Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The timing of monozygotic twinning: a criticism of the common model

  • Gonzalo Herranz (a1)

Summary

In the dominant model, monozygotic (MZ) twinning is universally accepted as a post-fertilization event resulting from splitting of the embryo along its first 2 weeks of development. The stage at which splitting occurs determines chorionicity and amnionicity. A short history on how the model was built is presented, stressing the role played by some embryologists, in particular George Corner, in its completion and final success. Strikingly, for more than 60 years no deep criticisms have been raised against the model, which, in virtue of its rational and plausible character, enjoys the status of undisputed truth. At close examination, the embryological support of the model shows some important weak points, particularly when dealing with late splitting. In the author's view, the model not only has contributed to ‘suspend’ our knowledge on the timing of MZ twinning, but seems indefensible and claims to be substituted. That factor could imply relevant consequences for embryology and bioethics. As an alternative to the model, a new theory to explain the timing of MZ twinning is proposed. It is based on two premises. First, MZ twinning would be a fertilization event. In that case, due to an alteration of the zygote–blastomere transition, the first zygotic division, instead of producing two blastomeres, generates twin zygotes. Second, monochorionicity and monoamnionicity would not depend on embryo splitting, but on fusion of membranes. Some support for this theory can be found in recent embryological advances and also in some explanations of old.

Copyright

Corresponding author

All correspondence to: Gonzalo Herranz. Department of Medical Humanities, School of Medicine, University of Navarre, Apartado 177, 31080 Pamplona, Spain. Tel: +34 948 425 600, ext. 6354. Fax: +34 948 425 630. e-mail: gherranz@unav.es

References

Hide All
Allen, F.D. (1969). Essentials of Human Embryology, 2 edn.New York: Oxford University Press, p. 34.
Anonymous Review of Current Literature (1956). J. Obstet. Gynaecol. Br Emp. 63, 459–79.
Arey, L.B. (1922). Direct proof of the monozygotic origin of human identical twins. Anat. Rec. 23, 245–8.
Assheton, R. (1893). An account of a blastodermic vesicle of the sheep of the seventh day, with twin germinal areas. J. Anat. Physiol. 32, 362–72.
Aston, K.I., Peterson, C.M. & Carrell, D.T. (2008). Monozygotic twinning associated with assisted reproductive technologies: a review. Reproduction 136, 377–86.
Bamforth, F., Brown, L., Senz, J. & Huntsman, D. (2003). Mechanisms of monozygotic (MA) twinning: a possible role for the cell adhesion molecule, E-cadherin. Am. J. Med. Genet. 120A, 5962.
Beck, A.C. & Rosenthal, A.H. (1957). Obstetrical Practice, 7 edn.Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, p. 546.
Behr, B. & Milki, A.A. (2003). Visualization of atypical hatching of a human blastocyst in vitro forming two identical embryos. Fertil. Steril. 80, 1502–3.
Benirschke, K. (1965). Major pathologic features of the placenta, cord and membranes. Birth Defects Original Article Series 1, 5263.
Benirschke, K. & Driscoll, S.G. (1967). The Pathology of the Human Placenta. New York: Springer–Verlag, p. 168.
Benirschke, K. & Kim, C.K. (1973). Multiple pregnancy (first of two parts). New Engl. J. Med. 288, 1276–84.
Blickstein, I. (2006). Monochorionicity in perspective. Ultrasound Obstet. Gynecol. 27, 235–8.
Boklage, C.E. (2005). The biology of human twinning: a needed change of perspective. In Multiple Pregnancy. Epidemiology, Gestation and Perinatal Outcome, 2nd edn (eds Blickstein, I. & Keith, L.G.), London: Taylor & Francis. A Parthenon Book, p. 258
Boklage, C.E. (2010). How New Humans Are Made. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing, pp. 114–5.
Bompiani, A. (2006). Le Tecniche di Fecondazione Assistita: Una Rasegna Critica. Milano: Vita e Pensiero, p. 102
Boyd, J.D. & Hamilton, W.J. (1970). The Human Placenta. Cambridge: W. Heffer & Sons, p. 314.
Bulmer, M.G. (1970). The Biology of Twinning in Man. Oxford: Clarendon Press, p. 27.
Bumm, E. (1902). Grundriss zum Studium der Geburtshülfe. Wiesbaden: J.F. Bergmann, p. 282.
Conybeare, R.C. (1954). Monoamniotic twins. A review of the literature with case report. Obstet. Gynecol. 4, 444–7.
Corner, G.W. (1922). The morphological theory of monochorionic twins as illustrated by a series of supposed early twin embryos of the pig. Johns Hopkins Hosp. Bull. 33, 389–92.
Corner, G.W. (1955). The observed embryology of the human single-ovum twins and other multiple births. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 70, 933–51.
Corner, G.W. (1958). Anatomist at Large: An Autobiography and Selected Essays. New York: Basic Books.
Corner, G.W. (1981). The Seven Ages of a Medical Scientist. An Autobiography. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Coulton, D., Hertig, A.T. & Long, W.N. (1947). Monoamniotic twins. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 54, 119–23.
Craig, I.T. (1957). Monoamniotic twins with double survival. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 73, 202–4.
Derom, R. & Derom, C. (2005). Placentation. In Multiple Pregnancy. Epidemiology, Gestation & Perinatal Outcome, 2nd edn (eds Blickstein, I. & Keith, L.G.), London: Taylor & Francis: a Parthenon Book, p. 158.
Dollander, A.I. (1970). Embryologie générale comparée et humaine. In Éléments d'Embryologie (eds A. Dollander & R. Fenart), Paris: Flammarion, p. 328.
Downs, K.M. (2008). Embryological origins of the human individual. In Controversies in Science & Technology: From Climate to Chromosomes (eds Kleiman, D.L., Cloud-Hausen, K.A., Matta, C. & Handelsmaneds, J.), pp. 4668. New Rochelle, NY: Mary Ann Liebert.
Ebert, J.D. (1956). Department of Embryology. Carnegie Institution of Washington. Year Book, 1955–1956. Washington DC: Carnegie Institution of Washington, p. 290.
Edwards, R.G., Mettler, L. & Walters, D.E. (1986). Identical twins and in vitro fertilization. J. In Vitro Fertil. Embr. Transf. 3, 114–7.
Greenhill, (1956). Year Book of Obstetrics and Gynecology. Chicago: Year Book Publishers, p. 258.
Grosser, O. (1927). Frühentwicklung, Eihautbildung und Placentation des Menschen und der Säugetiere. Deitsche Frauenheilkunde, Geburtshilfe, Gynäkologie und Nachbargebiete in Einzeldarstellungen. Band 5. München: J.F. Bergmann, p. 64.
Hall, J.G. (1996). Twins and twinning. Am. J. Med. Gen. 61, 202–4.
Hanes, M.V. (1954). Monoamniotic twins. Review of the literature with case report. Obstet. Gynecol. 4, 448–51.
Hartman, C.G. (1956). The scientific achievements of George Washington Corner, M.D. Am. J. Anat. 98, 519.
Hertig, A.T. (1945). On the development of the amnion and exocoelomic membrane in the pre-villous human ovum. Yale J. Biol. Med. 18, 107–15.
Hertig, A.T., Rock, J. & Adams, E.C. (1956). A description of 34 human ova within the first 17 days of development. Am. J. Anat. 98, 435–93.
Hertwig, R. (1906). Eireif, Befruchtung und Furchungsprozess. In Handbuch der Vergleichenden und Experimentellen Entwickelungslehre der Wirbeltiere, I. Band, I. Teil. Allgemeine Missbildungslehre. Jena: Gustav Fischer. Teil, I Hälfte (ed. Hertwig, O.) Jena: Verlag Gustav Fischer, p. 487.
Hughes, W. (1927). Sex-intergrades in foetal pigs. Biol. Bull. 52, 121–37.
Jones, H.W. Jr & Schrader, C. (1987). The process of human fertilization: implications for moral status. Fertil. Steril. 48, 189–92.
Kaufman, M.H. (2004). The embryology of conjoined twins. Childs Nerv. Syst. 20, 508525.
Klein, P. (1927). Zur Frage der Diagnose der Eineiigkeit bei Zwillingsschwangerschaft. Arch. Gynäk. 130, 788812.
Klein, J., Grunfeld, L., Duke, M., Mukherjee, T., Sandler, B. & Copperman, A.B. (2005). Challenging traditional dogma: a report of two cases of late monozygotic splitting resulting in dichorionic twinning. Fertil. Steril. 84(Suppl. 1), S2389.
Knopman, J., Kray, L.C., Lee, J., Fino, M.E., Novetsky, A.P. & Noyes, N. (2010). Monozygotic twinning: an eight-year experience at a large IVF center. Fertil. Steril. 94, 502–10.
Leroy, F. (1985). Early embryology and placentation of human twins. In Implantation of the Human Embryo. Proceedings of the Second Bourne Hall Meeting (eds Edwards, R.G., Purdy, J.M. & Steptoe, P.C.), pp. 396–8. London: Academic Press.
Lejeune, J. (1992). The Concentration Can: When does Human Life Begin. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, p. 197.
Leroy, F. (1985). Early embryology and placentation of human twins. In Implantation of the Human Embryo. Proceedings of the Second Bourne Hall Meeting (eds Edwards, R.G., Purdy, J.M. & Steptoe, P.C.), p. 395. London: Academic Press.
Librach, S. & Terrin, A.J. (1957). Monoamniotic twin pregnancy, with report of three cases of double survival, one of them with knotted cords. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 74, 440–3.
López-Moratalla, N. & Cerezo, M. (2011). The self-construction of a living organism. In Information and Living Systems: Philosophical and Scientific Perspectives (eds Terzis, G. & Arp, R.), pp. 177204. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Lord Zuckerman (1983). George Washington Corner. Biograph. Mem. Fell. Roy. Soc. 29, 92112.
Matias, A., Montenegro, N. & Blickstein, I. (2011). Monochorionicity: unveiling the black box. In Donald School Textbook of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology, 3rd edn (eds Kurjak, A. & Chervenak, F.A.), p. 462. New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers.
McGeady, T.A., Quinn, P.J., Fitzpatrick, E.S. & Ryan, M.T. (2006). Veterinary Embryology. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing Ltd, p. 39.
McLaren, A. (1982). The embryo. In Reproduction in Mammals. Book 2. Embryonic and Fetal Development (eds Austin, C.R. & Short, R.V.), p. 19. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Meintjes, M., Guerami, A.R., Rodriguez, J.A., Crider-Pirkle, S.S. & Madden, J.D. (2001). Prospective identification of an in-vitro-assisted monozygotic pregnancy based on a double-inner-cell-mass blastocyst. Fertil. Steril. 76, S1723.
Ménézo, Y.J.R. & Sakkas, D. (2002). Monozygotic twinning: is it related to apoptosis in the embryo? Lett. Hum. Reprod. 17, 247–8.
Mio, Y. & Maeda, K. (2008). Time-lapse cinematography of dynamic changes occurring during in vitro development of human embryos. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 199, 660.e15.
Morton, W.R.M. (1957). Duplication of the pituitary and stomodeal structures in a 38-week male infant. Arch. Dis. Child. 32, 135–41.
Nance, W.E. (1990). Invited editorial: Do twin lions have larger spots? Am. J. Hum. Gen. 45, 646–8.
Newman, H.H. (1917). The Biology of Twins. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, p. 13.
Niimura, S. (2003). Time-lapse videomicrographic analyses of contractions in mouse blastocysts. J. Reprod. Dev. 49, 413–23.
O'Rahilly, R. (1973). Developmental Stages in Human Embryos, including a survey of the Carnegie Collection. Part A. Embryos of the First Three Weeks (Stages 1–9). Carnegie Institution of Washington, p. 38.
O'Rahilly, R. & Müller, F. (1998). Embriología y Teratología Humanas. Barcelona: Masson.
Osborne, R.H. & de George, F.V. (1957). Selective survival in dizygotic twins in relation to the ABO blood groups. Am. J. Hum. Gen. 9, 321–30.
Patterson, J.T. (1913). Polyembryonic development in Tatusia novemcincta. J. Morphol. 24, 559682.
Payne, D., Okuda, A., Wakatsuki, Y., Takeshita, C., Iwata, K., Shimura, T., Yumoto, K., Ueno, Y., Flaherty, S. & Mio, Y. (2007). Time-lapse recording identifies human blastocysts at risk of producing monozygotic twins. Hum. Reprod. 22(Suppl. 1), i9.
Potter, J.C. (1927). Human monochorial twin embryos in separate amnions. Anat. Rec. 34, 253257.
Ramsey, E.M. (1994). George Washington Corner. Nat. Acad. Sci. Biograph. Mem. 65, 5693.
Redline, R.W. (2003). Nonidentical twins with a single placenta–disproving dogma in perinatal pathology. New Engl. J. Med. 349, 111–4.
Roberts, R.M. & Fisher, S.J. (2011). Trophoblast stem cells. Biol. Reprod. 84, 412–21.
Roode, M., Blair, K., Snell, P., Elder, K., Marchant, S., Smith, A. & Nichols, J. (2012). Human hypoblast formation is not dependent on FGF signalling. Dev. Biol. 361, 358–63
Salerno, L.J. (1959). Monoamniotic twinning. A survey of the American literature since 1935 with a report of four new cases. Obstet. Gynecol. 14, 205–13.
Schultze, O. (1897). Grundriss der Entwicklungsgeschichte des Menschen und der Säugethiere, für Studirende und Ärzte. Bearb. unter Zugrundelegung der 2. Aufl. des Grundrisses der Entwicklungsgeschichte von A. Koelliker. Leipzig: W. Engelmann, p. 176
Schwalbe, E. (1906). Die Morphologie der Missbildungen der Menschen und der Tiere. I. Teil. Allgemeine Missbildungslehre. Jena; Gustav Fischer.
Shibuya, Y. & Kyono, K. (2012). A successful birth of healthy monozygotic dichorionic diamniotic (DD) twins of the same gender following a single vitrified-warmed blastocyst transfer. J. Assist. Reprod. Genet. 29, 255–7.
Siemens, H.W. (1925). Die Diagnose der Eineiigkeit in geburtshilflicher und in dermatologischer Betrachtung. Arch. Gynäkol. 126, 625–45.
Sills, E.S, Tucker, M.J. & Palermo, G.D. (2000). Assisted reproductive technologies and monozygous twins: implications for future study and clinical practice. Twin Res. 3, 217–23.
Silver, L.M. (1987). Remaking Eden. Cloning and Beyond in a Brave New World. New York: Avon Books, p. 38;
Sobotta, J. (1901). Neuere Anschauungen über der Doppel(miss)bildungen mit besonderer Berücksichtigung der menschlichen Zwillingsgeburten. Würzb Abhand Gesamtgeb prakt Med. 4, 85105.
Spencer, R. (2000). Theoretical and analytical embryology of conjoined twins: Part I: Embryogenesis. Clin. Anat. 13, 3653.
Steinman, G. & Valderrama, E. (2001). Mechanisms of twinning. III. Placentation, calcium reduction and modified compaction. J. Reprod. Med. 46, 9951002.
Stern, K. (1960). Principles of Human Genetics. 2nd edn. San Francisco: WH Freeman, pp. 538–9.
Streeter, G.L. (1924). Carnegie Institution of Washington. Year Book No. 22. November 1, 1922, to October 31, 1923. Washington, Carnegie Institution of Washington; p. 85.
Strong, S.J. & Corney, G. (1967). The Placenta in Twin Pregnancy. Oxford:Pergamon Press, p. 17.
Tam, P.P.L. & Gad, J.M. (2004). Gastrulation in the mouse embryo. In Gastrulation. From Cells to Embryo (ed. Stern, C.D.), pp. 239–43. New York: SCHL Press.
Tarkowski, A.K. & Wojewodzka, M. (1982). A method for obtaining chimaeric mouse blastocysts with two separate inner cell masses: a preliminary report. J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 71, 215–21.
Van Langendonckt, A., Wyns, C., Godin, P.A., Toussaint-Demylle, D. & Donnez, J. (2000). Atypical hatching of a human blastocyst leading to monozygotic twinning: a case report. Fertil. Steril. 74, 1047–50.
Verpoest, W., Van Landuyt, L., Desmyttere, S., Cremers, A., Devroey, P. & Liebaers, I. (2009). The incidence of monozygotic twinning following PGD is not increased. Hum. Reprod. 24, 2945–50.
Verschuer, O. (1932). Die biologischen Grundlagen der menschlichen Mehrlingsforschung. Z. Indukt. Abstamm. Vererb. 61, 147207.
Wilder, H.H. (1904) Duplicate twins and double monsters. Am. J. Anat. 3, 387472, p. 391.

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed