Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-mp689 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T00:18:59.091Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Rite of Confirmation in Anglican Thought during the Eighteenth Century

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Robert Cornwall
Robert Cornwall
Affiliation:
Pastor of First Christian Church of Santa Barbara, Calif.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

S. L. Ollard's 1926 study of the Church of England's understanding and practice of the rite of confirmation remains the most significant examination of this topic for the eighteenth century. He insisted that eighteenth-century Anglicans took a low view of the rite, contending that the religious consequences of the Glorious Revolution set the tone for Anglican sacramental views. That the church allowed three unconfirmed monarchs (William III and the first two Georges) to receive the Eucharist provided evidence of the neglect of this rite. Louis Weil more recently echoes Ollard's critique, suggesting that after 1660 Anglican writers “virtually ignored the rite.” Weil believes that interest in the rite was limited to Thomas Wilson, the eighteenth-century bishop of Sodor and Man, and a few like-minded members of the “old high church tradition.” Thus, according to most accounts, Anglicans gave little attention to confirmation until the nineteenth century, when the Tractarians supposedly rediscovered the importance of the rite. Ironically, Weil undermines his own position by pointing out that the only “concentrated material” on the rite in the Tracts for the Times was a reprinting of the work on confirmation by the eighteenth-century bishop of Sodor and Mann, Thomas Wilson.

Type
Articles
Information
Church History , Volume 68 , Issue 2 , June 1999 , pp. 359 - 372
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Ollard, S. L., “Confirmation in the Anglican Communion,” in Confirmation or the Laying on of Hands (London: SPCK, 1926), 1: 176–77.Google Scholar

2. Weil, Louis, Sacraments and Liturgy: The Outward Signs (Oxford: Blackwell, 1983), 75, 79.Google Scholar

3. Sykes, Norman, Church and State in England in the XVIIIth Century (1934; reprint, Hamden, Conn.: Archon, 1962).Google ScholarFor a good example of a pessimistic view of the era see Virgin, Peter, The Church in an Age of Negligence: Ecclesiastical Structure and Problems of Church Reform, 1700–1840 (Cambridge: James Clarke, 1989).Google ScholarFor an excellent overview of recent scholarship on the eighteenth-century Church of England see Walsh, John and Taylor, Stephen, “Introduction: The Church and Anglicanism in the ‘Long’ Eighteenth Century,” in The Church of England, c. 1689–1833: From Toleration to Tractarianism, ed. Walsh, John, Haydon, Colin, and Taylor, Stephen (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 1–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4. Burns, R. Arthur, “A Hanoverian Legacy? Diocesan Reform in the Church of England c. 1800–1833,” in Church of England, 265–66.Google ScholarAlso see Jago's, Judith recent study of the episcopal work of Robert Drummond of York, Aspects of the Georgian Church: Visitation Studies of the Diocese of York, 1761–1776 (Madison, N.J.: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 1997).Google Scholar

5. Eighteenth Century Short Title Catalog, CD-ROM database (London: British Library Board, 1992).Google Scholar

6. Sykes, Church and State, 118, 121, 132.Google ScholarAbbey, Charles J. and Overton, John H., The English Church in the Eighteenth Century (London: Longmans, Green, 1878), 2: 502.Google ScholarVirgin, Church in an Age of Negligence, 158–59.Google Scholar

7. Carpenter, S. C., The Eighteenth Century Church and People (London: John Murray, 1959), 187.Google ScholarSykes, Church and State, 122–23,133–34.Google Scholar

8. Grisbrooke, W. Jardine, Anglican Liturgies of the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries, Alcuin Club Collection, no. 40 (London: SPCK, 1958), 122.Google ScholarEvery, George, The High Church Party, 1688–1718 (London: SPCK, 1956), 121–22.Google Scholar

9. Isham, Z., A Discourse of Confirmation: Preach'd at Coleshill, April 21, 1705. At the Triennial Visitation of the Right Reverend Father in God, John, Lord Bishop of Coventry and Litchfield (London, 1705), 9.Google Scholar

10. Prowde, Francis, A Sermon Preached in the Parish Church of Bridgewater, July 16,1693. Before the Right Reverend Father in God, Richard, Lord Bishop of Bath and Wells, at a Confirmation (London, 1694), 17.Google Scholar

