Hostname: page-component-7c8c6479df-hgkh8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-03-29T04:40:19.931Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Heritage preservation in religious contexts. Disciplinary challenges for the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 December 2021

Trinidad Rico*
Affiliation:
Department of Art History, Rutgers University, USA

Abstract

This article examines the ways in which global heritage discourse has operated across the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, from an ideological and historical perspective. Ideologically, I consider tensions between heritage preservation practice and religious traditions that share the same landscape or material culture. This discussion, which is relatively marginalized in the heritage literature, has an adverse effect on many attempts by heritage preservationists to mediate or resolve conflicts and contradictions surrounding this type of historic resource. Historically, I revisit the presence and inclusion of experts from the MENA region in the formative years of a global heritage ideology. In this discussion, I juxtapose the relative marginalization of the Middle East and North Africa in global heritage debates against the frequency with which sites and communities across this region are put in the spotlight of religion-driven heritage conflict. Addressing these two forms of (mis)representation, I aim to bring to the foreground the way in which heritage studies is implicated in the constructions of narratives about – not from or by – the MENA region.

Type
Discussion Article
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adams, C., 1998: Japan’s Ise Shrine and its thirteen-hundred-year-old reconstruction tradition, Journal of architectural education 52(1), 4960.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Byrne, D., 2004: Chartering heritage in Asia’s postmodern world, Conservation. The Getty Conservation Institute newsletter 19(2), 1619.Google Scholar
Byrne, D., 2007: Surface collection. Archaeological travels in Southeast Asia, Lanham.Google Scholar
Byrne, D., 2014: Counterheritage. Critical perspectives on heritage conservation in Asia, London and New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Byrne, D., 2019: Prospects for a postsecular heritage practice. Convergences between posthumanism and popular religious practice in Asia, Religions 10(7), 436.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Daher, R., and Maffi, I. (eds), 2014: The politics and practices of cultural heritage in the Middle East. Positioning the material past in contemporary societies, London.10.5040/9780755699872CrossRefGoogle Scholar
De Cesari, C., 2015: Post-colonial ruins. Archaeologies of political violence and IS, Anthropology today 31(6), 2226.10.1111/1467-8322.12214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deeb, L., and Winegar, J., 2016: Anthropology’s politics. Disciplining the Middle East, Stanford.Google Scholar
El Daly, O., 2008: Egyptology. The missing millennium. Ancient Egypt in medieval Arabic writings, London.Google Scholar
Elias, J., 2007: (Un)making idolatry. From Mecca to Bamiyan, Future anterior. Journal of historic preservation, history, theory and criticism 4(2), 1329.Google Scholar
Feener, R.M., 2017: Muslim cultures and pre-Islamic pasts. Changing perceptions of ‘heritage’, in Rico, T. (ed.), Islamic pasts and heritage presents, London, 2346.10.1007/978-981-10-4071-9_3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flood, F.B., 2002: Between cult and culture. Bamiyan, islamic iconoclasm, and the museum, Art bulletin 84(4), 641–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldstein, E., 2011: Redeeming holy wisdom. Britain and St. Sophia, in M. Hall (ed.), Towards world heritage. International origins of the preservation movement 1870–1930, Farnham, 4562.Google Scholar
Hall, M., 2011: Introduction, in M. Hall, Towards world heritage. International origins of the preservation movement 1870–1930, London, 1–19.Google Scholar
Harmanşah, Ö., 2015: ISIS, heritage, and the spectacles of destruction in the global media, Near Eastern archaeology 78(3), 170–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harrison, R., 2013: Heritage. Critical approaches, London.Google Scholar
Harrison, R., 2016: World heritage listing and the globalization of the endangerment sensibility, in Vidal, F. and Dias, N. (eds), Endangerment, biodiversity and culture, Abingdon and New York, 195217.Google Scholar
Huxley, J., 1954: From an antique land. Ancient and modern in the Middle East, London.Google Scholar
Alrawaibah, A., 2014: Archaeological site management in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Protection or isolation?, in Exell, K. and Rico, T. (eds), Cultural heritage in the Arabian peninsula. Debates, discourses and practices, Farnham, 143–56.Google Scholar
ICOMOS, 2011: 17th General Assembly of ICOMOS Paris, France, 27 November to 2 December 2011, atwww.icomos.org/en/9-uncategorised/1836-icomos-17th-general-assembly-scientific-symposium-proceedings.Google Scholar
Isnart, C., and Cerezales, N., 2020: Introduction, in Isnart, C. and Cerezales, N. (eds), The religious heritage complex. Legacy, conservation, and christianity, London, 114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Karlström, A., 2005: Spiritual materiality. Heritage preservation in a Buddhist world?, Journal of social archaeology 5(3), 338–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Karlström, A., 2013: Spirits and the ever-changing heritage, Material religion 9(3), 395–99.10.2752/175183413X13730330869112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Labadi, S., 2005: A review of the global strategy for a balanced, representative and credible world heritage list 1994–2004, Conservation and management of archaeological sites 7, 89102.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lockman, Z., 2016: Field notes. The making of Middle East studies in the United States, Stanford.Google Scholar
Lowenthal, D., 1998: The heritage crusade and the spoils of history, Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baillie, B., 2006: Conservation of the sacred site at Angkor Wat. Further reflections on living heritage, Conservation and management of archaeological sites 8(3), 123–31.10.1179/175355206x265788CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meskell, L., 2018: A future in ruins. UNESCO, world heritage, and the dream of peace, New York.Google Scholar
Meyer, B., and de Witte, M., 2013: Heritage and the sacred. Introduction, Material religion. The journal of objects, art and belief 9(3), 274–81.Google Scholar
Paine, C., 2013: Religious objects in museums. Private lives and public duties, London.Google Scholar
Barkan, E., and Barkey, K., 2014: Choreographies of shared sacred sites. Religion, politics, and conflict resolution, New York.Google Scholar
Rico, T., 2014. Islamophobia and the location of heritage debates in the Arabian peninsula, in Exell, K. and Rico, T. (eds), Cultural heritage in the Arabian peninsula. Debates, discourses and practices, Farnham, 1932.Google Scholar
Rico, T., 2015: Heritage at risk. The authority and autonomy of a dominant framework, in Lafrenz-Samuels, K. and Rico, T. (eds), Heritage keywords. Rhetoric and redescription in cultural heritage, Boulder, CO, 147–62.10.5876/9781607323846.c009CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rico, T., 2017a: Heritage studies and Islam. A crisis of representation, Review of Middle East studies, Roundtable: ‘What is preservation? Diversifying engagement with the Middle East’s material past’, 51(2), 1–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rico, T., 2017b: The making of Islamic heritages. An overview of disciplinary interventions, in Rico, T. (ed.), The making of Islamic heritage. Muslim pasts and heritage presents, Singapore, 111.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rico, T., and Lababidi, R., 2017: Extremism in contemporary heritage debates about Islam. Future anterior. Journal of historic preservation, history, theory and criticism 14(1), 94105.Google Scholar
Rosen, L., 2008: Book review. Proceedings of the Doha conference of ‘Ulama on Islam and cultural heritage. Doha, Qatar. December 30–31, 2001, p. 73 in English and Arabic each. New York: UNESCO, 2005, International journal of cultural property 15, 101–3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rots, Aike P., 2019: World heritage, secularization, and the new ‘public sacred’ in East Asia, Journal of religion in Japan 8(1–3), 151–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sabri, R., 2015: Transitions in the Ottoman Waqf’s traditional building upkeep and maintenance system in Cyprus during the British colonial era (1878–1960) and the emergence of selective architectural conservation practices, International journal of heritage studies 21(5), 512–27.10.1080/13527258.2014.968604CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sabri, R., 2019: The imperial politics of architectural conservation. The case of Waqf in Cyprus, New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shanks, M., and Svabo, C., 2013: Archeology and photography. A pragmatology, in Gonzáles-Ruibal, A. (ed.), Reclaiming archaeology. Beyond the tropes of modernity, New York, 89102.Google Scholar
Shaw, J., 2002: Ayodhya’s sacred landscape. Ritual memory, politics and archaeological ‘fact’, Antiquity 74, 673700.Google Scholar
Brusius, M., and Dukelgrün, T., 2016: Photography, antiquity, scholarship, special issue of History of photography 40(3).Google Scholar
Sherman, D.J., 1989: Worthy monuments. Art museums and the politics of culture in nineteenth-century France, Cambridge, MA.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sherman, D.J., 1999: The construction of memory in interwar France, Chicago and London.Google Scholar
Smith, L., 2006: Uses of heritage, London.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stovel, H., 2008: Conserving the sacred. Special challenges for world heritage sites, World heritage review 51, 2633.Google Scholar
Stovel, H., Stanley-Price, N. and Killick, R. (eds), 2005: Conservation of living religious heritage. Papers from the ICCROM 2003 forum on living religious heritage. Conserving the sacred, Rome.Google Scholar
Tallet, F., and Atkin, N., 1991: Dechristianizing France. The Year II and the revolutionary experience, in F. Tallet and N. Atkin, Religion, society and politics in France since 1789, London and Rio Grande, 128.Google Scholar
Teryukova, E., 2014: Display of religious objects in a museum space. Russian museum experience in the 1920s and 1930s, Material religion. The journal of objects, art and belief 10(2), 255–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bumbaru, D., 2008: Religious heritage and sacred places, ICOMOS news 17, 67.Google Scholar
Turnbridge, J.E., and Ashworth, G.J., 1996: Dissonant heritage. The management of the past as a resource in conflict, Chichester.Google Scholar
UNESCO, 1994: Global strategy for a representative, balanced and credible world heritage list, at https://whc.unesco.org/en/globalstrategy.Google Scholar
UNESCO, 2005: Proceedings of the Doha conference of ‘ulamâ on Islam and cultural heritage. Doha, Qatar, 30–31 December 2001, Doha.Google Scholar
UNESCO, 2011: World heritage centre. Initiative on heritage of religious interest, at http://whc.unesco.org/en/religious-sacred-heritage.Google Scholar
UNESCO, 2020: UNESCO statement on Hagia Sophia, Istanbul, 10 July 2020, at https://en.unesco.org/news/unesco-statement-hagia-sophia-istanbul.Google Scholar
Wild, R., and McLeod, C. (eds.), 2008: Sacred natural sites. Guidelines for protected area managers, Gland and Paris.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Byrne, D., 1995: Buddhist stupa and Thai social practice, World archaeology 27(2), 266–81.10.1080/00438243.1995.9980307CrossRefGoogle Scholar