Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The Copernican principle, intelligent extraterrestrials, and arguments from evil

  • SAMUEL RUHMKORFF (a1)

Abstract

The physicist Richard Gott defends the Copernican principle, which claims that when we have no information about our position along a given dimension among a group of observers, we should consider ourselves to be randomly located among those observers in respect to that dimension. First, I apply Copernican reasoning to the distribution of evil in the universe. I then contend that evidence for intelligent extraterrestrial life strengthens four important versions of the argument from evil. I remain neutral regarding whether this result is a reductio of these arguments from evil or the statement of a genuine evidential relationship.

Copyright

Corresponding author

References

Hide All
Adams, Marilyn McCord (1999) Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God (Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press).
Adams, Robert (1972) ‘Must God create the best?’, The Philosophical Review, 81, 317332.
Alston, William (1996) ‘The inductive argument from evil and the human cognitive condition’, in Howard-Snyder, D. (ed.) The Evidential Argument from Evil (Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press), 97125.
Baggett, David (2006) ‘Bruce Russell's analogy and the evidential problem of evil’, Philosophia Christi, 8, 463473.
Carter, Brandon (1983) ‘The anthropic principle and its implications for biological evolution’, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, A 310, 347363.
Chisholm, Roderick (1990) ‘The defeat of good and evil’, in Adams, M. M. & Adams, R. M. (eds) The Problem of Evil (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 5368.
Cohen, Yishai (2013) ‘Skeptical theism and the threshold problem’, Forum Philosophicum, 18, 7392.
Dostoevsky, Fyodor (1990) The Brothers Karamazov, Pevear, R. & Volokhonsky, L. (trs) (New York: Farrar, Straus, & Giroux).
Draper, Paul (2004) ‘Cosmic fine-tuning and terrestrial suffering: parallel problems of naturalism and theism’, American Philosophical Quarterly, 41, 311321.
Gale, Richard M. (1996) ‘Some difficulties in theistic treatments of evil’, in Howard-Snyder, D. (ed.) The Evidential Argument from Evil (Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press), 206218.
Gott, J. Richard (1993) ‘Implications of the Copernican Principle for our future prospects’, Nature, 363, 315319.
Gott, J. Richard (1994) ‘Future prospects discussed’, Nature, 368, 108.
Gott, J. Richard (1996) ‘Our future in the universe’, in Trimble, V. & Reisenegger, A. (eds) Clusters, Lensing, and the Future of the Universe (San Francisco: Astronomical Society of the Pacific), 140151.
Gott, J. Richard (2001) Time Travel in Einstein's Universe (Boston: Houghton Mifflin).
Hasker, William (1992) ‘The necessity of gratuitous evil’, Faith and Philosophy, 9, 2344.
Hick, John (1990) ‘Soul-making and suffering’, in Adams, M. M. & Adams, R. M. (eds) The Problem of Evil (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 168188.
Jeffreys, Harold (1939) Theory of Probability (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Kraay, Klaas J. (2013) ‘Megill's multiverse meta-argument’, International Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 73, 235241.
Leslie, John (1990) ‘Is the end of the world nigh?’, The Philosophical Quarterly, 40, 6572.
Lewis, David (2001) ‘Survival and identity’, in Loux, M. (ed.) Metaphysics: Contemporary Readings (London: Routledge), 395419.
McGrath, P. J. (1992) ‘Is the problem of evil misconceived?’, Religious Studies, 28, 6164.
Monton, Bradley (2010) ‘Against multiverse theodicies’, Philo, 13, 113135.
Monton, Bradley & Kierland, Brian (2006) ‘How to predict future duration from present age’, The Philosophical Quarterly, 56, 1638.
Nagel, Thomas (1970) ‘Death’, Nous, 4, 7380.
NASA (2014) ‘TESS: Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite’, <https://tess.gsfc.nasa.gov/documents/TESS_FactSheet_Oct2014.pdf>, [accessed 3 August 2016].
NASA (2015) ‘James Webb Space Telescope – The science mission’, <http://jwst.nasa.gov/resources/2015JWSTlitho.pdf> [accessed 3 August 2016].
Parfit, Derek (1984) Reasons and Persons (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Plantinga, Alvin (1977) God, Freedom, and Evil, 2nd edn (Grand Rapids MI: William B. Eerdmans).
Plantinga, Alvin (1979) ‘The probabilistic argument from evil’, Philosophical Studies, 35, 153.
Plantinga, Alvin (1996) ‘Epistemic probability and evil’, in Howard-Snyder, D. (ed.) The Evidential Argument from Evil (Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press), 6996.
Rowe, William (1979) ‘The problem of evil and some varieties of atheism’, American Philosophical Quarterly, 16, 335341.
Rowe, William (1984) ‘Evil and the theistic hypothesis: a response to Wykstra’, International Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 16, 95100.
Rowe, William (1996) ‘The evidential argument from evil: a second look’, in Howard-Snyder, D. (ed.) The Evidential Argument from Evil (Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press), 262285.
Rowe, William (2006) ‘Friendly atheism, skeptical theism, and the problem of evil’, International Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 59, 7992.
Russell, Bruce (1996) ‘Defenseless’, in Howard-Snyder, D. (ed.) The Evidential Argument from Evil (Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press), 193205.
Simpson, Fergus (2016) ‘The size distribution of inhabited planets’, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, <http://arxiv.org/abs/1503.07804> [accessed 25 February 2016].
Stump, Eleanore (1985) ‘The problem of evil’, Faith and Philosophy, 2, 392423.
Stump, Eleanore (2010) Wandering in Darkness: Narrative and the Problem of Suffering (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
Swinburne, Richard (1998) Providence and the Problem of Evil (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
Tracy, Thomas F. (1992) ‘Victimization and the problem of evil: a response to Ivan Karamazov’, Faith and Philosophy, 9, 301319.
Trakakis, Nick (2008) ‘Theodicy: the solution to the problem of evil, or part of the problem?’, Sophia, 47, 161191.
Vallentyne, Peter, & Kagan, Shelly (1997) ‘Infinite value and finitely additive value theory’, The Journal of Philosophy, 94, 526.
van Inwagen, Peter (1996) ‘The problem of evil, the problem of air, and the problem of silence’, in Howard-Snyder, D. (ed.) The Evidential Argument from Evil (Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press), 151175.
van Inwagen, Peter (2006) The Problem of Evil (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Velleman, David (2015) Beyond Price: Essays on Birth and Death. (Cambridge: Open Book Publishers).
Wykstra, Stephen J. (1990) ‘The Humean obstacle to evidential arguments from suffering: on avoiding the evils of “appearance”’, in Adams, M. M. & Adams, R. M. (eds) The Problem of Evil (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 138160.
Wykstra, Stephen J. (1996) ‘Rowe's noseeum arguments from evil’, in Howard-Snyder, D. (ed.) The Evidential Argument from Evil (Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press), 126150.
Zagzebski, Linda (1996) ‘An agent-based approach to the problem of evil’, International Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 39, 127139.

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed