Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-5nwft Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-09T06:34:50.463Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

What Came First, The Nation or the State? Political Process in the Comoro Islands

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 March 2011

Iain Walker
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The widespread failure of the post-colonial state in Africa is often attributed to a lack of social and cultural unity, and hence of national identity, in the territories in question. In Europe the state has historically been conceptualized as coterminous with the nation, an apparently ‘natural’ cultural unit that allowed for subsequent political cohesion and the avoidance of ethnic conflict. In Africa the concept (and the reality) of the nation is often absent and this is sometimes considered to be a stumbling block on the path to political stability. However, the suggestion that a state whose population exhibits the requisite cultural homogeneity would construct and maintain a nation and, subsequently, successful and stable statehood is challenged by evidence from the Comoro Islands. Here, despite apparent socio-cultural unity, there has been little movement towards the development of a nation; indeed, there is evidence that an explicit denial of socio-cultural unity underpins the failure of the state.

Résumé

On attribue souvent le large échec de l'État post-colonial en Afrique à un manque d'unité sociale et culturelle, et donc d'identité nationale, dans les territoires en question. En Europe, l'État a été conceptualisé, sur un plan historique, comme ayant les mêmes limites géographiques que la nation, une unité culturelle apparemment “naturelle” débouchant sur une cohésion politique et permettant d'éviter un conflit ethnique. En Afrique, le concept (et la réalité) de nation est souvent absent, ce qui est parfois considéré comme un obstacle sur la voie de la stabilité politique. Or, la suggestion selon laquelle un État dont la population afficherait l'homogénéité culturelle nécessaire formerait et resterait une nation puis, par là-même, un État stable et prospère, est remise en question par le cas des Comores. Malgré une unité socioculturelle apparente, on y décèle peu d'évolution vers le développement d'une nation; on constate en effet qu'à la base de l'échec de l'État se trouve un déni explicite de l'unité socioculturelle.

Type
Research Article
Information
Africa , Volume 77 , Issue 4 , November 2007 , pp. 582 - 605
Copyright
Copyright © International African Institute 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abdallah, C. and Kassim, M. (1986) Marriage and Its Impact on Mohelian Society. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Abrams, P. (1988) ‘Notes on the difficulty of studying the state (1977)’, Journal of Historical Sociology 1 (1): 58–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ahmed, A. C. (1999) Islam et Politique aux Comores. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Alence, R. (2004) ‘Political institutions and developmental governance in sub-Saharan Africa’, Journal of Modern African Studies 42 (2): 163–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ali Abdou, Mdahoma (1989) Le rôle et l'influence du mwalimu sur les habitants de Mboinkou. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Alonso, A. M. (1994) ‘The Politics of space, time and substance: state formation, nationalism, ethnicity’, Annual Review of Anthropology 23: 379–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Amdjad Ben, Said Omar (1968) ‘Cinq années d'expérience communale aux Comores’, Revue juridique et politique 22 (2): 455–62.Google Scholar
Anderson, B. (1991) Imagined Communities. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Anon, Anon (1830) ‘A visit to the island of Johanna’, The United Service Journal 1: 144–52.Google Scholar
Bakari Msaidie, Haninga Jelhad (1985) État et idéologies aux Comores. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Bang, A. (2003) Sufis and Scholars of the Sea: family networks in East Africa, 1860–1925. London: Routledge Curzon.Google Scholar
Barnard, E. (1969) A Three Years Cruise in the Mozambique Channel. London: Dawsons.Google Scholar
Baxter, P., and Almagor, U. (eds) (1978) Age, Generation and Time: some features of East African age organisations. London: C. Hurst.Google Scholar
Bernardi, B. (1985) Age Class Systems. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Besteman, C. (1996) ‘Violent politics and the politics of violence: the dissolution of the Somali nation-state’, American Ethnologist 23 (3): 579–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blanchy, S. (1990) La vie quotidienne à Mayotte, archipel des Comores. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Blanchy, S. (1992) ‘Famille et parenté dans l'archipel des Comores,’ Journal des Africanistes 62 (1): 7–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blanchy, S. (1996) ‘Le partage des buufs dans le mariage coutumier de la Grande Comore’, Journal des Africanistes 66 (1–2): 168–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blanchy, S. (1998) ‘Les Comoriens: une immigration méconnue’, Hommes et migrations, 1215: 5–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blanchy, S. (2002) ‘Mayotte: “française à tout prix”’, Ethnologie Française 4: 677–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blanchy, S. (2003) ‘Seul ou tous ensemble? Dynamique des classes d'âge dans les cités de l'île de Ngazidja, Comores,’ L'Homme 167–8: 153–86.Google Scholar
Blanchy, S. (2004) ‘Cités, citoyenneté et territorialité dans l'île de Ngazidja (Comores)’, Journal des Africanistes 74 (1–2): 341–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Abdou El-Ghaniyou, Boinaidi (1988) Essai de monographie d'Itsandramdjini. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Boulinier, Georges (1987) ‘Le rôle de Said Mohamed el-Maarouf dans le développement de la confrérie shadhili’, Ya Mkobe 3: 14–17.Google Scholar
Breslar, J. (1981) ‘An Ethnography of the Mahorais (Mayotte, Comoro Islands)’. PhD thesis, University of Pittsburgh.Google Scholar
Caminade, P. (2003) Comores-Mayotte: une histoire neocoloniale. Marseille: Agone.Google Scholar
Carroll, B. and Carroll, T. (1997) ‘State and ethnicity in Botswana and Mauritius: a democratic route to development?’, Journal of Development Studies 33 (4): 464–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chouzour, S. (1994) Le Pouvoir de l'honneur: tradition et contestation en Grande Comore. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Cidey, G. (Fou'ndi Kana-Hazi) (1997) Histoire des Iles. Ha'ngazidja, Hi'ndzou'ani, Maiote et Mwali. St Denis: Editions Djahazi.Google Scholar
Ben Ali, Damir (1977) Musique et société dans l'archipel des Comores. Paris: École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales.Google Scholar
Ben Ali, Damir (1984) ‘Organisation sociale et politique aux Comores avant le Xvème siècle’, Ya Mkobe 1: 25–31.Google Scholar
Ben Ali, Damir (1989) ‘Approche historique des structures administratives des Comores’, Annuaire des pays de l'Océan Indien XI: 17—42.Google Scholar
Bacar Nadia, Dossar (1986) La Cuisine dans les cérémonies coutumières comoriennes. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
du Plantier, N. (1904) La Grande Comore: sa colonisation. Paris: Augustin Challamel.Google Scholar
Ehret, C. (1974) Ethiopians and East Africans: the problem of contacts. Nairobi: East African Publishing House.Google Scholar
Elaniou, Ali Abdou (2003) Ali Soilihi, ou l'indépendance dans la citerne. Moroni: Komedit.Google Scholar
Fasquel, Jean (1991) Mayotte, les Comores et la France. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Favoreu, L. and Maestre, J.-C.. (1975) ‘L'accession des Comores à l'indépendance’, Annuaire des pays de l'Océan Indien 2: 15–33.Google Scholar
Fortes, M. and Evans-Pritchard, E. E. (1940) ‘Introduction’ in Fortes, M. and Evans-Pritchard, E. E. (eds), African Political Systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Galabru, J.-J. (1952) La Grande Comore, terre d'Islam et de coutumes. Paris: CHEAM.Google Scholar
Gevrey, A. (1972) [1870] Essai sur les Comores. Tananarive: Musée d'art et d'archéologie, University of Madagascar.Google Scholar
Goldsmith, A. (2000) ‘Sizing up the African state’, Journal of Modern African Studies 38 (1): 1–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gourlet, J.-F. (2001) Chroniques Mahoraises. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Gueunier, N. J. (2001) ‘Métissage linguistique dans le sud-ouest de l'océan Indien’. Seminar paper, University of Paris 7.Google Scholar
Guibernau i Berdún, M. M. (1999) Nations Without States: political communities in a global age. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Guy, P. (1946) ‘Histoire de l'organisation judiciaire des Comores’, Revue de Madagascar 25: 17–31.Google Scholar
Guy, P. (1951) ‘La justice aux Iles Comores’, Revue juridique de Madagascar 1: 86–9.Google Scholar
Guy, P. (1956) L'Islam aux Comores. Paris: CHEAM.Google Scholar
Guy, P. (1986) ‘Le Minhadj at Twalibin et les coutumes comoriennes dans le statut personnel’, Études Océan Indien 6: 7–34.Google Scholar
Guy, P. and Abdourahmane Ben, Cheikh Amir (1959) La vie et l'oeuvre du grand marabout des Comores, Said Mohammed ben Ahmed al Ma'arouf, 1852–1904, selon son panégyrique en arabe par Said Kaabi. Tananarive: Government Printer; Moroni: CNDRS.Google Scholar
Harries, L. (1977) Said Bakari bin Sultan Ahmed: the Swahili chronicle of Ngazidja. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Hébert, J.-C. (1960.) ‘Fêtes agraires dans l'Ile d'Anjouan’, Journal de la Société des Africanistes 30 (1): 101–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hébert, J.-C. (1961) ‘Analyses structurales des géomancies comoriennes, malgaches et africaines’, Journal de la Société des Africanistes 21 (2): 115–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hocquet, Y. (1957) Pour une meilleure connaissance de l'Archipel des Comores: La Grande Comore (Ngazidja). Paris: CHEAM.Google Scholar
Madi, Houssamou Mohamed (1993) Approche historique et analytique sur les fonctionnaires aux Comores. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Ibrahime, M. (1997) État français et colons aux Comores (1912–1946). Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Hébert, J.-C. (2000) La Naissance de l'élite politique Comorienne (1945–1975). Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Soidri, Issouffi and Maanfou, Echati (1991) L'Éducation non-formelle: l'alphabétisation des adultes. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Laitin, D. and Samatar, S. (1987) Somalia: nation in search of a state. Boulder CO: Westview.Google Scholar
Lambek, M. (1981) Human Spirits: a cultural account of trance in Mayotte. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Lambek, M. (1990) ‘Exchange, time, and person in Mayotte: the structure and destructuring of a cultural system’, American Anthropologist 92 (3): 647–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lambek, M. (1993) Knowledge and practice in Mayotte: local discourses of Islam, sorcery and spirit possession. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Le Guennec-Coppens, F. (2004) ‘The monetization of matrimonial prestations in the Comorian great marriage’ in Caplan, P. and Topan, F. (eds), Swahili Modernities: culture, politics and identity on the East Coast of Africa. Trenton: Africa World Press.Google Scholar
Leguével de Lacombe, B. F. (1840) Voyage à Madagascar et aux îles Comores. Paris: Louis Desessart (2 vols).Google Scholar
Lewis, I. M. (2002) A Modern History of the Somali: nation and state in the Horn of Africa. Oxford: James Currey.Google Scholar
Mahamoud, A. W. (1992) Mayotte: le contentieux entre la France et les Comores. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Mansouri, A. (1986) Essai de monographie de Dembeni. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Martin, J. (1983) Comores: quatre îles entrepirates etplanteurs. Paris: l'Harmattan (2 vols).Google Scholar
Mattoir, N. (2004) Les Comores de 1975 à 1990. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Meunier, A. (1970a) ‘Le statut politique et administratif de l'archipel des Comores de l'annexation à l'autonomie restreinte (1912–1968)’, Penant 80 (729): 281–99.Google Scholar
Meunier, A. (1970b) ‘Le statut politique et administratif de l'archipel des Comores de l'annexation à l'autonomie restreinte (1912–1968)’, Penant 80 (730): 441–57.Google Scholar
Mill, J. S. (1946) [1861] ‘Considerations on representative government’ in McCallum, R. B. (éd.), On Liberty, and Considerations on Representative Government. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Mohamed, A. R. (2001) Comores: les institutions d'un état mort-né. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Ahmed, Moilim (1988) Événements de 1915 dans la région du Dimani (études sur traditions orales). Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
