Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c4f8m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T07:25:08.377Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Fantasies of Liberalism and Liberal Jurisprudence: State Law, Politics, and the Israeli Arab-Palestinian Community

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 July 2014

Gad Barzilai
Get access

Extract

Some thirty years after the Bergman decision, Israel's constitutional structure and legal culture are still not responsive to minority needs or, more broadly, to the social needs of deprived communities. The liberal language and judicial review of Knesset legislation that were empowered by Bergman have not reconciled this problematic discrepancy between jurisprudence and social needs.

The Bergman ruling signified the onset of a new era in Israel jurisprudence — the era of liberalism, in that it generated the notion of judicial counter-majoritarianism as the center, however problematic, of democracy. It was a modest ruling and a careful one, dwelling only on procedural deficiencies as cause for judicial abrogation of parliamentary legislation. Later on, after 1992, and propelled by the spirit of judicial activism, the Supreme Court adopted a more expansive judicial policy. It asserted the need for much more active judicial review of the substance of Knesset legislation and even the possibility of annulling it if it fell within the provisions of the Basic Law: Human Dignity and Freedom and the Basic Law: Freedom of Occupation.

Type
Articles
Information
Israel Law Review , Volume 34 , Issue 3 , Summer 2000 , pp. 425 - 451
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press and The Faculty of Law, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 HCJ 98/69 Bergman v. Minister of Finance (1969) 23(i) P.D. 693Google Scholar.

2 HCJ 6698/95 Ka'adan v. Israel Lands Authority (2000) 54(i) P.D. 258. My references are to the original text of the ruling (March 8, 2000).

3 Ibid.

4 Kymlicka, W., Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights (Oxford, Oxford Univ. Press, 1995)Google Scholar.

5 Jaros, D. and Roper, R., “The U.S. Supreme Court: Myth, Diffuse Support, Specific Support, and Legitimacy” (1980) 8:1American Politics Quarterly 85–105CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Bierbrauer, Gunter, “Toward an Understanding of Legal Culture: Variations in Individualism and Collectivism between Kurds, Lebanese, and Germans” (1994) 28:2Law and Society Rev. 243–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Sierra, T. Maria, “Indian Rights and Customary Law in Mexico: A Study of the Nahuas in the Sierra de Puebla” (1995) 29:2Law and Society Rev. 227–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Wieacker, F., “Foundations of European Legal Culture” (1990) 38 American J. Comp. L. 1–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Friedman, M. Lawrence “Is There a Modern Legal Culture?” (1994) 7 (2) Ratio Juris 117–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Greenhouse, J. Carol, “Just in Time: Temporality and the Cultural Legitimation of Law” (1989) 98 Yale L. J. 1631–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Sierra, “Indian Rights and Customary Law in Mexico”, supra n. 7.

11 Zureik, E., Moughrabi, F. and Sacco, F.V., “Perceptions of Legal Inequality in Deeply Divided Societies: The Case of Israel” (1993) 25 Int'l J. of Middle East Studies 423–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rattner, Arye, “The Margins of Justice: Attitudes towards the Law and the Legal System among Jews and Arabs in Israel” (1994) 6:4Int'l J. of Public Opinion Research 362–70Google Scholar.

12 Israel Statistical Yearbook, 1994, No. 45, Table 2.1, p. 43Google Scholar.

13 Barzilai, G., Democracy and War: Consensus and Dissent in Israel (Tel Aviv, Sifriat Hapoalim, 1992)Google Scholar; Reiter, Y., Between “A Jewish State” and “A State of Its Residents”: The Civil Status of the Arabs in Israel in an Era of Peace (Raanana, Institute for Research of the Arab Society in Israel, 1996)Google Scholar; Rouhana, N.N., “Coping with the Contradictions of Ethnic Policies: How Israeli Society Maintains a Democratic Self-Image” (1998)Google Scholar, unpublished paper presented before the Van Leer Jerusalem Institute's research group on “Encounters in the Middle East: Key Political Concepts in the Dialogue of Cultures.”

14 Korn, A., “Criminalization of the Arab Minority during the Military Rule” (1999) 8 Plilim 157–91Google Scholar.

15 Lustick, I., Arabs in a Jewish State: Israeli Control of an Ethnic Minority (Haifa, Mifrash, 1985)Google Scholar. M. Hofnung, Israel: National Security vs. the Rule of Law (Jerusalem, Nevo, 1991).

16 Lecture in Givat Haviva, May 1996.

17 Ganam, A., Israeli Arab Political Participation, 1997, Doctoral dissertation, Haifa UniversityGoogle Scholar.

18 Prevention of Terrorism Act, 1948.

19 See Barzilai, G., “Center Against Periphery: Prevention of Terrorism Laws as Politics” (1999) 8 Plilim 229–49Google Scholar.

20 Israel Statistical Yearbook, 1995, Table 11.1, p. 324Google Scholar.

21 Ibid., Table 22.3, p. 639.

22 Ibid., Table 22.48, p. 700.

23 Peled, Y., “Ethnic Democracy and the Legal Construction of Citizenship: Arab Citizens of the Jewish State” (1992) 86:2American Political Science Rev. 432–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Barzilai, G., Democracy and War: Consensus and Dissent in Israel (Tel Aviv, Sifriat Hapoalim, 1992)Google Scholar; Barzilai, G. and Keren, M., “The Incorporation of Periphery Groups in Israeli Society and Polity in an Age of Peace”, internal paper presented to the Israeli Democracy Institute, Jerusalem, 1997Google Scholar. For a detailed analysis, see Kretzmer, D., The Legal Status of the Arabs in Israel (Boulder, Col., Westview Press, 1990)Google Scholar. For a different perspective, see Stendel, U., “The Rights of Israeli Arabs to Be Different: Legal Aspects” (1989) 32 The New East 192–207Google Scholar.

25 Barzilai, Democracy and War, supra n. 24; Barzilai and Keren, “Incorporation of Periphery Groups in Israeli Society”, supra n. 24.

26 Survey by the Tami Steinmetz Peace Research Center, Tel Aviv University, March 1995.

27 Amara, M., “The Collective Identity of Israeli Arabs in Peacetime” in Israeli Society between Division and Unity (Tami Steinmetz Center, Tel Aviv University, 1998)Google Scholar.

28 Peres, Y. and Yuchtman-Yaar, E., Democracy and Security (Jerusalem, Israeli Democracy Institute, 1998)Google Scholar.

29 Smooha, S., “Existential Policies and Alternatives Regarding Arab Israelis” (1980) 26:1Megamot 7–36Google Scholar; Smooha, S., “Three Approaches to the Sociology of Ethnic Relations in Israel” (1984) 28:2–3Megamot 69–96Google Scholar; Lustick, Arabs in a Jewish State, supra n. 15; Reches, E., “Arabs in Israel and the Arabs in the Territories: Political Ties and National Solidarity (1967-1988)” (1989) 31 The New East 165–91Google Scholar; Reches, E., The Arab Minority in Israel: Between Communism and Arab Nationalism 1965-1991 (Tel Aviv, Dayan Center/Hakibbutz Hameuhad, 1993)Google Scholar; Cohen, R., The Loyalty Thicket: Society and Politics in the Arab Sector (Tel Aviv, Am Oved, 1990)Google Scholar; Benziman, E. and Manzur, E., Second Class Citizens (Jerusalem, Keter, 1992)Google Scholar; Peled, “Ethnic Democracy”, supra n. 23; Yiftachel, O., “Research on the Arab Minority in Israel and Its Relations with the Jewish Majority: Survey and Analysis” in Surveys on Arabs in Israel (Givat Haviva, Center for Peace Research, 1993)Google Scholar; Lewin-Epstein, N. and Semyonov, M., The Arab Minority in Israel's Economy: Patterns of Economic Inequality (Boulder, Col., Westview, 1993)Google Scholar; Alhag, M., Education among Israeli Arabs: Control and Social Change (Jerusalem, Magnes, 1996)Google Scholar; Shamir, R., “Suspended in Space: Bedouins under the Law of Israel.” (1996) 30 Law and Society Rev. 231–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ganam, Israeli Arab Political Participation, supra n. 17; Kaufman, I., Arab National Communism in the Jewish State (Gainesville, Florida Univ. Press, 1997)Google Scholar; Kedar, S., “Majority Time, Minority Time: Land, Nation, and the Law of Adverse Possession in Israel” (1998) 21:3TAU L. Rev. 746Google Scholar.

30 Meyir, T., “Young Muslims in Israel” (1989) 32 The New East 10–20Google Scholar.

31 Sheikh Abdhala Darwish, at Tel Aviv University, 1996.

32 Clause 2(b).

33 See, e.g., HCJ 409/72 Said Chatar v. Haifa Druze Court (1973) 27(i) P.D 449.

34 HCJ 240/98 Adalah v. Ministry of Religion, 55 Dinim 162.

35 Protection of Holy Sites Law, 1967.

36 Protection of Holy Sites Regulations, 1981.

37 Adalah Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, Legal Violations of Arab Minority Rights in Israel (Shfaram, Adalah, 1998)Google Scholar.

38 See, e.g., HCJ 175/71 Abu-Gosh Music Festival v. Minister of Education (1971) 25(ii) P.D. 821. The Court justified the Ministry's position of not financially supporting a festival of Christian religious music, claiming that freedom of religion does not include an obligation of the state to support the dissemination of religion. The Court ignored the fact, however, that Jewish religious institutions are heavily supported by the state. It is interesting to note that the ruling was written by an Orthodox Jewish justice, Justice Kister.

39 Administration of Antiquities Law, 1989; National Parks, Natural Reservations and National Sites Law, 1963.

40 Article 82 of the Palestine Order in Council, 1922.

41 C.A. 105/92 Re'em Engineering Ltd. v. Municipality of Upper Nazereth (1993) 47(v) P.D. 189.

42 M. Alhag, Education among Israeli Arabs, supra n. 29.

43 Asba, Aben, The Arab Education System in Israel (Givat Haviva, Center for Peace Studies, 1997)Google Scholar.

44 Zureik et al., “Perceptions of Legal Inequality”, supra n. 11; Rattner, “The Margins of Justice” supra n. 11.

45 Zureik et al., “Perceptions of Legal Inequality”, supra n. 11.

46 Barzilai, G., Yuchtman-Yaar, E., and Segal, Z., The Supreme Court and the Israeli Society (Tel Aviv, Papyrus–Tel Aviv University Press, 1994)Google Scholar.

47 Kedar, “Majority Time, Minority Time”, supra n. 29; Shamir, “Suspended in Space”, supra n. 29.

48 E.g., Ka'adan, supra n. 2, at 19.