Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-18T01:17:25.026Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Archaeological Indices of Resistance: Diversity in the Removal Period Potawatomi of the Western Great Lakes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Mark R. Schurr
Mark R. Schurr*
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556 (Mark.R.Schurr.l@nd.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Dichotomies or bipolar scales usually provide the conceptual framework for discussions of historic period Native American cultural change in the western Great Lakes. Archaeological and historical studies of Removal period (A.D. 1795-1840) Potawatomi of northern Indiana and southern Michigan provide challenges to common dichotomous frameworks used to define identity, political affiliation, geographic location, or other attributes of individual Potawatomi. Examples of these classifications include dichotomies such as Catholic vs. Non-Catholic, assimilationist vs. traditionalist, or accommodationist vs. non-accommodationist (among others). Case studies of four Potawatomi, two of whom successfully resisted removal (Pokagon and Benack) and two who did not (Menominee and Ashkum), illustrate the need for multiple lines of evidence that facilitate comparisons between diverse communities living in a rapidly changing world. Relations with the colonizer were the most significant element related to successful resistance. Site location provides a visible signal of these wider social ties extending beyond the local community.

Resumen

Resumen

Las dicotomías o escalas bipolares suelen proporcionar el marco conceptual para las discusiones en torno al cambio cultural de los Nativos Americanos durante el período histórico. Los estudios arqueológicos e históricos del período Removal (desplazamiento) Potawatomi (1795-1840 D.C.) en el norte de Indiana y el sur de Michigan proporcionan un desafío a los marcos dicotómicos tradicionales como, por ejemplo, Católicos frente a no Católicos, asimilacionistas frente a tradicionalistas, o los a favor de aceptar el cambio frente a los que no (y muchos otros), como consecuencia de la gran diversidad de respuestas a las condiciones cambiantes. El estudio de cuatro grupos Potawatomi, de los cuales dos resistieron con éxito la retirada (Pokagon y Benack) y dos no (Menominee y Ashkum), ilustra la necesidad de múltiples líneas de investigación que faciliten las comparaciones entre las diferentes comunidades que vivieron en un mundo en constante cambio. Las relaciones con el colonizador constituyeron el elemento más significativo en relación con el éxito de la resistencia. La ubicación de los asentamientos nos ofrece una señal evidente de estos vínculos sociales más amplios y que fueron más allá de la comunidad local.

Type
Articles
Information
American Antiquity , Volume 75 , Issue 1 , January 2010 , pp. 44 - 60
Copyright
Copyright © Society for American Archaeology 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Bergmann, William H. 2005 Commerce and Arms: The Federal Government, Native Americans, and the Economy of the Old Northwest, 1783–1807. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Cincinnati. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Berkson, Alice 1992 Cultural Resistance of the Prairie Kickapoo at the Grand Village, McLean County, Illinois. Illinois Archaeology 4:107–205.Google Scholar
Bollwerk, Elizabeth 2006 Controlling Acculturation: A Potawatomi Strategy for Avoiding Removal. Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology 31:117–142.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bonhage-Freund, Mary Theresa, Johnson, Kari-Jo, and Knarr, Aimmi 2002 Assimilation or Adaptation? Late Historic Chippewa Subsistence Strategies in Central Lower Michigan. The Michigan Archaeologist 48:117–148.Google Scholar
Brown, James A. 1990 Ethnohistoric Connections. In At the Edge of Prehistory: Huber Phase Archaeology in the Chicago Area, edited by J. A. Brown and P. J. O’Brien, pp. 155–160. Center for American Archaeology, Kampsville, Illinois.Google Scholar
Brown, Margaret Kimball 1975 The Zimmerman Site: Further Excavations at the Grand Village ofthe Kaskaskia. Reports of Investigations 32. Illinois State Museum, Springfield.Google Scholar
Buechner, Cecilia Bain 1933 The Pokagons. Indiana Historical Society Publications 10(5). Indiana Historical Society, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Clifton, James A. 1977 The Prairie People: Continuity and Change in Potawatomi Indian Culture 1665–1965. The Regents Press of Kansas, Lawrence.Google Scholar
Clifton, James A. 1984 The Pokagons, 1683–1983: Catholic Potawatomi Indians ofthe St. Joseph River Valley. University Press of America, New York.Google Scholar
Cooke, Sarah E., and Ramadhyani, Rachel B. 1993 Images of Indiana Potawatomis & Miamies with Related Views. In Indians and a Changing Frontier: The Art of George Winter, edited by S. E. Cooke and R. B. Ramadhyani, pp. 41–142. Indiana Historical Society in cooperation with the Tippecanoe County Historical Association, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Cooke, Sarah E., and Ramadhyani, Rachel B. (editors) 1993 Indians and a Changing Frontier: The Art of George Winter. Indiana Historical Society in cooperation with the Tippecanoe County Historical Association, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Cusick, James G. 1998 Historiography of Acculturation: An Evaluation of Concepts and Their Application in Archaeology. In Studies in Culture Contact: Interaction, Culture Change, and Archaeology, edited by J. G. Cusick, pp. 126–145. Occasional Papers No. 25. Center for Archaeological Investigations, Carbondale, Illinois.Google Scholar
Edmunds, R. David. 1978 The Potawatomis: Keepers ofthe Fire. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.Google Scholar
Edmunds, R. David. 1980 Redefining Red Patriotism: Five Medals of the Potawatomi. Red River Valley Historical Review 5(Spring):12–24.Google Scholar
Edmunds, R. David. 1981 “Designing Men, Seeking a Fortune”: Indian Traders and the Potawatomi Claims Payment of 1836. Indiana Magazine of History 77:109–122.Google Scholar
Edmunds, R. David. 1993 George Winter: Mirror of Acculturation. In Indians and a Changing Frontier: The Art of George Winter, edited by S. E. Cooke and R. B. Ramadhyani, pp. 23–40. Indiana Historical Society in cooperation with the Tippecanoe County Historical Association, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Emerson, Thomas E., and Brown, James A. 1992 The Late Prehistory and Protohistory of Illinois. In Calumet and Fleur-de-Lys: Archaeology of Indian and French Contact in the Midcontinent, edited by J. A. Walthall and T. E. Emerson, pp. 77–128. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Faulkner, Charles H. 1961 An Archaeological Survey of Marshall County. Indiana History Bureau, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Faulkner, Charles H. 1972 The Late Prehistoric Occupation of Northwestern Indiana: A Study of the Upper Mississippi Cultures of the Kankakee Valley. Prehistory Research Series Vol. 5(1). Indiana Historical Society, Indianapolis, Indiana.Google Scholar
Feest, Christian F. 1993 George Winter, Artist. In Indians and a Changing Frontier: The Art of George Winter, edited by S. E. Cooke and R. B. Ramadhyani, pp. 1–22. Indiana Historical Society in cooperation with the Tippecanoe County Historical Association, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Gosden, Chris 2004 A rchaeology and Colonialism: Cultural Contact from 5000 B.C. to the Present. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Griffin, James Bennett 1937 The Archaeological Remains of the Chiwere Sioux. American Antiquity 2:180–181.Google Scholar
Hauser, Mark W., and DeCorse, Christopher R. 2003 Low-Fired Earthenwares in the African Diaspora: Problems and Prospects. International Journal of Historical Archaeology 7:67–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Howard, Timothy Edward 1907 A History of St. Joseph County, Indiana. Lewis Publishing, New York.Google Scholar
Jones, James Richard III 1989 Degrees of Acculturation at Two Eighteenth Century Aboriginal Villages near Lafayette, Tippecanoe County, Indiana: Ethnohistoric and Archaeological Perspectives. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, Indiana University.Google Scholar
Kinietz, W. Vernon 1940 The Indians of the Western Great Lakes, 1615–1760. Occasional Contributions No. 10. Museum of Anthropology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Leeper, David R. 1898 Some Early Local Footprints. Reprinted from the South Bend Daily Times, South Bend, Indiana.Google Scholar
Lightfoot, Kent G. 2005 Indians, Missionaries, and Merchants: The Legacy of Colonial Encounters on the California Frontiers. University of California Press, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Loren, Diana DiPaolo 2008 In Contact: Bodies and Spaces in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Century Eastern Woodlands. Issues in Eastern Woodlands Archaeology. Altamira, New York.Google Scholar
Mainfort, Robert C Jr. 1985 Wealth, Space, and Status in a Historic Indian Cemetery. American Antiquity 50:555–579.Google Scholar
Mann, Rob 1999 The Silenced Miami: Archaeological and Ethnohis-torical Evidence for Miami-British Relations, 1795–1812. Ethnohistory 46:399–427.Google Scholar
Mann, Rob 2003 Colonizing the Colonizers: Canadien Fur Traders and Fur Trade Society in the Great Lakes Region, 1763–1850. Ph.D. dissertation, State University of New York, Binghamton. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Mann, Rob 2004 Smokescreens: Tobacco, Pipes, and the Transformational Power of Fur Trade Rituals. In Smoking and Culture: The Archaeology of Tobacco Pipes in Eastern North America, edited by S. M. Rafferty and R. Mann, pp. 165–184. University of Tennessee Press, Knoxville.Google Scholar
Mann, Rob 2007 “True Portraitures of the Indians, and of Their Own Peculiar Conceits of Dress”: Discourses on Dress and Identity in the Great Lakes, 1830–1850. Historical Archaeology 4:37–52.Google Scholar
Martin, Terrance J. 2001 Animal Remains from the Windrose Site 1994–1995 Investigations. In The Windrose Site: An Early Nineteenth-Century Potawatomi Settlement in the Kankakee River Valley of Northeastern Illinois, edited by M. J. Wagner, pp. 145–164. Reports of Investigations, No. 56. Illinois State Museum, Springfield, Illinois.Google Scholar
Martin, Terrance J., and Richmond, J. C. 1996 Animal Remains from 12-Hu-1022. In Archaeological Investigations at the EhlerSite (12-Hu-1022): An Early 19th Century Miami Indian Habitation Site Near the Forks of the Wabash, Huntington County, Indiana, edited by R. Mann, pp. 158–176. Reports of Investigations 95IN0062-P3r01. Landmark Archaeological and Environmental Services, Inc., Sheridan, Indiana.Google Scholar
Mason, Ronald J. 1986 Rock Island: Historical Indian Archaeology in the Northern Lake Michigan Basin. Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology Special Paper No. 6. Kent State University Press, Kent, Ohio.Google Scholar
McDonald, Daniel 1881 History of Marshall County, Indiana, 1836 to 1880. Kingman Brothers, Chicago.Google Scholar
McKee, Irving 1939 The Centennial of the Trail of Death. Indiana Magazine of History 35(March):27–41.Google Scholar
McKee, Irving 1941 The Trail of Death: Letters of Benjamin Marie Petit. Indiana Historical Society Publications 14. Indiana Historical Society, Indianapolis, Indiana.Google Scholar
Myhre, Paul Odell 1998 Potawatomi Transformation: Potawatomi Responses to Catholic and Baptist Mission Strategy and Competition, 1822–1872. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of History, Saint Louis University. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Quimby, George I. 1966a The Dumaw Creek site, A Seventeenth Century Prehistoric Indian Village and Cemetery in Oceania County, Michigan. Fieldiana 56(1).Google Scholar
Quimby, George I. 1966b Indian Culture and European Trade Goods. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, Wisconsin.Google Scholar
Quimby, George I., and Spoehr, Alexander 1951 Acculturation and Material Culture - I. Fieldiana Anthropology 36(6):107–147.Google Scholar
Rafert, Stewart 1996 The Miami Indians of Indiana: A Persistent People, 1654–1994. Indiana Historical Society, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Reitz, Elizabeth J., and Margaret Scarry, C. 1985 Reconstructing Historic Subsistence with an Example from Sixteenth-Century Spanish Florida. Special Publication Series Number 3. The Society for Historical Archaeology, Ann Arbor, Michigan.Google Scholar
Robertson, Nellie Armstrong, and Riker, Dorothy 1942 The John Tipton Papers 1. Indiana Historical Bureau, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Rubertone, Patricia E. 2001 Grave Undertakings: An Archaeology of Roger Williams and the Narragansett Indians. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Schurr, Mark R. 1997 The 1996 Archaeological Investigations at the Benack Village Site (12 Mr 231): An Historic Metis VillageSite in Marshall County, Indiana. Archaeology Laboratory, Report of Investigations 97–1, Part 1. Department of Anthropology, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana.Google Scholar
Schurr, Mark R. 1998 The 1997 Archaeological Investigations at the Benack Village Site (12 Mr 231): An Historic Metis Village Site in Marshall County, Indiana. Archaeology Laboratory, Report of Investigations 98-1. Department of Anthropology, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana.Google Scholar
Schurr, Mark R. 2006 Untangling Removal Period Archaeology: The Complexity of Potawatomi Sites. Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology 31:5–20.Google Scholar
