Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2015
  • Online publication date: November 2015

12 - Reinterpreting “Pagans” and “Christians” from Rome's Late Antique Mortuary Evidence

from Section B - Death and the Afterlife

Summary

The great Christian catacombs of Rome – Commodilla, Priscilla, Domitilla, Sebastian, Callixtus, to name only the largest complexes – have been since the Renaissance the chief data set for discovering the nature of emergent Christianity “on the ground,” or better, underground. Here, frescoed on the walls of plastered tufa and traced along the ancient routes of the pious, one can witness the rise of a new yet robust Christian identity, already coalesced in the third century. The catacombs reveal a large and protected ancient community of ordinary humble citizens of Rome, united in their vision of an eternal refrigerium that awaited them. Unlike their pagan adversaries, Christians created vast networks of subterranean eschatological hope, clustered together against the pressures of superstition and the sham religions of pagan imitators, against those who believed that death was the end and who abandoned their dead in the cold, dark ground.

Given the potential usefulness of the catacombs as a data set for recovering emergent Christianity, it seems important to consider them as we determine to what degree the terms pagan and Christian are useful or accurate to describe religious identities in late antique Rome. Surely Christians distinguished themselves from pagans in their chosen mode of burial, such that we might be able to discern difference, if not actual conflict, from their archaeological remains. Indeed, the very phenomenon of “Christian catacombs” presupposes difference – a distinct Christian community, united in doctrine and praxis, living in the broader environment of the late Roman city. There are no “pagan catacombs,” only the scant remains of pagan hypogea and necropoleis. Yet this supposition – that Christian catacombs reflect the sturdiness, differentiation, and united front of emergent Christianity against paganism – while not incorrect, is fraught with interpretive pitfalls. The picture painted in the opening paragraph of this chapter – often found with only slight variations in scholarship – is entirely wrong. It has emerged, not from the astonishing 170 kilometers of catacombs that are indeed critical sources for uncovering late antique Christianity, but from a way of reading them that has remained dominant and authoritative until very recently.

The centrality of the Roman catacombs to Catholic self-identity began with their “rediscovery” fortuitously one day in 1578, when workers laboring at the Vigna Sanchez off the Via Salaria punctured the soft tuff to discover a vast labyrinth of graves below.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Bargebuhr, F. P. The Paintings of the “New” Catacomb of the Via Latina and the Struggle of Christianity against Paganism, ed. Utz, Joachim (Heidelberg, 1991).
Beard, Mary, et al. Religions of Rome, Vol. 2: A Sourcebook (Cambridge, 1998).
Bodel, J. “From Columbaria to Catacombs: Communities of the Dead in Pagan and Christian Rome,” in Brink, L. and Greene, D., eds., Roman Burial and Commemorative Practices and Earliest Christianity (Berlin/New York, 2008), 177–242.
Bowes, K. D. Private Worship, Public Values, and Religious Change in Late Antiquity (Cambridge, 2008).
Burrus, V. and Lyman, R.. “Shifting the Focus of History,” in Burrus, Virginia and Lyman, Rebecca, eds., Late Ancient Christianity. A People's History of Christianity 2 (Philadelphia, 2005), 1–26.
Deckers, J. “Wie genau ist eine Katakombe zu datieren? Das beispiel SS.Marcellino e Pietro,” in Memoriam Sanctorum Venerantes. Miscellanea in onore di Monsignor Victor Saxer (Vatican City, 1992), 217–38.
Denzey, N. The Bone Gatherers (Boston, 2007).
De Rossi, G. B., ed. Roma sotterranea Cristiana. 3 vols. (Rome, 1864–77).
De Rossi, G. B. Inscriptiones christianae urbis romae septimo saeculo (Rome, 1887–).
De Santis, P. “Glass Vessels as Grave Goods and Grave Ornament in the Catacombs of Rome: Some Examples,” in Pearce, J., Millett, M., and Struck, M., eds., Burial, Society, and Context in the Ancient World (Oxford, 2000), 240–2.
Ditchfield, S. “Reading Rome as a Sacred Landscape, ca. 1586–1635,” in Coster, W. and Spicer, A., eds., Sacred Space in Early Modern Europe (Cambridge, 2005), 167–91.
Ditchfield, S.Thinking with the Saints: Sanctity and Society in the Early Modern World.” Critical Inquiry 35, no. 3 (2009): 552–84.
Dunbabin, K. The Roman Banquet: Images of Conviviality (New York, 2003).
Ferrari, G., ed. Charles Rufus Morey (1877–1955): The Gold-Glass Collection of the Vatican Library: With Additional Catalogues of Other Gold-Glass Collections (Vatican City, 1959).
Ferrua, A. The Unknown Catacomb: A Unique Discovery of Early Christian Art. Introduction by Nardini, Bruno, trans. Inglis, Iain (New Lanark, 1991).
Finney, P. C. The Invisible God: The Earliest Christians on Art (New York, 1994).
Frend, W. H. C. The Archaeology of Early Christianity: A History (Minneapolis, 1996).
Goodenough, E. R.Catacomb Art.” JBL 81 (1962).
Guyon, J.La vente des tombes à travers l’épigraphie de la Rome chrétienne (IIIe-VIIe siècles): Le rôle des fossores, mansionarii, praepositi et prètres.” MEFRA 86 (1974): 549–96.
Jastrzebowska, E.Les scènes de banquet dans les peintures et sculptures chrétienne des IIIe et IVe siècles.” Recherches Augustiniennes 14 (1979).
Jensen, R.Dining in Heaven: The Earliest Christian Visions of Paradise.” Bible Review 14, no. 5 (1998): 32–9, 48–9.
Johnson, M.Pagan-Christian Burial Practices of the Fourth Century: Shared Tombs?JECS 5, no. 1 (1997): 37–59.
Logan, A. H. B. The Gnostics: Identifying an Early Christian Cult (London, 2006).
MacMullen, R. The Second Church: Popular Christianity, A.D. 200–400 (Leiden/Boston, 2009).
McGowan, A.Rethinking Eucharistic Origins.” Pacifica 23 (2010): 173–91.
Murphy, S. C. Rebirth and Afterlife: A Study of the Transmutation of Some Pagan Imagery in Early Christian Funerary Art. British Archaeological Reports, International Series 100 (Oxford, 1981).
Nuzzo, D. “Evidence of Amulet Use from the Christian Catacombs.” In Pearce, John, Millett, Martin, and Struck, Manuela, eds., Burial, Society, and Context in the Roman World (Oxford, 2000), 249–55.
Oryshkevich, I. T. “The History of the Roman Catacombs from the Age of Constantine to the Renaissance.” PhD diss. Columbia University (2003).
Osborne, J.The Roman Catacombs in the Middle Ages.” PBSR 53 (1985): 278–328.
Palladio, A. The Churches of Rome, trans. and commentary by Howe, Eunice D. (Binghamton, 1991).
Pergola, P. Le catacombe romane: storia e topografia, catalogo a cura di Barbini, P. M. (Rome, 1998).
Perry, J. “A Death in the Familia: The Funerary Colleges of the Roman Empire.” PhD diss., University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (1999).
Rebillard, É.Koimeterion, Coemeterium: Tombe, Tombe Sainte, Nécropole.” MEFRA 105, no. 2 (1993): 975–1001.
Rebillard, É. The Care of the Dead in Late Antiquity (Ithaca, 2009).
Rutgers, L. Subterranean Rome: In Search of the Roots of Christianity in the Catacombs of the Eternal City (Leuven, 2000).
Saller, R. and Shaw, B.. “Tombstones and Roman Family Relations in the Principate: Civilians, Soldiers, and Slaves.” JRS 74 (1984): 124–56.
Shaw, B.Latin Funerary Epigraphy and Family Life in the Later Roman Empire.” Historia 33 (1984): 457–97.
Spera, L.The Christianization of Space along the Via Appia: Changing Landscape in the Suburbs of Rome.” AJA 107, no. 1 (2003): 23–43.
Smith, D. E. From Symposium to Eucharist: The Banquet in the Early Christian World (Minneapolis, 2003).
Snyder, H. G.Pictures in Dialogue: A Viewer-Centered Approach to the Hypogeum on Via Dino Compagni.” JECS 13, no. 3 (2005): 347–94.
Vermaseren, M. J. Corpus inscriptionum et monumentorum religionis mithriacae. 2 vols. (The Hague, 1956, 1960).
Wilpert, J. Fractio Panis, die alteste Darstellung der eucharistischen Opfers (Freiburg in Breisgau, 1895).
Wilpert, J. Die Malereien der Katakomben Roms (Freiburg im Breisgau, 1903).
Yasin, A. M.Displaying the Sacred Past: Ancient Christian Inscriptions in Early Modern Rome.” International Journal of the Classical Tradition 7, no. 1 (2000): 39–57.