Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-18T07:38:18.074Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Revival of Spiritual Healing in the Church of England 1920–26

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Stuart Mews
Stuart Mews*
Affiliation:
University of Lancaster
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

‘How are your healing groups going?’ the present archbishop of Canterbury, Robert Runcie, enquired rhetorically in a charge to service chaplains in 1979. ‘The renewal of the Church’s ministry of healing’ the bishop of Selby has even more recently written, ‘is one hard obstinate fact that future historians will be unable to ignore when examining the Christian scene in the present century.’ The bishop, who is co-chairman of the Churches’ Council for Health and Healing, particularly singled out for praise the pioneers of this renewal: ‘individuals like James Moore Hickson, George Bennett and Dorothy Kerin’ as well as such later contributors as Leslie Weatherhead from the free churches, and more recently Cameron Peddie in Scotland and the American Dominican, Francis MacNutt. The bishop has further argued that ‘these powerful initiatives given to the healing movement by individual leaders were matched by the leadership of the Churches’, an assertion which is backed by citing the discussions devoted to the subject at the Lambeth conferences of 1908, 1920, 1930 and 1958. The first two of these conferences were presided over by archbishop Randall Davidson, who in the bishop of Selby’s book is presented as a crypto-champion of spiritual healing.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 19: The Church and Healing , 1982 , pp. 299 - 332
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1982

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 ‘The Archibishop of Canterbury’s Charge to his Service Chaplains’, The Journal of the Royal Army Chaplains’ Department 25 (July 1980) p 14.

2 Maddocks, Morris, ‘The Renewal of the Healing Ministry in the Churches’, Burrswood Herald Quarterly XI (1981) p 10.Google Scholar

3 Maddocks, , The Christian Healing Ministry (London 1981) pp 103, l00f.Google Scholar

4 Gunstone, John, A People For His Praise: Renewal and Congregational Life (London 1978) p 125.Google Scholar See also The Charismatic Movement in the Church of England which states (p 33): ‘Healing has a long and respectable history in the Christian Church, and (p 34): ‘healing has some actual background in Anglican practice’.

5 Robertson, Roland, ‘The Salvation Army: the Persistence of Sectarianism’, Wilson, Bryan R. ed, Patterns of Sectarianism (London 1967) pp 68f.Google Scholar

6 Henson, H. Hensley, ‘Spiritual Healing’, Hib[bert] J[ournal] XXIII (April 1925), p 385 Google Scholar; Henson, [H. Hensley], Notes [on Spiritual Healing] (London 1925) p xii.Google Scholar

7 Y[orkshire] O[bserver] 14 October 1924.

8 YO 18 October 1924.

9 It is a pleasure to acknowledge here my gratitude to my neighbour, Canon Robert Tindall, curate of Heaton, Bradford 1921-25. Canon Tindall also pointed out to me the important role of Canon E.T.G. Hunter, rector of Kcighlcy 1919-26, who was an enthusiast for spiritual healing, and who is cited frequently in the local press as an authenticator of specific instances of recovery in the Frizinghall mission.

10 YO 18 October 1924.

11 M[orning] P[ost] 6, 8 November 1924.

12 YO 23 October 1924.

13 Ibid 22 October 1924. For a valuable discussion of vegetarianism which indicates the religious dimension: Twigg, Julia, ‘Food for Thought’, Religion 9 (1979) pp 20f.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

14 YO 22 October 1924.

15 Ibid 18 October 1924.

16 B[ritish] W[eekly] 22 October 1924.

17 Henson, Notes pp xvii, xvi.

18 Manchester Guardian 17 October 1924.

19 Hickson, J.M., Heal the Sick (London 1924).Google Scholar

20 [Durham Chapter Library Ms] Diary of H.H. Henson [16 November 1924.] I am grateful to Professor W.O. Chadwick for assistance in consulting volumes in his care. Henson, Notes xiii.

21 Chatterton, Eyre, India Through a Bishop’s Diary (London 1935) p 190f.Google Scholar

22 Ingram, A.F. Winnington, A Charge Delivered to the Clergy and Churchwardens of London (London 1905) p 33.Google Scholar

23 Quoted in the Expository Times XXIII (November 1911) p 51.

24 Church Family Newspaper 22 May 1911.

25 Inge, W.R., The Church and the Age (London 1912) pp 18f.Google Scholar

26 Ingram, A.F. Winnington, The Gospel in Action (London 1906) p 99.Google Scholar

27 Mews, Stuart, ‘Religion and Conscription 1906-1916’, The Church in a Changing Society: Conflict-Reconciliation or Adjustment? (Stockholm 1978) p 248.Google Scholar

28 [Lambeth Palace Library:] Davidson Ms: Memorandum of interview with Major F. Maurice 21 October 1910.

29 Ramsey, A.M., From Gore to Temple (London 1960) p vii.Google Scholar

30 Illingworth, J.R., ‘The Incarnation and Development’, Lux Mundi (Oxford 1889) p 207 Google Scholar, ‘The Problem of Pain’, Lux Mundi pp 84, 85, 90.

31 Waggett, Philip N., Religion and Science (London 1906) pp 77fGoogle Scholar. On Waggctt, see Nias, John, Flame from an Oxford Cloister. The Life and Writings of Philip Napier Waggett SSIE (London 1961).Google Scholar

32 Anson, Harold, Looking Forward (London 1938) p 173.Google Scholar

33 Ibid.

34 The Healer 5 (1912) p 54; Maillard, John, Healing in the Name of Jesus (London 1936), p 19.Google Scholar

35 Guardian 18 November 1908.

36 Davidson Ms: Memoranda of interviews with J.M. Hickson 2 July, 24 September, 28 November 1909; R.T. Davidson —J.M. Hickson 6 March, 27 September 1909. J.M. Hickson — R.T. Davidson 3, 4, 8 March, 3, 6 July. 5, 10, 27 September, 24 November 1909.

37 Samuel McComb, ‘The Christian Religion as a Healing Power’, Hib J (October 1909) pp 10-27, Harrington Sainsbury, ‘Christianity, Science and “Christian Science” ’, C[hurch] Q[uarterly] R[eview] (April 1910) pp 63-68, B[ritish] M[edical] J[ournal] 18June 1910.

38 Thompson, J.M., Miracles in the New Testament (London 1911) p 218.Google Scholar

39 Oxford Bodleian Ms: F.C. Burkitt —J.M. Thompson 21 May 1911.

40 Oxford Bodleian Ms: J.H. Skrine —J.M. Thompson 30 May 1911. For a fuller account of Thompson’s views and contemporary reactions to them, see Mews, Stuart, ‘Liberalism and Liberality in the Church of England 1911-22’, (Cambridge University Hulsean Prize essay 1968).Google Scholar

41 Gascoyne-Cecil, Lord William, ‘Centralization and Decentralization’, Church Assembly News April and May 1924, quoted in Thompson, Kenneth A., Bureaucracy and Church Reform (Oxford 1970) p 196.Google Scholar

42 Ibid p 197.

43 Annual Report of the Central Board of Finance (London 1925) p 27, quoted in Thompson p 194.

44 Iremonger, K.A., William Temple, Archbishop of Canterbury (London 1948) p 256 Google Scholar; Roxby, C.L.M. — Temple, W., ‘Tuesday before Easter 1925’, quoted in Norman, E.R., Church and Society in England 1770-1970 (Oxford 1976) p 309 Google Scholar. On these developments see Mews, Stuart, ‘The Churches’, The General Strike (Harmondsworth 1976) ed Morris, Margaret pp 318–337.Google Scholar

45 Diary of H.H. Henson 23 August 1923.

46 Ibid 11 June 1924. S. McComb, ‘The New Reformation’, Contemporary Review (1924). On McComb, see Gottschalk, Stephen, The Emergence of Christian Science in American Religious Life (Berkeley 1973) p 214.Google Scholar

47 Inge, W.R., Lay Thoughts of a Dean (London 1926) p 304.Google Scholar

48 Sharpe, Eric J., ‘Sadhu Sundar Singh and his critics: An episode in the meeting of East and West’, Religion 6/1 (1976) pp 48–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

49 Nelson, Geoffrey K., Spiritualism and Society (London 1969) pp 153f.Google Scholar

50 Henson, Notes p xviii.

51 Studdert-Kennedy, G. A., The Unutterable Beauty (London 1927) p 107.Google Scholar

52 L.W. Grensted, ‘The New Psychology and its significance’, CQR (January 1923) p 286.

53 Leed, Eric J., No Man’s Land: Combat and Identity in World War I (Cambridge 1979) pp 163f.Google Scholar

54 Pym, Dora, Tom Pym A Portrait (Cambridge 1952) p 69.Google Scholar

55 Weatherhead, Leslie D., ‘Present-day non-medical methods of healing’, Religion and Medicine, ed. Crowlesmith, John (London 1962), pp 63fGoogle Scholar; Weatherhead, Kingsley, Leslie Weatherhead. A Personal Portrait (London 1975).Google Scholar

56 Hadfield, J.A., ‘The Psychology of Power’, The Spirit ed Streeter, B.H. (London 1922) p 114.Google Scholar

57 Hadfield, J.A., Psychology and Morals (London 1932).Google Scholar

58 Anson, p 212.

59 YO 20 October 1924.

60 CQR (October 1924) p 38.

61 Diary of Henson 22 May 1924.

62 Ibid 16 November 1924.

63 Anson pp 200, 179.

64 Divine Healer January 1915 p 3.

65 Davidson Ms: H.M. Burge — R.T. Davidson lO Novewmber 1921.

66 Burge, H.M. — Cook, A. Kemball 26 March 1922, Discourses and Letters of Hubert Murray Burge. With a memoir by Charnwood, Lord (London 1930) p 291.Google Scholar

67 Davidson Ms: R.T. Davidson — H.M. Burge 21 November 1921.

68 Diary of H.H. Henson 19 November 1924.

69 Davidson Ms: J.A. Robinson — R.T. Davidson 28 September 1921.

70 Ibid: B.H. Streeter — R.T. Davidson 1 October 1921.

71 Ibid: H. Anson — H.M. Burge 24 March 1922.

72 Ibid: H. Anson — H.M. Burge27 March 1922.

73 Ibid: E. Jones — H.M. Burge 12July 1922.

74 Ibid: H. Anson — H.M. Burge 23 December 1922.

75 Ibid: H. Anson — H.M. Burge 29June 1922.

76 Ibid: H.M. Burge — R.T. Davidson 12 April 1923.

77 Ibid: R.T. Davidson — H.M. Burge 10 August 1922; Lambeth Palace Library: Bishops’ Meeting minutes 22 May 1924 p 33.

78 Davidson Ms: H. Anson — H.M. Burge 16 August 1923.

79 Ibid: H.M. Burge — H. Anson 2 August 1923.

80 Ibid: Jane Walker — H.M. Burge 9 August 1923.

81 Ibid: R.T. Davidson — H.M. Burge 12 November 1922.

82 Ibid: H.M. Burge — R.T. Davidson 18 November 1922.

83 The Ministry of Healing (London 1924).

84 MP 9 January 1924, Challenge 18 January 1924, Observer 20 January 1924, BW 17 January 1924, BMJ 19 January 1924, Nature 19 January 1924, English Churchman 17 January 1924, Church Family Newspaper 15 February 1924.

85 BMJ 19 January 1924.

86 Davidson Ms: H. Anson — R.T. Davidson 5 February 1924.

87 CT 9 May 1924, BMJ 12 May 1924.

88 Diary of Henson 22 May 1924.

89 Bishops’ Meeting minutes 22 May 1924.

90 Ibid 24 October 1924.

91 Diary of Henson 29 January 1925.

92 Ibid 8 February 1925, Durham County Advertiser 13 March 1925, Diary of Henson 9 March 1925, H.H. Henson ‘Spiritual Healing’, Hib J April 1925 pp 385-401, Harold Anson, ‘Spiritual Healing — What is it? A reply to the Bishop of Durham’ Hib J October 1925 pp 101-111, H.H. Henson, Notes. A year later Henson recorded that the book had only earned him £11.6s.5d.: ‘It is sufficiently evident that that book also has been an almost total failure’ (Diary of Henson 29 May 1926). The report of Burge’s committee sold a first edition of 2,000, a second edition of 3,000, and went into a third edition: Davidson Ms: W.K. Lowther Clark — H.M. Burge 13 February 1924.

93 Diary of H.H. Henson 11 November 1925.

94 Ibid 13 November 1925, Iremonger pp 612f.

95 J.M. Hickson, ‘The Value of Missions’, The Healer June 1925 p 247f. For a specific critique of Hickson’s missions, see Weatherhead, Leslie D., Psychology in Service of the Soul (London 1929) pp 18f.Google Scholar

96 Fifty Years at Crowhurst. The Wardens of Crowhurst (1978, no place of publication) pp 1f. I wish to thank the acting warden, Ralph Essex, and staff, for permitting me to use the library at Crowhurst.

97 Dimont, C.T. and Batty, F. de Witt, St Clair Donaldson (London 1939) pp 209f.Google Scholar

98 Davidson Ms: CG. Lang — H.M. Burge 26 July 1924; R.T. Davidson — H.M. Burge 5 August 1924.

99 The Archbishop of Canterbury’s Advisory Committee on Spiritual Healing: Interim Report on Missions and Cases of Healing Investigated. (Privately published 1928) p 2.

100 Diary of H.H. Henson 19 November 1925, [York Minster Library] Garbett Ms, C.F. Garbett — R.T. Davidson 15July 1925.1 am grateful to Dr Gerald Ellison for permission to consult these papers.

101 Inge, W.R., Diary of a Dean (London 1949) p 111 Google Scholar, Garbett Ms, W.R. Inge — CF. Garbett 11 March 1925.

102 arbett Ms, H. Anson — C.F. Garbett 1 June 1925, 14 July 1928.

103 Garbett Ms, A. W. Perowne — C. F. Garbett 7 July 1925.

104 Grensted, L.W., Psychology and God (London 1930) pp 106f.Google Scholar

105 Ibid pp 123f. A similar approach was taken by the Melbourne conference of the World Council of Churches on World mission and evangelism. See the report: Your Kingdom Come (Geneva 1980) p 200. I owe this reference to Miss Monica Humble.