Schurr, Mark R., Martin, Terrance J., and Secunda, William B. 2006 How the Pokagon Band Avoided Removal: Archaeological Evidence from the Faunal Assemblage of the Pokagon Village Site (20BE13). Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology 31:143–164.Google Scholar
Secunda, William B. 2006 To Cede or Seed? Risk and Identity Among the Woodland Potawatomi During the Removal Period. Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology 31:57–88.Google Scholar
Secunda, William B. 2008 In the Shadow of the Eagle’s Wings: The Effects of Removal on the Unremoved Potawatomi. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of History, University of Notre Dame.Google Scholar
Secunda, William B., and Schurr, Mark R. 2005 Comparative Surveys of Menominee Village Locations in Marshall County, Indiana. Archaeology Laboratory, Report of Investigations 2005-1. Department of Anthropology, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana.Google Scholar
Secunda, William B., Schurr, Mark R., and Pribber-now, Michelle 2002 Investigations of Historic Potawatomi Villages in Northern Indiana. Archaeology Laboratory, Report of Investigations 2002-1. Department of Anthropology, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana.Google Scholar
Silliman, Stephen W. 2001 Theoretical Perspectives on Labor and Colonialism: Reconsidering the California Missions. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 20:379–407.Google Scholar
Silliman, Stephen W. 2005 Culture Contact or Colonialism? Challenges in the Archaeology of Native North America. American Antiquity 70:55–74.Google Scholar
Sleeper-Smith, Susan 2001 Indian Women and French Men: Rethinking Cultural Encounter in the Western Great Lakes. University of Massachusetts Press, Amherst.Google Scholar
Smith, D. L. 1949 The Attempted Potawatomi Migration of 1839. Indiana Magazine of History 45:51–80.Google Scholar
Spicer, Edward 1962 Cycles of Conquest: The Impact of Spain, Mexico, and the United States on the Indians of the Southwest, 1533–1960. University of Arizona Press, Tucson.Google Scholar
Trubowitz, Neal L. 1992a Native Americans and French on the Central Wabash. In Calumet & Fleur-De-Lys: Archaeology of Indian and French Contact in the Midcontinent, edited by J. A. Walthall and T. E. Emerson, pp. 241–264. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Trubowitz, Neal L. 1992b Thanks, But We Prefer to Smoke Our Own: Pipes in the Great Lakes-Riverine Region during the Eighteenth Century. In Proceedings of the 1989 Smoking Pipe Conference, Research Records No. 22, edited by C. F. Hayes, pp. 97–111. Rochester Museum and Science Center, Rochester, New York.Google Scholar
Trubowitz, Neal L. 2004 Smoking Pipes: An Archaeological Measure of Native American Cultural Stability and Survival in Eastern North America. In Smoking and Culture: The Archaeology of Tobacco Pipes in Eastern North America, edited by S. M. Rafferty and R. Mann, pp. 143–164. University of Tennessee Press, Knoxville.Google Scholar
Wagner, Mark J. 1998 Some Think It Impossible to Civilize Them at All: Cultural Change and Continuity Among the Early Nineteeth-Century Potawatomi. In Studies in Culture Contact: Interaction, Culture Change, and Archaeology, edited by J. G. Cusick, pp. 430–456. Occasional Papers No. 25. Center for Archaeological Investigations, Carbondale, Illinois.Google Scholar
Wagner, Mark J. 2001 The Windrose Site: An Early Nineteenth-Century Potawatomi Settlement in the Kankakee River Valley of Northeastern Illinois. Illinois State Museum, Springfield, Illinois.Google Scholar
Wagner, Mark J. 2003 In All the Solemnity of Profound Smoking: Tobacco Smoking and Pipe Manufacture and Use among the Potawatomi of Illinois. In Stone Tool Traditions in the Contact Era, edited by C. R. Cobb, pp. 109–126. The University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa, Alabama.Google Scholar
Wagner, Mark J. 2006 “He is Worst Than the [Shawnee] Prophet”: The Archaeology of Nativism among the Early Nineteenth Century Potawatomi of Illinois. Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology 31:89–116.Google Scholar
Walthall, John A. (editor) 1991 French Colonial Archaeology: The Illinois Country and the western Great Lakes, University of Illinois Press, Urbana.Google Scholar
Walthall, John A., and Emerson, Thomas E. (editors) 1992 Calumet & Fleur-De-Lys: Archaeology of Indian and French Contact in the Midcontinent. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
White, Richard 1991 The Middle Ground: Indians, Empires, and Republics in the Great Lakes Region. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England.Google Scholar