Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface and acknowledgements
- 1 Hermeneutics and the philosophical future of religious studies
- 2 Bernard Williams on the gods and us
- 3 Hume's legacy
- 4 Feuerbach: religion's secret?
- 5 Marx and Engels: religion, alienation and compensation
- 6 Tylor and Frazer: are religious beliefs mistaken hypotheses?
- 7 Marett: primitive reactions
- 8 Freud: the battle for ‘earliest’ things
- 9 Durkheim: religion as a social construct
- 10 Lévy-Bruhl: primitive logic
- 11 Berger: the avoidance of discourse
- 12 Winch: trying to understand
- 13 Understanding: a philosophical vocation
- Index of names
- Index of subjects
3 - Hume's legacy
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 03 December 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface and acknowledgements
- 1 Hermeneutics and the philosophical future of religious studies
- 2 Bernard Williams on the gods and us
- 3 Hume's legacy
- 4 Feuerbach: religion's secret?
- 5 Marx and Engels: religion, alienation and compensation
- 6 Tylor and Frazer: are religious beliefs mistaken hypotheses?
- 7 Marett: primitive reactions
- 8 Freud: the battle for ‘earliest’ things
- 9 Durkheim: religion as a social construct
- 10 Lévy-Bruhl: primitive logic
- 11 Berger: the avoidance of discourse
- 12 Winch: trying to understand
- 13 Understanding: a philosophical vocation
- Index of names
- Index of subjects
Summary
HUME AND HERMENEUTICS
It is not an extravagant judgement to say that most philosophers today regard Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion to be the most devastating critique of religion in the history of philosophy. Philosophers sympathetic to religion have called it ‘the greatest work on philosophy of religion in the English language’. Why should this be so? The answer lies in the fact that it has shaped, if not determined, the terms of reference within which most philosophy of religion is carried on. In any discussion of religion and modernity, there is no way of avoiding Hume.
How is Hume's work related to the hermeneutics of recollection, the hermeneutics of suspicion, and the hermeneutics of contemplation? The fundamental claim of the Dialogues is that it is impossible to infer anything substantive about God from the world about us. That being so, it would seem that Hume makes little contribution to the hermeneutics of recollection. But this is not so. Many philosophers of religion sympathetic to religion attempt to answer Hume on his own terms. The work of Richard Swinburne can be seen in this light. He has been described as a twentieth-century Cleanthes.
It is easy to see how Hume's work contributes to the hermeneutics of suspicion, although how it does so is a matter of dispute. According to some, Hume concludes that religion is the product of illusion. Others argue that although Hume merely says that we must suspend judgement where religious belief is concerned, since this situation cannot conceivably change, it demonstrates the irrelevance of religion for human life.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Religion and the Hermeneutics of Contemplation , pp. 55 - 86Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2001