Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c47g7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T14:21:40.369Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Jurors' Subjective Experiences of Deliberations in Criminal Cases

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Alix S. Winter  and
Matthew Clair
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Research on jury deliberations has largely focused on the implications of deliberations for criminal defendants' outcomes. In contrast, this article considers jurors' outcomes by integrating subjective experience into the study of deliberations. We examine whether jurors' feelings that they had enough time to express themselves vary by jurors' gender, race, or education. Drawing on status characteristics theory and a survey of more than 3,000 real-world jurors, we find that the majority of jurors feel that they had enough time to express themselves. However, blacks and Hispanics, and especially blacks and Hispanics with less education, are less likely to feel so. Jurors' verdict preferences do not account for these findings. Our findings have implications for status characteristics theory and for legal cynicism among members of lower-status social groups.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 43 , Issue 4 , Fall 2018 , pp. 1458 - 1490
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abramson, Jeffrey B. 1994. We, the Jury: The Jury System and the Ideal of Democracy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Albonetti, Celesta A. 1986. Criminality, Prosecutorial Screening, and Uncertainty: Toward a Theory of Discretionary Decision Making in Felony Case Processings. Criminology 24 (4): 623–44.Google Scholar
Allport, Gordon Willard. 1979. The Nature of Prejudice. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Antonio, Michael E., and Hans, Valerie P. 2001. Race and the Civil Jury: How Does a Juror's Race Shape the Jury Experience? In Psychology in the Courts, ed. Roesch, Ronald, Corrado, Raymond R., and Dempster, Rebecca, 69–82. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Balkwell, James W., and Berger, Joseph. 1996. Gender, Status, and Behavior in Task Situations. Social Psychology Quarterly 59 (3): 273–83.Google Scholar
Bell, Monica C. Forthcoming. Police Reform & the Dismantling of Legal Cynicism. Yale Law Journal. Google Scholar
Berger, Joseph M., Cohen, Bernard P., and Zelditch, Morris Jr. 1972. Status Characteristics and Social Interaction. American Sociological Review 37 (3): 241–55.Google Scholar
Berger, Joseph, Fisek, M. Hamit, Norman, Robert Z., and Zelditch, Morris Jr. 1977. Status Characteristics and Social Interaction: An Expectation-States Approach. New York: Elsevier Scientific.Google Scholar
Bobo, Lawrence D., and Johnson, Devon. 2004. A Taste for Punishment: Black and White Americans' Views on the Death Penalty and the War on Drugs. Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race 1 (01): 151–80.Google Scholar
Bobo, Lawrence D., and Thompson, Victor. 2006. Unfair by Design: The War on Drugs, Race, and the Legitimacy of the Criminal Justice System. Social Research 73 (2): 445–72.Google Scholar
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1984. Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Bradbury, Mark D., and Williams, Marian R. 2013. Diversity and Citizen Participation: The Effect of Race on Juror Decision Making. Administration & Society 45 (5): 563–82.Google Scholar
Brooks, Richard R. W., and Jeon-Slaughter, Haekyung. 2001. Race, Income, and Perceptions of the U.S. Court System. Behavioral Sciences & the Law 19 (2): 249–64.Google Scholar
Brower, Todd. 2010. Twelve Angry—and Sometimes Alienated—Men: The Experiences and Treatment of Lesbians and Gay Men During Jury Service. Drake Law Review 59:669–706.Google Scholar
Clair, Matthew, and Denis, Jeffrey S. 2015. Sociology of Racism. In The International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2nd ed., ed. Wright, James D., 19:857–63. Oxford: Elsevier.Google Scholar
Cornell, Stephen Ellicott, and Douglas, Hartmann. 2007. Ethnicity and Race: Making Identities in a Changing World. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.Google Scholar
Cornwell, Erin York. 2010. Opening and Closing the Jury Room Door: A Sociohistorical Consideration of the 1955 Chicago Jury Project Scandal. Justice System Journal 31 (1): 49–73.Google Scholar
Cornwell, Erin York, and Hans, Valerie P. 2011. Representation Through Participation: A Multilevel Analysis of Jury Deliberations. Law & Society Review 45 (3): 667–98.Google Scholar
Correll, Shelley J. 2004. Constraints into Preferences: Gender, Status, and Emerging Career Aspirations. American Sociological Review 69 (1): 93–113.Google Scholar
Correll, Shelley J., and Ridgeway, Cecilia L. 2003. Expectation States Theory. In The Handbook of Social Psychology, ed. Delamater, John, 29–51. New York: Kluwer Academic Press.Google Scholar
Crenshaw, Kimberlé. 1991. Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence Against Women of Color. Stanford Law Review 43 (6): 1241–99.Google Scholar
Cutler, Brian L., and Hughes, Donna M. 2001. Judging Jury Service: Results of the North Carolina Administrative Office of the Courts Juror Survey. Behavioral Sciences & the Law 19 (2): 305–20.Google Scholar
Devine, Dennis J. 2012. Jury Decision Making: The State of the Science. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Devine, Dennis J., Clayton, Laura D., Dunford, Benjamin B., Seying, Rasmy, and Pryce, Jennifer. 2001. Jury Decision Making: 45 Years of Empirical Research on Deliberating Groups. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 7 (3): 622–727.Google Scholar
Diamond, Shari Seidman. 1993. What Jurors Think: Expectations and Reactions of Citizens Who Serve as Jurors. In Verdict: Assessing the Civil Jury System, ed. Litan, Robert E., 282–305. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.Google Scholar
Diamond, Shari Seidman, and Rose, Mary R. 2005. Real Juries. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 1 (1): 255–84.Google Scholar
Diamond, Shari Seidman, Vidmar, Neil, Rose, Mary R., and Ellis, Leslie. 2003. Juror Discussions During Civil Trials: Studying an Arizona Innovation. Arizona Law Review 45:1–82.Google Scholar
Eisenstein, James, and Herbert, Jacob. 1977. Felony Justice: An Organizational Analysis of Criminal Courts. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
Evans, Louwanda, and Moore, Wendy Leo. 2015. Impossible Burdens: White Institutions, Emotional Labor, and Micro-Resistance. Social Problems 62 (3): 439–54.Google Scholar
Farrell, Amy, Pennington, Liana, and Cronin, Shea. 2013. Juror Perceptions of the Legitimacy of Legal Authorities and Decision Making in Criminal Cases. Law & Social Inquiry 38 (4): 773–802.Google Scholar
Feeley, Malcolm M. 1992. The Process Is the Punishment: Handling Cases in a Lower Criminal Court. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Fiske, Susan T. 2010. Interpersonal Stratification: Status, Power, and Subordination. In Handbook of Social Psychology, ed. Fiske, Susan T., Gilbert, Daniel T., and Lindzey, Gardner, Ch. 26. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.Google Scholar
Fiske, Susan T., and Markus, Hazel Rose. 2012. Facing Social Class: How Societal Rank Influences Interaction. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Fukurai, Hiroshi, and Krooth, Richard. 2003. Race in the Jury Box: Affirmative Action in Jury Selection. Albany: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
Gastil, John, Pierre Deess, E., Weiser, Philip J., and Simmons, Cindy. 2010. The Jury and Democracy: How Jury Deliberation Promotes Civic Engagement and Political Participation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Hagan, John, Shedd, Carla, and Payne, Monique R. 2005. Race, Ethnicity, and Youth Perceptions of Criminal Injustice. American Sociological Review 70 (3): 381–407.Google Scholar
Hannaford-Agor, Paula L., Hans, Valerie P., Mott, Nicole L., and Thomas Munsterman, G. 2002. Are Hung Juries a Problem? Williamsburg, VA: National Center for State Courts.Google Scholar
Harris, Alexes, Evans, Heather, and Beckett, Katherine. 2011. Courtesy Stigma and Monetary Sanctions: Toward a Socio-Cultural Theory of Punishment. American Sociological Review 76 (2): 234–64.Google Scholar
Hastie, Reid, Penrod, Steven, and Pennington, Nancy. 1983. Inside the Jury. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Hughes, Everett Cherrington. 1945. Dilemmas and Contradictions of Status. American Journal of Sociology 50 (5): 353–59.Google Scholar
Hunt, Jennifer S. 2015. Race, Ethnicity, and Culture in Jury Decision Making. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 11 (1): 269–88.Google Scholar
Jack, Anthony Abraham. 2014. Culture Shock Revisited: The Social and Cultural Contingencies to Class Marginality. Sociological Forum 29:453–75.Google Scholar
James, Rita M. 1959. Status and Competence of Jurors. American Journal of Sociology 64 (6): 563–70.Google Scholar
Jost, John T., Pelham, Brett W., and Carvallo, Mauricio R. 2002. Non-Conscious Forms of System Justification: Implicit and Behavioral Preferences for Higher Status Groups. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 38 (6): 586–602.Google Scholar
Kalvin, Harry, and Hans, Zeisel. 1966. The American Jury. Boston: Little Brown.Google Scholar
Kirk, David S., and Papachristos, Andrew V. 2011. Cultural Mechanisms and the Persistence of Neighborhood Violence. American Journal of Sociology 116 (4): 1190–1233.Google Scholar
Kramer, Greg M., Wolbransky, Melinda, and Heilbrun, Kirk. 2007. Plea Bargaining Recommendations by Criminal Defense Attorneys: Evidence Strength, Potential Sentence, and Defendant Preference. Behavioral Sciences & the Law 25 (4): 573–85.Google Scholar
Lamont, Michèle, Silva, Graziella Moraes, Welburn, Jessica, Guetzkow, Joshua, Mizrachi, Nissim, Herzog, Hannah, and Reis, Elisa. 2016. Getting Respect: Responding to Stigma and Discrimination in the United States, Brazil, and Israel. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Lareau, Annette. 2002. Invisible Inequality: Social Class and Childrearing in Black Families and White Families. American Sociological Review 67 (5): 747–76.Google Scholar
Li, Ji, Karakowsky, Leonard, and Siegel, Jacob P. 1999. The Effects of Proportional Representation on Intragroup Behavior in Mixed-Race Decision-Making Groups. Small Group Research 30 (3): 259–79.Google Scholar
Lynch, Mona, and Haney, Craig. 2015. Emotion, Authority, and Death: (Raced) Negotiations in Mock Capital Jury Deliberations. Law & Social Inquiry 40 (2): 377–405.Google Scholar
McCall, Leslie. 2005. The Complexity of Intersectionality. Signs 30 (3): 1771–1800.Google Scholar
Meeker, B. F., and Weitzel-O'Neill, P. A. 1977. Sex Roles and Interpersonal Behavior in Task-Oriented Groups. American Sociological Review 42 (1): 91–105.Google Scholar
Miller, Monica K., and Bornstein, Brian H. 2004. Juror Stress: Causes and Interventions. Thurgood Marshall Law Review 30:237–70.Google Scholar
Mills, Carol J., and Bohannon, Wayne E. 1980. Character Structure and Jury Behavior: Conceptual and Applied Implications. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 38 (4): 662–67.Google Scholar
Mize, Gregory E., Paula, Hannaford-Agor, and Waters, Nicole L. 2007. The State-of-the-States Survey of Jury Improvement Efforts: A Compendium Report. Williamsburg, VA: National Center for State Courts.Google Scholar
Moran, Gary, and Comfort, John C. 1982. Scientific Juror Selection: Sex as a Moderator of Demographic and Personality Predictors of Impaneled Felony Juror Behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 43 (5): 1052–63.Google Scholar
Muller, Christopher, and Schrage, Daniel. 2014. Mass Imprisonment and Trust in the Law. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 651 (1): 139–58.Google Scholar
Musick, Marc A., Rose, Mary R., Dury, Sarah, and Rose, Roger P. 2015. Much Obliged: Volunteering, Normative Activities, and Willingness to Serve on Juries. Law & Social Inquiry 40 (2): 433–60.Google Scholar
Overby, L. Marvin, Brown, Robert D., Bruce, John M. Jr. Smith, Charles E., and Winkle, John W. III. 2005. Race, Political Empowerment, and Minority Perceptions of Judicial Fairness. Social Science Quarterly 86 (2): 444–62.Google Scholar
Pettigrew, Thomas F. 1981. Race and Class in the 1980s: An Interactive View. Daedalus 110 (2): 233–55.Google Scholar
Ridgeway, Cecilia L. 1991. The Social Construction of Status Value: Gender and Other Nominal Characteristics. Social Forces 70 (2): 367–86.Google Scholar
Ridgeway, Cecilia L. 2014. Why Status Matters for Inequality. American Sociological Review 79 (1): 1–16.Google Scholar
Ridgeway, Cecilia L., and Berger, Joseph. 1986. Expectations, Legitimation, and Dominance Behavior in Task Groups. American Sociological Review 51 (5): 603–17.Google Scholar
Ridgeway, Cecilia L., and Kricheli-Katz, Tamar. 2013. Intersecting Cultural Beliefs in Social Relations: Gender, Race, and Class Binds and Freedoms. Gender & Society 27 (3): 294–318.Google Scholar
Ridgeway, Cecilia L., and Smith-Lovin, Lynn. 1999. The Gender System and Interaction. Annual Review of Sociology 25:191–216.Google Scholar
Rose, Mary R. 2005. A Dutiful Voice: Justice in the Distribution of Jury Service. Law & Society Review 39 (3): 601–34.Google Scholar
Rose, Mary R. 2009. Access to Juries: Some Puzzles Regarding Race and Jury Participation. In Access to Justice, ed. Sandefur, Rebecca L., 12:119–44. Bradford, UK: Emerald Group.Google Scholar
Rose, Mary R., Ellison, Christopher, and Diamond, Shari Seidman. 2008. Preferences for Juries Over Judges Across Racial and Ethnic Groups. Social Science Quarterly 89 (2): 372–91.Google Scholar
Sampson, Robert J., and Bartusch, Dawn Jeglum. 1998. Legal Cynicism and (Subcultural?) Tolerance of Deviance: The Neighborhood Context of Racial Differences. Law & Society Review 32 (4): 777–804.Google Scholar
Saperstein, Aliya, and Penner, Andrew M. 2012. Racial Fluidity and Inequality in the United States. American Journal of Sociology 118 (3): 676–727.Google Scholar
Seaman, Shaun R., Bartlett, Jonathan W., and White, Ian R. 2012. Multiple Imputation of Missing Covariates with Non-Linear Effects and Interactions: An Evaluation of Statistical Methods. BMC Medical Research Methodology 12:1–13.Google Scholar
Sharkey, Patrick. 2013. Stuck in Place: Urban Neighborhoods and the End of Progress Toward Racial Equality. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Sommers, Samuel R. 2007. Race and the Decision Making of Juries. Legal and Criminological Psychology 12 (2): 171–87.Google Scholar
Sommers, Samuel R., and Ellsworth, Phoebe C. 2003. How Much Do We Really Know About Race and Juries: A Review of Social Science Theory and Research. Chicago-Kent Law Review 78:997–1031.Google Scholar
Strodtbeck, Fred L., James, Rita M., and Hawkins, Charles. 1957. Social Status in Jury Deliberations. American Sociological Review 22 (6): 713–19.Google Scholar
Strodtbeck, Fred L., and Mann, Richard D. 1956. Sex Role Differentiation in Jury Deliberations. Sociometry 19 (1): 3–11.Google Scholar
Sugie, Naomi F. 2015. Chilling Effects: Diminished Political Participation Among Partners of Formerly Incarcerated Men. Social Problems 62 (4): 550–71.Google Scholar
Thompson, Victor R., and Bobo, Lawrence D. 2011. Thinking About Crime: Race and Lay Accounts of Lawbreaking Behavior. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 634 (1): 16–38.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., and Huo, Yuen. 2002. Trust in the Law: Encouraging Public Cooperation with the Police and Courts. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Waters, Nicole L., and Hans, Valerie P. 2009. A Jury of One: Opinion Formation, Conformity, and Dissent on Juries. Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 6 (3): 513–40.Google Scholar
Weber, Max. 1968. Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology. New York: Bedminster Press.Google Scholar
Webster, Murray Jr., and Driskell, James E. Jr. 1978. Status Generalization: A Review and Some New Data. American Sociological Review 43 (2): 220–36.Google Scholar
Weitzer, Ronald, and Tuch, Steven A. 2005. Racially Biased Policing: Determinants of Citizen Perceptions. Social Forces 83 (3): 1009–30.Google Scholar
Western, Bruce. 2006. Punishment and Inequality in America. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
White, Ian R., Royston, Patrick, and Wood, Angela M. 2011. Multiple Imputation Using Chained Equations: Issues and Guidance for Practice. Statistics in Medicine 30 (4): 377–99.Google Scholar
York, Erin, and Cornwell, Benjamin. 2006. Status on Trial: Social Characteristics and Influence in the Jury Room. Social Forces 85 (1): 455–77.Google Scholar