Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The “Problem” of Interdisciplinarity in Theory, Practice, and History

  • Harvey J. Graff

Abstract

Interdisciplinarity is among the most talked about but most misunderstood topics in education on all levels today. Seen as the savior of research and teaching, especially in universities, and of society, or the seeds of destruction, interdisciplinarity's proponents and critics talk past each other. Seldom do they seek common terms; typically, they mean very different approaches when they refer to interdisciplinarity. They erroneously dichotomize disciplines and interdisciplines, confuse specialization and synthesis, and misconstrue “integration.” They also date the historical turn to interdisciplinarity too late. This article critically reviews the history, historiography, and sociology of knowledge of interdisciplinarity with a focus on etiology, epistemology, definitions, relationships among and between disciplines, intellectual and institutional locations, and the organization of knowledge. A new, more historical approach to the “problem” of interdisciplinarity is proposed.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Abbott, Andrew (2001) Chaos of Disciplines. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Aronowitz, Stanley (2000) The Knowledge Factory: Dismantling the Corporate University and Creating True Higher Learning. Boston: Beacon Press.
Austin, Timothy R., Rauch, Alan, Blau, Herbert, Yudice, George, van DenBerg, Sara, Robinson, Lillian S., Henkel, Jacqueline, Murray, Timothy, Schoenfield, Mark, Traub, Valerie, and de Marco Torgovnick, Marianna (1996) “Defining interdisciplinarity.” PMLA 111 (2): 271–72.
Bok, Derek (2013) Higher Education in America. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Brint, Steven (2001) “Professionals and the ‘knowledge economy’: Rethinking the theory of postindustrial society.” Current Sociology 49 (4): 101–32.
Brint, Steven (2002) “The rise of the ‘practical arts,’ in Brint, Steven (ed.) The Future of the City of Intellect: The Changing American University. Stanford: Stanford University Press: 6189.
Brint, Steven (2005) “Creating the future: ‘New directions’ in American research universities.” Minerva 43: 2350.
Brint, Steven, Riddle, Mark, Turk-Bicakci, Lori, and Levy, Charles S. (2005) “From the liberal to the practical arts in American colleges and universities: Organizational analysis and curricular change.” Journal of Higher Education 76: 151–80.
Calhoun, Craig (2000) “The specificity of American higher education.” Comparative Social Research 19: 4881.
Calhoun, Craig (2006) “The university and the public good.” Thesis Eleven 84: 743.
Camic, Charles Neil Gross, and Lamont, Michele, eds. (2011) Social Knowledge in the Making. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Campbell, Colin (1986) “Scholarly disciplines breaking out.” New York Times, April 25.
CERI (1972) “General conclusions,” in Centre for Educational Research and Innovation, Interdisciplinarity: Problems of Teaching and Research in Universities, report based the results of a Seminar on Interdisciplinarity in Universities, organized by CERI in Collaboration with the French Ministry of Education at the University of Nice, Sept 7–12, 1970: 285.
Change (2007) The Path to Interdisciplinary Collaboration. Change 36 (6): special issue.
Chronicle of Higher Education (2007) “Institutionalizing interdisciplinary study,” January 30.
Chronicle of Higher Education (2008a) University of Minnesota advertisement, May 2.
Chronicle of Higher Education (2008b) Claremont Graduate University advertisement, October 31.
Committee on a New Biology for the 21st Century (2009) Ensuring the United States Leads the Coming Biology Revolution, Board on Life Sciences, Division on Earth and Life Studies, National Research Council, A New Biology for the 21st Century. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
Crow, Michael, Frodeman, Robert, Guston, David, Mitcham, Carl, Sarewitz, Daniel, and Zachary, G. Pascal (2013) The Rightful Place of Science: Politics. Tempe: Consortium for Science, Policy, and Outcomes, Arizona State University.
Davis, Lennard J. (2007) “A grand unified theory of interdisciplinarity.” Chronicle of Higher Education, June 8.
De Mey, Marc (1982) The Cognitive Paradigm: Cognitive Science, a Newly Explored Approach to the Study of Cognition Applied in an Analysis of Science and Scientific Knowledge. Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing.
Dogan, Mattei, and Pahre, Robert (1990) Creative Marginalization: Innovation at the Intersections of Social Sciences. Boulder: Westview Press.
Edwards, David (2010) The Lab: Creativity and Culture. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Fish, Stanley (1989) “Being interdisciplinary is so very hard to do.” Profession 89 (MLA): 1522.
Fisher, Donald (1988) “Boundary work: A model of the relation between power and knowledge.” Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Utilization 10: 156–76.
Frank, Roberta (1988) “‘Interdisciplinarity’: The first half-century,” in Stanley, E. G. and Hoad, T. F. (eds.) Words for Robert Burchfield's Sixty-Fifth Birthday. Woodbridge, UK: D. S. Brewer: 91101.
Frodeman, Robert (2014) Sustainable Knowledge: A Theory of Interdisciplinarity. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Frodeman, Robert, Klein, Julie Thompson, and Mitcham, Carl, eds. (2010) The Oxford Handbook of Interdisciplinarity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fuller, Steven (2003) “Interdisciplinarity: The loss of the heroic vision in the marketplace of ideas.” October 1, 2003, http://www.academia.edu/1161664/Rethinking_Interdisciplinarity, 1.
Galison, Peter (1992) “The many faces of big science,” in Galison, Peter and Hevly, Bruce (eds.) Big Science: The Growth of Large Scale Research. Stanford: Stanford University Press: 117.
Gershon, Diane (2000) “Laying a firm foundation for interdisciplinary research endeavours.” Nature 406: 107–8.
Gieryn Thomas, F. (1983) “Boundary-work and the demarcation of science from non-science: Strains and interests in professional ideologies of scientists.” American Sociological Review 48: 781–95.
Gilman, Sander (2000) The Fortunes of the Humanities: Teaching the Humanities in the New Millennium. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Graff, Harvey J. (2001) “The shock of the ‘“new” histories’: Social science histories and historical literacies,” Presidential Address, Social Science History Association, 2000, Social Science History 25 (1): 483533.
Graff, Harvey J. (2011) “LiteracyStudies@OSU as theory and practice,” in Graff, Harvey J. (ed.). Literacy Myths, Legacies, and Lessons: New Studies on Literacy. New Brunswick: Transaction: 141–78.
Graff, Harvey J. (2015) Undisciplining Knowledge: Interdisciplinarity in the Twentieth Century. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Grafton, Anthony, and Jardine, Lisa (1986) From Humanism to the Humanities. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Guillory, John (2002) “The Sokal affair and the history of criticism.” Critical Inquiry 28: 470508.
Gusdorf, Georges (1977) “Past, present, and future in interdisciplinary research.” International Social Science Journal 29: 580600.
Heckhausen, Heinz (1972) “Discipline and interdisciplinarity,” in Centre for Educational Research and Innovation, Interdisciplinarity: Problems of Teaching and Research in Universities, report based the results of a Seminar on Interdisciplinarity in Universities: 83–89.
Herbst, Susan (2008) “Disciplines, intersections, and the future of communication research.” Journal of Communication 58: 605–6.
Hunt, Lynn (1997) “Democratization and decline? The consequences of democratic change in the humanities,” in Kerman, Alvin (ed.). What's Happened to the Humanities? Princeton: Princeton University Press: 1731.
Inside Higher Education (2007) “‘Institutionalizing’ interdisciplinary research,” July 25.
Inside Higher Education (2013) “Study finds that Ph.D.s who write interdisciplinary dissertations earn less,” October 31.
Jacobs, Jerry (2013) In Defense of Disciplines: Interdisciplinarity and Specialization in the Research University. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Jacobs, Jerry A., and Frickel, Scott (2009) “Interdisciplinarity: A critical assessment.” Annual Review of Sociology 35: 4365.
Katsouleas, Tom (2011) “A Convergence science for today's problems.” Chronicle of Higher Education, August 14.
Klein, Julie Thompson (1990) Interdisciplinarity: History, Theory, and Practice. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
Klein, Julie Thompson (1996) Crossing Boundaries: Knowledge, Disciplinarities, and Interdisciplinarities. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia.
Klein, Julie Thompson (1999). Crossing Boundaries; Mapping Interdisciplinary Studies: The Academy in Transition. Washington, DC: Association of American Colleges and Universities.
Klein, Julie Thompson (2005) Humanities, Culture, and Interdisciplinarity: The Changing American Academy. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Klein, Julie Thompson (2010) Creating Interdisciplinary Campus Cultures: A Model for Strength and Sustainability. Association of American Colleges and Universities. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Lamont, Michele (2009) How Professors Think: Inside the Curious World of Academic Judgment. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Latucca, Lisa R. (2001) Creating Interdisciplinarity: Interdisciplinary Research and Teaching Among College and University Faculty. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press.
Lawrence, Roderick J., and Després, Carole (2004) “Futures of transdisciplinarity.” Futures 36 (4): 397405.
Lloyd, G. E. R. (2009) Disciplines in the Making. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Markin, Karen M. (2005) “So happy together.” Chronicle of Higher Education, November 25.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (2011) The Third Revolution: The Convergence of the Life Sciences, Physical Sciences, and Engineering. Washington, DC: MIT.
Matthiasson, John S. (1968) “My discipline is better than your discipline: Some barriers to interdisciplinary research.” Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 5: 263–75.
Menand, Louis (2010) The Marketplace of Ideas: Reform and Resistance in the American University. New York: W. W. Norton.
Moran, Joe (2002) Interdisciplinarity. London: Routledge.
Newfield, Christopher (2009) Unmaking the Public University: The Forty-Year Assault on the Middle Class. Cambridge, MA.: Harvard University Press.
Nicolescu, Basarab (2002) Manifesto of Transdisciplinarity, trans. Voss, Karen-Claire. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Nissani, Moti (1995) “Fruits, salads, and smoothies: A working definition of interdisciplinarity.” Journal of Educational Thought 29: 121–28.
Nissani, Moti (1997) “Ten cheers for interdisciplinarity: The case for interdisciplinary knowledge and research.” Social Science Journal 34: 201–16.
Peters, Julie Stone (2005) “Law, literature, and the vanishing real: On the future of an interdisciplinary illusion.” PMLA 120: 442–53.
Pfirman, Stephanie L., Collins, James P., Lowes, Susan, and Michaels, Anthony (2005) “Collaborative efforts: Promoting interdisciplinary scholars.” Chronicle of Higher Education, February 7.
Readings, Bill (1996) The University in Ruins. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Rose, Nikolas (2013) “Nikolas Rose interviewed by Todd Meyers.” Public Culture 25: 435–52.
Salter, Liora, and Hearn, Alison, eds. (1996) Outside the Lines: Issues in Interdisciplinary Research. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Smelser, Neil J. (2004) “Interdisciplinarity in theory and practice,” in Camic, Charles and Joas, Hans (eds.) The Dialogical Turn: New Roles for Sociology in the Postdisciplinary Age. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield: 4364.
Strathern, Marilyn (2011) “An experiment in interdisciplinarity: Proposals and promises,” in Camic, Charles, Gross, Neil, and Lamont, Michele (eds.) Social Knowledge in the Making. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Strober, Myra H. (2010) Interdisciplinary Conversations: Challenging Habits of Thought. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Torgovnick, Marianna De Marco (1996) “Defining interdisciplinarity.” PMLA 111: 271–82.
Trow, Martin (1984–85) “Interdisciplinary studies as a counterculture: Problems of birth, growth and survival.” Issues in Integrative Studies 3: 116.
Turner, Steven (2000) “What are disciplines? And how is interdisciplinarity different?,” in Weingart, Peter and Stehr, Nico (eds.) Practising Interdisciplinarity. Toronto: University of Toronto: 4665.
University of Michigan News Service (2008) “Interdisciplinary faculty,” May 5.
Valenza, Robin (2009) Literature, Language, and the Rise of the Intellectual Disciplines in Britain, 1680–1820. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wasserstrom, Jeffrey (2006) “Expanding the I-Word.” Chronicle of Higher Education, January 20.
Weingart, Peter (2000) “Interdisciplinarity: The paradoxical discourse,” in Weingart, Peter and Stehr, Nico (eds.) Practising Interdisciplinarity. Toronto: University of Toronto Press: 2541.
Weingart, Peter, and Stehr, Nico, eds. (2000) Practising Interdisciplinarity. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed