Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T10:44:22.408Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Usos y Costumbres and Postelectoral Conflicts in Oaxaca, Mexico, 1995-2004: An Empirical and Normative Assessment

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 September 2022

Todd A. Eisenstadt
Todd A. Eisenstadt*
Affiliation:
American University
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

This article evaluates postelector al conflicts in Mexico’s Oaxaca state before and after the state government legally recognized usos y costumbres—local leader selection via traditional practices (rather than parties and secret ballots). Assessing usos y costumbres within the normative debate between multiculturalists and pluralists on incorporation of ethnic minorities, the article compares the level of postelectoral conflict in usos y costumbres and non-usos y costumbres municipalities. It argues that since such conflicts have increased in Oaxaca over the last decade while simultaneously diminishing dramatically in Mexico’s other 31 states, the cause is probably unique to Oaxaca. Conflict may be at least partially attributed to perverse implementation incentives created by the law’s provocation of conflicts requiring mediation (rather than judicial verdicts). While further research is needed to test normative claims that usos y costumbres increase governing institutions’ credibility and foster positive group identities, the article concludes that while the customary practices “experiment” has failed at least by one criterion, it may warrant reconsideration if customary elections can be viewed as a set of evolving, instrumental processes, rather than as fixed, static, and essentialist conditions.

Resumo

Resumo

Este artículo compara los conflictos postelector ales en el estado mexicano de Oaxaca antes y después del reconocimiento legal de “usos y costumbres,” es decir, de la selección de dirigentes locales a través de prácticas tradicionales, a oposición de prácticas basadas en partidos políticos y voto secreto. Analizando los usos y costumbres dentro del debate normativo que multicul- turalistas y pluralistas han sostenido sobre la incorporación de minorías étnicas, el artículo compara el nivel de conflictividad en municipios donde se ejerce la práctica de usos y costumbres, y en municipios donde no se ejerce. En este trabajo se argumenta que, dado que los conflictos postelectorales han aumentado en Oaxaca durante la última década, y han disminuido dramáticamente en los otros 31 estados de México, las causas del aumento de conflictividad se encuentran exclusivamente en Oaxaca. La conflictividad puede ser atribuida, al menos parcialmente, a la implementación perversa de incentivos que motivan conflictos que requieren mediación (y no conflictos que pueden ser solucionados por veredictos jurídicos). Sostengo que es necesaria más investigación para poder comprobar normativamente que los usos y costumbres aumentan la credibilidad de las instituciones gubernamentales y fortalecen las identidades colectivas. Este artículo concluye que, aunque el éxito de los usos y costumbres ha sido limitado, al menos bajo el criterio de conflictividad, posiblemente, merezca la pena reconsiderarlo si se observan a las elecciones consuetudinarias como procesos instrumentalistas en evolución, y no como condiciones estáticas y esencialistas.

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Research Review , Volume 42 , Issue 1 , February 2007 , pp. 52 - 77
Copyright
Copyright © 2007 by the University of Texas Press

Footnotes

1.

The author thanks Moisés Jaime Bailón Corres, David Recondo, and Viridiana Ríos Contreras and several anonymous reviewers for comments and acknowledges research support from a United States Agency for International Development (USAID) Higher Education and Development Program grant and American University’s School of Public Affairs (SPA). The conclusions reached and any errors are the author’s alone.

References

References

Anaya-Muñoz, Alejandro 2002 “Governability and Legitimacy in Mexico: The Legalisation of Indigenous Electoral Institutions in Oaxaca.” Department of Government, University of Essex, Ph.D. thesis.Google Scholar
Aquino Moreschi, Alejandra 2002 “Acción colectiva, autonomía y conflicto: La reinvención de la identidad entre los Zapotecas de la Sierra Juárez.” Department of Sociology, Instituto de Investigaciones Dr. José María Luís Mora, M.A. thesis.Google Scholar
Aziz Nassif, Alberto and Horcasitas, Juan Molinar 1990 “Los resultados electorales.” In Casanova, Pablo González, ed. Segundo informe sobre la democracia: México el 6 de Julio de 1988. Mexico City: Siglo Veintiuno Editores. 138–171.Google Scholar
Bailón Corres, Moisés Jaime 2006 “Las reformas constitucionales indígenas de 2001 en México: Avances nacionales y regionales a cinco años de su apropación.” Paper presented at the 2006 meeting of the Latin American Studies Association, March 15-18 (San Juan, PR).Google Scholar
Barry, Brian 2001 Culture and Equality: An Egalitarian Critique of Multiculturalism. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. 293–328.Google Scholar
Benhabib, Seyla 2002 The Claims of Culture: Equality and Diversity in the Global Era. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Manaus, Benitez, Raúl, Andrew Selee, and Arnson, Cynthia J. 2005 “Frozen Negotiations: The Peace Process in Chiapas.” Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos 22 (1): 131–51.Google Scholar
Benton, Allyson Lucinda 2006 “The Effects of Electoral Rules on Indigenous Voting Behavior in Mexico.” Paper presented at the 2006 meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, April 19-23 (Chicago).Google Scholar
Burguete Cal y Mayor, Araceli 2004 “Ayuntamientos indígenas de facto en el Chiapas postzapatista (1994-2004): Una tipología.” Paper presented at the XXI meeting of the Latin American Studies Association, October 9. (Las Vegas, NV).Google Scholar
Chance, John K. 1986 “Colonial Ethnohistory of Oaxaca.” In Ethnohistory: Supplement to the Handbook of Middle American Indians. Volume 4, edited by Spores, Ronald, 165–89. Austin: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Collier, George Α., with Quaratiello, Elizabeth Lowery 1999 Basta! Land and the Zapatista Rebellion in Chiapas. Oakland: Food First Books.Google Scholar
Consejo Nacional de Población 2005 Indicadores demográficas básicas. At http://www.conapo.gob.mx (accessed June 27, 2005).Google Scholar
De Vos, Jan 2002 Una tierra para sembrar sueños: Historia redente de la Selva Lacandona, 1950-2000. Mexico City: Centro de Investigaciones y Estudios Superiores en Antropología Social/Fonda de Cultura Económica.Google Scholar
Dennis, Philip A. 1987 Intervillage Conflict in Oaxaca. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Díaz Montes, Fausto 1992 Los municipios: La lucha por el poder local en Oaxaca. Oaxaca City: Instituto de Investigaciones Sociales-UABJO/Gobierno del Estado de Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Eisenstadt, Todd Α. 2004 Courting Democracy in Mexico: Party Strategies and Electoral Institutions. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Electoral Tribunal of the Judicial Power of the Federation 2001 Elección de Concejales al Ayuntamiento del Municipio de Asunción Tlacolulita, Estado de Oaxaca, por Usos y Costumbres. Mexico City: Tribunal Electoral del Poder Judicial de la Federación.Google Scholar
Federal Institute for Information Access (IFAI) 2005 Legislación estatal en materia de transparencia. Available at http://www.ifai.org.mx/test/eym/estatales.htm (accessed August 2006).Google Scholar
Fox, Jonathan 2002 “La relación recíproca entre la participación ciudadana y la rendición de cuentas: La experiencia de los fondos municipales en el México rural.” Política y Gobierno 9 (1): 95–133.Google Scholar
Fox, Jonathan, and Rivera-Salgado, Gaspar 2004 Indigenous Mexican Migrants in the United States, edited by Jonathan, Fox and Rivera-Salgado, Gaspar. La Jolla: Center for U.S.-Mexican Studies, University of California, San Diego.Google Scholar
González Compeán, Miguel, and Lomeli, Leonardo 2000 El Partido de la Revolución: Institución y conflicto (1928-1999). Mexico City: Fondo de Cultura Económica.Google Scholar
Goodman, Gary L., and Hiskey, Jonathan T. 2006 “The Participation Paradox of Local Autonomy: Voter Turnout in Usos Municipalities in Oaxaca, Mexico.” Paper presented at the 2006 Meeting of the Latin American Studies Association, March 15-18 (San Juan, PR).Google Scholar
Greenberg, James B. 1989 Blood Ties: Life and Violence in Rural Mexico. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.Google Scholar
Pulido, Guerra, Melisa, Maira 2000 “Usos y costumbres o partidos políticos: Una decision de los municipios oaxaquenos.” Undergraduate thesis in political science, Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económicas (CIDE), Mexico City.Google Scholar
Hernández Castillo, Aida 2002 “National Law and Indigneous Customary Law: The Struggle for Justice of Indigenous Women of Chiapas.” In Gender, Justice Development, and Rights, edited by Molyneux, Maxine and Razavi, Shahra, 384–413. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/0199256454.003.0012CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Templos, Ibarra, Mayek, Yuribi 2003 “Espacios alternativos de poder: Participación de las mujeres en una comunidad transnacional.” Undergraduate thesis in social anthropology, Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana—Unidad Iztapalapa, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional para el Federalismo y el Desarrollo Municipal 2003 Sistema Nacional de Información Municipal, versión 7. Mexico City: Instituto Nacional para el Federalismo y el Desarrollo Municipal. CD-ROM and also available at www.inafed.gob.mx (access August 2006).Google Scholar
Kearney, Michael, and Besserer, Francisco 2004 “Oaxacan Municipal Governance in Transnational Context,” in Indigenous Mexican Migrants in the United States, edited by Jonathan, Fox and Rivera-Salgado, Gaspar, 449–466. La Jolla: Center for U.S.-Mexican Studies, University of California, San Diego.Google Scholar
Kymlicka, Will 1995 Multicultural Citizenship. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Madrid, Raúl 2003 “Indigenous Voters and Party System Fragmentation in Latin America.” Paper presented at the Latin American Studies Association meeting in Dallas, Texas.Google Scholar
Martínez, Víctor Leonel Juan 2000 “Yalalag: Historia de una violenta lucha indígena.” In En Marcha—Realidad Municipal de Oaxaca 3 (16): (April) 5–9.Google Scholar
Mattiace, Shannan L. 2003 To See with Two Eyes: Peasant Activism and Indian Autonomy in Chiapas, Mexico. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.Google Scholar
Minnesota Advocates for Human Rights and the Heartland Alliance for Human Needs and Human Rights 1996 The Rule of Lawlessness in Mexico: Human Rights Violations in the State of Oaxaca. Minneapolis: Minnesota Advocates for Human Rights and the Heartland Alliance for Human Needs and Human Rights.Google Scholar
Morales Canales, Lourdes 2003 “Conflicto electoral y cambio social: El caso de San Miguel Quetzaltepec, Mixes.” Unpublished manuscript.Google Scholar
Oaxaca State Legislature 1993 “Registry of Legislative Decrees,” vol. 13, 1992–1995.Google Scholar
Zago, Osorio, Javier, Francisco 2004 “Protesta Poselectoral en municipios de usos y costumbres en Oaxaca, 1992-1998.” Undergraduate thesis in political science, Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económicas (CIDE), Mexico City.Google Scholar
Pichardo Peña, David 2001 “Migración y cambio sociocultural en la zapoteca sur, Oaxaca.” Undergraduate thesis in social anthropology, Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana—Unidad Iztapalapa, Mexico City. Typescript.Google Scholar
Pineda, Luz Olivia 2002 “Maestros Bilingues, Burocracia y Poder Político en los Altos de Chiapas,” in Chiapas: Los Rumbos de Otra Historia, edited by Viqueira, Juan Pedro and Ruz, Mario Humberto, 279–300. Mexico City: Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.Google Scholar
Recondo, David 2001 “Usos y costumbres, procesos electorales y autonomía indígena en Oaxaca,” in Costumbres, leyes y movimiento indio en Oaxaca y Chiapas, edited by Pasquel, Lourdes de León, 91–113. Mexico City: Centro de Investigaciones y Estudios Superiores en Antropología Social and Miguel Ángel Porrúa.Google Scholar
Recondo, David 2006 “Las costumbres de la democracias: Multiculturalismo y democratización en Oaxaca.” Paper presented at the 2006 Meeting of the Latin American Studies Association, March 15-18 (San Juan, Puerto Rico).Google Scholar
Ríos Contreras, Viridiana 2006 “Conflictividad postelectoral en los usos y costumbres de Oaxaca.” Undergraduate thesis in political science, Instituto Tecnológico Autónomo de México (ITAM).Google Scholar
Rus, Jan 1994 “The ‘Comunidad Revolucionaria Institutional’: The Subversion of Native Government in Highland Chiapas, 1936-168,” in Everyday Forms of State Formation: Revolution and the Negotiation of Rule in Modern Mexico, edited by Joseph, Gilbert M. and Nugent, Daniel, 265–300. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Rus, Jan, Castillo, Aída Hernández, and Mattiace, Shannon L., eds. 2003 Mayan Lives, Mayan Utopias: The Indigenous Peoples of Chiapas and the Zapatista Revolution. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, Inc.Google Scholar
Sarabia, Ernesto, and Verónica Galán 2005 “Vive país de remesas y gobierno del crudo.” Reforma, May 11, A–1.Google Scholar
Servicios para una Educación Alternativa, A.C. 2004 Informe — Observación Electoral en Municipios Indígenas que se Rigen por Sistemas Normativos Internos, Oaxaca 2004. Oaxaca City: Servicios para una Educación Alternativa, A.C.Google Scholar
Servicios para una Educación Alternativa, A.C. and Comisión Diocesana de Pastoral Social 2002 Informe de Observación Electoral en Municipios de Usos y Costumbres, Oaxaca 2001. Oaxaca City: Servicios para una Educación Alternativa, A.C. and Comisión Diocesana de Pastoral Social.Google Scholar
Taylor, Charles, Appiah, Kwame Anthony, Habermas, Jurgen, Rockefeller, Stephen C., Walzer, Michael, and Wolf, Susan 1994 Multiculturalism: Examining the Politics of Recognition. Edited by Gutmann, Amy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Tribunal Electoral del Poder Judicial de la Federación 2001 Colección Sentencias Relevantes No. 4: Elección de Concejales al Ayuntamiento del Municipio de Asunción Tlacolulita, Estado de Oaxaca, por Usos y Costumbres (Caso Oaxaca). Mexico City: Tribunal Electoral del Poder Judicial de la Federación.Google Scholar
Van Cott, Donna Lee 2003 “Institutional Change and Ethnic Parties in South America.” Latin American Politics and Society 45 (2): (summer) 1–39.Google Scholar
VanWey, Leah K., Tucker, Catherine M., and McConnell, Eileen Diaz 2005 “Community Organization, Migration, and Remittances in Oaxaca.” Latin American Research Review 40 (1): 83–107.10.1353/lar.2005.0016CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Velásquez, María Cristina 2000 El nombramiento—Las elecciones por usos y costumbres en Oaxaca. Oaxaca City: Instituteo Estatal Electoral de Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Velásquez, María Cristina 2004 “Migrant Communities, Gender, and Political Power in Oaxaca,” in Indigenous Mexican Migrants in the United States, edited by Jonathan, Fox and Rivera-Salgado, Gaspar. La Jolla: Center for U.S.-Mexican Studies, University of California, San Diego.Google Scholar
Velásquez, María Cristina, et al. 1997 Usos y costumbres para la renovación de los ayuntamientos de Oaxaca. Oaxaca City: Centro de Investigaciones y Estudios Superiores de Antropologia Social/Instituto Estatal Electoral de OaxacaGoogle Scholar

INTERVIEWS

Aguilar, Hugo 2005 Lawyer for Servicios al Pueblo Míxe legal advocacy group. May 12. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca. Alcántara Guzmán, Armando, Oaxaca delegate of the Commission of Indigenous Rights (CDI). July 17. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Aquino Maldonado, Joel 2004 Leader of Zapoteco indigenous rights movement. July 24. Villa Hidalgo Yalalag, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Bautista, Emilio 2004 Zapoteco critic of usos y costumbres, Villa Hidalgo Yalalag, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Castillo Peraza, Carlos 1996 Former national PAN president. August 16. Mexico City, D.F.Google Scholar
Cortés López, Elias 1998 Oaxaca PRI sub-secretary of elections. November 26. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Cruz López, Oscar 1998 PRD state legislator. July 20. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Flores Cruz, Cipriano 2004, 2005 Advisor to the PRI and ex-director of the Oaxaca State Electoral Institute. July 22 and May 17. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Gómez Hernandez, Caralampios 2004 Director of Emiliano Zapata Proletariat Organization (OPEZ). July 28. Tuxtla Gutierrez, Chiapas.Google Scholar
Pacheco, Jiménez, José, Juan 1998 Director of usos y costumbres section of Oaxaca Electoral Institute. November 24. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
López, Eric 1998 Advisor to the Secretary of Government, Oaxaca State Government. November 24. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
López López, Leovijildo 2005 Secretary for Doctrine and Policy, Oaxaca state chapter of the National Action Party (PAN). May 12. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Martínez Luna, Jaime 2005 Anthropologist. May 14. Gelatao, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Méndez, Sara 2005 Human rights activist at Centro Derechos Humanos Tierra del Sol in Tlaxi-aco. May 15. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Moreno Alcantara, Carlos 1998 PAN representative to the Oaxaca Electoral Institute. November 24. Oaxaca City, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Zenon Flores, Anastasia 2004 Tortilla factory owner and womens’ rights advocate. July 24. Asunción Tlacolulita, Oaxaca.Google Scholar