Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-gq7q9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-18T06:06:56.007Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Marxism and National Socialism in Taishō Japan: The Thought of Takabatake Motoyuki

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 March 2011

Get access


Takabatake Motoyuki was one of several prewar Japanese socialists who combined the Marxian ideal of proletarian socialism with nationalism. The first to produce a full Japanese translation of Karl Marx's Capital in 1919, Takabatake formulated a doctrine of national or state socialism that same year and dedicated the rest of his life to the promotion of that ideal. While Takabatake continued to call himself a Marxist, he criticized Marx's understanding of the state and drew on the work of Western political theorists such as Thomas Hobbes to construct his own functionalist interpretation of the state. Takabatake's work not only exposes some important lacunae in Marxist-Leninism, but his continued appeal to Marxism while embracing an ideology usually associated with the political Right defies analysis on the basis of conventional Left-Right distinctions. As his treatment of contemporary domestic and international problems demonstrates, both socialist and nationalist movements of this era constituted impassioned responses to social, economic, and political crises that were already apparent in the Taishō years.

Copyright © Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1984

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)


List of References

Haruki, Aikawa. 1982. “Nōson keizai to nōgyō kyōkō” [The agrarian economy and the agricultural recession]. In Nihon shihon-shugi hattatsu shi kōza (Kōza) [Symposium on the history of the development of Japanese capitalism] 7 vols. and suppl. Tokyo: Iwanami shoten. Reprint of 1932–1933 ed.Google Scholar
Kanson, Arahata. 1948. Kanson jiden [Autobiography of (Arahata) Kanson] 2 vols. Tokyo: Itagaki shoten. Reprinted by Iwanami shoten, Iwanami bunko, 1975.Google Scholar
Bamba, Nobuya, and Howes, John F.. 1978. Pacifism in Japan: The Christian and Socialist Tradition. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.Google Scholar
Beckmann, George M. 1962. “Japanese Adaptations of Marx-Leninism.” In Studies on the Modernization of Japan by Western Scholars. Asian Cultural Studies, vol. 3. Tokyo: International Christian University.Google Scholar
Beckmann, George M., and Okubo, Genji. 1969. The Japanese Communist Party, 1922–1945. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Berki, R. N. 1971. “On Marxian Thought and the Problem of International Relations.” World Politics 24, 1:80105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bernstein, Gail Lee. 1974. “Kawakami Hajime: A Japanese Marxist in Search of the Way.” In Japan in Crisis: Essays on Taishō Democracy, ed. Silberman, Bernard S. and Harootunian, H. D.. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1974.Google Scholar
Bernstein, Gail Lee. 1976a. Japanese Marxist: A Portrait of Kawakami Hajime, 1879–1946. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Harvard East Asian Series, no. 86.Google Scholar
Bernstein, Gail Lee. 1976b. “The Russian Revolution, the Early Japanese Socialists, and the Problem of Dogmatism.” Studies in Comparative Communism 9, 4:327–48.Google Scholar
Brown, Delmer M. 1955. Nationalism in Japan. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
International, Communist. 1922. “Nihon kyōsantō kōryō sōan” [Draft program of the Japanese Communist Party]. In Kominterun Nihon ni kansuru tēze shū.[Collected Comintern theses on Japan], Ishidō Kiyotomo and Yamabe Kentarō, comps. Tokyo: Aoki shoten, Aoki bunko, 1961.Google Scholar
