Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-17T19:35:30.222Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Barbarians in Gaul, Usurpers in Britain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2011

Michael Kulikowski
Michael Kulikowski
Affiliation:
Smith College, Northampton, MA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the first decade of the fifth century Gaul and Britain, Spain and Italy all suffered from a succession of barbarian invasions and Roman civil wars. We possess not just one but several literary accounts of the crisis, along with chronicles, poetry, and imperial laws that all help to illuminate its course, but the sequence of events bristles with technical difficulties. These have not been satisfactorily resolved in the countless modern narratives of the period, which regularly depend on one another rather than the ancient sources. The most recent treatment of the topic, by John Drinkwater, appeared in the pages of this journal, and represents a tremendous advance on our understanding of the crisis. Drinkwater's analysis clarifies any number of crucial interpretative points, and should be the first port of call for any one interested in the study of the period. Problems nevertheless remain. Drinkwater's episodic treatment of the period encourages a certain obscurity that a more systematic narrative might dispel, and he relies heavily upon badly understood ancient slanders against the regent Stilicho to underpin important parts of his narrative. What follows is in no sense an attack on Drinkwater's magisterial interpretation of usurpation and crisis, which warrants wholehearted endorsement. Instead, I would like to suggest that the welter of modern literature on the crisis has blinded us to how little we actually know about it, and that only by maintaining a rigorous awareness of what actually appears in the primary sources can we hope to enjoy the fruits of more nuanced interpretation.

Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 31 , November 2000 , pp. 325 - 345
Copyright
Copyright © Michael Kulikowski 2000. Exclusive Licence to Publish: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Amory, P. 1997: People and Identity in Ostrogothic Italy, 489–554, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anton, H.H. 1984: ‘Trier im Übergang von der römischen zur fränkischen Herrschaft’, Francia 12, 1–52Google Scholar
Arce, J. 1988: ‘Gerontius, el usurpador’, in España entre el mundo antiguo y el mundo medieval, Madrid, 68–121Google Scholar
Arce, J. 1995: ‘El catastrofismo de Hydacio y los camellos de laGallaecia’, in Velázquez, A.et al. (eds), Los últimos romanos en Lusitania, Mérida, 219–29Google Scholar
Bartholomew, P. 1982: ‘Fifth-century facts’, Britannia 13, 261–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baynes, N. 1955: ‘Stilicho and the barbarian invasions’, JRS 12 (1922), reprinted in Byzantine Studies and Other Essays, London, 326–42Google Scholar
Blockley, R.C. 1983: The Fragmentary Classicising Historians of Late Antiquity II, LiverpoolGoogle Scholar
Brennan, P. 1995: ‘The Notifia Dignitatum’, in Nicolet, C. (ed.), Les littératures techniques dans l'antiquité romaine. Entretiens Hardt 42, Geneva, 147–78Google Scholar
Burgess, R.W. 1993: The Chronicle ofHydatius and the Consularia Constantinopolitana, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Burns, T.S. 1994: Barbarians within the Gates of Rome, Bloomington, INGoogle Scholar
Bury, J.B. 1923: History of the Later Roman Empire from the Death of Theodosius I to the Death of Justinian (2 vols), LondonGoogle Scholar
Cameron, A. 1970: Claudian: Poetry and Propaganda at the Court ofHonorius, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Castellvi, G. 1995: ‘Clausurae (Les-Cluses, P.-O.): forteresses-frontières du Bas-Empire romain’, in Rouselle, A. (ed.), Frontières terrestres, frontières célestes dans l'antiquité, Perpignan, 81–117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cavallera, F. 1922: Saint Jérôme, sa vie et ses oeuvres (2 vols), LouvainGoogle Scholar
Chastagnol, A. 1973: ‘Le repli sur Arles des services administratifs gaulois en l'an 407 de notre ère’, RevHist 249, 23–40Google Scholar
Christie, N. 1995: The Lombards, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Clarke, C. (ed.) 1990: Reading the Past in Late Antiquity, SydneyGoogle Scholar
Courcelle, P. 1964: Histoire littéraire des grandes invasions germaniques (3rd edn), ParisGoogle Scholar
Courtois, C. 1955: Les Vandales et l'Afrique, ParisGoogle Scholar
Croke, B., and Emmett, A.M. (eds) 1983: History and Historians in Late Antiquity, SydneyGoogle Scholar
Demougeot, E. 1951: De l'unité à la division de l'empire romain, ParisGoogle Scholar
Demougeot, E. 1974: ‘Constantin III, empereur d'Arles’, in Hommages à A. Dupont, Montpellier, 83–125Google Scholar
de Ste. Croix, G.E.M. 1981: The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World, LondonGoogle Scholar
Drinkwater, J.F. 1998: ‘The usurpers Constantine III (407–411) and Jovinus (411–413)’, Britannia 29, 269–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dumville, D. 1977: ‘Sub-Roman Britain: history and legend’, History 62, 173–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ehling, K. 1997: ‘Zur Geschichte Constantins III’, Francia 23, 1–11Google Scholar
Elton, H. 1996: Warfare in Roman Europe, AD 350–425, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Esmonde, Cleary A.S. 1989: The End of Roman Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
Favrod, J. 1993: La chronique de Marius d'Avenches, LausanneGoogle Scholar
Fernández, Castro M.C. 1982: Villas romanas de España, MadridGoogle Scholar
Freeman, E.A. 1904: Western Europe in the Fifth Century, LondonGoogle Scholar
Gillett, A. 1993: ‘The date and circumstances of Olympiodorus of Thebes’, Traditio 48, 1–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halsall, G. 1999: ‘Movers and shakers: barbarians and the fall of Rome’, Early Medieval Europe 8, 131–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harries, J. 1992: ‘Christianity and the city in late Roman Gaul’, in Rich, J. (ed.), The City in Late Antiquity, London, 77–98Google Scholar
Heather, P. 1991: Goths and Romans, 332–489, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Heather, P. 1995: ‘The Huns and the end of the Roman Empire in western Europe’, EHR 110, 4–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holdsworth, C., and Wiseman, T.P. (eds) 1986: The Inheritance of Historiography, ExeterCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Járrega, Domínguez R. 1991: ‘Consideraciones sobre la cronologia de las murallas tardorromanas de Barcelona: ¿un fortificación del siglo V?’, Archivo Español de Arqueologia 64, 326–35Google Scholar
Jones, A.H.M. 1964: The Later Roman Empire, 284–602 (3 vols), OxfordGoogle Scholar
Jones, M.E. 1996. The End of Roman Britain, IthacaGoogle Scholar
Kulikowski, M. 1998: ‘The Epistula Honorii, again’, ZPE 122, 247–52Google Scholar
Kulikowski, M. 2000: ‘The Notitia Dignitatum as a historical source’, Historia forthcomingGoogle Scholar
Liebeschuetz, J.H.W.G. 1989: Barbarians and Bishops, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Liebeschuetz, J.H.W.G. 1992:, ‘Alaric's Goths: nation or army?’ in Drinkwater, J. and Elton, H. (eds), Fifth-Century Gaul: A Crisis of Identity?, Cambridge, 75–83Google Scholar
Lindner, R.P. 1981: ‘Nomadism, horses, and Huns’, Past and Present 92, 1–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Loseby, S.T. 1996: ‘Aries in Late Antiquity: Gallula Roma Arelas and Urbs Genesii’, in Christie, N. and Loseby, S.T. (eds), Towns in Transition, Aldershot, 45–70Google Scholar
MacMullen, R. 1965: Soldier and Civilian in the Later Roman Empire, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
Marrou, H.-I. 1952: ‘L'épitaphe vaticane du consulaire de Vienne Eventius’, REA 54, 326–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matthews, J.F. 1970: ‘Olympiodorus of Thebes and the history of the west (A.D. 407–425)’, JRS 60, 79–97Google Scholar
Matthews, J.F. 1975: Western Aristocracies and Imperial Court, AD 365–425, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Muhlberger, S. 1983: ‘The Gallic Chronicle of 452 and its authority for British events’, Britannia 14, 22–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Muhlberger, S. 1984: ‘Heroic kings and unruly generals: the Copenhagen Continuation of Prosper reconsidered’, Florilegium 6, 50–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Muhlberger, S. 1990: The Fifth-Century Chroniclers, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Musset, L. 1975: The Germanic Invasions, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
Paschoud, F. 1986: Zošime: Histoire nouvelle III, I (Livre V), ParisGoogle Scholar
Paschoud, F. 1989: Zošime: Histoire nouvelle III, 2 (Livre VI et index), ParisGoogle Scholar
Paschoud, F., and Szidat, J. (eds) 1997: Usurpationen in der Spätantike, Historia Einzelschriften 111, StuttgartGoogle Scholar
Placanica, A. 1997: Vittore da Tunnuna: Chronica. Chiesa e impero nell'età di Giustiniano, FlorenceGoogle Scholar
Pohl, W., and Reimitz, H. (eds) 1998: Strategies of Distinction: Th Construction of Ethnic Communities, 300–800, LeidenCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reinhart, W. 1952: Historia general del reino hispánico de los Suevos, MadridGoogle Scholar
Rivet, A.L.F. 1988: Gallia N arb onensis, LondonGoogle Scholar
Roberts, M. 1992: ‘Barbarians in Gaul: the response of the poets’, in Drinkwater, J.F. and Elton, H. (eds), Fifth-Century Gaul: A Crisis of Identity?, Cambridge, 97–106Google Scholar
Sanz, R. 1986: ‘Aproximación al estudio de los ejércitos privados en Hispánia durante la antigüedad tardía’, Gerión 4, 225–64Google Scholar
Scharf, R. 1992: ‘Der spanische Kaiser Maximus und die Ansiedlung der Westgoten in Aquitanien’, Historia 41, 374–84Google Scholar
Schmidt, L. 1933: Geschichte der deutschen Stämme I: Die Ostgermanen (2nd edn), MunichGoogle Scholar
Schmidt, L. 1942: Geschichte der Wandalen (2nd edn), MunichGoogle Scholar
Seeck, O. 1876: Notitia Dignitatum accedunt Notitia urbis Constantinopolitanae et latercula provinciarum, BerlinGoogle Scholar
Seeck, O. 1913: Geschichte des Untergangs der antiken Welt 5, BerlinGoogle Scholar
Seeck, O. 1920: Geschichte des Untergangs der antiken Welt 6, StuttgartGoogle Scholar
Sivan, H. 1993: Ausonius of Bordeaux: Genesis of a Gallic Aristocracy, LondonGoogle Scholar
Stein, E. 1959: Histoire du Bas-Empire I (2nd edn), J.-R. Palanque trans., ParisGoogle Scholar
Stevens, C.E. 1957: ‘Marcus, Gratian, Constantine’, Athenaeum 35, 316–47Google Scholar
Stroheker, K.F. 1948: Der senatorischen Adel im spätantiken Gallien, TübingenGoogle Scholar
Stroheker, K.F. 1972: ‘Spanien im spätrömischen Reich (284–475)’, Archivo Español de Arqueología 40-2, 587–605Google Scholar
Thompson, E.A. 1982: ‘Zosimus 6.10.2 and the letters of Honorius’, CQ 32, 445–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Valentin, L. 1900: St Prosper d'Aquitaine, ToulouseGoogle Scholar
Wolfram, H. 1988: History of the Goths, Berkeley and Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
Wolfram, H. 1995: Die Germanen, MunichGoogle Scholar
Wood, I.N. 1994: The Merovingian Kingdoms, 450–751, LondonGoogle Scholar