Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures and Tables
- Notes on Contributors
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Secondary Cities: Introduction to a Research Agenda
- 2 Shedding Light or Casting Shadows? Relations between Primary and Secondary Cities
- 3 Small and Medium-Sized Towns as Secondary Cities: The Case of Switzerland
- 4 From Sleepy Hollow to Winning from Second: Identity, Autonomy and Borrowed Size in an Australian Urban Region
- 5 Metropolization Processes and Intra-Regional Contrasts: The Uneven Fortunes of English Secondary Cities
- 6 Situating the Secondary City: Uneven Development and Regional Gentrification in Tacoma, WA
- 7 Borrowed Social Performance: Labour and Community Organizations in Los Angeles and Long Beach, California
- 8 Intra-Regional Relationality and Green City-Regionalism: Placing the Role of ‘Secondary Cities’
- 9 Conclusion: Advancing the Secondary City Perspective
- Index
9 - Conclusion: Advancing the Secondary City Perspective
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 January 2022
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures and Tables
- Notes on Contributors
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Secondary Cities: Introduction to a Research Agenda
- 2 Shedding Light or Casting Shadows? Relations between Primary and Secondary Cities
- 3 Small and Medium-Sized Towns as Secondary Cities: The Case of Switzerland
- 4 From Sleepy Hollow to Winning from Second: Identity, Autonomy and Borrowed Size in an Australian Urban Region
- 5 Metropolization Processes and Intra-Regional Contrasts: The Uneven Fortunes of English Secondary Cities
- 6 Situating the Secondary City: Uneven Development and Regional Gentrification in Tacoma, WA
- 7 Borrowed Social Performance: Labour and Community Organizations in Los Angeles and Long Beach, California
- 8 Intra-Regional Relationality and Green City-Regionalism: Placing the Role of ‘Secondary Cities’
- 9 Conclusion: Advancing the Secondary City Perspective
- Index
Summary
The varied contributions to this book confirm the value of employing a relational analysis to understand the conditions and prospects of secondary cities across a wide range of urban contexts. While a welcome and growing body of research has moved beyond ‘global winners’ to focus on ‘small cities’, ‘shrinking cities’ and ‘legacy cities’, it is essential to highlight the connections between different cities if we are to avoid an overly fragmented accounting of contemporary urban conditions. In Ward's (2010: 477) terms, following Tilly (1984), this work constitutes a form of ‘individualizing comparison’ focused on exploring the relationship between ‘primary’ and ‘secondary’ cities within the context of post-crisis urban redevelopment in the Global North. In line with Massey's (2007) insights (and, we hope, avoiding the essentializing tendencies that Ward (2010) critiques), we suggest that taking a relational approach to this investigation of multiple cases can help us to see how the ‘failings’, struggles and policy dilemmas faced by secondary cities are often intimately tied to the ‘successes’ of larger, dominant cities. Such cities have often been construed (especially in the US) as ‘left-behind’ places (Hendrickson et al, 2018) that should look to superstar cities to identify their own paths forward. Conversely, more dynamic secondary cities have at times been celebrated for their niche identities and associated economic success. Counter to this kind of decontextualized emphasis on the policy choices and internal strengths or shortcomings of particular secondary cities, the approach taken here highlights instead the extent to which the trajectories of these cities need to be understood as already reflecting a history of interactions with their more dominant neighbours.
This emphasis on relationality in turn raises crucial issues of scale. Analyses of ‘second cities’ in the US have almost entirely focused on national-level relationships between cities like New York and Chicago or Philadelphia (Hodos, 2011). But to understand cities such as those explored in this book we need to operate at the regional level, to grapple with how proximity to a regionally dominant city plays a central role in defining a range of economic, social and policy opportunities and limitations. This is not, of course, to rule out other scales of analysis in assessing, for instance, how capital and population flows have reached or evaded otherwise similar cities.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Secondary CitiesExploring Uneven Development in Dynamic Urban Regions of the Global North, pp. 209 - 222Publisher: Bristol University PressPrint publication year: 2021