Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

What's Gender Got to Do with It? Incivility in the Federal Courts

  • Lilia M. Cortina, Kimberly A. Lonsway, Vicki J. Magley, Leslie V. Freeman, Linda L. Collinsworth, Mary Hunter and Louise F. Fitzgerald...

Abstract

The current study examines experiences of interpersonal mistreatment in federal litigation among a random sample of 4,608 practicing attorneys. Using both quantitative and qualitative survey data, we documented the nature and interplay of general incivility, gender-related incivility, and unwanted sexual attention. Nearly 75% of female attorneys had experienced some form of this misconduct in the previous five years, compared to half of male attorneys. An in-depth examination of instigators revealed that not only fellow attorneys but also federal judges, court personnel, marshals, and court security officers instigated the inappropriate behavior. We further found that most attorneys responded to this mistreatment with avoidance and denial; few used or trusted existing reporting mechanisms. The current study surpassed simple prevalence estimates to document effects of interpersonal mistreatment on the professional well-being of targeted attorneys. We discuss implications of these results, drawing on theories of social dominance, sex-role spillover, cognitive stress, organizations, and intervention.

Copyright

Corresponding author

Please address correspondence to Lilia M. Cortina, University of Michigan, Department of Psychology, 525 E. University, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1109. E-mail: lilia@umich.edu.

References

Hide All
American Bar Association. 1986. In the Spirit of Public Service: A Blueprint for the Rekindling of Lawyer Professionalism. 112 F. R. D. 243.
Arvey, Richard D., and Cavanaugh, M. A. 1995. Using Surveys to Assess the Prevalence of Sexual Harassment: Some Methodological Problems. Journal of Social Issues 51: 3952.
Ashton, William A., and Fuehrer, Ann. 1993. Effects of Gender and Gender Role Identification of Participant and Type of Social Support Resource on Support Seeking. Sex Roles 28: 461–76.
Aspen, Marvin E. 1998. It's How You Play the Game. Trial, July, 2832.
Bateman, Thomas S., and Organ, Dennis W. 1983. Job Satisfaction and the Good Soldier: The Relationship between Affect and Employee “Citizenship. Academy of Management Journal 26: 587–95.
Beere, Carole A. 1990. Gender Roles: A Handbook of Tests and Measures. New York: Greenwood Press.
Black, Donald. 1976. The Behavior of Law. New York: Academic Press.
Brownmiller, Susan. 1975. Against Our will: Men, Women and Rape. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Burger, Warren. 1971. The Necessity for Civility. 52 F. R. D. 211.
Butler, Timothy, Giordano, Stephen, and Neren, Steven. 1985. Sex Roles 13: 515–24.
Carli, Linda L. 1999. Gender, Interpersonal Power, and Social Influence. Journal of Social Issue 55 (1): 8199.
Committee on Civility of the Seventh Federal Judicial Circuit. 1992a. Interim Report of the Committee on Civility of the Seventh Federal Judicial Circuit. 143 F. R. D. 371.
Committee on Civility of the Seventh Federal Judicial Circuit. 1992b. Final Report of the Committee on Civility of the Seventh Federal Judicial Circuit. 143 F. R. D. 441.
Corr, Kelly P., and Madden, Patrick M., 1995. Goodbye, Rambo-Hello, Mr. Rogers For the Defense 37 (12): 814.
Cortina, Lilia M., and Magley, Vicki J. 2001. Retaliation in the Context of Interpersonal Mistreatment: The Dangers of Speaking Out. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Psychological Society, June 1417, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Cortina, Lilia M., Magley, Vicki J., Williams, Jill Hunter, and Day Langhout, Regina. 2001. Incivility in the Workplace: Incidence and Impact, Journal of Occupational Health Psychology. 6 (1): 6480.
DiLorenzo, Louis P. 1992. Civility and Professionalism. New York State Bar Journal 68 (1): 8.
Eighth Circuit Gender Fairness Task Force. 1997. Final Report and Recommendations of the Eighth Circuit Gender Fairness Task Force. Creighton Law Review. 31 (1): 1181.
Felstiner, William L. F, Abel, Richard L., and Sarat, Austin. 198081. The Emergence and Transformation of Disputes: Naming, Blaming, Claiming. Law and Society Review 15: 631–54.
Fiske, Susan T. 1993. Controlling Other People: The Impact of Power on Stereotyping. American Psychologist 48: 621–28.
Fitzgerald, Louise F. 1990. Assessing Strategies for Coping with Sexual Harassment: A Theoretical/Empirical Approach. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Association for Women in Psychology, March, Tempe, Arizona.
Fitzgerald, Louise F., Shullman, Sandra, Bailey, Nancy, Richards, Margaret, Swecker, J., Gold, Yael, Ormerod, Alayne J., and Weitzman, Lauren. 1988. The Incidence and Dimensions of Sexual Harassment in Academia and the Workplace. Journal of Vocational Behavior 32: 152–75.
Fitzgerald, Louise F., Swan, Suzanne, and Fischer, Karla. 1995. Why Didn't She Just Report Him? The Psychological and Legal Implications of Women's Strategies for Responding to Sexual Harassment. Journal of Social Issues 51: 117–38.
French, John R. P., and Raven, Bertram. 1959. The Bases of Social Power. In Studies in Social Power, ed. Cartwright, D., 150–67. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Glaser, Barney F., and Strauss, Anselm L. 1967. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago: Aldine.
Gruber, James E., and Bjorn, Lars. 1982. Blue-Collar Blues: The Sexual Harassment of Women Autoworkers. Work and Occupations 9 (3): 271–98.
Gruber, James E., and Bjorn, Lars. 1986. Women's Responses to Sexual Harassment: An Analysis of Sociocultural, Organizational, and Personal Resource Models. Social Science Quarterly 67: 814–26.
Guccione, Jean. 1997. Bar Leaders Take Aim at Incivility of “Rambo” Lawyers. Los Angeles Daily Journal, April 14, 1.
Gutek, Barbara A. 1985. Sex and the Workplace: Impact of Sexual Behavior and Harassment on Women, Men, and Organizations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Gutek, Barbara A., and Morasch, Bruce. 1982. Sex-Ratios, Sex-Role Spillover, and Sexual Harassment of Women at Work. Journal of Social Issues 38: 5574.
Hackett, Rick D. 1989. Work Attitudes and Employee Absenteeism: A Synthesis of the Literature. Journal of Occupational Psychology 62: 235–48.
Hansen, Mark. 1991. Incivility a Problem, Survey Says. ABA Journal 77: 22.
Hobfoll, Stevan E., Dunahoo, Carla L., Ben-Porath, Yossef, and Monnier, Jeannine. 1994. Gender and Coping: The Dual-Axis Model of Coping. American Journal of Community Psychology, 22: 4982.
Honeywell, Mark G. 1994. How to Be on the Offensive without Being Offensive. Trial 30 (6): 86.
Huberman, Michael A., and Miles, Matthew. 1994a. Data Management and Analysis Methods. In Handbook of Qualitative Research, 428–44. Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage Publications.
Huberman, Michael A., and Miles, Matthew. 1994b. Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook. Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage Publications.
Jöreskog, Karl and Sörbom, Dag. 1996. LISREL VIII: User's Reference Guide. Chicago: Scientific Software International.
Kay, Fiona M. 1997. Flight from Law: A Competing Risks Model of Departures from Law Firms. Law and Society Review 31: 301–55.
Koss, Mary P., Goodman, Lisa A., Browne, Angela, Fitzgerald, Louise F., Puryear Keita, Gwendolyn, and Felipe Russo, Nancy. 1994. No Safe Haven: Male Violence against Women at Home, at Work, and in the Community. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association.
Laband, David N., and Lentz, Bernard F. 1998. The Effects of Sexual Harassment on Job Satisfaction, Earnings, and Turnover among Female Lawyers. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 51: 594607.
Lazarus, Richard S., and Folkman, Susan. 1984. Stress, Appraisal and Coping. New York: Springer.
Lonsway, Kimberly A., Freeman, Leslie V., Cortina, Lilia M., Magley, Vicki J., and Fitzgerald, Louise F. 2002. Understanding the Judicial Role in Addressing Gender Bias: A View from the Eighth Circuit Federal Court System. Law & Social Inquiry 27(2): 205233.
MacKinnon, Catherine. 1979. Sexual Harassment of Working Women. New Haven, Conn: Yale University Press.
McMurry, Kelly. 1996. Lawyer Incivility: War Games or Bad Manners Trial 32: 1012.
Miceli, Marcia P., and Near, Janet P. 1992. Blowing the Whistle: The Organizational and Legal Implications for Companies and Employees. New York: Lexington Books.
Miceli, Marcia P., Rehg, Michael, Near, Janet P., and Ryan, Katherine C. 1999. Can Laws Protect Whistle-Blowers? Results of a Naturally Occurring Field Experiment. Work and Occupations 26: 129–51.
Near, Janet P., Dworkin, Terry M., and Miceli, Marcia P. 1993. Explaining the Whistle-Blowing Process: Suggestions from Power Theory and Justice Theory. Organization Science 4: 393411.
Ninth Circuit Gender Bias Task Force. 1994. The Effects of Gender in the Federal Courts: The Final Report of the Ninth Circuit Gender Bias Task Force. Southern California Law Review 67: 7451106.
Ostroff, Cheri. 1992. The Relationship Between Satisfaction, Attitudes, and Performance: An Organizational Level Analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology 77: 963–74.
Padavic, Irene, and Orcutt, James D. 1997. Perceptions of Sexual Harassment in the Florida Legal System: A Comparison of Dominance and Spillover Explanations. Gender and Society 11: 682–98.
Pierce, Jennfier L. 1995. Gender Trials: Emotional Lives in Contemporary Law Firms. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Podgor, Ellen. 1996. Lawyer Professionalism in a Gendered Society. South Carolina Law Review 47 (2): 323–48.
Resnik, Judith. 1996. Asking about Gender in the Courts. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 21: 952–90.
Ring, Leonard M. 1992. The Incivility Crisis. Trial 29 (8): 78.
Schultz, Vicki. 1998. Reconceptualizing Sexual Harassment. Yale Law Journal 107: 16831805.
Sells, Benjamin. 1993. Looking in All the Wrong Places for Civility. Los Angeles Daily Journal, 106: 7.
Sidanius, James. 1993. The Psychology of Group Conflict and the Dynamics of Oppression: A Social Dominance Perspective. In Explorations in Political Psychology, ed. Lyengar, Shanto and McGuire, William J., 183219. Durham, N. C.: Duke University Press.
Smith, John Stuart. 1997. Civility in the Courtroom from a Litigator's Perspective. New York State Bar Journal, May/June, 2830.
Smith, Patricia C., Balzer, William K., Ironson, Gail H., Paul, Karen B., Bob Hayes, Sarah Moore-Hirschl, and Fernando Parra, Luis. 1992. Development and Validation of the Stress in General (SIG) Scale. Paper presented at the Seventh Annual Convention of the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology, May, Montreal, Canada.
Sullivan, Sherry E., and Bhagat, Rabi S. 1992. Organizational Stress, Job Satisfaction and Job Performance: Where Do We Go from Here Journal of Management 18: 353–74.
Tangri, Sandra S., Burt, Martha R., and Johnson, Leanor B. 1982. Sexual Harassment at Work: Three Explanatory Models. Journal of Social Issues 38: 3354.
Tinkham, Thomas W. 1990. Incivility Revisited. Bench and Bar of Minnesota 47 (7): 5.
Wallis-Honchar, Cornelia. 1997. Right to Remain Silent Can Quiet Incivility. Chicago Daily Law Bulletin 143 (87): 5.
Women's Legal Defense Fund. 1991. Sexual Harassment in the Workplace. Washington, D. C.: Women's Legal Defense Fund.
Wright, Thomas. A., and Bonnett, Douglas G. 1993. Role of Employee Coping and Performance in Voluntary Employee Withdrawal: A Research Refinement and Elaboration. Journal of Management 19: 147–61.

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed