Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

From Punishment to Control: Assessing Juvenile Diversion in China

  • Enshen Li and Mingyue Su

Abstract

China’s juvenile justice system has grown and changed substantially since the 1980s. While considerable research focuses on institutional treatment of juvenile delinquents, little attention has been paid to the diversion processes and measures that allow troubled juveniles to be directed away from the formal justice system. Through a comparison with juvenile justice in the United States, this article aims to investigate the development of the juvenile diversion framework in China. We argue that despite their similar efforts to divert juvenile delinquents from traditional court proceedings, in practice China’s diversionary arrangements diverge from those of their US counterparts. Unlike in the United States, Chinese juvenile diversion does not operate according to welfarist or restorative models. Rather, juvenile diversion in China is a managerialism-driven scheme that rests on two key pillars: institutional diversion, which imposes punishment and control on juvenile offenders pursuant to their level of offending and dangerousness, and noninstitutional diversion, which revolves around risk-based management and correction through community-level interventions. We conclude that China’s distinctive sociolegal culture and political priorities have shaped a practice that appears to be at odds with the officially advertised narratives of the state’s juvenile justice policy.

Copyright

Corresponding author

References

Hide All
Andrews, Don A., Bonta, James, and Hoge, Robert D.. “Classification for Effective Rehabilitation Rediscovering Psychology.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 17 (1990): 1952.
Bai, Jianjun. “Looking at the Correlation between Causes of Crime, Types of Offending and Sentencing through the Crime Statistics in China (Cong zhongguo fanzuilv shuju kan zuiyin, zuixing yu xingfa de guanxi” China Social Science, no.2 (2010): 144223.
Bakken, Børge. “Crime, Juvenile Delinquency and Deterrence policy in China.” Australian Journal of Chinese Affairs 30 (1993): 2958.
Bakken, Børge. “Moral Panics, Crime Rates and Harsh Punishment in China.” Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology 37, no. 1 (2004): 6789.
Bartollas, Clemens, and Miller, Stuart. “Juvenile Justice” In Criminology. Edited by John, E. Conklin.11th ed. Boston: Prentice Hall, 2012. National Center for Juvenile Justice.
Becker, Howard S.Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance. New York: Free Press, 1963.
Bian, Jianlin, and Liao, Senlin. “Improving China’s Bail Pending Trial System: A Comparative Study Based on Practices in China Mainland, Hong Kong and Taiwan (Lun woguo qubaohoushen zhidu de wanshan – jiyu dalu, xianggang, taiwan sandi de bijiao fenxi)Legal Research 222, no. 9 (2012): 5964.
Biddulph, Sarah. Law Reform and Administrative Detention Powers in China. Melbourne: Cambridge University, 2007.
Biddulph, Sarah. “The Book Review of China Modernizes: Threat to the West and Model for the Rest?China Journal 62 (2009) 172–73.
Biddulph, Sarah. The Stability Imperative: Human Rights and Law in China. Toronto: University of British Columbia Press, 2015.
Biddulph, Sarah, Elisa Nesossi, E., Sapio, Flora, and Trevaskes, Susan. “Detention and Its Reforms in the PRC.” China Law & Society Review 2, no. 1 (2017a): 162.
Biddulph, Sarah, Nesossi, Elisa, and Trevaskes, Susan. “Criminal Justice Reform in Xi Jinping’s China.” China Law & Society Review 2, no.1 (2017b): 63128.
Binder, Arnold, and Geis, Gilbert. “Ad Populum Argumentation in Criminology: Juvenile Diversion as Rhetoric.” Crime & Delinquency 30, no. 4 (1984): 624–47.
Blackmore, John, and Welsh, Jane. “Selective Incapacitation: Sentencing According to Risk.” Crime & Delinquency 29, no. 4 (1983): 504–28
Bonta, James, and Andrews, Don A.. “Risk-Need-Responsivity Model for Offender Assessment and Rehabilitation.” Rehabilitation 6 (2007): 122.
Butts, Jeffrey A., and Travis, Jeremy. The Rise and Fall of American Youth Violence: 1980 to 2000. Washington: The Urban Institute, 2002.
Chen, Guangzhong. “Issue in the Reform of China’s Public Prosecution System against the Backdrop of New Revisions to the Criminal Procedure Law.” In Comparative Perspectives on Criminal Justice in China. Edited by McConville, Mike and Pils, Eva, 153–70. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar, 2013.
Chan, Kin-man. “Harmonious Society.” In International Encyclopedia of Civil Society. Edited by Anheier, Helmut and Toepler, Stefan, 821–25. New York: Springer, 2008.
Clark, John. “Conflict Management Outside the Courtrooms of China.” In Social Control in the People’s Republic of China. Edited by Ronald, J. Troyer, John, P. Clark, and Dean, G. Rojek, 5769. New York: Praeger, 1989.
Cocozza, Joseph J., Veysey, Bonita M., Chapin, Deborah A., Dembo, Richard, Walters, Wansley, and Farina, Sylvia. “Diversion from the Juvenile Justice System: The Miami-Dade Juvenile Assessment Center Post-arrest Diversion Program.” Substance Use & Misuse 40, no. 7 (2005): 935–51.
Cohen, Stan. “Social Control and the Politics of Reconstruction.” In The Futures of Criminology. Edited by Nelken, David, 6388. London: Sage Publications, 1994.
Cox, Steven M., Conrad, John J., and Allen, Jennifer M.. Juvenile Justice: A Guide to Theory and Practice. Boston: McGraw Hill, 2003.
Curran, Daniel J., and Cook, Sandra. “Growing Fears, Rising Crime: Juveniles and China’s Justice System.” Crime & Delinquency 39 (1993): 296315.
Davidson, William S., Redner, Robin, Blakely, Craig H., Mitchell, Christina M., and Emshoff, James G.. “Diversion of Juvenile Offenders: An Experimental Comparison.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 55, no. 1 (1987): 6875.
Duxbury, Elaine. Evaluation of Youth Service Bureaus. Sacramento, CA: California Youth Authority, 1973.
Feeley, Malcolm M., and Simon, Jonathan. “The New Penology: Notes on the Emerging Strategy of Corrections and Its Implications.” Criminology 30, no. 4 (1992): 449–74.
Feng, Chongyi. “The Dilemma of Stability Preservation in China.” Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 42, no. 2 (2013): 319.
Finley, Laura L.Juvenile Justice: Historical Guides to Controversial Issues in America. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2007.
Forest, Natasha A.The Mismeasure of Punishment: Alternative Measures of Punitiveness and Their (Substantial) Consequences.” Punishment & Society 10, no. 3 (2008): 277300.
Fouts, Jeffrey T., and Chan, Jack C. K.. “The Development of Work-Study School and School Enterprises in China’s Schools.” Journal of Curriculum Studies 29, no. 1 (1997): 3146.
Garland, David. The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press (2001).
Greenwood, Peter W., and Abrahamse, Allan. Selective Incapacitation. Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation, 1982.
Gough, Dennis. “Risk and Rehabilitation: A Fusion of Concepts?” In Risk and Rehabilitation Aaron Pycroft and Suzie Clift, 6586. Bristol, UK: The Policy Press, 2012.
Hannah-Moffat, Kelly. “Criminogenic Needs and the Transformative Risk Subject: Hybridizations of Risk/Need in Penalty.” Punishment & Society 7, no. 1 (2005): 2951.
Hawkins, J. David, and Weis, Joseph G.. “The Social Development: An Integrated Approach to Delinquency Prevention.” Journal of Primary Prevention 6, no. 2 (1985): 7397.
He, Ting, and Li, Luojia. “The Supervisory Body of Conditional Non-prosecution: Research Based on Participation and Observation.” Journal of National Prosecutors College 25, no. 3 (2017): 3349
Hockenberry, Sarah, and Puzzanchera, Charles. Juvenile Court Statistics 2014. The National Center for Juvenile Justice, 2017.
Hoge, Robert. “Application of Precharge Diversion Programs.” Criminology & Public Policy 15, no. 3 (2016): 991–99.
Holman, Barry, and Ziedenberg, Jason. The Dangers of Detention: The Impact of Incarcerating Youth in Detention and other Secure Congregate Facilities. Baltimore, MD: Annie E. Casey Foundation, 2006.
Jou, Susyan, and Hebenton, Bill. “Researching and Explaining the Punitive: Lessons and Reflections from a Comparative Empirical Study of Taiwan and England and Wales.” International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice 39, no. 1 (2011): 1236.
Jou, Susyan, Chang, Lennon, and Hebenton, Bill. Youth Justice in China. Oxford Handbooks Online, 2014.
Jiang, Zuzhen, Song, Qiuying, and Zhang, Kai. “The Empirical Analysis of the Correctional Effectiveness on Community-Based Convicts and Its Relevant Factors (Shequ fuxing renyuan jiaozheng xiaoguo jiqi xiangguan yinsu shizheng.” Justice of China 5 (2017): 3844.
Kammer, James J., Minor, Kevin I., and Wells, James B.. “An Outcome Study of the Diversion Plus Program for Juvenile Offenders.” Federal Probation 61 (1997): 5156.
Kohler-Hausmann, Issa. “Managerial Justice and Mass Misdemeanors.” Stanford Law Review 66, no. 3 (2014): 611–94.
Lacey, Nicola. “Punishment (Neo)liberalism and Social Democracy.” In The SAGE Handbook of Punishment and Society. Edited by Simon, Jonathan and Sparks, Richard, 261–80. London: Sage Publications, 2013.
Lacey, Nicola, and Soskice, David. “American Exceptionalism in Crime, Punishment, and Disadvantage: Race, Federalization, and Politicization in the Perspective of Local Autonomy.” In American Exceptionalism in Crime and Punishment. Edited by Kevin, R. Reitz, 53102. New York: Oxford University Press, 2018.
Law Yearbook of China. The National Statistics on Juvenile Crimes Handled by Courts. China Law Society, 2009–2016.
Lemert, Edwin M.Instead of Court: Diversion in Juvenile Justice. National Institute of Mental Health, Center for Studies of Crime and Delinquency, 1971.
Lemert, Edwin M.Diversion in Juvenile Justice: What Hath Been Wrought?Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 18, no. 1 (1981): 3446.
Lewis, Margaret K.Leniency and Severity in China’s Death Penalty Debate.” Columbia Journal of Asian Law 24, no. 2 (2011): 304–32.
Li, Enshen. Punishment in Contemporary China: Its Evolution, Development and Change. New York: Routledge, 2018
Li, Siwen., Xu, Diwei, Diwei, Kai He, and Chen, Yi. “Re-evaluation of Work and Study Schools: It Can Change Troubled Students, but Parents Say No to Enrollment (Gongdu xuexiao zai shenshi: neng gaibian wenti xuesheng, ke jiazhang jujue songlai).” Pengpai News, December 30, 2016.
Li, Zhijie. The Study on Detention for Reformation in China (Zhongguo shourong jiaoyang zhidu). Beijing: Law Press, 2016.
Liu, Alan P. L.Opinions and Attitudes of Youth in the People’s Republic of China.” Asian Survey 24, no. 9 (1984): 975–96.
Liu, R. W.The Light and Thread of Law (Falv de dengshen). Beijing: Democracy and Law Press, 2012.
Liu, Yan. “Exploring the Contemporary Value of Work and Study Schools through a Historical and Educational View (Cong gongduxuexiao jiaoyu lishi fazhan tanjiu qi shidai jiazhi).” Juvenile Delinquency Prevention Research 3 (2018): 415.
Lo, T. Wing, Maxwell, Gabrielle M., and Wong, Dennis S. W.. “Diversion from Youth Courts in Five Asia Pacific Jurisdictions: Welfare or Restorative Solutions.” International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 50, no. 1 (2006): 520.
Lv, Yiwei,. and Xie, Wei. “The Deficiency and Resolution of the Current Bangjiao System Involving Juvenile Offenders (Dangqian shezui weichengnianren guanhu bangjiao zhidu de queshi yu duice).” Legal System and Society 8 (2013): 4955.
Matthew, Roger, “The Myth of Punitiveness.” Theoretical Criminology 9, no. 2 (2005): 175201.
Meng, Aaron., Segal, Roland, and Boden, Eric. “American Juvenile Justice System: History in the Making.” International Journal of Adolescent Medicine Health 25, no. 3 (2013): 275–78.
Muncie, John. “The Deinstitutionalization of Juvenile and Young Offenders in Victoria, Australia.” International Social Work 34, no. 3 (1991): 229–50.
Niedzwiecki, Emily, Irazola, Seri, Churchill, Caitlin, and Field, Michael. Massachusetts Juvenile Diversion Assessment Study. Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, 2015.
Petit, Philip. “Is Criminal Justice Politically Feasible?Buffalo Criminal Law Review 5, no. 2 (2001): 427–50
Polk, Kenneth, Alder, Christine, Muller, Damon, and Rechtman, Katherine. “Early Intervention: Diversion and Youth Conferencing: A National Profile and Review of Current Approaches to Diverting Juveniles from the Criminal Justice System.Canberra, Australia: Australian Department of the Attorney-General, 2003.
Puzzanchera, Charles, and Hockenberry, Sarah. National Disproportionate Minority Contact Databook. The National Center for Juvenile Justice for the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, 2018.
Rausch, Sharla. “Court Processing Versus Diversion of Status Offenders: A Test of Deterrence and Labeling Theories.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 20, no. 1 (1983): 3954.
Ray, James V. and Childs, Kristina. “Juvenile Diversion.” In The Handbook of Juvenile Delinquency and Juvenile Justice. Edited by Marvin, D. Krohn and Lane, Jodi, 422–28. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2015.
Roberts, Albert R.Emergence and Proliferation of Juvenile Diversion Programs.” In Juvenile Justice Sourcebook: Past, Present and Future. Edited by Albert, R. Roberts, 183–95. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.
Ryan, Liz. “Youth in the Adult Criminal Justice System.” Cardozo Law Review 35 (2014): 1167–84.
Shaw, Victor N.Corrections and Punishment in China: Information and Analysis.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 26, no. 1 (2010): 5371.
Shen, Anqi. “The Role of the Study-Work School: A Chinese Case Study on Early Intervention and Child-Centered Juvenile Justice.” Youth Justice 16, no. 2 (2016): 95112.
Shen, Anqi, and Hall, Steve. “The Same the Whole World over? A Review Essay on Youth Offending from the 1980s and Youth Justice in Contemporary China.” International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice 54, no. 2 (2015): 273–91.
Shi, Yanfang. “Why Juvenile Crimes Occur Frequently: A New Investigation Exploring the Reasons of Juvenile Crime (Qingshaonian fanzui heyi pinfa: woguo qingshaonian fanzui yuanyin xintan).” The Issue on Juvenile Delinquency 1 (2014): 4145.
Simon, Jonathan. Governing through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear. New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.
Singer, Simon I.Recriminalizing Delinquency: Violent Juvenile Crime and Juvenile Justice Reform. New York: Oxford University Press, 1996.
Sullivan, Christopher J., Dollard, Norin, Sellers, Brian, and Mayo, John. “Rebalancing Response to School-Based Offenses: A Civil Citation Program.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice 8, no. 4 (2010): 279–94.
Trevaskes, Susan. “The Shifting Sands of Punishment in China in the Era of ‘Harmonious Society.’” Law & Policy 32, no. 3 (2010): 332–61.
Trevaskes, Susan. “Rationalising Stability Preservation through Mao’s Not So Invisible Hand.” Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 42, no. 2 (2013): 5177.
Wacquant, Loïc. Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2009.
Wang, Mu. “Juvenile Justice System Is a Significant Strategic Approach to Preventing and Reducing Crimes (Shaonian sifa zhidu shi guojia yufang he jianshao fanzui de zhongda zhanlv cuoshi).” Issues on Juvenile Crimes and Delinquency 1 (2007): 7374.
Wang, Ran. “The Institutional Construction and Supervisory Model of Conditional Non-prosecution (Futiaojian buqisu de kaocha moshi yu jizhi jiangou).” In The Theory and Practice of Conditional Non-prosecution. Edited by Shengming, Miao and Wensheng, Ye, 8499. Beijing: Law Press, 2015.
Wei, Hongqian. “Thirty Years of Juvenile Prosecution: Why Shanghai Is Taking the Lead? (Weijian gongzuo 30nian: Shanghai weihe yaoyao lingxian).” Procuratorial Daily, June 15 2016.
Whitehead, John T., and Lab, Steven P.. Juvenile Justice: An Introduction. New York: Routledge, 2001.
Wilson, Holly A., and Hoge, Robert D.. “The Effect of Youth Diversion Programs on Recidivism: A Meta-Analytic Review.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 40, no. 5 (2013): 497518.
Wong, Dennis S.W.Delinquency Control and Juvenile Justice in China.” Australia & New Zealand Journal of Criminology 32, no. 1 (1999): 2741.
Wong, Kam C.Chinese Policing: History and Reform. New York: Peter Lang Publishing, 2009.
Xiong, Wei. “The Problems Facing China’s Work and Study Education and Their Solutions (Woguo gongdu jiaoyu mianlin de wenti yu duiceIssues on Juvenile Crime and Delinquency 5 (2011): 4144.
Xu, Jianhua. “Legitimization Imperative: The Production of Crime Statistics in Guangzhou, China.” British Journal of Criminology 58, no. 1 (2018): 155–76.
Xu, Zhilin., and Liu, Yejie. “The Study on the Development Strategy for Shanghai Work and Study Education (Shanghai gongdu jiaoyu fazhan celv yanjiu).” Journal of Shanghai Police College 6 (2009): 6571.
Yao, Jianlong. Doctrinal Analysis and Program Design of Juvenile Courts (Shaonian fayuan de xueli lunzheng yu fangan sheji). Shanghai: Shanghai Social Science Institute Press, 2014.
Yao, Jianlong., and Sun, Jian. “From ‘Work and Study’ to ‘Specialized’—The Plight and Way Out of Work and Study Schools in China (Cong ‘gongdu’ dao ‘zhuanmen’—woguo gongdu jiaoyu de kunjin yu chulu).” Juvenile Delinquency Prevention Research 2 (2017): 4656.
Yao, Wanqin. “Detention for Reformation: Its status quo, Problems and Solutions (Weichengnianren shourong jiaoyang zhidu: xianzhuang, wenti yu wanshan duice).” Legal Forum 2 (2017): 4549.
Yue, Huiqing. “Reforming the System of Juvenile Prosecution in the Context of Judicial Reforms (Sifa gaige beijingxia de weichengnianren jiancha tizhi gaige).” Issues on Juvenile Crimes and Delinquency 1 (2015): 7581.
Zhang, Hongwei., and Lu, Saihuan. “The Investigation and Thinking of Detention for Reformation— Empirical Analysis on Data Collected in Province G (Weichengnianren Shourong Jiaoyang de diaocha yu sikao – jiyu G sheng de shizheng fenxiJournal of Shandong Police College 4 (2012): 3945.
Zhang, Hongwei, and He, Ni “Phil”. “Status, Issues, and Challenges of Chinese Juvenile Justice.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 34, no. 2 (2018): 219–29.
Zhang, Lening. “Juvenile Delinquency and Justice in Contemporary China: A Critical Review of the Literature over 15 Years.” Crime, Law and Social Change 50, no. 3 (2008): 149–60.
Zhang, Lening, Zhou, Dengke, Messner, Steven F., Liska, Allen E., Krohn, Marvin D., Liu, Jianhong, and Lu, Zhou. “Crime Prevention in a Communitarian Society: Bang-jiao and Tiao-jie in the People’s Republic of China.” Justice Quarterly 13, no. 2 (1996): 199222.
Zhao, Ruohui, Zhang, Hongwei, and Liu, Jianhong. “China’s Juvenile Justice: A System in Transition.” In Juvenile Justice: International Perspectives, Models, and Trends. Edited by John, A. Winterdyk, 137–62. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2015.
Zhou, Ying. “The Plight and Re-building of the System of Work and Study Schools in China (Woguo qingshaonian gongdu jiaoyu zhidu de kunjing yu chonggou).” Issues on Juvenile Crimes and Delinquency 5 (2017): 3339.
Zhu, Jie. The Empirical Research on the Supervisory System of Conditional Non-prosecution (Futiaojian buqisu jiandu kaocha zhidu shizheng yanjiu). Master’s Thesis. Southwest University of Political Science & Law, 2014.
Zimring, Franklin E.The Common Thread: Diversion in Juvenile Justice.” California Law Review 88, no. 6 (2000): 2477–96.
Zimring, Franklin E.American Juvenile Justice. New York: Oxford University Press, 2005.

From Punishment to Control: Assessing Juvenile Diversion in China

  • Enshen Li and Mingyue Su

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.