Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-m6dg7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-18T01:16:47.927Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Fall and Rise of Church and State? Religious History, Politics and the State in Britain, 1961–2011*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 January 2016

Matthew Grimley*
Affiliation:
Merton College, Oxford

Extract

In trying to trace the development of church-state relations in Britain since 1961, one encounters the difficulty that conceptions of both ‘church’ and ‘state’ have changed radically in the half-century since then. This is most obviously true of the state. The British state in 1961 was (outside Stormont-governed Northern Ireland) a unitary state governed from London. It still had colonies, and substantial overseas military commitments. One of its Houses of Parliament had until three years before been (a few bishops and law-lords apart) completely hereditary. The prime minister controlled all senior appointments in the established Church of England, and Parliament had the final say on its worship and doctrine. The criminal law still embodied Christian teaching on issues of personal morality.

Type
Part III: Church and State in History
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I am grateful to the audience and the other speakers at the EHS winter conference in January 2012 for their comments, and in particular to Sheridan Gilley, Perry Butler, David Thompson, Sarah Foot and the editors of this volume.

References

1 Hart, H. L. A., Law, Liberty and Morality (London, 1963), Preface.Google Scholar

2 ODNB, s.n. ‘Ramsey, (Arthur) Michael (1904–1988)’.

3 Grimley, Matthew, ‘Law, Morality and Secularisation: The Church of England and the Wolfenden Report, 1954–1967’, JEH 60 (2009), 72541 Google Scholar; Lewis, Jane and Wallis, Patrick, ‘Fault, Breakdown, and the Church of England’s Involvement in the 1969 Divorce Reform’, 20th Century British History 11 (2000), 30832.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4 Green, S. J. D., ‘Survival and Autonomy: On the Strange Fortunes and Peculiar Legacy of Ecclesiastical Establishment in the Modern British State, c. 1920 to the Present Day’, in idem and Whiting, R. C., eds, The Boundaries of the State in Modern Britain (Cambridge, 1994), 299324.Google Scholar

5 See, e.g., Green, Humphrey, ‘Erastus rebutted – or, the Obstacle of Establishment’, Prism, April 1958, 818; Disestablishment and Unity, Prism special issue, January 1959; Editorial, Prism, June 1959, 1.Google Scholar

6 Vidler, Alec, ‘Religion and the National Church’, in idem, ed., Soundings; Essays Concerning Christian Understanding (Cambridge, 1962), 24163, at 2612.Google Scholar

7 Robinson, John, Honest to God (London, 1963), 141.Google Scholar

8 Stephenson, Alan, The Rise and Decline of English Modernism (London, 1984).Google Scholar

9 Modood, Tariq, ‘Establishment, Multiculturalism and British Citizenship’, Political Quarterly 65 (1994), 5373.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

10 Queen Elizabeth II, speech at Lambeth Palace, 15 February 2012, online at: <http://www.archbishopofcanterbury.org/articles.php/2358/the-queen-attends-multi-faith-reception-at-lambeth-palace>, accessed 28 August 2012.

11 Parsons, Gerald, ‘There and back again? Religion and the 1944 and 1988 Education Acts’, in idem, ed., The Growth of Religious Diversity: Britain from 1945, 2: Issues (London, 1994), 16198 Google Scholar; Parker, Stephen and Freathy, Rob, ‘Ethnic Diversity, Christian Hegemony and the Emergence of Multi-faith Religious Education in the 1970s’, History of Education 41 (2012), 381404 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; eidem, ‘Context, Complexity and Contestation: Birmingham’s Agreed Syllabuses since the 1970s’, Journal of Beliefs and Values 32 (2011), 24763.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

12 Archbishop of Canterbury’s Commission on Urban Priority Areas, Faith in the City: A Call for Action by Faith and Nation (London, 1985)Google Scholar. For wider relations between the Church of England and the Thatcher governments, see Filby, Liza, ‘God and Mrs Thatcher: Religion and Politics in 1980s Britain’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Warwick, 2010).Google Scholar

