Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-dfsvx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T14:51:25.743Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Beyond “imagined” nostalgia: Gunsan's heritagization of Japanese colonial architecture in South Korea

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 June 2021

Hyun Kyung Lee
Hyun Kyung Lee*
Affiliation:
CRASSH, Cambridge CB3 9DT, UK Research Institute of Cultural Heritage (RICH), Hankuk University of Foreign Studies, 107 Imun-ro, Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul 02450, South Korea
*
Corresponding author: Hyun Kyung Lee, E-mail: hklee2278@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In South Korea, romanticization of the era of Japanese colonial rule (1910–1945) has long been taboo: the period is widely regarded as one of the most painful and shameful parts of South Korean history. However, during the past decade unexpected cracks have appeared in established national narratives on the colonial period. This paper explores the dissonance between long-standing national narratives and the commodification of local heritage sites for tourism, by examining the heritagization of Japanese colonial architecture in the city of Gunsan. Despite the Gunsan Municipal Government positions the city's colonial stories in ways that largely align with national official narratives on Japanese colonial history, such efforts have unexpectedly generated feelings of imagined nostalgia in three ways: (1) through clashes between official colonial history and the means by which colonial daily life is depicted in Gunsan's Modern Cultural Belt; (2) through the interwoven colonial and post-colonial stories presented in the city's Modern Historic Landscape District and (3) through the commercialized colonial and post-colonial stories articulated by private businesses in Gunsan. This paper suggests that productive nostalgia can help to overcome the limit of the current form of Gunsan's heritagization, and to construct Gunsan's diverse local memories

Keywords

Gunsanheritagization, (imagined)nostalgiaJapanese colonial architectureproductive nostalgia
Type
Research Article
Information
International Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 20 , Issue 1 , January 2023 , pp. 91 - 113
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

‡

The online version of this article has been updated since original publication. A notice detailing the changes has also been published at http://doi.org/10.1017/S1479591422000134

References

Bae, Joo-Hee. (2015). “도시를 열다: 아픈 역사를 안고 새로운 미래로 나아가는 곳, 군산.” [Opening of a City: Gunsan, a City with a Painful History and a New Future]. Urban Affairs 50:555, pp. 36–40.Google Scholar
Bang, Sang-yeol and Amara, Mahfoud (2014). “The Study of Discourse on Change in South Korean Football: Between Tradition and Modernity, from Colonial to Post-Colonial.” The International Journal of the History of Sport 31:6, pp. 618–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blunt, Alison. (2003). “Collective Memory and Productive Nostalgia: Anglo-Indian Homemaking at McCluskieganj.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 21:6, pp. 717–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brigard, Felipe De (2018). “Nostalgia Reimagined.” Aeon. https://aeon.co/essays/nostalgia-doesnt-need-real-memories-an-imagined-past-works-as-well [Accessed on October 20, 2020].Google Scholar
Brown, Andrew D., Michael Humphreys, (2002). “Nostalgia and the Narrativization of Identity: A Turkish Case Study.” British Journal of Management 13:2, pp. 141–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Campbell, Gary, Laurajane, Smith and Margaret, Wetherell (2017). “Nostalgia and Heritage: Potentials, Mobilisations and Effects.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 23:7, pp. 609–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chiang, Min-Chin, Li-Ling, Huang, Shu-Mei, Huang and Hsiao, S. H. (2017). “Policy Formation and Civil Society Engagement in Heritage-Making in Taiwan: A Historical Examination.” In Citizens, Civil Society and Heritage-Making in Asia (pp. 232–50). Taiwan: ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute.Google Scholar
Cho, Geun-Young. (2019). 사진관⋅음악다방 복고감성 물씬… “낭만항구 목포로 오세요” [Photo Studio, Music Cafe, Retro Vibes … “Come Visit Romantic Mokpo Port”]. 24 April 2019. Yonhap News. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20190424139300054?input=1195m [Accessed on July 15. 2020].Google Scholar
Choi, Soon-Ho. (2016). “[전북 군산 도심] 사진관에 남겨진 18 년 전의 감동: 영화< 8 월의 크리스마스> 촬영지.” [[Gunsan, Jeollabukdo] Filming Location of the Movie <Christmas in August> Recreating Feelings from 18 Years Ago]. Monthly Samtoh, pp. 68–71.Google Scholar
Cronberg, Anja Aronowsky. (2009). Imagined Nostalgia and False Memories: Postmodernism and Fashion in the Late Twentieth Century. Vestoj. http://vestoj.com/postmodernism-and-fashion-in-the-late-twentieth-century/ [Accessed on October 13, 2020]Google Scholar
Empathy Museum. (n.d.). https://www.empathymuseum.com [Accessed on January 5, 2021].Google Scholar
Gunsan History Museum of Japanese Occupation. http://www.xn--zb0b8hl32cpa918d.com/contents.htm?code=1_1 [Accessed on July 2, 2020].Google Scholar
Gunsan Municipal Government. (n.d.). Gunsan Modern Architecture Exhibition Hall Brochure. Gunsan: Gunsan Municipal Government.Google Scholar
Gunsan Municipal Government. (n.d.). Gunsan Modern Art Museum Brochure. Gunsan: Gunsan Municipal Government.Google Scholar
Gunsan Modern History Museum. https://museum.gunsan.go.kr/index.jsp [Accessed on July 10, 2020].Google Scholar
Ha, Tae-Min. (2019). 1970 년대풍 세트장⋅순천만… 발길 닿는 곳곳 “인생샷” 하루가 짧아 [Suncheon Bay, Scenic Locations Everywhere, Including 1970s Themed Movie Set]. 8 March 2019. Hankuk Ilbo. https://www.hankookilbo.com/News/Read/201903071039019519 [Accessed on July 15, 2020].Google Scholar
Hartley, Leslie Poles. (1953). The Go-Between. London: Hamish Hamilton.Google Scholar
Henderson, Joan C. (2001). “Conserving Colonial Heritage: Raffles Hotel in Singapore.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 7:1, pp. 7–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henderson, Joan C. (2002). “Heritage Attractions and Tourism Development in Asia: A Comparative Study of Hong Kong and Singapore.” International Journal of Tourism Research 4:5, pp. 337–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hyun, Che-Hwa. (1994). 구.군산시 통합으로 광역도시 발판 구축 [Blueprint of a Metropolitan City Ready with the Integration of Okgu and Gunsan City]. 12 October 1994. Joongang Ilbo. https://news.joins.com/article/2952276 [Accessed on June 15, 2020]Google Scholar
Im, Sang-Hyeon. (2014). 추억의 달동네 구경오세요 [Come Visit the Old Village]. 15 December 2014. Yonhap News. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20141205067500053?input=1195m [Accessed on July 15, 2020].Google Scholar
Jang, Mi-Young. (2011). “군산, 식민지 근대의 디스토피아-채만식 장편소설 [탁류].” [Gunsan, Colonial Modern Dystopia-Chae Mansik's Novel [Takryu]]. Yeollin Jeonbuk 143, pp. 79–85.Google Scholar
Jinhua, Dai and Chen, Judy TH (1997). “Imagined Nostalgia.” Boundary 2, pp. 143–61.Google Scholar
