Budget Cuts Surveyed,” Istoé Senhor, 22 April, in FBIS-LAT-92-107 (3 June): 26–29.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1992g) “Borja Hears Complaints About Miltary Salaries,” O Globo, 15 April, in FBIS-LAT-92-076 (20 April): 18.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1991a) Armed Forces Said Experiencing Raison D'etre,” Estado de São Paulo, 8 December, in FBIS-LAT-91-242 (17 December): 4.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1991b) “New Army Chief of Staff Balza on Army Role,” Buenos Aires Telam 12:55 GMT, 17 November, in FBIS-LAT-91-223 (19 November): 18.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1991c) “Olazabal (Planning Secretary) Views Military Industry Privatization,” Buenos Aires Telam 23:45 GMT, 14 November, in FBIS-LAT-91-222 (18 November): 40.Google Scholar
Foreign Broadcast Information Service (1991d) “Armed Forces to Sell Real Estate Properties,” Somos, 22 July, in FBIS-LAT-91-171 (4 September): 29.Google Scholar
Fraga, R. (1992a) Interview with author, Buenos Aires (29 July).Google Scholar
Fraga, R. (1992b) “La Crise de Brasil,” La Nacion (26 July).Google Scholar
Fraga, R. (1991) Menem y la Cuestión Militar. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Centro de Estudios Union para la Nueva Mayoría.Google Scholar
Franko-Jones, P. (1992) The Brazilian Defense Industry. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Franko-Jones, P. and R. Dagnino (1992) “Membership in the First World Geostrategic Club: Possibilities for Brazil.” Defense Analysis 8, 3 (December): 277–294.Google Scholar
Fuentes, C (1993) “Perspectivas de los Temas de Seguridad en Chile,” working paper prepared for the Fourth Annual Workshop on Latin American Security Issues: Values and Perspectives in Latin American-U.S. Security Relations, 23–25 May, Santa Fe, New Mexico.Google Scholar
Fuentes, C (1991) “Debateen Torno Al Gasto Militar: Nuev as Perspectivas,” Fuerzas Armadas y Sociedad 6, 4, (Oct-Dec).Google Scholar
Fuerzas Armadas y Sociedad, (1991) “Cronologia: Septiembre-Diciembre 1991,” Vol. 6, No. 4 (Oct-Dec).Google Scholar
Gupta, A (1993) “Third World Militaries: New Suppliers, Deadlier Weapons,” Orbis 37, 1 (Winter): 57–68.Google Scholar
Hewitt, D. (1991) “Military Expenditure: International Comparison of Trends.” IMF Working Paper (WP/91/54), May.Google Scholar
Hunter, W. (1993) “The Brazilian Military After the Cold War,” working paper prepared for the Fourth Annual Workshop on Latin American Security Issues: Values and Perspectives in Latin American-US Security Relations, 23–25 May, Santa Fe, New Mexico.Google Scholar
Istoe (1993) “ A Caserna no Sufoco.” (21 Julio) 34–41.Google Scholar
Latin American Weekly Report (LAWR) (1991a) “Pay award follows spate of unrest.” WR-91-40 (17 October): 10.Google Scholar
Latin American Weekly Report (LAWR) (1991b) “Funding comes under debate,” WR-91-33 (29 August).Google Scholar
Latin American Weekly Report (LAWR) (1991c) “Paring defence to the very bone,” WR-91-23 (20 June).Google Scholar
Latin American Weekly Report (LAWR) (1991d) “Crisis for Cavallo as funds run out,” WR-91-22 (13 June).Google Scholar
Latin American Weekly Report (LAWR) (1991e) “Condor plus pay spells unrest,” WR-91-20 (30 May).Google Scholar
Lopez, E (1990) “Argentina: Desarme de Hecho y Cooperation Para la Paz,” paper for the XII Reunion de Rial (Relaciones Internationales de America Latina), held at Santiago de Chile, 21–25 Octubre.Google Scholar
Loveman, B (1991) “¿Mision Cumplida? Civil Military Relations and the Chilean Political Transition.” Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs 33, 3 (Fall): 35–74.Google Scholar
McNamara, R. (1991) “Reducing Military Expenditures in the Third World.” Finance and Development 28, 3 (September): 26–28.Google Scholar
Myers, D.J. (1991) “Brazil: The Quest for South American Leadership,” pp. 225–268 in Myers, D. (ed) Regional Hegemons: Threat Perception and Strategic Response. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Norden, D. (1990) “Democratic Consolidation and Military Professionalism: Argentina in the 1980s.” Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs 32, 3 (Fall): 151–176.Google Scholar
Odom, W. (Lt. Gen.) (1993) “US Military Assistance After the Cold War.” Testimony before the US Senate Foreign Relations Sub-Committee on International Economic Policy, Trade, Oceans and Environment (16 June), 103rd Congress, 1st session.Google Scholar
Patino, H. M. (1993) “Support for a New Concept of Hemisphere Security” (draft document; 17 May). Permanent Council of the Organization of American States (OAS). Washington, DC: OAS.Google Scholar
Pion-Berlin, D. (1991) “Between Confrontation and Accommodation: Military and Government Policy in Democratic Argentina.” Journal of Latin American Studies 23 (October): 543–571.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rojas, F. A. (1993) “Regimes de Seguridad en el Hemisferio Occidental, Una Perspectiva Desde America Latina.” Paper prepared for the conference on “Security, Democracy and Development in the Western Hemisphere,” North-South Center, University of Miami (FL), 25–27 February.Google Scholar
Scheetz, T. (1992) “The Evolution of Public Sector Expenditures: Changing Political Priorities in Argentina, Chile, Paraguay and Peru.” Journal of Peace Research 29, 2 (May): 175–190.Google Scholar
Scheetz, T. (1990) “Military Expenditures in Argentina, Chile and Peru,” pp. 228–252 in Hartley, K. and Sandler, T. (eds.) The Economics of Defense Spending. London, England: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Scheetz, T. (1985) “Gastos Militares en Chile, Peru y La Argentina.” Desarrollo Económico 25, 99 (Octubre-Diciembre): 315–327.Google Scholar
Socrates DA Costa Monteiro, (1991) “Estamos preparados.” Veja 13 (March): 86.Google Scholar
Varas, A. (1993) “Intereses de Seguridady Percepciones de Amenaza en el Hemisferio Occidental en la Post Guerra Fria.” Paper prepared for the International Conference on “Security, Democracy and Development in the Western Hemisphere,” North-South Center, University of Miami (FL), 25–27 February.Google Scholar
Varas, A. (1990) “Civil-Military Relations in a Democratic Framework,” pp. 199–218 in Goodman, L., J. Mendelson, and J. Rial (eds) The Military and Democracy: The Future of Civil-Military Relations in Latin America. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
Villar Rojas, C. (1992) “Gasto militar, tema de reflexion.” Memorial de Ejército (Chile) Primero Semester (Abril): 102–121.Google Scholar