13 Though for the argument that anti-Catholicism remained a force during and after 1982, see John Wolflfe, ‘Change and Continuity in British Anti-Catholicism 1829–1982’, in Tallett, Frank and Atkin, Nicholas, eds, Catholicism in Britain and France since 1789 (London, 1996), 6783.Google Scholar

14 Though just prior to the papal visit, the Scottish National Party president, William Wolfe, had spoken of the need to protect the Falkland Islands ‘from the cruel and ruthless fascist dictatorship of a Roman Catholic State’: quoted in Keith Robbins, Nicholas, England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales: The Christian Church 1900–2000, OHCC (Oxford, 2008), 434.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

15 Brose, Olive, Church and Parliament: The Reshaping of the Church of England (Stanford, CA, 1959)Google Scholar; Best, Geoffrey, Temporal Pillars: Queen Anne’s Bounty, the Ecclesiastical Commissioners and the Church of England (Cambridge, 1964).Google Scholar

16 Vidler, Alec, The Orb and the Cross: A Normative Study in the Relations between Church and State with Reference to Gladstone’s Early Writings (London, 1945)Google Scholar; Forbes, Duncan, The Liberal Anglican Idea of History (Cambridge, 1952).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17 Harris, Jose, ‘Political Thought and the State’, in Green, and Whiting, , eds, Boundaries of the State, 1528, at 15.Google Scholar

18 Laslett, Peter, Introduction to idem, ed., Philosophy, Politics and Society (Oxford, 1956), viixv, at vii.Google Scholar

19 Berlin, Isaiah, ‘Does Political Theory still exist?’, in Laslett, Peter and Runciman, W. G., eds, Philosophy, Politics and Society (Second Series) (Oxford, 1962), 133.Google Scholar

20 Brown, Peter, ‘St Augustine’, in Smalley, Beryl, ed., Trends in Medieval Political Thought (Oxford, 1963), repr. in Brown, Religion and Society in the Age of St Augustine (London, 1972), 2545, at 28.Google Scholar

21 For a more detailed discussion of the ‘turns’ towards anthropology and sociology, see, in this volume, Sarah Foot, ‘Has Ecclesiastical History Lost the Plot?’, 1–25.

22 Fletcher, Stella, ‘A Very Agreeable Society’: The Ecclesiastical History Society 1961–2011 (Southampton, 2011), 10.Google Scholar

23 Thompson, E. P., The Making of the English Working Class (London, 1968 edn), 411, 405 respectively.Google Scholar

24 Wilson, Bryan, Religion in Secular Society: A Sociological Comment (London, 1966); Alasdair MacIntyre, Secularization and Moral Change (Oxford, 1967).Google Scholar

25 Wickham, E. R., Church and People in an Industrial City (London, 1957), 11.Google Scholar

26 Ibid. 198.

27 Inglis, K. S., Churches and the Working Classes in Victorian England (London, 1963).Google Scholar

28 Morris, Jeremy, ‘Secularization and Religious Experience: Arguments in the Historiography of Modern British Religion’, HistJ 55 (2012), 195219, at 198–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

29 Wickham, , Church and People, 12.Google Scholar

30 McLeod, Hugh, Class and Religion in the Late Victorian City (London, 1974)Google Scholar; Gilbert, Alan, Religion and Society in Industrial England: Church, Chapel and Social Change, 1740–1914 (London, 1976).Google Scholar

31 For a more recent discussion of this relationship, see the essays in Cooper, Kate and Gregory, Jeremy, eds, Elite and Popular Religion, SCH 42 (Wcodbridge, 2006).Google Scholar

32 Cox, Jeffrey, The English Churches in a Secular Society: Lambeth, 1870–1930 (Oxford, 1982)Google Scholar; Morris, Jeremy, Religion and Urban Change: Croydon, 1840–1914 (Woodbridge, 1992).Google Scholar

33 McLeod, Hugh, Piety and Poverty: Working-Class Religion in Berlin, London, and New York 1870–1914 (New York, 1993)Google Scholar; idem, ‘Protestantism and National Identity 1815–1945’, in Van der Veer, Peter and Lehmann, Hartmut, eds, Nation and Religion: Perspectives on Europe and Asia (Princeton, NJ, 1999), 4470.Google Scholar

34 Williams, S. C., Religious Belief and Popular Culture in Southwark, c. 1880–1939 (Oxford, 1999)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Brown, Callum, The Death of Christian Britain: Understanding Secularisation 1800–2000 (London, 2001).Google Scholar

35 Morris, Jeremy, ‘The Strange Death of Christian Britain: Another look at the Secularization Debate’, HistJ (2003), 96376, at 968.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

36 Bell, Daniel, ‘The Return of the Sacred? The Argument on the Future of Religion’, British Journal of Sociology 28 (1977), 41949.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

37 Markus, R.A., Saeculum: History and Society in the Theology of St Augustine, rev. edn (Cambridge, 1988), viiiix.Google Scholar

38 See, e.g., Morrill, John, ‘The Religious Context of the English Civil War’, TRHS ser. 5, 34 (1983), 15578 Google Scholar; Russell, Conrad, The Causes of the English Civil War (Oxford, 1990).Google Scholar

39 Clark, J. C. D., English Society, 1688–1832 (Cambridge, 1985)Google Scholar; Hilton, Boyd, The Age of Atonement: The Influence of Evangelicalism on Social and Political Thought, 1785–1865 (Oxford, 1988)Google Scholar; Parry, Jonathan, Democracy and Religion: Gladstone and the Liberal Parly (Cambridge, 1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Brent, Richard, Liberal Anglican Politics: Whiggery, Religion and Reform, 1830–1841 (Oxford, 1987)Google Scholar; Matthew, H. C. G., Gladstone, 2 vols (Oxford, 1986–95)Google Scholar; Bebbington, David, The Mind of Gladstone, Religion, Homer and Politics (Oxford, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bentley, Michael, Lord Salisbury’s World: Conservative Environments in Late-Victorian Britain (Cambridge, 2001).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

40 Although, as Hilton pointed out, the parallel was ‘tempting but misleading, for we are not really living in another Age of Atonement’: Age of Atonement, 374.

41 Cowling, Maurice, Religion and Public Doctrine in Modern England, 3 vols (Cambridge, 19802001)Google Scholar; Williamson, Philip, ‘The Doctrinal Politics of Stanley Baldwin’, in Public and Private Doctrine: Essays in British History Presented to Maurice Cowling, ed. Bentley, M. (xsCambridge, 1993), 181208; idem, Stanley Baldwin: National Leadership and National Values (Cambridge, 1999); idem, ‘Christian Conservatives and the Totalitarian Challenge 1933–40’, EHR 115 (2000), 60742 Google Scholar. For a discussion of the influence of religion on the early Labour Party, see Peter Caterall, ‘The Distinctiveness of British Socialism? Religion and the Rise of Labour, c. 1900–1939’, in Worley, Matthew, ed., The Foundations of the British Labour Party: Identities, Cultures and Perspectives, 1900–1939 (Farnham, 2009), 13152.Google Scholar

42 Machin, G. I. T., Politics, Society and the Churches 1869–1921 (Oxford, 1987); idem, ‘Disestablishment and Democracy, c. 1840–1930’, in Biagini, Eugenio F., ed., Citizenship and Community: Liberals, Radicals and Collective Identities in the British Isles 1865–1931 (Cambridge, 1996), 12047 Google Scholar; Maiden, John, National Religion and the Prayer Book Controversy, 1927–1928 (Woodbridge, 2009)Google Scholar; Grimley, Matthew, Citizenship, Community and the Church of England: Liberal Anglican Theories of the State between the Wars (Oxford, 2004), ch. 4.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

43 Grimley, , Citizenship, Community and the Church of England; Green, S. J. D., The Passing of Protestant England: Secularisation and Social Change c. 1920–1960 (Cambridge, 2011), ch. 6; Grimley, , ‘Law, Morality and Secularisation’.Google Scholar

44 See, e.g., Samuel, Raphael, ed., Patriotism: The Making and Unmaking of British National Identity, 3 vols (London, 1989)Google Scholar. For an investigation of role of religion in national identity from the same period, see Mews, Stuart, ed., Religion and National Identity, SCH 18 (Oxford, 1982).Google Scholar

45 Colley, Linda, Britons: Forging the Nation, 1707–1837 (New Haven, CT, 1992).Google Scholar

46 Claydon, Tony and McBride, Ian, eds, Protestantism and National Identity, c. 1650-c.1850 (Cambridge, 1999)Google Scholar; McLeod, , ‘Protestantism and National Identity’; Wolffe, John, God and Greater Britain: Religion and National Life in Britain and Ireland 1843–1945 (London, 1994); Grimley, Matthew, ‘The Religion of Englishness: Puritanism, Providentialism and National Character 1918–1945’, JBS 46 (2007), 884906; Green, , Passing of Protestant England.Google Scholar

47 Hastings, Adrian, The Construction of Nationhood: Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism (Cambridge, 1997).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

48 Wolffe, John, Great Deaths: Grieving, Religion and Nationhood in Victorian and Edwardian Britain (Oxford, 2000)Google Scholar; idem, ‘National Occasions at St Paul’s since 1800’, in Keane, Derek, Burns, Arthur and Saint, Andrew, eds, St Paul’s: The Cathedral Church of London 604–2004 (New Haven, CT, 2004), 38191 Google Scholar; Burns, Arthur, ‘From 1830 to the Present’, in Keane, , Burns, and Saint, , eds, St Paul’s, 84110 Google Scholar; Williamson, Philip, ‘The Monarchy and Public Values, 1910–1953’, in Olechnowicz, Andrzej, ed., The Monarchy and the British Nation, 1780 to the Present (Cambridge, 2007), 22357.Google Scholar

49 Nicholls, David, Deity and Domination: Images of God and the State in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries (London, 1989)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Norman, Edward, Church and Society in England, 1770–1970: A Historical Study (Cambridge, 1976).Google Scholar

50 Skinner, S. A., Tractarians and the Condition of England: The Social and Political Thought of the Oxford Movement (Oxford, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Nicholls, David, The Pluralist State: The Political Ideas of J. N. Figgis and his Contemporaries, 2nd edn (Basingstoke, 1994).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

51 Carey, Hilary M., ed., Empires of Religion (Basingstoke, 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cox, Jeffrey, The British Missionary Enterprise since 1700 (London, 2008)Google Scholar; idem, ‘From the Empire of Christ to the Third World: Religion and the Experience of Empire in the Twentieth Century’, in Thompson, Andrew, ed., Britain’s Experience of Empire in the Twentieth Century (Oxford, 2011), 76–121CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Porter, Andrew, Religion versus Empire? British Protestant Missionaries and Overseas Expansion, 1700–1914 (Manchester, 2004).Google Scholar

52 Bell, Stuart, ‘The First World War’, in Parker, S. G. and Lawson, T., eds, God and War: The Church of England and the Armed Conflicts of the Twentieth Century (Aldershot, 2012), 3359 Google Scholar; Chandler, Andrew, Brethren in Adversity: George Bell and the Crisis of German Protestantism (Woodbridge, 2007)Google Scholar; idem, The Church of England and the Obliteration Bombing of Germany during the Second World War’, EHR 108 (1993), 92046.Google Scholar

53 Stockwell, Sarah, ‘“Splendidly leading the way”: Archbishop Fisher and Decolonisation in British Colonial Africa’, Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 36 (2008), 54564 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Grimley, Matthew, ‘The Church and the Bomb: Anglicans and the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, c. 1958–1984’, in Parker, and Lawson, , eds, God and War, 14764.Google Scholar

54 Brown, Stewart J., Providence and Empire: Religion, Society and Politics 1815–1914 (Harlow, 2008).Google Scholar

55 Hastings, Adrian, A History of English Christianity 1920–1990, rev. edn (London, 1991)Google Scholar; Robbins, , England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