Kim, Byeong-Soo and Jae-Hang, Park. (2019). 뉴트로 신드롬 [New-tro Syndrome]. 26 July 2019. MK. https://www.mk.co.kr/news/culture/view/2019/07/569686/ [Accessed on July 31, 2020].Google Scholar
Kim, Hyeon-Jeong. (2014). “Making Korean Modern Museums: Japanese Colonial Buildings as Heritage and Resource.” Acta Koreana 17:2, pp. 583–607.Google Scholar
Kim, Hye-Young. (2020). “Relishing Retro in Gunsan” 17 May 2020. Monthly Korea. http://www.korea.net/NewsFocus/Travel/view?articleId=183322 [Accessed on August 2, 2020].Google Scholar
Kim, Jong-Soo. (2018). “식민지 미화 투어리즘: 군산 근대문화도시 사업.” [Romanticizing Colonialism with Tourism: Gunsan's Modern Culture City Project]. Naeil Eul Yeo'neun Yeogsa 71, pp. 185–97.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Jong-Soo, Kim, Min-Young, Goo, Hee-Jin, Song, Seog-Ki, Kim, Tae-Woong, Lee, Jun-Ho, Kong, Jong-Goo and Kim, Jung-Gyu (2009). 군산의 과거와 미래 [Gunsan City's Past and Future]. Seoul: Sunin Press.Google Scholar
Kim, Min-Young. (2013). “군산의 근대역사경관 활용과 원도심재생.” [Use of Modern Historical Landscape and Regeneration of Old Town in Gunsan City]. Journal of Regional Studies and Development 13:1, pp. 1–15.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Min-Young. (2019). “일제강점기 군산의 사회와 경제.” [Gunsan’ Economic and Social Status During Japanese Colonial Period]. The 8th Colloquium of the Academy of Korean Social Welfare History, pp. 3–12.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Sang-Goo. (2015). 김두한 출세기 : 정치깡패와 깡패정치인 [Kim Doo-Han's Success: A Political Gangster and a Gangster Politician]. Seoul: Chaekgwa namu.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Sung-Do. (2012). 근현대 문화재 [Modern and Contemporary of Cultural Heritage]. Seoul: Goryeo.Google Scholar
Kim, Tae-Woong. (2005). “한말 (韓末), 일제강점 (日帝强占) 초기 군산 (群山) 어물시장 (魚物市場) 의 변동과 객주 (客主).” [A Study on the Change of Fishes Market and Inland Market Brokers on Gunsan, 1899–1919]. The Journal of Fisheries Business Administration 36:1, pp. 103–20.Google Scholar
Kim, Tae-Woong. (2009). “日帝下 群山府에서 住民의 移動事情과 階層分化의 양상.” [The Human Migration Patterns and the Aspect of Social Stratification in Kunsan Prefecture under Japanese Imperial Rule]. Journal of Koreanology 35, pp. 3–56.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Young-Joong. (2014). “근대문화유산을 활용한 군산 원도심 재생.” [Old Town Regeneration of Gunsan City Through Modern Cultural Heritage]. The Korea Spatial Planning Review 391, pp. 84–90.Google Scholar
Lee, Ah-Young. (2020). [Insight] “엄마의 추억을 소환합니다”…지금은 뉴트로 시대 [Recalling My Mother's Memories: The Age of New-tro]. 13 February 2020. MK. https://www.mk.co.kr/news/business/view/2020/02/147811/ [Accessed on July 31, 2020]Google Scholar
Lee, Chang-Jo. (2017). 군산시 3.5 만세 운동길 조성사업 완료 [Gunsan City Completes the Establishment of March 5 Movement Road]. 28 December 2017. Network Korea and News. http://www.nknews.kr/ab-1695–5428 [Accessed on June 15, 2020]Google Scholar
Lee, Hyun-Kyung. (2019). Difficult Heritage in Nation Building: South Korea and Post-Conflict Japanese Colonial Occupation Architecture. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, Joo-Bong. (2013). “영화에 나타난 공간이미지와 지역문화의 가능성:< 8 월의 크리스마스> 에 나타난 군산이미지를 중심으로.” [Filmic Image and the Possibility of Local Culture – Focussing on Gunsan's Image in Christmas in August]. Humanities Contents 29, pp. 103–24.Google Scholar
Lee, Seung-Joo. (2016). 도새재생 성공사례: 낡은 군산 옛도심 근대건축물 테마로 부활…연 80만명 찾는 관광도시로 [Successful Case on Urban Regeneration: Old Town Gunsan's Modern Architecture Theme Attracts 800,000 Tourists a Year]. 1 March 2016. Chosun Ilbo. https://biz.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2016/02/29/2016022901782.html [Accessed on June 30, 2020]Google Scholar
Lee, Leo Ou-fan and Li, Oufan. (1999). Shanghai Modern: The Flowering of a new Urban Culture in China, 1930–1945. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Lowenthal, David. (1985). The Past is a foreign Country. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Lu, Tracey L-D. (2009). “Heritage Conservation in Post-Colonial Hong Kong.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 15:2–3, pp. 258–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moon, Il-Yo. (2019). “문일요 [도시 재생, 길을 묻다] 1. 군산은 어떻게 성공했나” [Redirecting Urban Regeneration: How Did Gunsan Succeed?]. 29 January 2019. Chosun Ilbo. http://futurechosun.com/archives/38590 [Accessed on July 30, 2020]Google Scholar
Moon, Jeong-Gon. (2018). “군산 영화촬영지 “초원사진관” 관광객 발길 “북적” [Film Site “Chowon Photo Studio” in Gunsan is Filled with Tourists]. 29 January 2018. Jeonbugilbo. http://www.jjan.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=1148230 [Accessed on August 2, 2020].Google Scholar
Nakano, Ryoko. (2021). “Mobilizing Meiji Nostalgia and Intentional Forgetting in Japan's World Heritage Promotion.” International Journal of Asian Studies 18:1, pp. 27–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oh, Mi-Young. (2009). “‘Eternal Other’ Japan: South Koreans’ Postcolonial Identity.” The International Journal of the History of Sport 26:3, pp. 371–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Orr, Raymond. (2017). “The Nostalgic Native? The Politics and Terms of Heritage and Remembrance in Two Communities.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 23:7, pp. 643–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Park, Seon-Young. (2018). “전라북도 군산시 아픈역사를 보여주는 히로쓰가옥 (신흥동 일본식 가옥).” [Hirotsu House: A House that Testifies to the Painful History of Gunsan in Jeollabukdo (Japanese-style House in Sinheung-dong)]. 22 September 2018. Travel Today. http://www.traveli.co.kr/read/contentsView/289/0/23/0 [Accessed on July 20, 2020].Google Scholar
Park, Tae-Geon. (2008). “쌀 수탁 전진기지의 풍경-군산세관 100주년.” [Landscape of the Outpost for Rice Plundering – 100th Year Anniversary of the Gunsan Customs]. Platform 11, pp. 74–77.Google Scholar
Podoler, Guy. (2011). Monuments, Memory, and Identity: Constructing the Colonial Past in South Korea. Bern: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Reckwitz, Andreas. (2018). The Invention of Creativity: Modern Society and the Culture of the new. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Ryu, Bo-Seon. (2016). “군산의 근대 문화 유산과 역사.” [Gunsan's Modern Cultural Heritage and History]. Bulletin of the National University Library 34, pp. 5–20.Google ScholarPubMed
Sang, Tze-lan. (2012). “Reclaiming Taiwan's Colonial Modernity: The Case of Viva Tonal: The Dance Age.” In Documenting Taiwan on Film: Issues and Methods in new Documentaries, eds. Sylvia, Lin Li-chun and Deborah, Sang Tze-lan, pp. 60–88). New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Sedikides, Constantine and Wildschut, Tim. (2016). “Past Forward: Nostalgia as a Motivational Force.” Trends in cognitive sciences 20:5, pp. 319–21.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sedikides, Constantines and Wildschut, Tim. (2019). “The Sociality of Personal and Collective Nostalgia.” European Review of Social Psychology 30:1, pp. 123–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shin, Gi-Wook and Robinson, Michael (1999). Harvard East Asian Monographs 184: Colonial Modernity in Korea. Harvard Univ. Asia Center. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Laurajane and Campbell, Gary. (2017). “‘Nostalgia for the Future’: Memory, Nostalgia and the Politics of Class.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 23:7, pp. 612–27.Google Scholar
Song, Seok-Ki. (2019). “위기를 기회로, 군산의 끝없는 변신.” [Crisis Turned into Opportunity: Gunsan's Endless Transformation]. Planning and Policy 450, pp. 60–65.Google Scholar
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport. (2017). 군산, 공업도시 → 근대문화도시로 새로운 먹거리 창출 [Gunsan, Industrial City → Modern Culture City, Creating New Economy]. 27 February 2017. Government Press Release. http://www.molit.go.kr/USR/NEWS/m_71/dtl.jsp?lcmspage=74&id=95078915 [Accessed on May 20, 2020].Google Scholar
Veale, Kevin. (2017). “Gone Home, and the Power of Affective Nostalgia.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 23:7, pp. 654–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Won, Do-Yeon. (2016). “근대 식민지 경험의 탈각과 변용: 군산의 사례.” [Exuviation and Acculturation of Modern Colonial Experience: Case of Gunsan City]. Journal of Regional Studies 24:4, pp. 151–73.Google Scholar
Yang, Eun-Jung and Park, So-Hyeon. (2017). “군산시 원도심에 관한 계획방식의 변화와 특성: 1960 년대부터 2010 년대까지의 군산시 도시계획안 내용분석을 중심으로.” [Changes and Characteristics of Planning for the Historic Urban Core in Gunsan City – Based on a Content Analysis of Gunsan's Municipal Plans from the 1960's to the 2010's]. Journal of The Urban Design Institute of Korea 18:5, pp. 5–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yapp, Lauren. (2020). “The Future in the Past: Colonial Modernity as Urban Heritage in Contemporary Indonesia.” South East Asia Research 28:2, pp. 178–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yeomilang (or Yeomirang). (n.d.). http://yeomirang.com/?act=info.page&pcode=sub1_1 [Accessed on July 14, 2020].Google Scholar
Yi, Chang-Hyo and Jun-Young, Ryu. (2015). “Growth, Decline and the Challenges Facing a Policy-Dependent and Former-Colonial City: Gunsan, Korea.” Cities (London, England) 43, pp. 37–47.Google Scholar
Youn, Seung-Ho. (2014). “The Impact of the Colonial Architectural Heritage on South Korean's National Identity.” Unpublished PhD Thesis. Guildford: University of Surrey.Google Scholar
Zoh, Minjae. (2020). The Impacts of Dictatorship on Heritage Management. Wilmington: Vernon Press.Google Scholar