M'trengoueni, M., Mouhktar, S. and Gueunier, N. J. (1999) ‘“Nom, prénom”: une étape vers l'uniformisation culturelle – identité et statut juridique à Mayotte (Océan Indien Occidental)’, Revue des sciences sociales de la France de l'Est 26: 45–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Newitt, M. (1984) The Comoro Islands: struggle against dependency in the Indian Ocean. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Mohamed, Nourouddine (1985) Les Danses comoriennes (repertoire). Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Nugent, D. (1994) ‘Building the state, making the nation: the bases and limits of state centralization in “modern” Peru’, American Anthropologist 96 (2): 333–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nurse, D. and Hinnebusch, T. J. (1993) Swahili and Sabaki: a linguistic history. Berkeley, Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Nurse, D. and Spear, T. (1985) The Swahili: reconstructing the history andlanguage of an African society, 800–1500. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ottenheimer, M. (1971) Domoni: formal analysis and ethnography of a Comoro island community. PhD thesis, Tulana University, Indiana.Google Scholar
Perri, P. (1994) Comores: les nouveaux mercenaires. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Ranger, T. (1983) ‘The invention of tradition in colonial Africa’ in Hobsbawm, E. and Ranger, T. (eds), The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Ranger, T. (1993) ‘The invention of tradition revisited: the case of colonial Africa’ in Ranger, T. and Vaughan, O. (eds), Legitimacy and the State in Twentieth-Century Africa. Basingstoke: Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Robineau, C. (1966) Société et économie d'Anjouan (Océan Indien). Paris: ORSTOM.Google Scholar
Rouveyran, J.-C. and Djabiri, A. (1968) ‘Reflexions sur le Dola N'Kou ou grand mariage comorien’, Revue Tiers Monde 9 (33): 95–127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mahamoud, Safiat (1988) Contribution à l'étude du vêtement en Grande Comore. Mvouni: ENES.Google Scholar
Abdourahim, Said (1983) ‘Mariage à Ngazidja, fondement d'un pouvoir’. PhD thesis, University of Bordeaux III.Google Scholar
Said Ahmed, M. (2000) Guerriers, princes et poètes aux Comores dans la littérature orale. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Said-Soilihi, Y. (1988) Comores: les défis du développement indépendant, 1975–1978. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Shain, Y. and Sherman, M. (2001) ‘Diasporic transnational financial flows and their impact on national identity’, Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 7 (4): 1–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shepherd, G. (1977) ‘Two marriage forms in the Comoro Islands: an investigation’, Africa 47 (4): 344–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sidi, A. (1998) Anjouan, l'histoire d'une crise foncière. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Vérin, P. (1994) Les Comores. Paris: Karthala.Google Scholar
Vivier, G. (2000) ‘Les associations comoriennes en France: processus migratoires, identités et transformations sociales’, Hommes et migrations 1226: 58–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker, I. (2002a) ‘An Historical Anthropology of Ngazidja’. PhD thesis, University of Sydney.Google Scholar
Walker, I. (2002b) ‘Les aspects économiques du grand mariage de Ngazidja (Comores)’, Autrepart 23: 157–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker, I. (2005) ‘Mimetic structuration, or, easy steps to building an acceptable identity’. History and Anthropology 16 (2): 187–210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Weber, M. (1991) From Max Weber: essays in sociology. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Wendt, A. (2004) ‘The state as person in international theory’, Review of International Studies 30 (2): 289–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
White, G. (2004) Nation, State and Territory: origins, evolutions, and relationships. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Wight, C. (2004) ‘State agency: social action without human activity?’ Review of International Studies 30 (2): 269–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wunsch, J. (2000) ‘Refounding the African state and local self-governance: the neglected foundation’, Journal of Modern African Studies 38 (3): 487–509.CrossRefGoogle Scholar