No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Peter Canisius and the Development of Catholic Education in Germany, 1549–97
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 03 June 2019
Abstract
The Jesuit Peter Canisius (1521–97) became widely respected as a catechist, pedagogue and preacher who worked tirelessly on behalf of the Catholic faith. Canisius's set of three catechisms – the Large, Small and Smaller – were the most popular and widely available Catholic catechisms in sixteenth-century Germany: by his death, at least 357 editions had appeared, in a number of languages. Employed in Catholic schools, churches and homes across the Holy Roman Empire, his catechisms have been interpreted as a direct response to the Protestant attack on Catholicism in Germany. However, the boundaries between Catholicism and heresy were not always clear to the laity. Drawing on examples from his catechisms and his approach to the Index of Prohibited Books, this article suggests that Canisius sought to promote a policy of inclusion among his fellow Catholics in a time of conflict and uncertainty. In recognizing the distinct nature of German Catholicism, Canisius advocated a tailored educational approach to contentious doctrines and practices. Directed towards the German laity, this approach taught the lesson of compromise and acceptance among those who identified as Catholic. The article adds to existing scholarship on Jesuit education, Canisius's contribution to the development of a German religious identity, Jesuit casuistry and the dissemination of religious knowledge in German society.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2019
Footnotes
I would like to thank Charlotte Methuen for her help and guidance, as well as the anonymous reviewers for their insightful feedback. I have included the original text for my own translations; in cases where the translation is taken from a secondary source, original and translated sources are both referenced.
References
1 ‘Errant ut plaerique Germani, natura simplices, rudes, faciles ad ea imbibenda, quae in haeresi Luterana nati et educati, partim in scholis, partim in templis, partim in scriptis haereticis didicerunt’: Beati Petri Canisii, Societatis Iesu, Epistulae et acta, ed. Otto Braunsberger, 8 vols (Freiburg im Breisgau, 1896–1923), 8: 131.
2 Strauss, Gerald, Luther's House of Learning: Indoctrination of the Young in the German Reformation (Baltimore, MD, 1978), 34–5Google Scholar.
3 Erasmus: The Education of a Christian Prince, with the Panegyric for Archduke Philip of Austria, ed. Lisa Jardine (Cambridge, 1997), 5.
4 Kusukawa, Sachiko, ‘Melanchthon’, in Bagchi, David and Steinmetz, David C., eds, The Cambridge Companion to Reformation Theology (Cambridge, 2004), 57–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 57.
5 Janssen, Johannes, Geschichte des deutschen Volkes seit dem Ausgang des Mittelalters, 8 vols (Freiburg im Breisgau, 1885)Google Scholar, 8: 382–3; Lippert, Peter, ‘Petrus Canisius, der Heilige (Zu seiner Heiligsprechung 21. Mai 1925)’, Stimmen der Zeit 109 (1925), 161–72Google Scholar; Max Pribilla, ‘Canisius und die Protestanten’, ibid. 396–400.
6 Oswald, Julius, ‘Ringen um die Einheit der Kirche, Petrus Canisius und Philipp Melanchthon’, in idem and Haub, Rita, eds, Jesuitica. Forschungen zur frühen Geschichte des Jesuitenordens in Bayern bis zur Aufhebung 1773 (Munich, 2001), 20–40Google Scholar, at 37.
7 Haub, Rita, Petrus Canisius. Botschafter Europas (Limburg an der Lahn, 2004), 49, 65Google Scholar.
8 Pabel, Hilmar, ‘Peter Canisius and the Protestants: A Model of Ecumenical Dialogue?’, Journal of Jesuit Studies 1 (2014), 373–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 373, 376. Hallensleben asks whether we should view Canisius as an early ecumenist: Hallensleben, Barbara, ‘Kirche in der Sendung. Die Antwort des Petrus Canisius auf die Erfahrung des “draußen”’, in Berndt, Rainer, ed., Petrus Canisius SJ (1521–1597). Humanist und Europäer (Berlin, 2000), 347–63Google Scholar, at 363.
9 Pabel, ‘Canisius’, 373.
10 Höpfl, Harro, Jesuit Political Thought: The Society of Jesus and the State, c.1540–1640 (Cambridge, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
11 Evans, R. J. W., The Making of the Habsburg Monarch 1550–1700: An Interpretation (Oxford, 1979), 59–61Google Scholar; Fulton, Elaine, ‘Wolves and Weathervanes: Confessional Moderation at the Habsburg Court of Vienna’, in Racaut, Luc and Ryrie, Alec, eds, Moderate Voices in the European Reformation (Aldershot, 2005), 145–61Google Scholar.
12 Louthan, Howard, The Quest for Compromise: Peacemakers in Counter-Reformation Vienna (Cambridge, 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13 O'Malley, John W., The First Jesuits (Harvard, MA, 1995)Google Scholar.
14 ‘Urgent et infestare pergunt Principes … Augustanae confessionis aut potius confusionis’: Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 1: 595.
15 Brodrick, James, Saint Peter Canisius (Chicago, IL, 1980), 354Google Scholar.
16 Ibid. 424.
17 Pabel, ‘Canisius’, 389.
18 ‘Qui onnes si in mortario contunderentur, non exprimeretur, inquit, vna uncia verae Theologiae’: Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 7: 73.
19 Pabel, ‘Canisius’, 374.
20 Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 8: 139.
21 ‘Italiens und Spaniens müssen wir vergessen und uns Deutschland allein hingeben, nicht auf einige Zeit, sondern für das ganze Leben. Hier müssen wir aus allen Kräften und mit dem größten Eifer arbeiten’: Braunsberger, Otto, Entstehung und erste Entwicklung der Katechismen des seligen Petrus Canisius aus der Gesellschaft Jesu (Freiburg im Breisgau, 1893), 126Google Scholar.
22 ‘Oltre di questo, communemente il zelo de la religione non bisogna cerear hora nelli Tedeschi’: Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 1: 308.
23 Ibid. 7: 358.
24 ‘Sunt optima portio Christianismi – Der edelste uorrat der Kirchen’: ibid. 7: 630.
25 For the development of his catechisms, see Braunsberger, Entstehung und erste Entwicklung. For their popularity, see Begheyn, Paul, ‘The Catechism (1555) of Peter Canisius, the most published Book by a Dutch Author in History’, Quaerendo 36 (2006), 51–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
26 Canisius, Peter, Summa doctrinae christianae (Vienna, 1555)Google Scholar; idem, Frag und Antwort Christlicher Leer (Vienna, 1556).
27 Canisius, Peter, Catechismus Minimus (Ingolstadt, 1556)Google Scholar; a German translation of this catechism appeared as idem, Der Klein Catechismus sampt kurtzen Gebeten für die ainfältigen (Ingolstadt, 1556); idem, Parvus catechismus (Dillingen, 1558).
28 ‘Und man benützt sie in den Schulen fur die erste Unterweisung der Kinder und auch in den Kirchen, damit die Anfangsgründe der katholischen Frömmigkeit von da aus besser den Gläubigen nahegebracht warden können’: Das Testament des Petrus Canisius. Vermächtnis und Auftrag, ed. Julius Oswald and Rita Haub (Frankfurt am Main, 1997), 86–7.
29 ‘Der lieben Jug-end zum Nu-ßen ha-be ich die-sen Ka-te-chis-mum von Sil-ben zu Sil-ben ab-getheilt ver-fer-ti-get, da-mit sie mit leich-ter Mü-he de-sto ge-schwin der le-sen ler-nen, wel-chet ih-nen als dann zum Schrei-ben be-stens die-nen wird’: Peter Canisius, Kleiner Catechismus (Freyburg im Uchtland, 1596), 3.
30 Roest, Bert, ‘Rhetoric of Innovation and Recourse to Tradition in Humanist Pedagogical Discourse’, in Gersh, Stephen and Roest, Bert, eds, Medieval and Renaissance Humanism: Rhetoric, Representation and Reform (Leiden, 2003), 115–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 147.
31 Whaley, Joachim, Germany and the Holy Roman Empire, 1: Maximilian I to the Peace of Westphalia, 1493–1648 (Oxford, 2013), 38–9Google Scholar, 339–42.
32 Höpfl, Jesuit Political Thought, 54.
33 Jürgen Helm, ‘Religion and Medicine: An Anatomical Education at Wittenberg and Ingolstadt’, in idem and Winkelmann, Annette, eds, Religious Confessions and the Sciences in the Sixteenth Century (Leiden, 2001), 51–70Google Scholar, at 53.
34 Soergel, Philip M., Wondrous in his Saints: Counter-Reformation Propaganda in Bavaria (Berkeley, CA, 1993), 79Google Scholar.
35 Pabel, Hilmar M., ‘Augustine's Confessions and the Autobiographies of Peter Canisius, SJ’, CHRC 87 (2007), 453–75Google Scholar, at 470.
36 ‘Ich will nichts mit denen gemein haben’: Canisius, Testament, 91; ‘Non noui Lutherum, Caluinum respuo, haereticis omnibus dico anathema: nihil mihi cum his commune esse volo … cum vna sancta Catholica, Apostolica, & Romana Ecclesia’: Canisius, Peter, Summa doctrinae christianae (Antwerp, 1574)Google Scholar, unpaginated.
37 ‘[H]aereticorum malleum’: Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 8: 447.
38 Fisher, Alexander J., Music, Piety, and Propaganda: The Soundscape of Counter-Reformation Bavaria (Oxford, 2014), 35–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Landersdorfer, Anton, Das Bistum Freising in der bayerischen Visitation des Jahres 1560 (St Ottilien, 1986)Google Scholar.
39 Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 2: 816.
40 ‘Et oro, ut Christi gratia fauente pietas tua confidenter agat in negotio Religionis, nec sinat usquam grassari lupos [siue in] templis, siue in scholis’: ibid. 284.
41 As Susan Karant-Nunn notes, dancing and other festivities, such as feasting and drinking, were discouraged by both Protestants and Catholics, although Catholic clergy were more tolerant of such pastimes: The Reformation of Feeling: Shaping the Religious Emotions in Early Modern Germany (Oxford, 2010), 62.
42 Brodrick, Canisius, 831; Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 3: 648–9.
43 Mullett, Michael A., The Catholic Reformation (London, 1999), 57Google Scholar.
44 Canisius, Peter, Catholischer Catechismus oder Sumārien Christlicher Lehr Inn frag un̄ anntwort / der Christlicher jugent / unnd allen einfaltigen zu nuz und heil gestelt (Cologne, 1563)Google Scholar, unpaginated.
45 ‘Die glaubigen Leien … sein nit verbunden auß dem gebot Gottes zu der empfahung des Sacraments under zweierlei gestalt … die gewonheit (den Leien zu peisen unter einerlei gestalt) von der Kirchē und heiligen Vattern nit on ursach eingefurt und gar lang gehaltē ist / ist si fur ein gesaz zubehalten / welchs nit mag um̄ gestollen / oder an der Kirchen Authoritet nach eins jeden wolgefallen verkert werden’: ibid.
46 ‘Nit on ursach eingefurt’: ibid.
47 ‘Die eusserlichen zeichen dieses Sacraments … Mit den newn verachtern der … bestendigen in der einigkeit der Kirch’: ibid.
48 Luebke, David M., Hometown Religion: Regimes of Coexistence in Early Modern Westphalia (Charlottesville, VA, 2016), 93Google Scholar.
49 Ibid. 101.
50 Canisius, Peter, Der kleine Catechismus, oder kurtze Summa des wahren Christlichen und Catholischen Glaubens (Dillingen, 1574), 107Google Scholar.
51 Wandel, Lee Palmer, Reading Catechisms, Teaching Religion (Leiden, 2016)Google Scholar.
52 Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 4: 447, 406.
53 Frymire, John, The Primacy of the Postils: Catholics, Protestants, and the Dissemination of Ideas in Early Modern Germany (Leiden, 2010), 339Google Scholar.
54 Creasman, Allyson F., Censorship and Civic Order in Reformation Germany, 1517–1648: ‘Printed Poison & Evil Talk’ (Farnham, 2012), 58Google Scholar.
55 Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 2: 358.
56 ‘Tum apud nouum Pont. impetrari gratiam velim Confessarijs, vt ne rigore Cathalogi arceantur ab absolutione conferenda studiosis ratione librorum, si quos habent impuros’: ibid. 533.
57 ‘Accedit durities Cathalogi, ut isti interpretantur, intollerabilis; nec videmus obtineri posse, quod praescriptum est’: ibid. 380.
58 ‘Certo non vedemo modo di potere intratenere le nostre classe et schole se dovemo andare secondo la lettera della stretta prohibitione’: ibid. 446.
59 Brodrick, Canisius, 138.
60 Ibid. 468.
61 Laqua-O'Donnell, Simone, ‘Family Matters: Peter Canisius as Confessor and Spiritual Guide in Early Modern Augsburg. A Case Study’, Journal of Jesuit Studies 2 (2015), 606–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 607.
62 Begheyn, Paul and Hunink, Vincent J. C., ‘Two Unpublished Letters by Peter Canisius (1521–97) to Cardinal Scipione Rebiba, 1577’, Lias: Sources and Documents relating to the Early Modern History of Ideas 34 (2007), 3–10Google Scholar, at 4 (Letter 2).
63 Pabel, ‘Canisius’, 379.
64 Hacke, Daniela, ‘Confessional Cultures and Sacred Space: Towards a History of Political Communication in Early Modern Switzerland’, in Calaresu, Melissa, de Vivo, Filippo and Rubiés, Joan Pau, eds, Exploring Cultural History: Essays in Honour of Peter Burke (Farnham, 2010), 169–90Google Scholar, at 174; Burnett, Amy Nelson and Campi, Emidio, eds, A Companion to the Swiss Reformation (Leiden, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
65 ‘Reducendi ab haereseos erroribus in viam’: Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 8: 881.
66 ‘Dass ich innerhalb der Grenzen eines rechtgläubigen Lehrers geblieben bin’: Canisius, Testament, 82.
67 ‘Non facile quiuis assequi uel compraehendere potest Germaniae miserum statum et necessitates, nisi qui eas suis oculis uidet et longa experientia didicit’: Beati Petri Canisii, ed. Braunsberger, 7: 362.
68 Laqua-O'Donnell, Simone, ‘Catholic Piety and Community’, in Bamji, Alexandra, Janssen, Geert H. and Laven, Mary, eds, Ashgate Research Companion to the Counter-Reformation (Farnham, 2013), 281–97Google Scholar, at 286.
69 Bast, Robert James, Honor your Fathers: Catechisms and the Emergence of a Patriarchal Ideology in Germany, 1400–1600 (Leiden, 1997), 231Google Scholar; Wandel, Reading Catechisms; Kaplan, Benjamin, Divided by Faith: Religious Conflict and the Practice of Tolerance in Early Modern Europe (Harvard, MA, 2010)Google Scholar.