Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-pfhbr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T11:25:12.436Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Imaginary Phrygians: Cognitive Consonance and the Assumed Phrygian Origin of Greek Ecstatic Cults and Music

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 July 2021

Yulia Ustinova
Yulia Ustinova*
Affiliation:
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev*
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

While Greeks called the ecstatic musical mode ‘Phrygian’, there is no evidence of high-arousal musical performances in Phrygia, and the musical characteristics of this mode were distinctively Greek. The image of wide-ranging excited celebrations practised in Phrygia seems to have existed only in the imagination of the Greeks and Romans. This paper suggests that the uneasiness felt by some Greeks facing high-arousal cults was assuaged by attributing them foreign origin, which was often fictitious. By culturally dissociating themselves from the ecstatic practices, the Greeks resolved the cognitive inconsistency between their self-perception as citizens of the decorous civilized world and their surrender to the irresistible allure of high-arousal cults and music. These false attitudes allowed cognitive consonance and attained the status of indubitable truth. Upheld throughout antiquity, they persuaded many modern scholars, who still mistakenly consider the Phrygian musical mode as an Oriental borrowing.

Keywords

Phrygian modeecstatic cultsCybeleMagna Matercognitive consonance
Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Hellenic Studies , Volume 141 , November 2021 , pp. 54 - 73
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

yulia@bgu.ac.il. I am very grateful to the anonymous reviewers of this paper for their insightful comments, and to Carolyn Gross-Baruch for polishing my English.

References

Alexandrescu Vianu, M. (1980) ‘Sur la diffusion du culte de Cybèle dans le bassin de la Mer Noire à l’époque archaïque’, Dacia 24, 261–65 Google Scholar
Alvar, J. (2008) Romanising Oriental Gods: Myth, Salvation, and Ethics in the Cults of Cybele, Isis, and Mithras (Leiden)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anderson, W.D. (1966) Ethos and Education in Greek Music (Cambridge MA)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anderson, W.D. (1994) Music and Musicians in Ancient Greece (Ithaca)Google Scholar
Ariely, D. (2008) Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces that Shape our Decisions (New York)Google Scholar
Barker, A. (1989) Greek Musical Writings (Cambridge)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barker, A. (2018a) ‘Disreputable music: a performance, a defence, and their intertextual and intermedial resonances (Plutarch Quaest. conv. 704c4–705b6)’, in Phillips, T. and D’Angour, A. (eds), Music, Text, and Culture in Ancient Greece (Oxford) 233–55Google Scholar
Barker, A. (2018b) ‘Migrating musical myths: the case of the Libyan aulos', GRMuS 6.1, 1–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Battezzato, L. (2005) ‘The new music of the Trojan women’, Lexis 23, 73–104 Google Scholar
Bélis, A. (1986a) Aristoxène de Tarente et Aristote: le traité d’harmonique (Paris) Google Scholar
Bélis, A. (1986b) ‘L’aulos phrygien’, RA, 21–40 Google Scholar
Bélis, A. (1999) Les musiciens dans l’Antiquité (Paris)Google Scholar
Bélis, A. (2003) ‘Harmonics’, in Brunschwig, J. and Lloyd, G.E.R. (eds), The Greek Pursuit of Knowledge (Cambridge MA) 161–76Google Scholar
Berndt-Ersöz, S. (2006) Phrygian Rock-Cut Shrines: Structure, Function, and Cult Practice (Leiden)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berndt-Ersöz, S. (2015) ‘Noise-making rituals in Iron Age Phrygia’, in Sporn, K., Ladstätter, S. and Kerschner, M. (eds), Natur-Kult-Raum: Akten des internationalen Kolloquiums Paris-Lodron-Universität Salzburg (Vienna) 29–44Google Scholar
Bøgh, B. (2007) ‘The Phrygian background of Kybele’, Numen 54, 304–39 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Borgeaud, P. (1996) Mother of the Gods: From Cybele to the Virgin Mary (Baltimore)Google Scholar
Brand, H. (2000) Griechische Musikanten im Kunst: von der Frühzeit bis zum Beginn der Spätklassik (Dettel-bach)Google Scholar
Brixhe, C. (1979) ‘Le nom de Cybèle’, Die Sprache 25, 40–45 Google Scholar
Bryce, T. (2002) Life and Society in the Hittite World (Oxford)Google Scholar
Budelmann, F. and LeVen, P. (2014) ‘Timotheus’ poetics of blending: a cognitive approach to the language of the New Music’, CPh 109, 191–210 Google Scholar
Bundrick, S.D. (2005) Music and Image in Classical Athens (Cambridge)Google Scholar
Burkert, W. (1985) Greek Religion (Cambridge MA)Google Scholar
Carastro, M. (2006) La cité des mages: penser la magie en Grèce ancienne (Grenoble)Google Scholar
Chiekova, D. (2008) Cultes et vie religieuse des cités grecques du Pont Gauche (VIIe-Ier siècle av. J.-C.) (Bern)Google Scholar
Comotti, G. (1989) Music in Greek and Roman Culture (Baltimore)Google Scholar
Cordano, F. (2004) ‘La musica e la politica, ovverto gli auloi ad Atene’, Quaderni di acme 68, 309–25 Google Scholar
Csapo, E. (2004) ‘The politics of the New Music’, in Murray, P. and Wilson, P. (eds), Music and the Muses: The Culture of Mousike in the Classical Athenian City (Oxford) 207–48 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cumont, F. (1929) Les religions orientales dans le paganisme romain (Paris)Google Scholar
Davidson, J. (1997) Courtesans and Fishcakes: The Consuming Passions of Classical Athens (London) de Martino, S. (1995) ‘Music, dance, and processions in Hittite Anatolia’, in Sasson, J.M. (ed.), Civilizations of the Ancient Near East 4 (New York) 2661–69 Google Scholar
Detienne, M. (1986) ‘Dionysos et ses parousies: un dieu épidémique’, L’assocition dionysiaque dans les sociétés anciennes (Rome) 53–83Google Scholar
Devine, P.G. (1989) ‘Stereotypes and prejudice: their automatic and controlled components’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 56, 5–18 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dubosson-Sbriglione, L. (2018) Le culte de la Mère des dieux dans l’Empire romain (Stuttgart)Google Scholar
Fachner, J.C. (2011) ‘Time is the key: music and altered states of consciousness’, in Cardena, E. and Winkelman, M. (eds), Altering Consciousness: Multidisciplinary Perspectives 1: History, Culture, and the Humanities (Santa Barbara) 355–76 Google Scholar
Fauconnier, G. (2018) Ten Lectures on Cognitive Construction of Meaning (Leiden)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fauconnier, G. and Turner, M. (2002) The Way We Think: Conceptual Blending and the Minds Hidden Complexities (New York)Google Scholar
Faulkner, A. (2011) ‘Introduction’, in Faulkner, A. (ed.), The Homeric Hymns: Interpretative Essays (Oxford) 1–25Google Scholar
Festinger, L. (1957) Theory of Cognitive Dissonance (Evanston)Google Scholar
Figari, J. (2006) ‘Musique et médicine dans la philosophie présocratique’, in Mortir-Waldschmidt, O. (ed.), Musique et antiquité (Paris) 121–45Google Scholar
Fiske, S.T. and Taylor, S.E. (2013) Social Cognition: From Brains to Culture (London)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Franklin, J.C. (2008) ‘“A feast of music”: the Greco-Lydian musical movement on the Assyrian periphery’, in Collins, B.J., Bacharova, M.R. and Rutherford, I.C. (eds), Anatolian Interfaces: Hittites, Greeks and Their Neighbours (Oxford) 191–201 Google Scholar
Franklin, J.C. (2011) ‘Aulos’, in Finkelberg, M. (ed.), The Homer Encyclopedia (Chichester and Malden MA) 119–20 Google Scholar
Gabbay, U. (2014) ‘The balag instrument and its role in the cult of ancient Mesopotamia’, in Westenholz, J.G., Maurey, Y. and Seroussi, E. (eds), Music in Antiquity: The Near East and the Mediterranean (Berlin and Jerusalem) 129–47 Google Scholar
Gawronski, B. and Strack, F. (2012) ‘Cognitive consistence as a basic principle of social information processing’, in Gawronski, B. and Strack, F. (eds), Cognitive Consistence: A Fundamental Principle in Social Condition (New York and London) 1–16 Google Scholar
Gerhard, Y. (1955) ‘Aulos’, in Snell, B. (ed.), Lexikon des frügriechischen Epos 1 (Gottingen) 1555-57 Goldin, O. (2015) ‘The Pythagorean table of opposites, symbolic classification, and Aristotle’, Science in Context 28.2, 171–93 Google Scholar
Graf, F. (1984) ‘The arrival of Cybele in the Greek East’, in Harmatta, J. (ed.), Proceedings of the VlIth Congress of the International Federation of the Societies of Classical Studies 1 (Budapest) 116–24 Google Scholar
Graf, F. (1995) ‘Excluding the charming: the development of the Greek concept of magic’, in Meyer, M. and Mirecki, P. (eds), Ancient Magic and Ritual Power (Leiden) 29–60 Google Scholar
Graf, F. and Johnston, S.I. (2007) Ritual Texts for the Afterlife: Orpheus and the Bacchic Gold Leaves (London and New York)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Graillot, H. (1912) Le culte de Cybèle, Mère des dieux, à Rome et dans l’Empire romaine (Paris)Google Scholar
Griffith, M. (2013) ‘Cretan harmonies and universal morals: early music and migrations of wisdom in Plato’s Laws’, in Peponi, A.-E. (ed.), Performance and Culture in Plato’s Laws (Cambridge) 15–66 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guarducci, M. (1970) ‘Cibele in un’ epigrafe arcaica di Locri Epizefiri’ Klio 52, 133–38 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Güterbock, H.G. (1995) ‘Reflections on the musical instruments arkammi, galgalturi, and huhupal in Hittite’, in van den Hout, T.P.J. and de Roos, J. (eds), Studio historiae ardens: Ancient Near Eastern Studies Presented to Philo H.J. Houwink ten Cate on the Occasion of His 65th Birthday (Leiden) 57–72Google Scholar
Hall, E. (1988) ‘When did the Trojans turn into Phrygians?’ ZPE 73, 15–18 Google Scholar
Hall, E. (1989) Inventing the Barbarian: Greek Self-Definition through Tragedy (Oxford)Google Scholar
Halliwell, S. (2011) Between Ecstasy and Truth: Interpretations of Greek Poetics from Homer to Longinus (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hanfmann, G.M.A. (1983) Sardis from Prehistoric to Roman Times (Cambridge MA)Google Scholar
Heintz, C. (2011) ‘Cognitive history and cultural epidemiology’, in Martin, L.H. and Sørensen, J. (eds), Past Minds: Studies in Cognitive Historiography (London) 11–28 Google Scholar
Henrichs, A. (1976) ‘Despoina Kybele: ein Beitrag zur religiösen Namenkunde’, HSPh 80, 253–86 Google Scholar
Hoffmann, H. (1997) Sotades: Symbols of Immortality on Greek Vases (Oxford)Google Scholar
Ito, T.A., Willadsen-Jensen, E. and Correll, J. (2007) ‘New perspectives on categorization, prejudice, and stereotyping’, in Harmon-Jones, E. and Winkielman, P. (eds), Social Neuroscience: Integrating Biological and Psychological Explanations of Social Behavior (New York and London) 401–21 Google Scholar
Jackson, L.M. (2011) The Psychology of Prejudice: From Attitudes to Social Action (Washington DC)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Janko, R. (1982) Homer, Hesiod and the Hymns: Diachronic Development in Epic Diction (Cambridge)Google Scholar
Jeanmaire, H. (1970) Dionysos: histoire du culte de Bacchus (Paris)Google Scholar
Jourdain, R. (1997) Music, the Brain, and Ecstasy: How Music Captures our Imagination (New York)Google Scholar
Kilmer, A.D. (1995) ‘Music and dance in ancient Western Asia’, in Sasson, J.M. (ed.), Civilizations of the Ancient Near East 4 (New York) 2601–13 Google Scholar
Kraut, R. (1997) Aristotle: Politics Books VII and VIII (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lancelotti, M.G. (2002) Attis: Between Myth and History: King, Priest and God (Leiden)Google Scholar
Landels, J.G. (1999) Music in Ancient Greece and Rome (London)Google Scholar
Lane, E.N. (1996) ‘The name of Cybele’s priests the “Galloi”’, in Lane, E.N. (ed.), Cybele, Attis, and Related Cults: Essays in Memory of M.J. Vermaseren (Leiden) 117–34 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laroche, E. (1960) ‘Koubaba, déesse anatolienne, et le problème des origines de Cybèle’, in Éléments orientaux dans le religion grecque ancienne: colloque de Strasboug (Strasbourg) 113–28 Google Scholar
Larson, J. (2016) Understanding Greek Religion: A Cognitive Approach (London)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lasserre, F. (1954) Plutarque, De la musique: texte, traduction, commentaire précédés d’une étude sur l’éducation musicale dans la Grèce antiquen (Lausanne)Google Scholar
Leclercq-Neveu, B. (1989) ‘Marsyas, le martyr de l’aulos’ Métis 4, 251–68 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levick, B. (2013) ‘In the Phrygian mode: a region seen from without’, in Thonemann, P. (ed.), Roman Phrygia: Culture and Society (Cambridge) 41–54 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levitin, D. (2006) This is Your Brain on Music: Understanding a Human Obsession (London)Google Scholar
Lucarini, C.M. and Moreschini, C. (eds) (2013) Hermias, In Platonis Phaedrum Scholia (Berlin)Google Scholar
Lynch, T. (2018) ‘The seductive voice of the aulos in Plato’s Symposium: from the dismissal of the auletris to Alcibiades’ praise of Socrates-auletes’, in Baldassarre, A. and Markovic, T. (eds), Music Cultures in Sounds, Words and Images (Vienna) 709–23 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lynch, T. (2020) ‘“Tuning the lyre, tuning the soul”: harmonia, justice and the kosmos of the soul in Plato’s Republic and Timaeus’, GRMuS 8.1, 111–55 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marek, C. (2016 ) In the Land of a Thousand Gods (Princeton)Google Scholar
Martin, L.H. and Leopold, A.M. (2008) ‘New approaches to the study of syncretism’, in Antes, P., Geertz, A.W. and Warne, R.R. (eds), New Approaches to the Study of Religion’ (Berlin and New York) 93–107 Google Scholar
Martin, R.P. (2003) ‘The pipes are brawling: conceptualizing musical performance in Athens’, in Dougherty, C. and Kurke, L. (eds), The Cultures within Ancient Greek Culture (Cambridge) 153–80 Google Scholar
Menier, T. (2001) ‘L’étrangeté dionysiaque’, in Brulé, P. and Vendries, C. (eds), Chanter les dieux: musique et religion dans l’Antiquité grecque et romaine (Rennes) 233–41 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mirelman, S. (2014) ‘The ala-instrument: its identification and role’, in Westenholz, J.G., Maurey, Y. and Seroussi, E. (eds), Music in Antiquity: The Near East and the Mediterranean (Berlin and Jerusalem) 148–71 Google Scholar
Moutsopoulos, E. (1959) La musique dans l’oeuvre de Platon (Paris)Google Scholar
Munn, M. (2006) The Mother of the Gods, Athens, and the Tyranny of Asia: A Study of Sovereignty in Ancient Religion (Berkeley and Los Angeles)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Munn, M. (2008) ‘Kybele as Kubaba in a Lydo-Phrygian context’, in Collins, B.J., Bacharova, M.R. and Rutherford, I.C. (eds), Anatolian Interfaces: Hittites, Greeks and Their Neighbours (Oxford) 159–64 Google Scholar
Naumann, F. (1983) Die Ikonographie der Kybele in derphrygischen und der griechischen Kunst (Tübingen)Google Scholar
Nisbett, R. and Ross, L. (1980) Human Inference: Strategies and Shortcomings of Social Judgement (Englewood Cliffs)Google Scholar
Olson, S.D. (2011) Athenaeus: The Learned Banqueters 7 (Cambridge MA)Google Scholar
Otto, W.F. (1933) Dionysos: Mythos und Kultus (Frankfurt)Google Scholar
Payne, B.K. (2001) ‘Prejudice and perception: the role of automatic and controlled processes in misperceiving a weapon’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81, 181–92 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Pirenne-Delforge, V. (2010) ‘Flourishing Aphrodite: an overview’, in Smith, A.C. and Pickup, S. (eds), Brill ’s Companion to Aphrodite (Leiden) 3–16 Google Scholar
Pirenne-Delforge, V. and Papadopoulou, Z. (2001) ‘Inventer et réinventer l’aulos: autour de la XIIe Pythique de Pindare', in Brulé, P. and Vendries, C. (eds), Chanter les dieux: musique et religion dans l’Antiquité grecque et romaine (Rennes) 37–58 Google Scholar
Provenza, A. (2016) La medicina delle Muse: la musica come cura nella Grecia antica (Rome)Google Scholar
Robertson, N. (1996) ‘The ancient Mother of Gods: a missing chapter in the history of Greek religion’, in Lane, E.N. (ed.), Cybele, Attis, and Related Cults (Leiden) 239–304 Google Scholar
Roller, L.E. (1994) ‘Attis on Greek votive monuments: Greek god or Phrygian?', Hesperia 63, 245–62 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roller, L.E. (1999) In Search of God the Mother: The Cult of Anatolian Cybele (Berkeley and Los Angeles)Google Scholar
Rouget, G. (1990) La musique et la trance (Paris)Google Scholar
Scherer, K.R. and Coutinho, E. (2013) ‘How music creates emotion: multifactorial process approach’, in Cochrane, T., Fantini, B. and Scherer, K.R. (eds), The Emotional Power of Music: Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Musical Arousal, Expression, and Social Control (Oxford) 121–45 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shorey, P. (1969) Plato, Republic 5 and 6 (Cambridge MA and London)Google Scholar
Seaford, R. (1994) Reciprocity and Ritual: Homer and Tragedy in the Developing City-State (Oxford)Google Scholar
Sfameni Gasparro, G. (1985) Soteriology and Mystic Aspects in the Cult of Cybele and Attis (Leiden)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Siegel, S. (2017) The Rationality of Perception (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, J.O. (1996) ‘The high priests of the temple ofArtemis at Ephesus’, in Lane, E.A. (ed.), Cybele, Attis, and Related Cults: Essays in Memory of M.J. Vermaseren (Leiden) 323–36 Google Scholar
Sourvinou-Inwood, C. (2005) Hylas, the Nymphs, Dionysus and Others (Stockholm)Google Scholar
Sperber, D. (2006) ‘The epistemology of beliefs: a naturalistic approach’, in Slone, D.J. (ed.), Religion and Cognition: A Reader (London) 36–53Google Scholar
Spinelli, E. (2016) ‘“Are flute-players better than philosohers?” Sextus Empiricus on music, against Pythagoras’, in Renger, A.-B. and Stavru, A. (eds), Pythagorean Knowledge from the Ancient to the Modern World: Askesis, Religion, Science (Wiesbaden) 305–18 Google Scholar
Taylor, P. (2008) ‘The GALA and the Gallos’, in Collins, B.J., Bacharova, M.R. and Rutherford, I.C. (eds), Anatolian Interfaces: Hittites, Greeks and Their Neighbours (Oxford) 173–80 Google Scholar
Thiemer, H. (1979) Der Einfluß der Phryger auf die altgriechische Musik (Bonn and Bad Godesberg)Google Scholar
Ustinova, Y. (2018) Divine Mania: Alteration of Consciousness in Ancient Greece (London)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vermaseren, M.J. (1977) Cybele and Attis: The Myth and the Cult (London)Google Scholar
Vernant, J.-P. (1980) Myth and Society in Ancient Greece (Brighton)Google Scholar
Versnel, H.S. (1990) Ter Unus: Isis, Dionysos, Hermes: Three Studies in Henotheism (Leiden)Google Scholar
Vinogradov, J.G. and Kryzickij, S.D. (1995) Olbia (Mnemosyne Supplement 129) (Leiden)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wallace, R.W. (2004) ‘Damon of Oa: a music theorist ostracised’, in Murray, P. and Wilson, P. (eds), Music and the Muses: The Culture of Mousike in the Classical Athenian City (Oxford) 249–67 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wallace, R.W. (2015) Reconstructing Damon: Music, Wisdom Teaching, and Politics in Pericles’ Athens (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wathelet, P. (1991) ‘Dionysos chez Homère ou la folie divine’, Kernos 4, 61–82 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
West, M.L. (1981) ‘The singing of Homer and the modes of early Greek music’, JHS 101, 113–29 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
West, M.L. (1984) ‘Music in Archaic Greece’, in Harmatta, J. (ed.), Proceedings of the VIIth Congress of the International Federation of the Societies of Classical Studies 1 (Budapest) 213–20 Google Scholar
West, M.L. (1992) Ancient Greek Music (Oxford)Google Scholar
West, M.L. (2000) ‘Music therapy in antiquity’, in Horden, P. (ed.), Music as Medicine: The History of Music Therapy since Antiquity (Aldershot) 51–68 Google Scholar
Wilson, P. (1999) ‘The aulos in Athens’, in Goldhill, S. and Osborne, R. (eds), Performance Culture and Athenian Democracy (Cambridge) 58–95 Google Scholar
Wilson, P. (2007) ‘Pronomos and Potamon: two pipers and two epigrams’ JHS 127, 141–49 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Winnington-Ingram, R.P. (1936) Mode in Ancient Greek Music (Cambridge)Google Scholar
Xagorari-Gleissner, M. (2008) Meter Theon: die Göttermutter bei den Griechen (Ruhpolding)Google Scholar
Zschätzsch, A. (2002) Verwendung und Bedeutung griechischer Musikinstrumente in Mythos und Kult (Rahden)Google Scholar