11. King, Peter, An Enquiry into the Constitution, Discipline, Unity, and Worship of the Primitive Church, which flourished within the First Three Hundred Years after Christ (1691; reprint, London: S. Cornish, 1839), 222.Google ScholarSee the response to Peter King offered by Sclater, William, An Original Draught of the Primitive Church (reprint, Columbus, Ohio: 1833), 166–68.Google Scholar

12. Ellison, Nathaniel, On Confirmation (London, 1701), 16–17.Google ScholarAlso see Kennett, White, The Office and Good Work of a Bishop: A Sermon preached in Lambeth Chappel, at the Consecration of the Right Reverend Father in God, William, Lord Bishop of Lincoln, on Sunday, October 21,1705 (London, 1706), 6–7.Google Scholar

13. Kennett, Office and Good Work of a Bishop, 22.Google Scholar

14. Jago, Aspects of the Georgian Church, 42–43.Google Scholar

15. Patrick, Simon, “An Answer to a Book spread abroad by the Romish Priests, intituled, The Touchstone of the Reformed Gospel, wherein the True Doctrine of the Church of England and many Texts of the Holy Scripture are Faithfully Explained,” in The Works of Symon Patrick, D.D.: Sometime Bishop of Ely, ed. Taylor, Alexander (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1858), 7: 297–98.Google ScholarLaw, William, “Three Letters to the Bishop of Bangor,” in The Works of the Reverend William Law, M.A. (1762; reprint, Setley: G. Moreton, 1892), 1: 27–28.Google ScholarPotter, John, A Discourse on Church-Government: Wherein the Rights of the Church and the Supremacy of Christian Bishops are Vindicated and Adjusted, 5th ed. (London: Samuel Bagster, 1839), 245–47.Google ScholarStebbing, Henry, A Defence of Confirmation as now settled in the Church of England in a Discourse on Acts 8:17 (London, 1729), 14.Google Scholar

16. Prowde, Sermon Preached in the Parish Church of Bridgewater, 7–8.Google Scholar

17. Potter, Discourse on Church-Government, 249. Patrick, “Answer to a Book,” 7: 298.Google Scholar

18. Brett, Thomas, The Extent of Christ's Commission to Baptize: A Sermon Shewing the Capacity of Infants to Receive and the Utter Incapacity of our Dissenting Teachers to Administer Christian Baptism (London, 1712), 12.Google ScholarNelson, Robert, A Companion for the Festivals and Fasts of the Church of England With Collects and Prayers for Each Solemnity, 5th ed. (1708; reprint, London: SPCK, 1841), 492.Google ScholarPaley, William, “On Confirmation,” in The Works of William Paley, D.D., new ed. (London, 1825), 7: 224.Google ScholarSimeon, Excellency of the Liturgy, 48–49. Stebbing, Defence of Confirmation, 3–6.Google ScholarStubbs, Philip, Of Confirmation. A Sermon Preach'd at St. Benedict Grace-Church, March 14th, 1693 (London, 1693), 17–18.Google ScholarWheatly, Charles, A Rational Illustration of the Book of Common Prayer of the Church of England (London: Wm. Tegg, 1853), 375–76.Google ScholarWilson, Thomas, “A Further Instruction for Such as have Learned the Church Catechism,” in The Works of the Right Reverend Father in God, Thomas Wilson, D.D. (Oxford: J. H. Parker, 1851), 4: 1–2.Google Scholar

19. Clarke, Samuel, “Three Practical Essays, on Baptism, Confirmation, and Repentance. Containing Full Instructions for a Holy Life: With Earnest Exhortations, especially to Young Persons, Drawn from the Consideration of the Severity of the Discipline of the Primitive Church,” in Samuel Clarke, The Works (1738) (New York: Garland, 1978), 3: 600.Google Scholar

20. Watson, Richard, An Address to Young Persons after Confirmation (Cambridge, 1788), 1–2.Google Scholar

21. Paley, “On Confirmation,” 7: 224.Google Scholar

22. Hoadly, Benjamin, “A Defense of the Reasonableness of Conformity to the Church of England, &c. In Answer to the Objections of Mr. Calamy, in his Defense of Moderate Non-Conformity,” in The Works of Benjamin Hoadly, D.D., ed. Hoadly, John (London, 1733), 1: 362.Google ScholarLaw, “Three Letters,” 1: 29.Google Scholar

23. [Blackburne, Francis], A Critical Commentary on Archbishop Seeker's Letter to the Right Honorable Horatio Walpole, Concerning Bishops in America (London, 1710), 15.Google Scholar

24. Kennett, White, Monitions and Advices Delivered to the Clergy of the Diocese of Peterborough, at the Primary Visitation held in the Months of July and August, MDCCXX. By the Right Reverend Father in God, White, Lord Bishop of Peterborough (London, 1720), 21.Google Scholar

25. Wheatly, Rational Illustration, 257.Google Scholar

26. Ellison, Confirmation, 4. Also see Isham, Discourse of Confirmation, 5–6.Google Scholar

27. Wilson, Thomas, “Parochialia,” in The Works of the Right Reverend Father in God, Thomas Wilson, D.D., Lord Bishop of Sodor and Man, new ed. (Oxford: John Henry Parker, 1847), 7: 12 (hereafter cited as Works).Google Scholar

28. Wilson, Thomas, “Sermon LXXXI: The Ordinances of God Attended with Certain, though Invisible Effects,” in Works, 3: 341.Google ScholarWilson, Thomas, “Sermon LXXXIII: Preached at a Confirmation. The knowledge necessary for everyone who takes upon himself the profession of a Christian, pointed out and illustrated,” in Works, 3: 366.Google ScholarStubbs, Confirmation, 14–15, 18–19.Google ScholarCf. Cuming, G. J., A History of Anglican Liturgy, 2nd ed. (London: MacMillan, 1984), 142–43.Google ScholarEvery, High Church Party, 122. Grisbrooke, Anglican Liturgy, 122.Google Scholar

29. Wheatly, Rational Illustration, 374.Google Scholar

30. George, Raymond, “The People Called Methodists—4. The Means of Grace,” in A History of the Methodist Church in Great Britain, ed. Davies, Rupert and Rupp, Gordon (London: Epworth, 1965), 1: 260–61, 269.Google ScholarRupp, Gordon, Religion in England, 1688–1791 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986), 442.Google ScholarAlso see Campbell, Ted A., John Wesley and Christian Antiquity: Religious Vision and Cultural Change (Nashville, Term.: Kingswood, 1991), 36–37.Google Scholar

31. Simeon, Charles, The Excellent of the Liturgy in Four Discourses Preached before the University of Cambridge, November 1811, 3d ed. (London, 1816), 48–49.Google ScholarBebbington, David, Evangelicalism in Modern Britain: A History from the 1730s to the 1980s (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker, 1989), 9–10.Google ScholarHennell, Michael, John Venn and the Clapham Sect (London: Lutterworth, 1958), 121–22.Google ScholarWebster, Douglas, “Simeon's Pastoral Theology,” in Charles Simeon (1759–1836): Essays Written in Commemoration of His Bi-Centenary by Members of the Evangelical Fellowship for Theological Literature, ed. Pollard, Arthur and Hennell, Michael (London: SPCK, 1959), 113.Google Scholar

32. Clarke, “Three Practical Essays,” 3: 570, 73. Nelson, Companion to the Festivals, 492. Stebbing, Confirmation, 4–5,10–12. Wilson, “Parochialia,” 7: 8–9,13–18.Google Scholar

33. Kennett, Monitions and Advices, 22. Wheatly, Rational Illustration, 376.Google Scholar

34. Stebbing, Confirmation, 10. Kennett, Monitions, 21–22. Wheatly, Rational Illustration, 376. King, Necessity and Benefit of Confirmation, 16–17. Thomas Deacon's Complete Devotions (1734) included this rite and it eventually found its way into the liturgical practice of the later Nonjuror movement.Google ScholarBroxap, Henry, The Biography of Thomas Deacon (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1911), 46.Google Scholar

35. Wheatly, Rational Illustration, 380.Google Scholar

36. Burnet, Gilbert, A Discourse of the Pastoral Care, ed. Cornwall, Robert D. (Lewiston, N.Y.: Edwin Mellen, 1997), 174–75.Google Scholar

37. King, John, The Necessity and Benefit of Confirmation: A Sermon Preach'd at West-Cowes-Chapel, in the Isle of Wight, on Sunday, August 15,1725 (Oxford, 1725), 4, 6–7.Google Scholar

38. Kennett, Monitions and Advices, 19–20.Google Scholar

39. Kennett, Monitions and Advices, 19. Wheatly, Rational Illustration, 379.Google Scholar

40. Porteus, Beilby, A Review of the Life and Character of the Right Rev. Dr. Thomas Seeker, Late Lord Archbishop of Canterbury, 5th corrected ed. (London, 1797), 22–23. Also see Sykes, Church and State, 116–17.Google Scholar