Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-42gr6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-20T03:08:09.331Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Catholic Interests and the Politics of English Overseas Expansion 1660–1689

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 October 2016

Gabriel Glickman
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Throughout the reign of Charles II, a growing number of Catholics entered into the civil and military infrastructure of the overseas colonies. While Maryland was consolidated as a center of settlement, a new crop of English and Irish officeholders shaped the political development of Tangier, New York and the Leeward Islands. Their careers highlighted the opportunities of overseas expansion as a route into the public domain: a chance for Catholics to sidestep the penal restrictions of the three kingdoms and construct an alternative relationship with the crown. This article examines the emergence of Catholic authority within the plantations, and situates the experiment within larger shifts in strategic and ideological debate over English colonization. I suggest that experiences in the colonies invigorated economic and political strategies that became central to the advancement of Catholic interests in the domestic realm. While colonial trade bolstered Catholic estates against penal pressures, the new settlements provided the training ground for attempts to demonstrate the compatibility of confessional pluralism with commercial flourishing and civil allegiance. The effect, however, was to raise conflict in colonial politics and heighten anxieties in the domestic realm over the effects of overseas plantation. I argue that by uncovering a neglected sphere of “recusant history” we gain new insights into the ideological fragilities that disrupted the pursuit of territories overseas. Catholic promotions exposed a growing tension between the “Protestant interest” and the principles and practices that informed the expansion of the Stuart realm.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 55 , Issue 4 , October 2016 , pp. 680 - 708
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Kupperman, K. O., “Errand to the Indies: Puritan Colonization from Providence Island through the Western Design,” William and Mary Quarterly 45, no. 1 (January 1988): 70–99 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Armitage, David, Ideological Origins of the British Empire (Cambridge, 2000), 61–63 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 173; Pestana, Carla Gardina, Protestant Empire: Religion and the Making of the British Atlantic World (Philadelphia, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Wilson, Kathleen, The Sense of the People: Politics, Culture and Imperialism in England 1715–1775 (Cambridge, 1995)Google Scholar.

3 Deane, Seamus, “Introduction,” in Nationalism, Colonialism and Literature, ed. Eagleton, Terry, Jameson, Frederick, and Said, Edward (Minneapolis, 1990), 3–19 Google Scholar; Colley, Linda, Britons: Forging the Nation (London, 1992), 11–71 Google Scholar; Williams, Eric, Capitalism and Slavery (London, 1994), 3–30 Google Scholar.

4 Questier, Michael C., Catholicism and Community in Early Modern England: Politics, Aristocratic Patronage and Religion c. 1550–1640 (Cambridge, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Baker, Geoff, Reading and Politics in Early Modern England: The Mental World of a Seventeenth-Century Catholic Gentleman (Manchester, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Bowden, Caroline and Kelly, James, eds., The English Colleges in Exile 1600–1800: Communities, Culture and Identity (Farnham, 2013)Google Scholar; Corens, Liesbeth, “Saints Beyond Borders: Relics and the Expatriate English Catholic Community,” in Exile and Religious Identity, 1500–1800, ed. Spohnholz, Jesse and Waite, Gary K. (London, 2014), 25–38 Google Scholar.

6 Cullen, L. M., “Galway Merchants in the Outside World, 1650–1800,” in Economy, Trade and Irish Merchants at Home and Abroad, 1600–1988, ed. Cullen, L. M. (Dublin, 2012), 169–81Google Scholar; Truxes, Thomas M., Irish-American Trade, 1660–1783 (Cambridge, 1988)Google Scholar; Akenson, Donald H., If the Irish Ran the World: Montserrat 1630–1730 (Liverpool, 1997)Google Scholar; Shaw, Jenny and Block, Kristen, “Subjects without an Empire: The Irish in the Early Modern Caribbean,” Past and Present 210, no. 1 (February 2011): 33–60 Google Scholar.

7 Most recently Farrelly, Maura Jane, Papist Patriots: The Making of an American Catholic Identity (Oxford, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Krugler, John, English and Catholic: The Lords Baltimore in the Seventeenth Century (Baltimore, 2004)Google Scholar.

8 Stein, Tristan, “Tangier in the Restoration Empire,” Historical Journal 54, no. 4 (December 2011): 985–1011 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Games, Alison, The Web of Empire: English Cosmopolitans in an Age of Expansion, 1560–1660 (Oxford, 2008), 47–80 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 289–99; Colley, Linda, Captives: Britain, Empire and the World (London, 2010), 23–72 Google Scholar.

9 Benton, Lauren, A Search for Sovereignty: Law and Geography in European Empires, 1400–1900 (Cambridge, 2010)Google Scholar; Greene, Jack P., Negotiated Authorities: Essays in Colonial Political and Constitutional History (Charlottesville, 1994)Google Scholar.

10 Stanwood, Owen, “The Protestant Moment: Antipopery, the Revolution of 1688–1689, and the Making of an Anglo-American Empire,” Journal of British Studies 46, no. 3 (July 2007): 481–508 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Pincus, Steve, 1688: The First Modern Revolution (New Haven, 2009), 246–47Google Scholar; Swingen, Abigail, Competing Visions of Empire: Labor, Slavery and the Origins of the British Empire (New Haven, 2015), 108–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Lorimer, Joyce, ed., English and Irish Settlement on the River Amazon 1550–1646 (London, 1989), 61–69 Google Scholar.

12 Pestana, Carla G., The English Atlantic in an Age of Revolution, 1640–1661 (Cambridge, MA, 2004)Google Scholar, 47.

13 “Dr Coxe's Paper,” 18 September 1699, Fulham Papers, ii, 16–17, Palace, Lambeth; Erickson, Peter and Hulse, Clark, Early Modern Visual Culture: Representation, Race and Empire in Renaissance England (Philadelphia, 2000), 286–90Google Scholar.

14 Walsh, Peter, The Irish colours folded (London, 1662), 8–9 Google Scholar; Proposals for Raising a Million of Money out of the Forfeited Estates in Ireland (London, 1694)Google Scholar, 20; Clarke, Aidan, “Colonial Identity in Early Seventeenth-Century Ireland,” in Nationality and the Pursuit of National Independence, ed. Moody, T. W. (Belfast, 1978), 57–71 Google Scholar.

15 Edwards, David, “A Haven of Popery: English Catholic Migration to Ireland in the Age of Plantations,” in The Origins of Sectarianism in Early Modern Ireland, ed. Ford, Alan and McCafferty, John (Cambridge, 2005), 95–126 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Horning, Audrey, Ireland in the Virginian Sea (Chapel Hill, 2013), 353–67Google Scholar.

17 Barnard, Toby, Improving Ireland? Projectors, Prophets and Profiteers 1641–1786 (Dublin, 2008)Google Scholar, 27.

18 Krugler, English and Catholic, chap. 4.

19 Fuller, Thomas, The History of the Worthies of England (London, 1662)Google Scholar, 202; Speed, John, An epitome of Mr. John Speed's theatre of the empire of Great Britain (London, 1676), 216–17Google Scholar.

20 Krugler, English and Catholic, 161.

21 Davis, Richard Beale, ed., William Fitzhugh and His Chesapeake World (Chapel Hill, 1963)Google Scholar, 189, 250.

22 Steiner, Bruce E., “The Catholic Brents of Colonial Virginia: An Instance of Practical Toleration,” Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 70, no. 4 (October 1962): 387–409 Google Scholar.

23 Cullen, Louis, “The Irish Diaspora of the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” in Europeans on the Move: Studies in European Migration, 1500–1800, ed. Canny, Nicholas (Oxford, 1994), 113–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gwynn, Aubrey, “Documents Relating to the Irish in the West Indies,” Analecta Hibernica 4 (October 1932): 139–286 Google Scholar, at 233–34, 252–57.

24 Beckles, Hilary McD., “A ‘Riotous and Unruly Lot’: Irish Indentured Servants and Freemen in the English West Indies, 1644–1713,” William and Mary Quarterly 47, no. 4 (October 1990): 503–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25 Swingen, Competing Visions, 11–12, 28–33.

26 The National Archives (hereafter TNA), Robert Southwell to Anthony Ashley Cooper, 31 August 1669, PRO 30/24/48, 53–54.

27 Shaw and Block, “Subjects without an Empire,” 34, 59–60.

28 Farrelly, Papist Patriots, 38.

29 Charter of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations, 8 July 1663, Calendar of State Papers Colonial, America and West Indies (hereafter CSPC) 1661–68, 512; “Instructions to our trusty and welbeloved Sir William Berkeley,” 1662, Coventry MSS fols. 76, 63, Longleat House.

30 Conde de Ponte to Charles II, 4 February 1660/1, Clarendon MSS 74, fols. 111–12, Bodleian Library (hereafter BodL); Earl of Sandwich, paper on Tangier, May 1661, Clarendon MSS 75, fols. 464–65, BodL; TNA, Council of Trade to the King, 1661, CO 389/52.

31 Chappell, Edwin, ed., The Tangiers Papers of Samuel Pepys (London, 1935), 76–77 Google Scholar; Cobbett, William, ed., The Parliamentary History of England, 36 vols. (London, 1806–1820)Google Scholar, 4:190.

32 Memorial by Portuguese ambassador, May 1661, Clarendon MSS 75, fols. 460–6, BodL; TNA, “Instructions for the Earl of Teviot,” 2 December 1663, CO 279/2/169.

33 Declaration of Samuel Martin, Consul in Algiers, 10 January 1674, Sloane MSS 3512, fol. 102, British Library; John Matthews to John Luke, 9 September 1671, Sloane MSS 3511, fol. 46, British Library; Francis Parry to Sir Edward Spragg, 2/12 August 1671, BL Add. MSS 35,100, fol. 149.

34 Conde de Ponte to Charles II, 4 February 1660/1, Clarendon MSS 74, fols. 111–12, BodL; “Grievances done us in Portugal by the Inquisition contrary to the Articles of Peace,” Coventry MSS 103, fol. 57, Longleat House; Stoye, John, English Travellers Abroad, 1604–1667, rev. ed. (New Haven, 1989), 233–77Google Scholar.

35 Zahedieh, Nuala, “Economy,” in The British Atlantic World, ed. Armitage, David and Braddick, Michael (New York, 2009), 53–70 Google Scholar, at 68.

36 Account book of Peter Lynch, Mannock MSS HA246, G/1, Ipswich, Suffolk County Record Office (hereafter CRO); Giffords Hall inventory, Mannock MSS H/4; Personal and household expenses of Sir Francis Mannock, Mannock MSS H3/18, Ipswich, Suffolk CRO; Thomas Huddleston to Henry Huddleston, 17 November 1710, Huddleston MSS TH, 2, Cambridgeshire CRO; Young, Francis The Gages of Hengrave and Suffolk Catholicism, 1640–1767 (Woodbridge, 2015)Google Scholar, chap. 5.

37 McBride, Ian, Eighteenth-Century Ireland: The Isle of Slaves (London, 2009)Google Scholar, 226, 231; Schuller, Karin, “Irish-Iberian Trade from the Mid-Sixteenth to the Mid-Seventeenth Centuries,” in Irish and Scottish Mercantile Networks in Europe and Overseas in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries, ed. Dickson, David, Parmentier, Jan, and Ohlmeyer, Jane (Ghent, 2006), 175–96Google Scholar.

38 William Godolphin to Coventry, 7/17 November 1678, Coventry MSS 60, fol. 257, Longleat House; Thomas Kendall to Francis Parry, 23 April 1671, MS Eng. Lett. c. 328, fol. 75, BodL.

39 Proposals from Portugal, February 1660/1, trans. Richard Russell, Clarendon MSS 75, 217–18, BodL; “A Memorial to the King given by the Embassador 19 September 1662,” Russell Papers, A25/11, Ushaw College.

40 Richard Fitzgerald to John Luke, from Madrid, 9 June 1676, Sloane MSS 3512, fol. 250, British Library; Sir Francis Bedingfield to John Luke, 20 April 1672, Sloane MSS 3512, fols. 88–89, British Library; TNA, Earl of Sandwich to earl of Arlington, n.d. [November 1667], SP 94/53, fols. 100–1.

41 John Bland to earl of Shaftesbury, 1680, Sloane MSS 3512, fol. 283, British Library; TNA, William Godolphin to Arlington, February 1675/6, SP 94/63, fol. 122.

42 William Godolphin to Francis Parry, 19 September 1669, MS Eng. Lett. c. 328, fols. 9–10, BodL; Spragg to Parry, January 1670/1, MS Eng. Lett. c. 328, fols. 9–10, 67–68, BodL.

43 Richard Russell to John Watkinson, 13 February 1675/6, Russell Papers, A26/36, Ushaw College; Russell to Watkinson, 1 January 1676/7, Russell Papers, A26/76, Ushaw College.

44 Bossy, John, “Reluctant Colonists: The English Catholics Confront the Atlantic,” in Early Maryland in a Wider World, ed. Quinn, David (Detroit, 1982), 149–64Google Scholar, at 154–55.

45 Minutes of the Council of Jamaica, 22 January 1673, CSPC 1669–74, 1025; Thomas Huddleston to Henry Huddleston, 3 May 1711, Huddleston MSS TH/2, Cambridge, Cambridgeshire CRO; Martin Killigrew to Lady Mary Caryll, 20 March 1727, BL Add. MSS 28,228, fol. 226.

46 A Collection of the Names of the Merchants Living in and about the City of London (London, 1677); Nash, R. C., “Irish Atlantic Trade in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” William and Mary Quarterly 42, no. 3 (July 1985): 329–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

47 Peter Lynch, Account book, Mannock MSS G/13, Ipswich, Suffolk CRO; Henry Goodricke to Coventry, 24 October 1679, Coventry MSS 60, fol. 295, Longleat House; TNA, William Stapleton to Committee of Trade, 14 April 1676, CO 153/2/129; Blake, Martin, ed., Blake Family Records (London, 1905), 228–43Google Scholar.

48 Zahedieh, Nuala “The Merchants of Port Royal, Jamaica, and the Spanish Contraband Trade, 1655–1692,” William and Mary Quarterly 43, no. 4 (October 1986): 570–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Walton, Julian “The Merchant Community of Waterford in the 16th and 17th Centuries” in Cities and Merchants: French and Irish Perspectives on Urban Development, 1500–1900, ed. Butel, Paul and Cullen, L. M. (Dublin, 1984), 183–91Google Scholar.

49 The Present interest of Tangiers (London, 1679), 2–3 Google Scholar; Sir Sheres, Henry, A discourse touching Tanger (London, 1680), 1–14 Google Scholar.

50 Richard Russell, “Motives for Peace and Commerce with Portugal,” 1661, Russell Papers, A25/54, Ushaw College.

51 TNA, Godolphin to Arlington, 11/21 September 1667, SP 94/53, fols. 49–50; TNA, Godolphin to Arlington, 30 December 1676, SP 94/63, fols. 332–33; Godolphin to Coventry, 5/15 May 1678, Coventry MSS 60, fols. 191–97, Longleat House.

52 Swingen, Competing Visions, 63.

53 Leslie Theibert, “The Making of an English Caribbean” (PhD diss., Yale University, 2013).

54 Thomas Lynch to earl of Arlington, 27 June 1671, BL Add. MSS 11,410, fol. 180; Sir Thomas Lynch, “Reflections on the State of the Spaniards and the island of Jamaica,” 20 June 1677, CSPC 1677 –80, 307.

55 Duke of Buckingham, A Letter to Sir Thomas Osborn (London, 1672), 10–11 Google Scholar.

56 “An Essay of the Interest of the Crown in American Plantations and Trade,” n.d., BL Add. MSS 47,131, fols. 22–23.

57 News from Tangiers, 7 September 1661, Clarendon MSS 75, fols. 183–85, BodL.

58 Latham, R. and Matthews, W., eds., The Diary of Samuel Pepys, 11 vols. (London, 1970–83), 3:282–83Google Scholar.

59 Latham and Mathews, Diary of Samuel Pepys, 5:170; Arlington to Sir Richard Fanshaw, 9 June 1664, Bebington, Thomas, ed., The right Honourable the Earl of Arlington's letters to Sir W. Temple, 2 vols. (London, 1706)Google Scholar, 2:27; Henry Norwood to Clarendon, n.d. [1666], Clarendon MSS 84, fols. 406–7, BodL. The openly Catholic governors were the earl of Teviot (1663–64), John Fitzgerald (1664–65), and John, Lord Belassis (1665–66). Thomas Dongan served as lieutenant governor from 1678 to 1683. The earl of Peterborough, governor from 1662 to 1663, was widely rumored to be Catholic and converted publicly in 1685.

60 Hugh Cholmley to Thomas Maynard, 15 March 1664/5, Cholmley MSS V/1/1/1, fol. 50, Northallerton, North Yorkshire CRO; Cholmley to Lord Henry Howard, 14 August 1670, Cholmley MSS V, 1/1/3, fol. 115, Northallerton, North Yorkshire CRO.

61 Webb, Stephen Saunders, 1676: The End of American Independence (New York, 1984)Google Scholar; idem, Lord Churchill's Coup: The Anglo-American Empire and the Glorious Revolution Reconsidered (New York, 1995)Google Scholar.

62 Earl of Castlehaven to Sir Robert Southwell, 5 July 1672, BL Add. MSS 34,345, fols. 15.

63 Don Pedro Colonia to Godolphin, n.d. 1677, Coventry MSS 60, fol. 81, Longleat House; Childs, John, General Percy Kirke and the Later Stuart Army (London, 2014), 23–30 Google Scholar.

64 The case of Thomas earl of Limerick lately call'd Colonel Thomas Dongan (London, 1700)Google Scholar.

65 Barnard, Toby, “Sir Richard Bellings, a Catholic Courtier and Diplomat from Seventeenth-Century Ireland,” in Reshaping Ireland, 1550–1700, ed. Cuarta, Brian Mac (Dublin, 2011), 326–47Google Scholar.

66 Note on Sir William Stapleton, 1686, Carte MSS 40/321, BodL; Johnston, J. R., “The Stapleton Sugar Plantations in the Leeward Islands,” Bulletin of the John Rylands Library 48, no. 1 (Spring 1965): 175–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

67 TNA, Sir William Stapleton to Committee of Trade, 20 December 1675, CO 153/2/78–79; Stapleton, to Coventry, 8 December 1679, Coventry MSS 78, fol. 428, Longleat House; TNA, Sir John Werden to Thomas Dongan, 27 August 1684, CO 5/1112/46; Thomas Dongan to William Blathwayt, 11 August 1685, CSPC 1685 –88, 315.

68 William, Lord Willoughby to the Council of Trade, 27 April 1668, Stapleton MSS 1/1, John Rylands Library, Manchester.

69 Zacek, Natalie, Settler Society in the English Leeward Islands, 1670–1776 (Cambridge, 2010), 45–48 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

70 TNA, Sir John Werden to Anthony Brockholes, 11 February 1681/2, CO 5/1112/33; TNA, “Col Dongan's answer to Heads of Inquiry sent from Committee touching New York,” 1687, CO 5/1113/59; Childs, John, The Army, James II and the Glorious Revolution (Manchester, 1980)Google Scholar, 25; Duncan, Jason K., Citizens or Papists: The Politics of Anti-Catholicism in New York 1685–1821 (New York, 2005), 3–8 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

71 TNA, Dongan to earl of Sunderland, 8 September 1687, CO 5/1113/76.

72 Hancock, David, ed., The Letters of William Freeman, London Merchant 1678–1685 (London, 2002), 15–16 Google Scholar, 22; “Public accounts of the island of Montserrat,” March 1673, Stapleton MSS 2/3, John Rylands Library, Manchester; Oldmixon, John, Memoirs of Ireland from the Restoration to the present times (London, 1716)Google Scholar, 184. Supreme office in Montserrat was handed successively to Stapleton's two brothers, Edmund and Redmond, followed by his son-in-law, Sir James Cotter.

73 Gwynn, “Documents Relating to the Irish,” 259; TNA, Humble address from the Deputy-Governor, Council and Representatives of Montserrat, 1684, CO 153/3/138.

74 Thomas Day to William Gage, 11 January 1742, Hengrave Hall MSS 88/4/48, Cambridge University Library; Levie enacted for houses in townes, 1679, Stapleton MSS 2/2, John Rylands Library, Manchester.

75 Philippe de Nogle to William Stapleton, 1684, Stapleton MSS 8/2, John Rylands Library, Manchester; Council of St. Christopher's to Lords of Trade, 12 July 1680, CSPC 1677 –80, 1441; Norwood to Clarendon, 1666, Clarendon MSS 84, fols. 406–10, BodL.

76 William Stapleton, Accounts, 1686, Stapleton MSS 3/1, John Rylands Library, Manchester; TNA, William Trumbull to earl of Sunderland, 4 September 1686, SP 78/150, fols. 135–36.

77 Haffenden, Philip S., “The Anglican Church in Restoration policy,” in Seventeenth-Century America: Essays in Colonial History, ed. Smith, J. M. (Chapel Hill, 1959), 166–91Google Scholar; Gregory, Jeremy, “The Later Stuart Church and America,” in The Later Stuart Church 1660–1714, ed. Tapsell, Grant (Manchester 2012), 160–70Google Scholar.

78 Akenson, Montserrat, 45; Sanford, Robert, Surinam Justice (London, 1662)Google Scholar, 44.

79 Directors to Council at Surat, 19 March 1679/80, India Office Records, E/3/89, fol. 110, British Library; Sir Abraham Shipman to George Oxenden, 21 September 1663, BL Add. MSS 40,709, fol. 4.

80 Knox, Robert, An Historical Relation of the Island Ceylon (London, 1681)Google Scholar, 189.

81 Cholmley to Lord Henry Howard, 14 August 1670, Cholmley MSS V, 1/1/3, fol. 115, North Yorkshire CRO, Northallerton.

82 Stapleton to the Council of Trade and Plantations, 23 June 1672, CSPC 1669 –74, 1333.

83 William Stapleton, “Answers to the Council for Plantations,” March 1672, Stapleton MSS 2/2, John Rylands Library, Manchester; Minutes of the council of Antigua, 27 April 1681, Stapleton MSS (uncatalogued), John Rylands Library, Manchester.

84 Cholmley to Lord Middleton, 30 May 1673, Cholmley MSS V, 1/1/3, fol. 281, North Yorkshire CRO, Northallerton.

85 Richard Langhorne to Lord Hatton, 12 June 1673, BL Add. MSS 29,554, fol. 170.

86 Parry to Arlington, 16/26 November 1672, BL Add. MSS 35,100, fol. 240; Jerdan, William, ed., Letters from James, Earl of Perth … to his sister the Countess of Erroll (London, 1895)Google Scholar, 79.

87 Toppan, R. N. and Goodrick, A. T., eds., Edward Randolph: Including His Letters and Official Papers, 7 vols. (Boston, 1898–1909)Google Scholar, 4:281; Codignola, Luca, “The Holy See and the Conversion of the Indians in French and British North America, 1486–1760,” in America in European Consciousness, 1493–1750, ed. Kupperman, Karen O. (Chapel Hill, 1995), 195–242 Google Scholar, at 208–10.

88 “A Note from new France,” BL Add. MSS 10,118, fol. 34; Krugler, English and Catholic, 89.

89 Stapleton to Committee of Trade, 30 November 1683, CO 153/3/114–15.

90 Marquis de Denonville to Thomas Dongan, 5 June 1686, CSPC 1685–88, 694.

91 Fuller, Worthies, 202; Parry, Graham, The Trophies of Time: English Antiquarians of the Seventeenth Century (London, 1993), 169–71Google Scholar.

92 Lee, J. W. M., ed., The Calvert Papers, 3 vols. (Baltimore, 1889), 1:281–82Google Scholar; Codignola, “Holy See,” 218–19.

93 Christoph, Peter R., The Dongan Papers (New York, 1993)Google Scholar, 82, 90; Ritchie, Robert, The Duke's Province (Chapel Hill, 1977)Google Scholar, 173.

94 Dongan to Sunderland, 8 September 1687, CO 5/1113, 77; Dongan to Denonville, 9 September 1687, CSPC 1685–88, 1530.

95 TNA, Thomas Dongan to committee touching New York, 1684, CO 5/113/12–13; Dongan to Denonville, 1 December 1686, CSPC 1685–88, 1027.

96 Ford, Alan, “‘Firm Catholics’ or ‘Loyal Subjects’? Religious and Political Allegiance in Early Seventeenth-Century Ireland,” in Political Discourse in Seventeenth and Eighteenth-Century Ireland, ed. Boyce, David George, Eccleshall, Robert, and Geoghegan, Vincent (Gordonsville, 2001), 1–31 Google Scholar; Campbell, K. L., The Intellectual Struggle of English Papists in the Seventeenth Century: The Catholic Dilemma (New York, 1986), 39–75 Google Scholar.

97 Lee, Calvert Papers, 1:217–18, 283.

98 Ibid, 1:266.

99 Minutes of the Council of Trade, June 1677, CSPC 1677–80, 121.

100 Montserrat Code of Laws, 7, no. 11; Akenson, Montserrat, 93–95.

101 Bossy, “Reluctant Colonists,” 159.

102 Lee, Calvert Papers, 1:237, 267–71.

103 Ibid., 1:246.

104 Blundell, Margaret, ed., Cavalier: The Letters of William Blundell to His Friends 1620–1688 (London, 1933), 82–83 Google Scholar, 100, 117, 201–2; Tyrer, Frank and Bagley, J. J., eds., The Great Diurnal of Nicholas Blundell of Little Crosby, Lancashire, 3 vols. (Preston, 1958–62)Google Scholar, 1:4, 8, 28.

105 Stock, L. F., ed., Proceedings and Debates of the British Parliaments Respecting North America, 5 vols. (Washington, DC, 1984), 1:318–19Google Scholar.

106 Blake, Martin J., Blake Family Records (London, 1905)Google Scholar, 107, 112–14; Hancock, The Letters of William Freeman, 15–17; Akenson, Montserrat, 67–71; Melvin, Patrick, “The Galway Tribes as Landowners and Gentry,” in Galway History and Society, ed. Moran, Gerard and Gillespie, Raymond (Dublin, 1996), 319–74Google Scholar.

107 Thomas Cholmley to Thomas Belassis, n.d., Cholmeley of Brandsby MSS xiii/11, North Yorkshire Record Office, Northallerton.

108 Thomas Parker to John Eberson, 18 January 1713, English Province of the Society of Jesus (hereafter EPSJ) Archives, Notes and Fragments, ii, 93, Farm Street, London.

109 A moderate and safe Expedient (London, 1646), 3, 6, 7.

110 Davenant, Charles Discourses on the publick revenues, and on the trade of England (London, 1698)Google Scholar.

111 A moderate and safe Expedient, 6–7.

112 Lee, Calvert Papers, 1:221; Krugler, English and Catholic, 75, 89.

113 Bozman, John Leeds, History of Maryland (Baltimore, 1837)Google Scholar, 110; Lee, Calvert papers, 1:137; Questier, Michael C., “Catholic Loyalism in Early Stuart England,” English Historical Review 123, no. 504 (October 2008): 1132–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

114 Russell to Watkinson, Russell Papers, 22 May 1675 and 19 February 1676, Russell Papers, A26/46, 77, Ushaw College.

115 Aveling, J. H. C., The Handle and the Axe: Catholic Recusants in England (London, 1676), 176–78Google Scholar.

116 Glickman, Gabriel, The English Catholic Community 1688–1745: Politics, Culture and Ideology (Woodbridge, 2009), 116–17Google Scholar, 203–9.

117 Riordan, Timothy B., The Plundering Time: Maryland and the English Civil War 1645–1646 (Baltimore, 2004), 284–86Google Scholar; Chaney, Nellie Owens, “Of Sackcloth and Ashes—The Wells/White marriage,” Maryland Genealogical Society Bulletin 37, no. 2 (Spring 1996): 143–53Google Scholar, at 146.

118 Tutino, Stefania, “The Catholic Church and the English Civil War: the Case of Thomas White,” Journal of Ecclesiastical History 58, no. 2 (April 2007): 232–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

119 John Belson, paper on oaths, 1673, Belson MSS F/1/4/D1/18; Belson to anon. correspondent, n.d., Belson MSS F/1/4/C1/19, both Berkshire CRO, Reading.

120 George Alsop, A character of the province of Maryland (1666), 17.

121 “The Persuasions and Suggestions the Irish Catholicks make to his Majesty,” in King, William, The state of the Protestants of Ireland (London, 1691)Google Scholar, 300.

122 TNA, William Leslie to Lord Henry Howard, 1667, SP/9/203/7, fol. 12.

123 “Concerning the present disturbances in England about religion,” BL Add. MSS 65,139, fols. 17–25.

124 Payne, Henry Neville, The persecutor expos'd (London, 1685)Google Scholar, 37, 39; Paul Hopkins, s.v., “Payne, Henry,” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, http://oxforddnb.com/view/article/21643?docPos=15.

125 Bliss, Robert M., Revolution and Empire: English Politics and the American Colonies in the Seventeenth Century (Manchester, 1990), 172–73Google Scholar; Farrelly, Papist Patriots, 118–28.

126 Council minutes, June 1677, CSPC 1677–80, 121; “The humble petition of Mary Tany,” n.d., Tanner MSS 31, 137, BodL; Calvert, Philip, A letter from the chancellour of Maryland (London, 1682)Google Scholar.

127 Latham and Matthews,  Diary of Samuel Pepys, 5:344–45.

128 John Bland to earl of Shaftesbury, 1679, Sloane MSS 3512, fol. 283, British Library; Present Interest of Tangiers, 2–4; Stein, “Tangier,” 1006–7.

129 Observator, no. 120, 23 August 1684.

130 Grey, Anchitel, Debates of the House of Commons, from the year 1667 to the year 1694, 10 vols. (London, 1763), 8:12–13 Google Scholar.

131 Cobbett, Parliamentary History, 4:1218–19; Leoline Jenkins to Henry Sheres, 14 February 1680/1, BL Add. MSS 19,872, fol. 63.

132 Robert Southwell to the duke of Ormonde, 19 November 1678, HMC Ormonde, iv, 477; Hancock, The Letters of William Freeman, 48–49, 136; TNA, “Conferences with Sir Charles Wheeler, 7 and 10 December 1672,” CO 153/1/53.

133 Godolphin to Coventry, 11/21 December 1678, Coventry MSS 60, fols. 261–62, Longleat House; Southwell to duke of Ormonde, 19 November 1678, HMC Ormonde, iv, 477.

134 Marotti, Arthur, “Alienating Catholics in Early Modern England,” in Catholicism and Anti-Catholicism in Early Modern English Texts, ed. Marotti, Arthur (New York, 2011), 1–34 Google Scholar.

135 Pestana, Protestant Empire, 100–58.

136 Lord Vaughan to Coventry, March 1675, Coventry MSS 74, fols. 33–34, Longleat House; Matar, Nabil, Turks, Moors and Englishmen in the Age of Discovery (New York, 1999), 91–94 Google Scholar.

137 Sewall, Samuel and Rawson, Edward, The Revolution in New England Justified (London, 1691)Google Scholar, 44; Byfield, Nathaniel, An account of the late revolution in New-England (London, 1689), 4–6 Google Scholar.

138 Bland to Shaftesbury, 1679, Sloane MSS 3512, fol. 283, British Library.

139 Present interest of Tangiers, 2.

140 Cholmley to the duchess of Lauderdale, December 1679, Cholmley MSS V/1/1/III, fols. 300–1, North Yorkshire CRO, Northallerton.

141 Loddington, William, Plantation work the work of this generation (London, 1682)Google Scholar, 3; Williamson, Arthur H., “An Empire to End Empire: the Dynamic of Early Modern British Expansion,” Huntington Library Quarterly 68, nos. 1–2 (March 2005): 227–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

142 Grey, Debates, 8:7.

143 Ibid., 8:5.

144 Henry Stubbe, Campanella revived (London, 1670), 1, 3–4.

145 Stillingfleet, Edward, A sermon preached on the fast-day, November 13, 1678 (London, 1678), 46–47 Google Scholar.

146 Correspondence of Henry Hyde, earl of Clarendon and of his brother, Laurence Hyde, earl of Rochester, ed. Singer, S. W., 2 vols. (London, 1828)Google Scholar, 1:576; Patrick Trant to Stapleton, 1 February 1682, Stapleton MSS 3/1, John Rylands Library, Manchester.

147 Lee, Calvert Papers, 1:318.

148 Cobbett, Parliamentary History, 4:924.

149 Sheres, Discourse, 33.

150 Trant to Stapleton, 7 February 1684, Stapleton MSS 3/1, John Rylands Library, Manchester.

151 Swingen, Competing Visions, 121–24; Philip Haffenden, “The Crown and the Colonial Charters, 1675–1688: Part 1,” William and Mary Quarterly 15, no. 3 (July 1958): 297–311.

152 The term “Tory ascendancy” is put forward in Swingen, Competing Visions, 121, to encompass court policies in America between 1681 and 1688.

153 Oldmixon, John, The British Empire in America (London, 1708)Google Scholar, 125; TNA, Stapleton to committee of trade, 15 June 1683, CO, 153/3, fols. 98–99; Stanwood, “Protestant Moment,” 492–93.

154 Taylor, Stephen, ed., The Entring Book of Roger Morrice, 6 vols. (Woodbridge, 2007)Google Scholar, 4:382; Oldmixon, The British Empire, 192–93.

155 Toppan and Goodrick, Edward Randolph, 4:268–69, 272.

156 Cotton Mather, Parentator (London, 1724), 114–15.

157 Morrice, Entring book, 4:225, 301.

158 Mather, Parentator, 109, 113–15. The Revolution at the end of the year ensured that this pledge was never tested.

159 Jacob, J. R., “Restoration Ideologies and the Royal Society,” History of Science 18 (1980): 25–38 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

160 Houghton, John, Collection of Letters for the improvement of husbandry and trade, 2 vols. (London, 1681–83)Google Scholar, 1:35.

161 Sheridan, Thomas, A discourse  … of the interest of England (London, 1678)Google Scholar, 139, 162.

162 Toppan and Goodrick, Edward Randolph, 3:201, 219, 4:12–13.

163 Marquis of Lansdowne, ed., The Petty Papers, 2 vols. (1927; repr., London, 1997), 1:59–63 Google Scholar, 256–57; Marquis of Lansdowne, ed., The Petty-Southwell Correspondence 1676–1687 (1928; repr., London, 1997), 187.

164 Pett, Peter, The Happy Future State of England (London, 1688)Google Scholar, 184, 200.

165 Minutes of the Council of Safety at Boston, 20 April, 1689, CSPC 1689–92, 286.I; Duncan, Citizens, 8–9; Dunn, Richard S., “The Glorious Revolution and America,” in The Oxford History of the British Empire, vol. 1, The Origins of Empire, ed. Canny, Nicholas (Oxford, 1998), 445–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

166 TNA, Petition from the Governor and Council of St Christopher's, 15 July 1689, CO 153/3/426; TNA, “A short remonstrance or account of ye sufferings of the poor inhabitants of St Christopher,” CO 153/3/438–39; Roger Hoare to Edward Clarke, 30 May 1694, Clarke of Chipley MSS DD/SF/7/1/14, Taunton, Somerset CRO; James II to John Aylward, Warrant, 6 February 1691, Howard Letters and Papers, I; Howard of Norfolk MSS; Arundel Castle.

167 Oldmixon, Memoirs, 250.

168 Account of the Society for Propagating the Gospel in Foreign Parts (London, 1706), 45, 69, 72.

169 Clergy of Maryland to Bishop Compton, 14 May 1698; Fulham Papers, Maryland, I, fols. 100–3, Lambeth Palace Library; Codignola, “Holy See,” 212.

170 Sir Robert Robinson to the Lords of the Admiralty, 10 May 1689, CSPC 1689–92, 114; Council of New York to Lord Cornbury, 9 May 1701, Rawlinson MSS A272, fols. 124–25.

171 Francis Nicholson to Archbishop Tenison, 18 Match 195/6, Fulham Papers, Maryland, I, fols. 51–52, Lambeth Palace Library.

172 Petition of Anthony Brockholes to Governor Fletcher, 30 May 1696, CSPC 1696–97, 16X. See also petition of John Cooley to Governor Fletcher, 30 May 1696, CSPC 1696–97, 16X.

173 Anonymous correspondent to Adam Colclough, 19 October 1692, D641/2/K/2/4, Stafford, Staffordshire CRO; Oldmixon, Memoirs, 251.

174 Thomas Bray to Sir William Gage, 23 October 1741, Hengrave Hall MSS 88/4/41, Cambridge University Library.

175 Richard Challoner to John Stonor, 14 September 1756, Main series, B45/135, Westminster Diocesan Archives, Kensington; Farrelly, Papist Patriots, 138–39.

176 Nary, Cornelius, The Case of the Roman Catholicks of Ireland (Dublin, 1724)Google Scholar, 29.

177 Bergin, John, “Irish Catholics in Eighteenth-Century London and Their Networks,” Eighteenth-Century Life 39, no. 1 (March 2015): 66–102 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bartlett, Thomas, “‘This Famous Island Set in a Virginian Sea’: Ireland in the British Empire 1690–1801,” in Oxford History of the British Empire, vol. 2, ed. Marshall, P. J. and Low, Alaine (Oxford, 1998), 253–75Google Scholar, at 255, 257.

178 Bergin, “Irish Catholics,” 94.

179 Livesey, James, Civil Society and Empire: Ireland and Scotland in the Eighteenth-Century Atlantic World (New Haven, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 98.

180 Questier, Michael C., “Arminianism, Catholicism, and Puritanism in England during the 1630s,” Historical Journal 49, no. 1 (March 2006): 53–78 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Glickman, English Catholic Community, 19–52.

181 Greene, Jack, Evaluating Empire and Confronting Colonialism in Eighteenth-Century Britain (Cambridge, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

182 Thomas Parker to Richard Plowden, 15 January 1714, Notes and Fragments, Section II, 93, EPSJ Archives, Farm Street.

183 Leith, William Forbes, Memoirs of Scottish Catholics during XVIIth and XVIIIth Centuries, 2 vols. (London, 1909)Google Scholar, 2:360; McGrath, Charles Ivar, Ireland and Empire, 1692–1770 (London, 2012)Google Scholar.

184 Rabin, Dana, “Imperial Disruptions: City, Nation and Empire in the Gordon Riots,” in The Gordon Riots: Politics, Culture and Insurrection in Late Eighteenth-Century Britain, ed. Haywood, Ian and Seed, John (Cambridge, 2012), 93–114 Google Scholar.