Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Contents
- List of tables
- List of boxes
- List of figures
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Part 1 Theoretical and general issues
- Part 2 Specific mental health conditions across cultures
- Part 3 Management issues in the cultural context
- 19 Cross-cultural psychiatric assessment
- 20 Clinical management of patients across cultures
- 21 Ethnic and cultural factors in psychopharmacology
- 22 Communication with patients from other cultures: the place of explanatory models
- 23 Working with patients with religious beliefs
- 24 Interpreter-mediated psychiatric interviews
- 25 Treatment of victims of trauma
- 26 Effective psychotherapy in an ethnically and culturally diverse society
- 27 Diversity training for psychiatrists
- 28 Informing progress towards race equality in mental healthcare: is routine data collection adequate?
- 29 Towards social inclusion in mental health?
- Index
23 - Working with patients with religious beliefs
from Part 3 - Management issues in the cultural context
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 02 January 2018
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Contents
- List of tables
- List of boxes
- List of figures
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Part 1 Theoretical and general issues
- Part 2 Specific mental health conditions across cultures
- Part 3 Management issues in the cultural context
- 19 Cross-cultural psychiatric assessment
- 20 Clinical management of patients across cultures
- 21 Ethnic and cultural factors in psychopharmacology
- 22 Communication with patients from other cultures: the place of explanatory models
- 23 Working with patients with religious beliefs
- 24 Interpreter-mediated psychiatric interviews
- 25 Treatment of victims of trauma
- 26 Effective psychotherapy in an ethnically and culturally diverse society
- 27 Diversity training for psychiatrists
- 28 Informing progress towards race equality in mental healthcare: is routine data collection adequate?
- 29 Towards social inclusion in mental health?
- Index
Summary
Summary Mental health professionals in Western societies are generally less religious than their patients and receive little training in religious issues. Using case studies, I discuss issues involved in working with patients who hold religious beliefs: problems of engagement; countertransference; religious and spiritual issues not attributable to mental disorder; problems of differential diagnosis; religious delusions; religion and psychotherapy; psychosexual problems; and religiously oriented treatments. The chapter ends with a discussion of the various ways in which religious themes can be incorporated into mental health work, especially the need to involve religious professionals and develop collaborative patterns of working together.
As part of their everyday clinical practice mental health professionals are likely to encounter patients with religious beliefs or patients who have religious issues. Traditionally, psychiatrists and psychologists have underemphasised religious issues in their work (Larson, 1986; Lukoff & Turner, 1992; Sims, 1994; Crossley, 1995). Religion is often seen by mental health professionals in Western societies as irrational, outdated and dependencyforming, a view deriving from Freud (1907: p. 25), who saw it as a ‘universal obsessional neurosis’ (Box 23.1). For similar reasons the topic of religion plays little part in psychiatric training, which may be selected by people of a lower level of religiosity than the background population (Shafranske & Malony, 1990; Larson & Larson, 1991; Rubenstein, 1994). It is no wonder that the Danish theologian Hans Kung referred to religion as ‘psychiatry's last taboo’ (Kung, 1986).
Box 23.1 Antagonism towards religion
Many psychiatrists see religion as:
• primitive
• guilt-inducing
• a form of dependency
• irrational
• having no empirical base
Several studies highlight a ‘religiosity gap’: psychiatrists are often far less religious than their patients (Kroll & Sheehan, 1981; Neeleman & Lewis, 1994). Both the general public and psychiatric patients report themselves to be more religious and to attend church more regularly than mental health professionals (American Psychiatric Association Task Force, 1975). In fact, a Gallup poll in 1985 indicated that a third of the general population in the USA considered religion to be the most important dimension of their lives, and another third considered it to be very important (Gallup, 1986). Keating & Fretz (1990) report evidence that religious individuals are less satisfied with a non-religious clinician than with a religious one.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Clinical Topics in Cultural Psychiatry , pp. 293 - 305Publisher: Royal College of PsychiatristsPrint publication year: 2010