Skip to main content Accessibility help

A Two-Level Theory of Presidential Instability

  • Aníbal Pérez-Liñán (a1)


This article analyzes the conditions that facilitate the ousting of Latin American presidents and the mechanisms that prevent their downfall. Drawing lessons from the impeachment of Paraguayan president Fernando Lugo, it extends previous arguments about the “legislative shield” to show that the same forces that sometimes conspire to terminate an administration at other times work to resist its demise. The argument underscores the interaction between legislators and social movements, two prominent actors in the literature on presidential instability. The article presents a two-level theory to identify possible configurations of mass and legislative alignments, and tests some implications of the theory with data for 116 Latin American presidents over 28 years. Multiple comparison tests based on random effects logistic models show that popular protests can be neutralized by strong support in Congress, and hint at the possibility that legislative threats can be neutralized by loyal demonstrators in the streets.



Hide All
ABC Color (Asunción). 2012. Editorial: a Lugo le faltó tiempo para emplear su fórmula salvadora. August 20.
Abente-Brun, Diego. 2009. Paraguay: the Unraveling of One-Party Rule. Journal of Democracy 20, 1: 143–56.
Alvarez, Michael E., and Marsteintredet, Leiv. 2010. Presidential and Democratic Breakdowns in Latin America: Similar Causes, Different Outcomes. In Llanos and Marsteintredet 2010. 3352.
Bosoer, Fabián. 2006. ¿Crisis con salvataje? Una hipótesis sobre el componente parlamentario en el auto-rescate de las democracias sudamericanas: 1999–2004. In Instituciones, democracia e integración regional en el Mercosur, ed. Alberti, Giorgio, Llenderrozas, Elsa, and Pinto, Julio. Buenos Aires: Bononiae Libris-Prometeo.
Braumoeller, Bear F., and Goertz, Gary. 2000. The Methodology of Necessary Conditions. American Journal of Political Science 44, 4: 844–58.
Buitrago, Miguel A. 2010. Civil Society, Social Protest, and Presidential Breakdowns in Bolivia. In Llanos and Marsteintredet 2010. 91107.
Carey, John. 2005. Presidential Versus Parliamentary Government. In Handbook of New Institutional Economics, ed. Menard, Claude and Shirley, Mary M.. Dordrecht: Springer. 91122.
Carlin, Ryan E., Martínez-Gallardo, Cecilia, and Hartlyn, Jonathan. 2012. Executive Approval Dynamics Under Alternative Democratic Regime Types. In Problems Confronting Contemporary Democracies: Essays in Honor of Alfred Stepan, ed. Chalmers, Douglas and Mainwaring, Scott. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Villagra, Cerna, Patricia, Sarah, and Mario Solís Delgadillo, Juan. 2012. La crisis institucional paraguaya de 2012 a la luz de las élites parlamentarias. Boletín Elites Parlamentarias Latinoamericanas 42. Accessed November 2012.
Clark, William Robert, Gilligan, Michael J., and Golder, Matt. 2006. A Simple Multivariate Test for Asymmetric Hypotheses. Political Analysis 14, 3: 311–31.
Collier, David, and Mahon, James E.. 1993. Conceptual Stretching Revisited: Adapting Categories in Comparative Analysis. American Political Science Review 87, 4: 845–55.
Collier, David, and Levitsky, Steven. 1997. Democracy with Adjectives: Conceptual Innovation in Comparative Research. World Politics 49, 3: 430–51.
Conaghan, Catherine M. 2012. Prosecuting Presidents: the Politics within Ecuador's Corruption Cases. Journal of Latin American Studies 44, 4: 649–78.
Dion, Douglas. 1998. Evidence and Inference in the Comparative Case Study. Comparative Politics 30, 2: 127–46.
Esarey, Justin, and Lawrence, Jane. 2012. Testing Interaction Hypotheses: Determining and Controlling the False Positive Rate. Working Paper. July 14. St. Louis: Society for Political Methodology, Washington University St. Louis. Accessed October 2012.
Figueiredo, Argelina Cheibub. 2010. The Collor Impeachment and Presidential Government in Brazil. In Llanos and Marsteintredet 2010. 111–27.
Carreras, Fretes, Antonio, Luis. 2012. La consolidación democrática en Paraguay. América Latina Hoy 60: 6782.
George, Alexander L., and Bennett, Andrew. 2005. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Goertz, Gary. 2006. Social Science Concepts: A User's Guide. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Goertz, Gary, and Mahoney, James. 2005. Two-Level Theories and Fuzzy-Set Analysis. Sociological Methods and Research 33, 4: 497538.
Hanmer, Michael J., and Kalkan, Kerem Ozan. 2013. Behind the Curve: Clarifying the Best Approach to Calculating Predicted Probabilities and Marginal Effects from Limited Dependent Variable Models. American Journal of Political Science 57, 1: 263–77.
Hartlyn, Jonathan. 1984. Military Governments and the Transition to Civilian Rule: the Colombian Experience of 1957–1958. Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs 26, 2 (Summer): 245–81.
Helmke, Gretchen. 2006. Explaining Institutional Instability in Latin America: a Crisis Bargaining Approach. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association, Philadelphia, August 31–September 3.
Helmke, Gretchen. 2010. The Origins of Institutional Crises in Latin America. American Journal of Political Science 54, 3: 737–50.
Hochstetler, Kathryn. 2006. Rethinking Presidentialism: Challenges and Presidential Falls in South America. Comparative Politics 38, 4: 401–18.
Hochstetler, Kathryn. 2011. The Fates of Presidents in Post-Transition Latin America: from Democratic Breakdown to Impeachment to Presidential Breakdown. Journal of Politics in Latin America 3, 1: 125–41.
Hochstetler, Kathryn, and Samuels, David. 2011. Crisis and Rapid Reequilibration: the Consequences of Presidential Challenge and Failure in Latin America. Comparative Politics 43, 2: 127–45.
Hochstetler, Kathryn, and Edwards, Margaret E.. 2009. Failed Presidencies: Identifying and Explaining a South American Anomaly. Journal of Politics In Latin America 1, 2: 3157.
Johnson, Gregg B., and Schwindt-Bayer, Leslie A.. 2009. Economic Accountability in Central America. Journal of Politics in Latin America 1, 3: 3356.
Kada, Naoko. 2003. Impeachment as a Punishment for Corruption? The Cases of Brazil and Venezuela. In Checking Executive Power: Presidential Impeachment in Comparative Perspective, ed. Baumgartner, J. C. and Kada, . Westport: Praeger. 113–35.
Kim, Young Hun, and Bahry, Donna. 2008. Interrupted Presidencies in Third Wave Democracies. Journal of Politics 70, 3: 807–22.
Landaburu, Juan. 2012. Los errores propios y las ambiciones ajenas. La Nación (Buenos Aires), June 22: 2.
Latin American Newsletters. 2007. Latin American Weekly Report. London: Latin American Newsletters Ltd. Accessed November 2008.
Latinobarómetro. 2012. Informe flash: Paraguay 1995–2012. Santiago: Corporación Latinobarómetro. Accessed December 2012.
Levitsky, Steven. 2005. Argentina: Democratic Survival Amidst Economic Failure. In The Third Wave of Democratization in Latin America: Advances and Setbacks, ed. Hagopian, Frances and Mainwaring, Scott. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 6389.
Llanos, Mariana, and Marsteintredet, Leiv, eds. 2010. Presidential Breakdowns in Latin America: Causes and Outcomes of Executive Instability in Developing Democracies. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Mainwaring, Scott, and Shugart, Matthew S.. 1997. Conclusion: Presidentialism and the Party System. In Presidentialism and Democracy in Latin America, ed. Mainwaring, and Shugart, . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 394439.
Marsteintredet, Leiv, and Berntzen, Einar. 2008. Reducing the Perils of Presidentialism in Latin America through Presidential Interruptions. Comparative Politics 41, 1: 83101.
Mejía Acosta, Andrés, and Polga-Hecimovich, John. 2011. Coalition Erosion and Presidential Instability in Ecuador. Latin American Politics and Society 53, 2 (Summer): 87111.
Mustapic, Ana María. 2005. Inestabilidad sin colapso. La renuncia de los presidentes: Argentina en el año 2001. Desarrollo Económico 45, 178: 263–80.
Mustapic, Ana María. 2010. Presidentialism and Early Exits: the Role of Congress. In Llanos and Marsteintredet 2010. 1732.
Nickson, Andrew. 2008. Una oportunidad para Paraguay: los desafíos de Fernando Lugo. Nueva Sociedad 216: 416.
Ollier, María Matilde. 2008. La institucionalización democrática en el callejón: la inestabilidad presidencial en el Cono Sur (1992–2003). América Latina Hoy 49: 73103.
Pérez-Liñán, Aníbal. 2003. Presidential Crises and Democratic Accountability in Latin America, 1990–1999. In What Justice? Whose Justice? Fighting for Fairness in Latin America, ed. Eckstein, Susan E. and Wickham-Crowley, Timothy P.. Berkeley: University of California Press. 98129.
Pérez-Liñán, Aníbal. 2005. Democratization and Constitutional Crises in Presidential Regimes: toward Congressional Supremacy? Comparative Political Studies 38, 1: 5174.
Pérez-Liñán, Aníbal. 2007. Presidential Impeachment and the New Political Instability in Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pousadela, Inés M. 2010. Fora Collor/Que se vayan todos: episodios de accountability en Argentina y Brasil. Revista de Sociología 24: 5986.
Ragin, Charles C. 2000. Fuzzy-Set Social Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ragin, Charles C. 2008. Redesigning Social Inquiry: Fuzzy Sets and Beyond. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Sartori, Giovanni. 1970. Concept Misinformation in Comparative Politics. American Political Science Review 64, 4: 1033–53.
Schamis, Hector. 2002. Argentina: Crisis and Democratic Consolidation. Journal of Democracy 13, 2: 8194.
Šidák, Zbynek. 1967. Rectangular Confidence Regions for the Means of Multivariate Normal Distributions. Journal of the American Statistical Association 62, 318: 626–33.
Smith, Peter H. 2005. Democracy in Latin America: Political Change in Comparative Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Taylor-Robinson, Michelle M., and Ura, Joseph Daniel. 2013. Public Opinion and Conflict in the Separation of Powers: Understanding the Honduran Coup of 2009. Journal of Theoretical Politics 25, 1 (January): 105–27.
Tedesco, Laura, and Diamint, Rut. 2014. Latin American Democracy: What to Do with the Leaders? Bulletin of Latin American Research 33, 1: 3145.
Ultima Hora (Asunción). 2012. Lugo mantiene mejor imagen que Federico Franco, según encuesta. July 16: 1.
Valenzuela, Arturo. 2004. Latin American Presidencies Interrupted. Journal of Democracy 15, 4: 519.
Waisbord, Silvio. 2011. Between Support and Confrontation: Civic Society, Media Reform, and Populism in Latin America. Communication, Culture and Critique 4, 1: 97117.
Waisbord, Silvio. 2013. Vox populista: medios, periodismo, democracia. Buenos Aires: Gedisa.
World Bank. 2010. World Development Indicators on-Line. Accessed November 2008.
Zamosc, Leon. 2012. Popular Impeachments: Ecuador in Comparative Perspective. In Shifting Frontiers of Citizenship: The Latin American Experience, ed. Sznajder, Mario, Roniger, Luis, and Forment, Carlos A.. Leiden: Brill. 237–66.


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed