Normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH) is characterized by pathologically enlarged ventricles without elevated cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pressure along with a triad of clinical symptoms including gait disturbances, urinary incontinence, and cognitive impairment. NPH is evaluated with lumbar drain trials (LDTs) where CSF is removed over several days to determine if patients would benefit from ventricular shunting. Candidate selection and success for these surgeries remains challenging because other diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease (AD) share common features with NPH in cognitive impairment and enlarged ventricles. Prior research has found that 20%-40% of presumed NPH cases have AD pathology as determined by brain biopsy or autopsy. CSF biomarkers of AD can be altered in NPH and are not always conclusive, complicating the interpretation of results when formulating diagnoses and prognoses. Studies to refine the analyses of AD CSF biomarkers in NPH are needed. We aimed to examine the frequency of CSF biomarker results among patients presenting for NPH evaluations with LDTs.

62 patients presented for LDTs upon physician recommendations. CSF specimens were sent to Mayo Clinic Laboratories for Alzheimer Disease Evaluation (ADEVL) that utilizes Elecsys (Lenexa, KS) CSF electrochemiluminescence immunoassays (Roche Diagnostics, Basel, Switzerland) to measure levels of amyloid-beta 42 (Aβ42), total tau (t-tau), and phosphorylatedtau (p-tau), and p-tau:Aβ42 ratio. Results were classified based on interpretation through the Amyloid/Tau/Neurodegeneration (ATN) framework1: 1) AD - biomarker profile consistent with AD pathologic change, 2) non-AD profile - biomarker levels normal or inconsistent with AD pathologic change, or 3) indeterminate - biomarkers were incongruous with only one or two abnormal levels of Aβ42, t-tau, p-tau, or ptau: Aβ42. Indeterminate cases may represent altered protein levels due to CSF dynamics or AD-related pathologic change. In reviewing recent research on CSF dynamics and AD biomarkers in NPH2 a p-tau threshold of 15 pg/mL was derived and implemented such that cases with Aß42 <=1026 pg/mL and p-tau <15 pg/mL were designated as suspected non-AD, and those with Aß42 <=1026 pg/mL and p-tau >15 pg/mL were designated suspected AD.

Of the 62 LDT cases, 12 (19.35%) were classified as AD, 31 (50%) were indeterminate and 22 (35.48%) were non-AD. Of the 31 indeterminate cases, 21 (33.87% of the overall sample) were suspected non-AD and 7 (11.29% of the full sample) were categorized as suspected AD.

Our findings show that 20%-30% of patients presenting for LDT showed evidence for AD-type pathologic change, consistent with prior reports of AD pathology in cases of possible NPH. Half of all LDT cases had indeterminate AD CSF biomarker results, the interpretations of which were confounded by the potential alterations of CSF biomarkers levels due to NPH independent of AD. Our findings emphasize the need to establish better approaches to interpreting CSF AD biomarkers in evaluating NPH. Future research should examine the discriminative utility of CSF AD biomarkers and the selected p-tau threshold in indeterminate cases for predicting response to LDT and shunting.