Skip to main content Accessibility help

Nitrogen Competition between Corn and Weeds in Soils under Organic and Conventional Management

  • Hanna J. Poffenbarger (a1), Steven B. Mirsky (a2), John R. Teasdale (a2), John T. Spargo (a3), Michel A. Cavigelli (a2) and Matthew Kramer (a4)...


Crop yields can be similar in organic and conventional systems even when weed biomass is greater in organic systems. Greater weed tolerance in organic systems may be due to differences in management-driven soil fertility properties. The goal of this experiment was to determine whether soil collected from a long-term organic cropping system with a diverse crop rotation and organic fertility inputs would support higher soil nitrogen (N) resource partitioning, as indicated by overyielding of corn–weed mixtures, than a cropping system with a less diverse crop rotation and inorganic N inputs. A replacement series greenhouse experiment was conducted using corn : smooth pigweed and corn : giant foxtail proportions of 0 : 1, 0.25 : 0.75, 0.5 : 0.5, 0.75 : 0.25, and 1 : 0 and harvested at 29, 40, or 48 d after experiment initiation (DAI). The monoculture density of corn was 4 plants pot−1 and the monoculture density of each weed species was 36 plants pot−1. Corn was consistently more competitive than both weed species at 40 and 48 DAI when soil inorganic N was limiting to growth. Corn–smooth pigweed mixtures had greater shoot biomass and shoot N content than expected based on the shoot biomass and shoot N content of monocultures (i.e., overyielding) at the onset of soil inorganic N limitation, providing some evidence for N resource partitioning. However, soil management effects on overyielding were infrequent and inconsistent among harvest dates and corn–weed mixtures, leading us to conclude that management-driven soil fertility properties did not affect corn–weed N resource partitioning during the early stages of corn growth.


Corresponding author

Corresponding author's E-mail:


Hide All
Alkamper, J, Pessips, E, Van Long, D (1979) Einfluss der dungung auf die entwicklung und nahr-stoffaufnahme verschiedener unkrauter in mais. Pages 181192 in Proceedings of the 3rd European Weed Research Society Symposium. Mainz, Germany European Weed Research Society
Anderson, RL (1991) Timing of nitrogen application affects downy brome (Bromus tectorum) growth in winter wheat. Weed Technol. 5:582585
Ashton, IW, Miller, AE, Bowman, WD, Suding, KN (2010) Niche complementarity due to plasticity in resource use: plant partitioning of chemical N forms. Ecology. 91:32523260
Blackshaw, RE (2005) Nitrogen fertilizer, manure, and compost effects on weed growth and competition with spring wheat. Agron J. 97:16121621
Blackshaw, RE, Brandt, RN (2008) Nitrogen fertilizer rate effects on weed competitiveness is species dependent. Weed Sci. 56:743747
Blackshaw, RE, Brandt, RN, Janzen, HH, Entz, T, Grant, CA, Derksen, DA (2003) Differential response of weed species to added nitrogen. Weed Sci. 51:532539
Blackshaw, RE, Semach, G, Janzen, HH (2002) Fertilizer application method affects nitrogen uptake in weeds and wheat. Weed Sci. 50:634641
Bol, R, Ostle, NJ, Petzke, KJ (2002) Compound specific plant amino acid δ15N values differ with functional plant strategies in temperate grassland. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci. 165:661667
Buhler, DD (2002) Challenges and opportunities for integrated weed management. Weed Sci. 50:273280
Cavigelli, MA, Teasdale, JR, Conklin, AE (2008) Long-term agronomic performance of organic and conventional field crops in the mid-Atlantic region. Agron J. 100:785794
Connolly, J, Wayne, P, Bazzaz, FA (2001) Interspecific competition in plants: how well do current methods answer fundamental questions? Am Nat. 157:107125
Connolly, J, Wayne, P, Murray, R (1990) Time course of plant–plant interactions in experimental mixtures of annuals: density, frequency, and nutrient effects. Oecologia. 82:513526
Curran, WS, Lingenfelter, DD, Tooker, JF, Dillon, JM, Bohnenblust, EW (2013) Pest Management, Penn State Agronomy Guide. State College, PA Penn State Cooperative Extension
Davis, AS, Hall, J, Jasieniuk, M, Locke, MA, Luschei, E, Mortensen, DA, Riechers, DE, Smith, RG, Sterling, TM, Westwood, JH (2009) Weed science research and funding: a call to action. Weed Sci. 57:442448
Davis, AS, Liebman, M (2001) Nitrogen source influences wild mustard growth and competitive effect on sweet corn. Weed Sci. 49:558566
Davis, AS, Renner, KA, Gross, KL (2005) Weed seedbank and community shifts in a long-term cropping systems experiment. Weed Sci. 53:296306
Delate, K, Cambardella, CA (2004) Agroecosystem performance during transition to certified organic grain production. Agron J. 96:12881298
de Wit, CT (1960) On competition. Versl lanbouwk onderz. 66:182
Dyck, E, Liebman, M (1994) Soil fertility management as a factor in weed control: the effect of crimson clover residue, synthetic nitrogen fertilizer, and their interaction on emergence and early growth of lambsquarters and sweet corn. Plant Soil. 167:227237
Dyck, E, Liebman, M, Erich, M (1995) Crop–weed interference as influenced by a leguminous or synthetic fertilizer nitrogen source: I. Doublecropping experiments with crimson clover, sweet corn, and lambsquarters. Agr Ecosyst Environ. 56:93108
Ellern, SJ, Harper, JL, Sagar, GR (1970) A comparative study of the distribution of the roots of Avena fatua and A. strigosa in mixed stands using a C-labelling technique. J Ecol. 58:865868
Fowler, N (1982) Competition and coexistence in a North Carolina grassland. III. Mixtures of component species. J Ecol. 70:7792
Goodman, LA (1962) The variance of the product of K random variables. J Am Stat Assoc. 57:5460
Hall, RL (1974) Analysis of the nature of interference between plants of different species. I. Concepts and extension of the de Wit analysis to examine effects. Aust J Agric Res. 25:639747
Harbur, MM, Owen, MDK (2004) Response of three annual weeds to corn population density and nitrogen fertilization timing. Weed Sci. 52:845853
Harper, JL (1977) Population Biology of Plants. London Academic
Harrison, KA, Bol, R, Bardgett, RD (2007) Preferences for different nitrogen forms by coexisting plant species and soil microbes. Ecology. 88:989999
Hauggaard-Nielsen, H, Gooding, M, Ambus, P, Corre-Hellou, G, Crozat, Y, Dahlmann, C, Dibet, A, von Fragstein, P, Pristeri, A, Monti, M, Jensen, ES (2009) Pea–barley intercropping for efficient symbiotic N2-fixation, soil N acquisition and use of other nutrients in European organic cropping systems. Field Crop Res. 113:6471
Horneck, DA, Miller, RO (1998) Determination of total nitrogen in plant tissue. Pages 7584 in Kalra, YP, ed. Handbook and Reference Methods for Plant Analysis. New York CRC
Jensen, ES (1996) Grain yield, symbiotic N2 fixation and interspecific competition for inorganic N in pea–barley intercrops. Plant Soil. 182:2538
Johnson, R, Kuby, P (2008) Just the Essentials of Elementary Statistics. 10th edn. Mason Cengage Learning. 944 p
Jumpponen, A, Högberg, C, Huss-Danell, P, Mulder, CPH (2002) Interspecific and spatial differences in nitrogen uptake in monocultures and two-species mixtures in north European grasslands. Funct Ecol. 16:454461
Klute, A (1986) Water retention: laboratory methods. Pages 636662 in Klute, A, ed. Methods of Soil Analysis. Part 1. Physical and Mineralogical Methods. 2nd edn. Madison, WI American Society of Agronomy
Mallory, EB, Griffin, TS (2007) Impacts of soil amendment history on nitrogen availability from manure and fertilizer. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 71:964973
Marose, BH, Dively, G, Hellman, J, Grybauskus, A (1991) Maryland Integrated Pest Management Scouting Guidelines. College Park, MD University of Maryland Cooperative Extension
McKane, RB, Grigal, DF (1990) Spatiotemporal differences in 15N uptake and the organization of an old-field plant community. Ecology. 71:11261132
Melander, B, Cirujeda, A, Jorgensen, MH (2003) Effects of inter-row hoeing and fertilizer placement on weed growth and yield of winter wheat. Weed Res. 43:428438
Menalled, FD, Gross, KL, Hammond, M (2001) Weed aboveground and seedbank community responses to agricultural management systems. Ecol Appl. 11:15861601
Mortensen, DA, Bastiaans, L, Sattin, M (2000) The role of ecology in the development of weed management systems: an outlook. Weed Res. 40:4962
Mulvaney, RL (1996) Nitrogen—inorganic forms. Pages 11291131, 1151–1159 in Sparks, DL, ed. Methods of Soil Analysis Part 3. Madison, WI Soil Science Society of America
Parrish, JAD, Bazzaz, FA (1976) Underground niche separation in successional plants. Ecology. 57:12811288
Pella, E (1990) Elemental organic analysis part 1. Am Lab. 22:116125
R Development Core Team (2013) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria R Foundation for Statistical Computing
Ryan, MR, Mortensen, DA, Bastiaans, L, Teasdale, JR, Mirsky, SB, Curran, WS, Seidel, R, Hepperly, PR, Wilson, DO (2010) Elucidating the apparent maize tolerance to weed competition in long-term organically managed systems. Weed Res. 50:2536
Ryan, MR, Mortensen, DA, Wilson, DO, Hepperly, PR (2008) Organic weed management: what farmers think. Pages 17 in Proceedings of Northeastern Weed Science Society. Philadelphia, PA Northeast Weed Science Society
Ryan, MR, Smith, RG, Mortensen, DA, Teasdale, JR, Curran, WS, Seidel, R, Shumway, DL (2009) Weed–crop competition relationships differ between organic and conventional cropping systems. Weed Res. 49:572580
Sackville Hamilton, NR (1994) Replacement and additive designs for plant competition studies. J Appl Ecol. 31:599603
Salas, ML, Hickman, MV, Huber, DM, Schreiber, MM (1997) Influence of nitrate and ammonium nutrition on the growth of giant foxtail (Setaria faberi). Weed Sci. 45:664669
SAS Institute (2008) SAS/STAT® 9.2 User's Guide. Cary, NC SAS Institute
Siebert, AC, Pearce, RB (1993) Growth analysis of weed and crop species with reference to seed weight. Weed Sci. 41:5256
Smith, RG, Mortensen, DA, Ryan, MR (2010) A new hypothesis for the functional role of diversity in mediating resource pools and weed-crop competition in agroecosystems. Weed Res. 50:3748
Spargo, JT, Cavigelli, MA, Mirsky, SB, Maul, JE, Meisinger, JJ (2011) Mineralizable soil nitrogen and labile soil organic matter in diverse long-term cropping systems. Nutr Cycl Agroecosyst. 90:253266
Taylor, DR, Aarssen, LW (1989) On the density dependence of replacement-series competition experiments. J Ecol. 77:975988
Teasdale, JR, Coffman, CB, Mangum, RW (2007) Potential long-term benefits of no-tillage and organic cropping systems for grain production and soil improvement. Agron J. 99:12971305
Teasdale, JR, Mangum, RW, Radhakrishnan, J, Cavigelli, MA (2004) Weed seedbank dynamics in three organic farming crop rotations. Agron J. 96:1429–1235
Teyker, RH (1992) Seedling response to band applied NH4OH rates and to N form in two maize hybrids. Plant Soil. 144:289295
Teyker, RH, Hoelzer, HD, Liebl, RA (1991) Maize and pigweed response to N supply and form. Plant Soil. 135:287292
University of Maryland Cooperative Extension (2009) Agronomic Crop Nutrient Recommendations Based on Soil Tests and Yield Goals. College Park, MD Maryland Cooperative Extension
[USDA-NASS] U.S. Department of Agriculture–National Agricultural Statistics Service (2010) Agricultural Chemical Use Program: 2010 Corn, Upland Cotton, and Fall Potatoes Data Tables. Washington, DC USDA-NASS
Wander, MM, Traina, SJ, Stinner, BR, Peters, SE (1994) Organic and conventional management effects on biologically active soil organic matter pools. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 58:11301139
Wang, WJ, Smith, CJ, Chen, D (2004) Predicting soil nitrogen mineralization dynamics with a modified double exponential model. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 68:12561265
Williams, AC, McCarthy, BC (2001) A new index of interspecific competition for replacement and additive designs. Ecol Res. 16:2940
Wilson, JB (1988) Shoot competition and root competition. J Appl Ecol. 25:279296
Wilson, RS, Hooker, N, Tucker, M, LeJeune, J, Doohan, D (2009) Targeting the farmer decision making process: a pathway to increased adoption of integrated weed management. Crop Prot. 28:756764
Wortman, SE, Davis, AS, Schutte, BJ, Lindquist, JL (2011) Integrating management of soil nitrogen and weeds. Weed Sci. 59:162170
Zimdahl, RL (2004) Definition of plant competition. Pages 68 in Zimdahl, RL, ed. Weed–Crop Competition: A Review, Second Edition. Ames, IA Blackwell Publishing Professional


Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Nitrogen Competition between Corn and Weeds in Soils under Organic and Conventional Management

  • Hanna J. Poffenbarger (a1), Steven B. Mirsky (a2), John R. Teasdale (a2), John T. Spargo (a3), Michel A. Cavigelli (a2) and Matthew Kramer (a4)...


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.