56 Harrison, Brian, Seeking a Role: The United Kingdom 1951–1970 (Oxford, 2009); idem, Finding a Role? The United Kingdom 1970–1990 (Oxford, 2010).Google Scholar

57 Martin, David, A General Theory of Secularization (Oxford, 1978)Google Scholar; Davie, Grace, Religion in Modern Europe: A Memory Mutates (Oxford, 2004)Google Scholar; Casanova, Jose, Public Religions in the Modern World (Chicago, IL, 1994).Google Scholar

58 Gill, Robin, The Myth of the Empty Church (London, 1993).Google Scholar

59 Hempton, David, ‘Established Churches and the Growth of Religious Pluralism: A Case Study of Christianisation and Secularisation in England since 1700’, in McLeod, Hugh and Ustorf, Werner, eds, The Decline of Christendom in Western Europe, 1750–2000 (Cambridge, 2003), 8198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

60 Clark, J. C. D., ‘Secularization and Modernization: The Failure of a “Grand Narrative”’, HistJ 55 (2012), 16194, at 188.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

61 Rawls, John, ‘The Idea of Public Reason Revisited’, in idem, The Law of Peoples: With The Idea of Public Reason Revisited (Cambridge, MA, 1999), 12980. For a recent Christian critique of Rawls, see the essays in Nigel Biggar and Linda Hogan, eds, Religious Voices in Public Places (Oxford, 2009).Google Scholar

62 Klausen, Jytte, ‘Europe’s Uneasy Marriage of Secularism and Christianity since 1945 and the Challenge of Contemporary Religious Pluralism’, in Katznelson, Ira and Jones, Gareth Stedman, eds, Religion and the Political Imagination (Cambridge, 2010), 31435.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

63 McLeod, Hugh, The Religious Crisis of the 1960s (Oxford, 2007); idem and Ustorf, eds, Decline of Christendom.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

64 Cox, Jeffrey, ‘Master-Narratives of Religious Change’, in McLeod, and Ustorf, , eds, Decline of Christendom, 20117, at 210.Google Scholar

65 For recent discussion by a legal theorist, see Rivers, Julian, The Law of Organised Religions: Between Establishment and Secularism (Oxford, 2011).Google Scholar

66 Asad, Talal, Formations of the Secular: Christianity, Islam, Modernity (Stanford, CA, 2003)Google Scholar; Taylor, Charles, A Secular Age (Cambridge, MA, 2007)Google Scholar; Warner, Michael, Van Antwerpen, Jonathan and Calhoun, Craig J., eds, Varieties of Secularism in a Secular Age (Cambridge, MA, 2010)Google Scholar; Calhoun, Craig J., Juergensmeyer, Mark and Van Antwerpen, Jonathan, eds, Rethinking Secularism (Oxford, 2011)Google Scholar. For a recent discussion of some of this literature by a historian, see Erdozain, Dominic, ‘“Cause is not quite what it used to be”: The Return of Secularisation’, EHR 127 (2012), 377400.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

67 Martin, Bernice, ‘The Non-Quantifiable Religious Dimension in Social Life’, in Avis, Paul, ed., Public Faith? The State of Religious Belief and Practice in Britain (London, 2003), 118, at 13.Google Scholar

68 For exceptions, see Budd, Susan, Varieties of Unbelief: Atheists and Agnostics in English Society, 1850–1960 (London, 1977)Google Scholar; Nash, David, Blasphemy in Modern Britain: 1789 to the Present (Aldershot, 1999)Google Scholar; Brown, Callum, ‘“The Unholy Mrs Knight and the BBC”: Secular Humanism and the Threat to the “Christian Nation”, c.1945–1960’, EHR 127 (2012), 34576.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

69 Kselman, Thomas, ‘Challenging De-Christianization: The Historiography of Religion in Modern France’, ChH 75 (2001), 1309.Google Scholar

70 Green, , Passing of Protestant England, 11.Google Scholar