International, Communist. 1927. “Nihon mondai ni kansuru ketsugi (Ni-nana nen tēze)” [Resolution on the Japan Problem (1927 Theses)] In Kominterun Nihon ni kansuru tēze shū (see Communist International 1922).Google Scholar
Duus, Peter. 1968. Party Rivalry and Political Change in TaishōJapan. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Duus, Peter. 1970. “The Era of Party Rule: 1905–1932.” In Modern East Asia: Essays in Interpretation, ed. Crowley, James B.. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.Google Scholar
Footman, David. 1947. Ferdinand Lasalle: Romantic Revolutionary. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Hall, John W. 1970. Japan: From Prehistory to Modern Times. New York: Dell.Google Scholar
Gorō, Hani. 1978. “Tōyō ni okeru shihon-shugi no keisei” [The formation of capitalism in the East] In Meiji ishin shi kenkyū [Studies in the history of the Meiji Restoration], ed. Gorō, Hani. Tokyo: Iwanami shoten, Iwanami bunko.Google Scholar
Harootunian, H. D. 1974. “Introduction: A Sense of An Ending and the Problem of Taishō.” In Japan in Crisis (see Bernstein 1974).Google Scholar
Harootunian, H. D. 1980. “Review of Pacifism in Japan: The Christian and Socialist Tradition, ed. Nobuya Bamba and John F. Howes.” American Historical Review 85, 3:697.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yū'ichi, Hayashi. 1981. “Dokusen shihon-shugi kakuritsu-ki: dai-ichiji taisen kara Shōwa kyōkō made” [The period of the establishment of monopoly capitalism: From World War I to the Shōwa panic] In Nihon nōgyōshi: shihon-shugi no tenkai to nōgyō mondai [History of Japanese agriculture: The development of capitalism and the agrarian problem] ed. Shōzō, Teruoka. Tokyo: Yūhikaku, Yūhikaku sensho.Google Scholar
Hilferding, Rudolf. 1981. Finance Capital: A Study of the Latest Phase of Capitalist Development. Trans. Bottomore, T. from German edition of 1910. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Yoshitarō, Hirano. 1948. Burujoa minshu-shugi kakumei: sono shiteki hatten [The bourgeois-democratic revolution: Its historical development] Hirano Yoshitarō ronbun shū [Collected writings of Hirano Yoshitarō], vol. 1. Tokyo: Nihon hyōron-sha.Google Scholar
Hoston, Germaine A. 1981. “State and Revolution in China and Japan: Marxist Perspectives on the Nation-State and Social Revolution in Asia.” Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard University.Google Scholar
Hoston, Germaine A. 1983. “Tenkō: Marxism and the National Question in Prewar Japan.” Polity 16, 1:96118.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoston, Germaine A. 1984. “Marxism and Japanese Expansionism: Takahashi Kamekichi and the Theory of ‘Petty Imperialism.’Journal of Japanese Studies 10, 1:130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsunao, Inomata. 1929. Gendai Nihon kenkyū: Marukishizumu no tachiba yori [Studies on contemporary Japan: From a Marxist perspective] Tokyo: Kaizō-sha.Google Scholar
Tsunao, Inomata. 1932. Nihon no dokusen shihon-shugi: kin'yū shihon no kyōkō taisaku [Japan's monopoly capitalism: Finance capital's policy toward the panic] Tokyo: Nanboku shoin.Google Scholar
Gi'ichi, Inumaru. 1961. “Nihon Marukusu-shugi no genryū” [Origins of Japanese Marxism] In Gendai no ideorogii [Contemporary ideology]. Vol. 2: Nihon no Marukusu-shugi [Japanese Marxism[, ed. Takuichi, Ikumi et al. Tokyo: San'ichi shobō.Google Scholar
Shūichi, Kato. 1974. “Taishō Democracy as the Pre-Stage for Japanese Militarism.” In Japan in Crisis (see Bernstein 1974).Google Scholar
Junichirō, Kida. 1965. Meiji no risō [Ideals of the Meiji period] Tokyo: San'ichi shobō.Google Scholar
Kolakowski, Leszek. 1978. Main Currents of Marxism: Its Rise, Growth, and Dissolution. 3 vols. Vol. 1: The Founders. London: Oxford University Press, Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Hirotake, Koyama and Eitarō, Kishimoto. 1962. Nihon no hi-kyōsantō Marukusu-shugisha: Yamakawa Hitoshi no shōgai to shisō [A Japanese non-Communist party Marxist: The life and thought of Yamakawa Hitoshi]. Tokyo: San'ichi shobō.Google Scholar
Lockwood, William W. 1954. The Economic Development of Japan: Growth and Structural Change, 1868–1938. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Maruyama, Masao. 1963. Thought and Behavior in Modern Japanese Politics. London: N.p.Google Scholar
Junnosuke, Masumi. 1963. “Nihon seitō no okeru chinō seiji no sho mondai” [Some problems of local politics in the history of Japanese political parties] Kokka gakkai zasshi, no. 76.Google Scholar
Hiroaki, Matsuzawa. 1973. Nihon shakai-shugi no shisō [Japanese socialist thought]. Tokyo: Chikuma shobō.Google Scholar
Mitchell, Richard H. 1976. Thought Control in Prewar Japan. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Masamitsu, Nakaura. 1961. “Nihon Marukusu-shugi no shisō hōhō no ichi toku-shitsu: Fukumotoizumu no shisō shi-teki igi o megutte” [One characteristic of the method of Japanese Marxist thought: On the intellectual-historical significance of Fukumotoism] In Gendai no ideorogii (see Inumaru 1961).Google Scholar
Eitarō, Noro. 1982. “Foreword.” In Nihon shihon-shugi hattatsu shi kōza. (Kōza). [Symposium on the history of the development of Japanese capitalism]. 7 vols. and suppl. Tokyo: Iwanami shoten. Reprint of 1932–1933 edition.Google Scholar
Notehelfer, Fred G. 1971. “Kōtoku Shūsui and Nationalism.” Journal of Asian Studies 31, 1:3139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ohkawa, Kazushi, and Rosovsky, Henry. 1973. Japanese Economic Growth: Trend Acceleration in the Twentieth Century. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press. Studies of Economic Growth in Industrialized Countries.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ka'ichirō, Ōishi. 1982. “‘Nihon shihon-shugi hattatsu shi kōza’ kankō jijō” [The circumstances of the publication of the “Symposium on the history of the development of Japanese capitalism”]. In Kōza (see Noro 1982).Google Scholar
Tsutomu, Ōuchi. 1947. Nihon shihon-shugi no nōgyō mondai [The agrarian problem of Japanese capitalism]. N.p.Google Scholar
Tsutomu, Ōuchi. 1950. Nihon nōgyō no zaisei-gaku [The finance of Japanese agriculture] Tokyo: Tōkyō daigaku shuppan-kai.Google Scholar
Tsutomu, Ōuchi. 1951. Nōgyō mondai [The agrarian problem]. Tokyo: Iwanami shoten.Google Scholar
Russell, Bertrand. 1965. German Social Democracy. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Hiroshi, Sano. 1950. “Mosukō to Nihon kyōsantō no kankei shi” [A history of relations between Moscow and the Japanese Communist Party]. Chūō kōron [Central review] 65, 3:96103.Google Scholar
Scalapino, Robert A. 1962. Democracy and the Party Movement in Prewar Japan. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Seizaburō, Shinobu. 1951. Taishō seiji shi [A history of Taishō politics]. Tokyo: Kawade shobō.Google Scholar
Silberman, Bernard S. 1974a. “The Bureaucratic Role in Japan, 1900–1945: The Bureaucrat as Politician.” In Japan in Crisis (see Bernstein 1974).Google Scholar
Silberman, Bernard S. 1974b. “Conclusion: Taishō Democracy and the Crisis of Secularism.” In Japan in Crisis (see Bernstein 1974).Google Scholar
Starr, John Bryan. 1979. Continuing the Revolution: The Political Thought of Mao. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Steinhoff, Patricia Golden. 1969. “Tenkō: Ideology and Social Integration in Prewar Japan.” Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard University.Google Scholar
Storry, Richard. 1957. The Double Patriots: A Study of Japanese Nationalism. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1919. Marukusu-gaku kenkyū [Studies on Marxism]. Tokyo: Daitō-kaku.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1920. Shakai-shugi-teki sho kenkyū [Studies on socialism]. Tokyo: Taishū-sha.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1926a. Jiko o kataru [On myself]. Tokyo: Jinbunkai shuppan-bu.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1926b. Marukusu jūni kō [Twelve lectures on Marx]. Tokyo: Daitō-kaku.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1927a. Marukishizumu to kokka-shugi [Marxism and statism]. Tokyo: Kaizōsha.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1927b. Shakai-shugi to shinka-ron [Socialism and evolutionism]. Rev. ed. Tokyo: Kaizō-sha.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1928a. Kokka shakai-shugi taigi [The great cause of national/state social ism]. Nihon shakai-shugi kenkyū-jo panfuretto [Pamphlets of the Japanese Socialist Institute]. Tokyo: Nihon shakai-shugi kenkyū-jo [Japanese Socialist Institute],1932.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1928b. Marukusu-gaku kaisetsu [An explanation of Marxism]. Tokyo: Kaizō-sha.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1934a. “Gunkoku-shugi” [Militarism] In Hihan Marukusu-shugi [Criticiz ing Marxism]. Motoyuki, Takabatake. Tokyo: Nihon hyōron-sha.Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1934b. “Kokka shakai-shugi no hitsuzen-sei” [The necessity/inevitability of state socialism]. In Hihan Marukusu-shugi (see Takabatake 1934a).Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1934c. “Kokka shakai-shugi no seisaku” [The policies of state socialism]. In Hihan Marukusu-shugi (see Takabatake 1934a).Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1934d. “‘Puroretaria kokka’ no ronri-teki hatan” [The logical bankruptcy of the ‘proletarian state’”]. In Hihan Marukusu-shugi (see Takabatake 1934a).Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1934e. “Teikoku-shugi no hatten” [The development of imperialism]. In Hihan Marukusu-shugi (see Takabatake 1934a).Google Scholar
Motoyuki, Takabatake. 1934f. “Teikoku-shugi no kisū” [The tendency of imperialism]. In Hihan Marukusu-shugi (see Takabatake 1934a).Google Scholar
Kamekichi, Takahashi. 1924. Nihon shihon-shugi keizai no kenkyū [Studies on the Japanese capitalist economy] Tokyo: Hakuyō-sha.Google Scholar
Kamekichi, Takahashi. 1926. Nihon keizai no yukizumari to musan-kaikyū no taisaku [The deadlock of the Japanese economy and the measures of the proletariat]. Tokyo: Hakuyō-sha.Google Scholar
Kamekichi, Takahashi. 1929. Nihon shihon-shugi hattatsu shi [History of the development of Japanese capitalism]. Rev. and enl. ed. Tokyo: Nihon hyōron-sha.Google Scholar
Kamekichi, Takahashi. 19541955. Taishō-Shōwa zaikai no heridō [Economic fluctuations in the Taishō and Shōwa periods]. Tokyo: Tōyō keizai shinpō-sha.Google Scholar
Kōhachirō, Takahashi. 1976. “A Contribution to the Discussion.” In The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism, ed. Hilton, Rodney. Atlantic Highlands, N.J.: Humanities Press.Google Scholar
