Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2015
  • Online publication date: November 2015

15 - Storytelling and Cultural Memory in the Making: Celebrating Pagan and Christian Founders of Rome

from Section B - Death and the Afterlife

Summary

To understand the complex processes of change that Roman society underwent with the advent and expansion of Christianity, scholars of the late antique and early Christian period have used cultural memory theory as an interpretive model. Despite the criticisms that may be raised against this approach, from vagueness and lack of terminology, to theoretical exaggeration, the efforts (whether conscious or unconscious) of late Roman people to establish a new collectively shared memory about their Christian past may be detected in and across diverse groups of Christian Romans – from the lower and middle classes to senators and emperors. Such efforts may be seen in the establishment of narratives and commemorative practices with respect to the new Christian guardians of Rome: the apostles and the martyrs. This chapter will discuss one of these commemorations, the festival honoring the Apostles Peter and Paul on June 29, and the narratives supporting it – ancient as well as modern.

According to tradition, Peter and Paul were the founders of the Roman Church by their joint martyrdom at Rome. The memory of the two apostles was anchored to Rome by way of their graves, which were, in fact, called memoriae. These memoriae were monumentalized with shrines donated by emperors, praised by poets, and visited by pilgrims throughout the year, but especially around the annual festival on June 29. On this day, the reenactment of the memory of the Apostles also took place at the so-called Memoriae Apostolorum on the Via Appia, today's S. Sebastiano. Six hundred graffiti from the third century onward contain prayers of intercession devoted to Peter and Paul, thus testifying to a joint cult of these apostles – all year round. In the second half of the fourth century, the cult and the festival on June 29 was intensified by Pope Damasus (366–84) who composed an epigram for Peter and Paul at the Memoriae Apostolorum.

For more than two centuries, a considerable number of scholars have claimed that the celebration of Saints Peter and Paul on June 29 reflected an effort, during the third century, to appropriate an existing celebration on the same day of the divine founder of Rome, Romulus/Quirinus. In this chapter it will be argued, however, that this narrative about a Christian “usurpation” of a pagan celebration of Rome's foundation is a misguided modern construction of religious politics and cultural memory in fourth- and fifth-century Rome.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Baumstark, A. Comparative Liturgy (London, 1958).
Bisconti, F. “L'abbraccio tra Pietro e Paolo ed un affresco inedito del cimitero romano dell'ex Vigna Chiaraviglio,” in XLII Corso di cultura sull'arte ravennate e bizantina in memoria di prof. Giuseppe Bovini (Ravenna, 1995), 71–93.
Bisconti, F. “Le iconografie,” in Ensoli, S. and Rocca, E. La, eds., Aurea Roma: dalla città pagana alla città cristiana (Rome, 2000), 361–7.
Brind'amour, P. Le calendrier romain: recherches chronologiques (Ottawa, 1983).
Carletti, C. “Damaso,” in Enciclopedia dei Papi (Rome, 2000), 349–72.
Castelli, E. A. Martyrdom and Memory: Early Christian Culture Making (New York, 2004).
Conway, A. and Freeland, J. P.. St Leo the Great: Sermons (Washington, DC, 1996).
Cracco Ruggini, L. “Quirinus and Peter: The Ideological Function of an Ancient Cult (III–IV Century),” in Paganism in the Later Roman Empire and in Byzantium (Cracow, 1991), 9–34.
Crook, J. The Architectural Setting of the Cult of Saints in the Early Christian West c.300–1200 (Oxford, 2000).
Cullmann, O. Saint Pierre, Disciple, Apôtre, Martyr (Neuchâtel-Paris, 1952).
Diefenbach, S. Römische Erinnerungsräume: Heiligenmemoria und kollektive Identitäten im Rom des 3. bis 5. Jahrhunderts n. Chr. (Berlin, 2007).
Dolle, R. Sermons. Léon le Grand, Latin text and Franch translation, Sources Chrétienne 200 (Paris, 1973).
Erbes, C. Die Todestage der Apostel Paulus und Petrus und ihre Römischen Denkmähler (Leipzig, 1899).
Ferrua, A. Epigrammata Damasiana (Vatican City, 1942).
Ferrua, A.Rileggendo i graffiti di San Sebastiano.” Civiltà Cattolica III (1956): 428–37; IV: 134–41.
Guarducci, M.Il culto degli apostoli Pietro e Paolo sulla Via Appia: riflessioni vecchie e nuove.” MEFRA 98 (1986): 811–42.
Haas, C. J.Imperial Religious Policy and Valerian's Persecution of the Church, AD 257–260.” ChHist 52, no. 2 (1983): 133–44.
Huskinson, J. M. Concordia Apostolorum: Christian Propaganda at Rome in the Fourth and Fifth Centuries: A Study in Early Christian Iconography and Iconology (Oxford, 1982).
Invernizzi, A. Il calendario, Vita e Costumi dei Romani Antichi, 16 (Rome, 1994).
Kent, J. P. C. The Divided Empire and the Fall of the Western Parts, Roman Imperial Coinage X (London, 1994).
Klauser, T. Die römische Petrustradition im Lichte der neuen Ausgrabungen unter der Peterskirche (Cologne, 1956).
Lietzmann, H. Die drei ältesten Martyrologien (Bonn, 1911).
Lønstrup Dal Santo, G.Constructing Myths: The Foundation of Roma Christiana on 29 June.” ARID (2008): 19–56.
Lønstrup Dal Santo, G. “Concordia Apostolorum – Concordia Augustorum: The Making of Shared Memory in and between the Two Romes in the Fourth and Fifth Century.” PhD diss. University of Aarhus (2010).
Lønstrup Dal Santo, G. “Bishop and Believers – Patrons and Viewers: Appropriating the Roman Patron Saints Peter and Paul in Constantinople,” in Birk, S. and Poulsen, B., eds., Patrons and Viewers in Late Antiquity (Aarhus, 2012), 237–57.
Matthews, J. F. Western Aristocracies and Imperial Court A.D. 364–425 (Oxford, 1990).
Mayer, W.Les homélies de S. Jean Chrysostome en juillet 399.” ByzSlav (1999): 273–303.
Mayer, W. and Allen, P.. John Chrysostom, The Early Church Fathers (London, 2000).
Morey, C. R. The Gold-Glass Collection of the Vatican Library: With Additional Catalogues of other Gold-Glass Collections (Vatican City, 1959).
Noreña, C. Imperial Ideals in the Roman West (Cambridge, 2011).
Pargoire, J.Rufinianes.” BZ 8 (1899): 429–77.
Pargoire, J.Les homélies de S. Jean Chrysostome en juillet 399.” Echos d'Orient 3 (1900): 151–62.
Pietri, C.Concordia Apostolorum et Renovatio Urbis. Culte des martyr et propagande pontificale.” MEFRA 73 (1961): 275–322.
Richardson, L. A New Topographical Dictionary of Ancient Rome (Baltimore and London, 1992).
Rimoldi, A. “L'Apostolo San Pietro,” in Analecta Gregoriana (Rome, 1958).
Salzman, M. R. On Roman Time: The Codex-Calendar of 354 and the Rhythms of Urban Life in Late Antiquity (Berkeley, Los Angeles, Oxford, 1990).
Thacker, A. “Rome of the Martyrs: Saints, Cults and Relics, Fourth to Seventh Centuries,” in Carragáin, É. Ó. and Vegvar, C. Neuman de, eds., Roma Felix – Formation and Reflections of Medieval Rome (Aldershot, 2007), 13–49.
Toynbee, J. M. C. and Ward-Perkins, J. B.. The Shrine of St Peter and the Vatican Excavations (London, New York, Toronto, 1956).
Voicu, S. J.Feste di apostoli alla fine di dicembre.” Studi sull'oriente cristiano, 82 (2004): 47–77.