Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-sxzjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T20:07:08.192Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The ziggurrat and temples of Nimrud

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 August 2014

J. E. Reade
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The buildings on the citadel of Nimrud, ancient Kalah or Kalḫu, constitute a most impressive monument (Fig. 1; Postgate and Reade 1980), but the sporadic way in which they have been excavated leaves many questions unanswered. One puzzling area lies north and north-east of the great North-West Palace. It includes the ziggurrat, and the shrines of Ninurta, of Ištar Šarrat Nipḫi (formerly read Bēlat Māti) and of the Kidmuri (or Ištar Bēlat Kidmuri). Their interrelationships have yet to be established, and texts refer to further gods resident at Kalah. Excavations in this quarter were conducted by Layard, Rassam, Rawlinson, Loftus and Smith in the nineteenth century, and by Mallowan in the 1950s, and were resumed by staff of the Iraq Directorate-General of Antiquities in the early 1970s. This paper summarizes some of what we know or may deduce about the area, and defines some of the remaining problems; it does not include, except in passing, the relatively well-known Nabû Temple to the south. I have endeavoured to refer to all items except sherds found during British excavations in the area, but have not attempted the detailed publication which many of the objects, groups of objects, and pottery records may merit.

A possible arrangement of the buildings in this area of Nimrud about 800 BC is given in Fig. 2, but it is a reconstruction from inadequate evidence. The relative dates, dimensions, locations and orientations of many excavated structures are arguable, and the plans published by different excavators cannot be fully reconciled. Major uncertainties concern the ziggurrat, the citadel-wall, the Kidmuri shrine and the area between the North-West Palace and the Ninurta shrine. There are many minor uncertainties. My reconstruction includes speculative features, while omitting some excavated walls which I regard as secondary.

Type
Research Article
Information
IRAQ , Volume 64 , 2002 , pp. 135 - 216
Copyright
Copyright © The British Institute for the Study of Iraq 2002 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abou-Assaf, A., Bordreuil, P., and Millard, A. R. 1982 La statue de Tell Fekherye et son inscription bilingue assyro-araméenne. Paris.Google Scholar
Agha, A. Ameen, and al-Iraqi, M. Sa'id 1976 Nimrud “Calah”. Baghdad.Google Scholar
Albenda, P. 1986 The Palace of Sargon, King of Assyria. Paris.Google Scholar
Albenda, P. 1991 Decorated Assyrian knob-plates in the British Museum. Iraq 53: 43–53.Google Scholar
Al-Gailani-Werr, L. 1999 Antiquities in Iraq. British School of Archaeology in Iraq Newsletter 3 (05 1999): 3–5.Google Scholar
Andrae, W. 1925 Coloured Ceramics from Ashur. London.Google Scholar
Andrae, W. 1935 Die jüngeren Ischtar-Tempel in Assur (Wissenschaftliche Veroffentlichung der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 58). Leipzig.Google Scholar
Anonymous n.d. Original Color Slides, Vol. 6: no. 68. Published by Republic of Iraq, Ministry of Culture and Information, State Organization of Antiquities and Heritage. About 1982. Produced by Alpha Industries Co. Ltd, Japan; printed by Dai Nippon Printing Co. Ltd, Japan.Google Scholar
Barag, D. P. 1985 Catalogue of Western Asiatic Glass in the British Museum, Vol. I. London.Google Scholar
Barnett, R. D. 1975 A Catalogue of the Nimrud Ivories in the British Museum. 2nd edition. London.Google Scholar
Barnett, R. D., and Falkner, M. 1962 The Sculptures of Tiglath-pileser III. London.Google Scholar
Barrelet, M.-T. 1955 Les déesses armées et ailées. Syria 32: 222–60.Google Scholar
Brinkman, J. A. 1968 A Political History of Post-Kassite Babylonia 1158-722 BC. (Analecta Orientalia 43). Rome.Google Scholar
Budge, E. A. W. 1914 Assyrian Sculptures in the British Museum: Reign of Ashur-nasir-pal, BC 885-860. London.Google Scholar
Budge, E. A. W., and King, L. W. 1902 Annals of the Kings of Assyria in the British Museum. London.Google Scholar
Calmeyer, P. 1974 Zur Genese altiranischer Motive II: der leere Wagen. Archaeologische Mitteilungen aus Iran (NF) 7: 49–77.Google Scholar
Canby, J. V. 1971 Decorated garments in Ashurnasirpal's sculpture. Iraq 33: 31–53.Google Scholar
Clive, R. H. 1852 Sketches between the Persian Gulf and the Black Sea. London.Google Scholar
Cole, S. W., and Machinist, P. 1998 Letters from Priests to the Kings Esarhaddon and Assurbanipal (State Archives of Assyria 13). Helsinki.Google Scholar
Curtis, J. E. 1979 An Examination of Late Assyrian Metalwork with Special Reference to Material from Nimrud (Ph.D. dissertation, Institute of Archaeology, University of London). 2 vols.Google Scholar
Curtis, J. E., and Maxwell-Hyslop, K. R. 1971 The gold jewellery from Nimrud. Iraq 33: 101–12.Google Scholar
Curtis, J. E., and Reade, J. E. (editors) 1995 Art and Empire: Treasures from Assyria in the British Museum. London.Google Scholar
Dalley, S., and Postgate, J. N. 1984 The Tablets from Fort Shalmaneser (Cuneiform Texts from Nimrud 3). London.Google Scholar
Damerji, M. S. B. 1999 Gräber assyrischer Königinnen aus Nimrud (Jahrbuch des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums 45 — 1998). Mainz.Google Scholar
Deller, K. 1966 The Neo-Assyrian epigraphical remains of Nimrud. Orientalia 35: 179–94.Google Scholar
Deller, K. 1992 Einleitung; Neuassyrische Rituale für den Einsatz der Götterstreitwagen. In Pongratz-Leisten, B., Deller, K., and Bleibtreu, E., Götterstreitwagen und Götterstandarten: Götter auf dem Feldzug und ihr Kult im Feldlager, Baghdader Mitteilungen 23: 291–356 (291–8, 341–6).Google Scholar
Dieulafoy, M. 1885 L'art antique de la Perse, troisième partie: la sculpture persépolitaine. Paris.Google Scholar
Dittmann, R. 1990 Ausgrabungen der Freien Universität Berlin in Assur und Kār-Tukulfī-Ninurta in den Jahren 1986–89. Mitteilungen der Deutchen Orient-Gesellschaft zu Berlin 122: 157–71.Google Scholar
Eickhoff, T. 1985 Kār Tukulti Ninurta: eine mittelassyrische Kult- und Residenzstadt (Abhandlungen der deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 21). Berlin.Google Scholar
Fales, F. M., and Postgate, J. N. 1992 Imperial Administrative Records, Part I: Palace and Temple Administration (State Archives of Assyria 7). Helsinki.Google Scholar
Filippi, W. de 1977 The royal inscriptions of Aššur-nāṣir-apli II (883–859 B.c.). Assur 1/7: 123–69 (1–47).Google Scholar
Finkel, I. L., and Reade, J. E. 1996 Assyrian hieroglyphs. Zeitschrift für Assyriologie 86/2: 244–68.Google Scholar
Frame, G. 1991 Assyrian clay hands. Baghdader Mitteilungen 22: 335–81.Google Scholar
Frankena, R. 1953 Tākultu: de Sakrale Maaltijd in het Assyrische Ritueel. Leiden.Google Scholar
Fuchs, A. 1993 Die Inschriften Sargons II. aus Khorsabad. Göttingen.Google Scholar
Gadd, C. J. 1936 The Stones of Assyria. London.Google Scholar
Gadd, C. J. 1938 A visiting artist at Nineveh in 1850. Iraq 5: 118–23.Google Scholar
Galter, H. D. 1987 On beads and curses. Annual Review of the Royal Inscriptions of Mesopotamia Project 5: 11–30.Google Scholar
George, A. R. 1992 Babylonian Topographical Texts (Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta 40). Leuven.Google Scholar
Grayson, A. K. 1987 Assyrian Rulers of the Third and Second Millennia BC (to 1115 BC) (The Royal Inscriptions of Mesopotamia, Assyrian Periods 1). Toronto/Buifalo/London.Google Scholar
Grayson, A. K. 1991 Assyrian Rulers of the Early First Millennium BC, Part 1 (1114-859 BC) (The Royal Inscriptions of Mesopotamia, Assyrian Periods 2). Toronto/Buifalo/London.Google Scholar
Grayson, A. K. 1996 Assyrian Rulers of the Early First Millennium BC, Part II (858–745 BC) (The Royal Inscriptions of Mesopotamia, Assyrian Periods 3). Toronto/Buffalo/London.Google Scholar
Hall, H. R. 1928 Babylonian and Assyrian Sculpture in the British Museum, Paris/Brussels.Google Scholar
Haller, A., and Andrae, W. 1955 Die Heiligtümer des Gottes Assur und der Sin-Šamaš-Tempel in Assur (Wissenschaftliche Veröffentlichung der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 67). Berlin.Google Scholar
Heinrich, E. 1982 Die Tempel und Heiligtümer im alten Mesopotamien; Typologie, Morphologie und Geschichte (Denkmäler Antiker Architektur, 14). 2 vols. Berlin.Google Scholar
Herrmann, G. 1986 Ivories from Room SW 37, Fort Shalmaneser: Commentary and Catalogue (Ivories from Nimrud IV. 1). London.Google Scholar
Herrmann, G., and Curtis, J. E. 1998 Reflections on the four-winged genie: a pottery jar and an ivory panel from Nimrud. Iranica Antiqua 33: 107–34.Google Scholar
Hincks, E. 1854 Readings of Inscriptions on the Nineveh Marbles. Manuscript, British Library, Add. Ms. 22097.Google Scholar
Hulin, P. 1966 Inscribed fragments of a statue from Nimrud. Iraq 28/1: 84–8.Google Scholar
Huxley, M. 2000 The gates and guardians in Sennacherib's addition to the Temple of Assur. Iraq 62: 109–37.Google Scholar
Jones, F. 1855 Topography of Nineveh. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society 15: 297–397.Google Scholar
Kataja, L., and Whiting, R. 1995 Grants, Decrees and Gifts of the Neo-Assyrian Period (State Archives of Assyria 12). Helsinki.Google Scholar
Kohler, J., and Ungnad, A. 1913 Assyrische Rechtsurkunden. Leipzig.Google Scholar
Koldewey, R. 1911 Die Tempel von Babylon und Borsippa (Wissenschaftliche Veröffentlichung der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 15). Leipzig.Google Scholar
Lambert, W. G. 1965 A Middle Assyrian tablet of incantations. In Güterbock, H. G. and Jacobsen, T., editors, Studies in Honor of Benno Landsberger on his Seventy-Fifth Birthday April 21 1965 (Assyriological Studies 16): 283–8. Chicago.Google Scholar
Larsen, M. T. 1994 The Conquest of Assyria: Excavations in an Antique Land, 1840–1860. London.Google Scholar
Layard, A. H. 1849 Nineveh and its Remains. 2 vols. London.Google Scholar
Layard, A. H. 1851 Inscriptions in the Cuneiform Character from Assyrian Monuments. London.Google Scholar
Layard, A. H. 1852 Mr Layard's remarks following a lecture, Royal Asiatic Society: Proceedings of the Twenty-Ninth Anniversary Meeting of the Society, xlii–xliii.Google Scholar
Layard, A. H. 1853 Discoveries in the Ruins of Nineveh and Babylon. London.Google Scholar
Layard, A. H. 1853A A Second Series of the Monuments of Nineveh. London.Google Scholar
Le Gac, Y. 1907 Les inscriptions d'Aššur-nasir-aplu III, roi d'Assyrie (885–860 av. J.-C.). Paris.Google Scholar
Loud, G., and Altman, C. B. 1938 Khorsabad, Part II: the Citadel and the Town (Oriental Institute Publications 40). Chicago.Google Scholar
Loud, G., Frankfort, H., and Jacobsen, T. 1936 Khorsabad, Part I: Excavations in the Palace and at a City Gate (Oriental Institute Publications 38). Chicago.Google Scholar
Luckenbill, D. D. 1927 Ancient Records of Assyria and Babylonia, Vol. II: Historical Records of Assyria from Sargon to the End. Chicago.Google Scholar
Mallowan, B. 1993 Assyrian temple furniture. In Mellink, M., Porada, E., and Özgüç, T., editors, Aspects of Art and Iconography: Anatolia and its Neighbours – Studies in Honor of Nimet Özgüç, Ankara: 383–7.Google Scholar
Mallowan, M. E. L. 1950 The excavations at Nimrud (Kalhu), 1949–1950. Iraq 12: 147–83.Google Scholar
Mallowan, M. E. L. 1952 The excavations at Nimrud (Kalhu), 1951. Iraq 14: 1–23.Google Scholar
Mallowan, M. E. L. 1953 The excavations at Nimrud (Kalhu), 1952. Iraq 15: 1–42.Google Scholar
Mallowan, M. E. L. 1954 The excavations at Nimrud (Kalhu), 1953. Iraq 16: 59–163.Google Scholar
Mallowan, M. E. L. 1957 The excavations at Nimrud (Kalhu), 1956. Iraq 19: 1–25.Google Scholar
Mallowan, M. E. L. 1966 Nimrud and its Remains.3 vols. London.Google Scholar
Margueron, J.-C. 1995 Le palais de Sargon: reflèxions préliminaires à une étude architecturale. In Caubet, A., editor, Khorsabad, le palais de Sargon II, roi d'Assyrie: 181–212. Paris.Google Scholar
Menzel, B. 1981 Assyrische Tempel (Studia Pohl: Series Maior 10). 2 vols. Rome.Google Scholar
Meuszyński, J. 1972 The representations of the four-winged genies on the bas-reliefs from Aššur-naṣir-apli times. Études et Travaux 6: 28–70.Google Scholar
Meuszyński, J. 1976 Neo-Assyrian Reliefs from the central area of Nimrud citadel. Iraq 38: 37–43.Google Scholar
Meuszyński, J. 1981 Die Rekonstruktion der Relief dar Stellungen und ihrer Anordnung im Nordwestpalast von Kalḫu ( Nimrud) (Baghdader Forschungen 2). Mainz am Rhein.Google Scholar
Millard, A. 1994 The Eponyms of the Assyrian Empire 910–612 BC (State Archives of Assyria Studies 2). Helsinki.Google Scholar
Moorey, P. R. S. 1994 Ancient Mesopotamian Materials and Industries: the Archaeological Evidence. Oxford.Google Scholar
Moortgat-Correns, U. 1988 Ein Kultbild Ninurtas aus neuassyrischer Zeit. Archiv für Orientforschung 35: 117–35.Google Scholar
Mahmoud, Muzahim 1995 Excavation and restoration works, Nabu Temple, Nimrud. Sumer 47 (1995), Arabic section: 28-34 = Sumer 47, Supplement (1997): 14–8.Google Scholar
Mahmud, Muzahim and Black, J. 1986 Recent work in the Nabu Temple, Nimrud. Sumer 44: 135–55.Google Scholar
Nassouhi, E. 1925 Les autels trépieds assyriens. Revue d'Assyriologie 22: 85–90.Google Scholar
Nunn, A. 1988 Die Wandmalerei und der glasierte Wandschmuck im alten Orient (Handbuch der Orientalistik 7/1/2/B6). Leiden.Google Scholar
Oates, D. 1957 Ezida: the Temple of Nabu. Iraq 19: 26–39.Google Scholar
Oates, D. 1958 The Assyrian building south of the Nabu Temple. Iraq 20: 109–13.Google Scholar
Oates, D. 1967 The Excavations at Tell al Rimah, 1966. Iraq 29: 70–96.Google Scholar
Oates, D. 1974 Balawat (Imgur Enlil): the site and its buildings. Iraq 36: 173–8.Google Scholar
Oates, J., and Oates, D. 2001 Nimrud — An Assyrian Imperial City Revealed, London.Google Scholar
Olmstead, A. T. 1923 History of Assyria. New York/London.Google Scholar
Paley, S. M. 1976 King of the World: Ashur-nasir-pal II of Assyria 883-859 BC. New York.Google Scholar
Paley, S. M., and Sobolewski, R. P. 1987 The reconstruction of the relief representations and their positions in the Northwest-Palace at Kalhu (Nimrud), II (Rooms I.S.T.Z, West Wing) (Baghdader Forschungen 10). Mainz am Rhein.Google Scholar
Parker, B. 1954 The Nimrud tablets, 1952 — business documents. Iraq 16: 29–58.Google Scholar
Parker, B. 1961 Administrative tablets from the North-West Palace, Nimrud. Iraq 23: 15–67.Google Scholar
Parker, B. 1962 Seals and seal impressions from the Nimrud excavations, 1955–58. Iraq 24: 26–40.Google Scholar
Parpola, S. 1987 The correspondence of Sargon II, Part 1: Letters from Assyria and the West (State Archives of Assyria 1). Helsinki.Google Scholar
Parpola, S. 1999 Letters from Priests to the Kings Esarhaddon and Assurbanipal (State Archives of Assyria 13). Helsinki.Google Scholar
Pomponio, F. 1978 Nabu: il Culto e la Figura di un Dio del Pantheon babilonese ed assiro (Studi Semitici 51). Roma.Google Scholar
Pongratz-Leisten, B. 1992 Mesopotamische Standarten in literarischen Zeugnissen. In Pongratz-Leisten, B., Délier, K., and Bleibtreu, E., Götterstreitwagen und Götterstandarten: Götter auf dem Feldzug und ihr Kult im Feldlager, Baghdader Mitteilungen 23: 291–356 (299–340).Google Scholar
Postgate, J. N. 1972 Editor, Excavations in Iraq, 1971–2. Iraq 34: 139–50.Google Scholar
Postgate, J. N. 1973 The Governor's Palace Archive (Cuneiform Texts from Nimrud 2). London.Google Scholar
Postgate, J. N. 1975 Editor, Excavations in Iraq, 1973–4. Iraq 37: 56–67.Google Scholar
Postgate, J. N. 1977 The First Empires. Oxford.Google Scholar
Postgate, J. N., and Reade, J. E. 1980. Kalhu. Reallexikon der Assyriologie 5: 303–23. Berlin.Google Scholar
Rassam, H. 1878–1879 Letters and reports in British Museum Central Archive: Assyrian Excavations , Vol. I, and Original Papers for 1879.Google Scholar
Rassam, H. 1882 Excavations and discoveries in Assyria. Transactions of the Society of Biblical Archaeology 7: 37–58.Google Scholar
Rassam, H. 1897 Asshur and the Land of Nimrod. New York/Cincinnati.Google Scholar
Ravn, O. E. 1953 Die Reliefs der assyrischen Könige, zweite Reihe. 2. Die assyrischen Reliefs in Kopenhagen. Archiv für Orientforschung 16: 231–44.Google Scholar
Rawlinson, H. C., and Norris, E. 1861 The Cuneiform Inscriptions of Western Asia, Vol. I. London.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1965 Twelve Ashurnasirpal reliefs. Iraq 27: 119–34.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1970 The Design and Decoration of Neo-Assyrian Public Buildings (Ph.D. dissertation, University of Cambridge). Available on microfilm.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1977 Shikaft–i Gulgul: its date and symbolism. Iranica Antiqua 12: 33–44.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1983 Assyrian Sculpture. London.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1985 Texts and sculptures from the North-West Palace, Nimrud. Iraq 47: 203–14.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1989 Shalmaneser or Ashurnasirpal in Ararat? State Archives of Assyria Bulletin 3: 93–7.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1993 Hormuzd Rassam and his discoveries. Iraq 55: 39–62.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1995 The symposion in ancient Mesopotamia: archaeological evidence. In Murray, O. and Tecusan, M., editors, In Vino Veritas: 35–56. London.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1995 A The Khorsabad glazed bricks and their symbolism. In Caubet, A., editor, Khorsabad, le palais de Sargon II, roi d'Assyrie: 225–51. Paris.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 1998 Assyrian illustrations of Nineveh. Iranica Antiqua 33: 81–94.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 2000 Ninive (Nineveh). Reallexikon für Assyriologie 9 (5–6): 388–433.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. 2000A Mesopotamia. 2nd edition. London.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E. Forthcoming: Sexism and homotheism in ancient Iraq. Proceedings of the 2001 Rencontre assyriologique internationale, Helsinki.Google Scholar
Reade, J. E., and Walker, C. B. F. 1982 Some Neo–Assyrian royal inscriptions. Archiv für Orientforschung 28: 113–22.Google Scholar
Russell, J. M. 1998 The program of the palace of Assurnasirpal II at Nimrud: issues in the research and presentation of Assyrian art. American Journal of Archaeology 102: 655–715.Google Scholar
Safar, F. 1957 The Temple of Sibitti at Khorsabad. Sumer 13: 219–21 (English section), Figs 1–4 (Arabic section) between pp. 196–7.Google Scholar
Searight, A., Finkel, I. L., Leslie, K., and Reade, J. E. Forthcoming: Assyrian Stone Vessels in the British Museum.Google Scholar
Smith, G. 1875 Assyrian Discoveries. London.Google Scholar
Sobolewski, R. 1982 The Shalmanaser III Building in the central area of the Nimrud citadel. Archiv für Orientforschung, Beiheft 19: 329–38.Google Scholar
Sollberger, E. 1987 A bead for Sennacherib. In Rochberg-Halton, F., editor, Language, Literature and History: Philological and Historical Studies Presented to Erica Reiner (American Oriental Series 67): 379–82. New Haven, Conn.Google Scholar
Stearns, J. B. 1961 Reliefs from the Palace of Ashurnasirpal II (Archiv für Orientforschung, Beiheft 15). Graz.Google Scholar
Stepniowski, F. M. 1988 Metrologische und geometrische Interpretationen der Grundrisse sakrale Bauwerke in Assur. Mitteilungen der Deutschen Orient–Gesellschaft zu Berlin 120: 173–88.Google Scholar
Strommenger, E. 1970 Die neuassyrische Rundskulptur. Berlin.Google Scholar
Stronach, D. 1958 Metal objects from the 1957 excavations at Nimrud. Iraq 20: 169–81.Google Scholar
Tadmor, H. 1994 The Inscriptions of Tiglath–pileser HI, King of Assyria. Jerusalem.Google Scholar
Thompson, R. Campbell, and Hutchinson, R. W. 1931 The site of the Palace of Ashurnasirpal at Nineveh, excavated in 1929–30 on behalf of the British Museum. Annals of Archaeology and Anthropology 18: 79–112.Google Scholar
Thureau-Dangin, F., Barrois, A., Dossin, G., and Dunand, M. 1931 Arslan–Tash (Bibliothèque archéologique et historique, 16). Paris.Google Scholar
Tucker, D. 1992 A Middle Assyrian hoard from Khirbet Karhasan, Iraq. Iraq 54: 157–82.Google Scholar
Turner, G. 1968 The palace and Bâtiment aux Ivoires at Arslan Tash: a reappraisal. Iraq 30: 62–8.Google Scholar
Walpole, F. 1851 The Ansayrii and the Assassins. 3 vols. London.Google Scholar
Weidner, E. F. 1926 Assyrische Emailgemälde vom achten Feldzuge Sargons II. Archiv für Orientforschung 3: 1–6.Google Scholar
Wiseman, D. J. 1953 The Nimrud tablets, 1953. Iraq 15: 135–60.Google Scholar
Wiseman, D. J., and Black, J. A. 1996 Literary Texts from the Temple of Nabu (Cuneiform Texts from Nimrud 4). London.Google Scholar
Wiseman, D. J., and Wilson, J. V. Kinnier 1951 The Nimrud tablets, 1950. Iraq 13: 102–19.Google Scholar
Woolley, C. L., and Barnett, R. D. 1952 Carchemish: Report on the Excavations at Jerablus on behalf of the British Museum. Part III: the Excavations in the Outer Town and the Hittite Inscriptions. London.Google Scholar