Kiyoko, Takeda. 1970. “Kakumei shisō to tennō-sei: Takabatake Motoyuki no kokka shakai-shugi o chūshin ni” [Revolutionary thought and the emperor system: On the state socialism of Takabatake Motoyuki]. In Kindai Nihon seiji shisō shi [History of modern Japanese political thought]. Vol. 2, Hashikawa Bunzō and Matsumoto Sannosuke, comps. Kindai Nihon shisō shi takei [Outline of the history of modern Japanese thought]. No. 4. Tokyo: Yūhikaku.Google Scholar
Yoshitomo, Takeuchi. 1965. “Nihon no Marukusu-shugi” [Japanese Marxism]. In Marukishizumu [Marxism]. Vol. 2. Yoshitomo, Takeuchi, ed. Gendai Nihon shisō taikei [Outline of contemporary Japanese thought]. Vol. 21. Tokyo: Chikuma shobō.Google Scholar
Masato, Tanaka. 1970. “Takabatake Motoyuki ron” [On Takabatake Motoyuki]. Shirin 53, 2:4144.Google Scholar
Masato, Tanaka. 1978. Takabatake Motoyuki: Nihon no kokka shakai-shugi [Takabatake Motoyuki: Japan's national socialism]. Tokyo: Gendai hyōron-sha.Google Scholar
Totten, George Oakley III, 1966. The Social Democratic Movement in Prewar Japan. Studies on Japan's Social Democratic Parties, vol. 1. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Kōzō, Uno. 1936. Keizei seisaku-ron [Theory of economic policy]. Tokyo: Kōbundō shobō. Enl. ed. 1948.Google Scholar
Kōzō, Uno. 1964. Keizai genron. Tokyo: Iwanami shoten.Google Scholar
Kōzō, Uno. 1977. Principles of Political Economy: Theory of a Purely Capitalist Society. Trans. Sekine, Thomas A.. Atlantic Highlands, N.J.: Humanities Press.Google Scholar
Wagner, Jeffrey Paul. 1978. “Sano Manabu and the Japanese Adaptation of Socialism.” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Arizona.Google Scholar
Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1976. “A World-System Perspective on the Social Sciences.” British Journal of Sociology 27, 3:343–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsunehiko, Watanabe. 1968. “Industrialization, Technological Progress, and Dual Structure.” In Economic Growth, the Japanese Experience Since the Meiji Era, ed. Klein, L. and Ohkawa, K.. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Wilson, George M. 1963. “Kita Ikki, Ōkawa Shūmei, and the Yūzonsha: A Study in the Genesis of Shōwa Nationalism.” In Papers on Japan. Vol. 2. Cambridge: Harvard University, East Asian Research Center.Google Scholar
Wilson, George M. 1969. Radical Nationalist in Japan: Kita Ikki, 1883–1937. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hitoshi, Yamakawa. 1944. “Shōnin shinsei” [Witness's summons]. Manuscript. Tokyo: Hōsei University, Ōhara Institute for the Study of Social Problems.Google Scholar
Hitoshi, Yamakawa. 1966a. “Kokka shakai-shugi to rōdō mondai” [State socialism and the labor problem]. Written 13 September 1919. In Yamakawa Hitoshi zenshū [Complete works of Yamakawa Hitoshi]. Tokyo: Keisō shobō.Google Scholar
Hitoshi, Yamakawa. 1966b. “Sovieto seiji no tokushitsu to sono hihan: puroretarian dikuteitā-shippu to demokurashii” [The special characteristics of the Soviet government and a critique of it: Proletarian dictatorship and democracy] In Yamakawa Hitoshi zenshū (see Yamakawa 1966a).Google Scholar
Hitoshi, Yamakawa. 1976. “Nihon ni okeru demokurashii no hattatsu to musankaikyū no seiji undō” [The development of democracy in Japan and the political movement of the proletariat] In Yamakawa Hitoshi shū [Collected works of Yamakawa Hitoshi], ed. Michitoshi, Takabatake. Kindai Nihon shisō taikei [Outline of modern Japanese thought], no. 19. Tokyo: Chikuma shobō.Google Scholar
Yamamura, Kozo. 1974. “The Japanese Economy, 1911–1930: Concentration, Conflicts, and Crises.” In Japan in Crisis (see Bernstein 1974).Google Scholar
Yasuba, Yasukichi. 1973. “Anatomy of the Debate on Japanese Capitalism.” Journal of Japanese Studies 2, 1:6382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar