Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The association of specific neuropsychological deficits with capacity to consent to research or treatment

  • BARTON W. PALMER (a1) and GAURI N. SAVLA (a1) (a2)

Abstract

Informed consent is key to ethical clinical research and treatment, but partially rests on the ability of individual patients or research participants to use disclosed information to make a meaningful choice. Although the construct of decisional capacity emerged from legal and philosophical traditions, several investigators have begun examining the relationship of specific neuropsychological abilities to decisional capacity. This line of research may foster development of better consent procedures, as well as aid in refining the construct of decisional capacity toward a form that better reflects the underlying neurocognitive processes. We conducted a systematic search of the published literature and thereby identified and reviewed 16 published reports of empirical studies that examined the relationship between specific neuropsychological abilities and capacity to consent to research or treatment. Significant relationships between neuropsychological scores and decisional capacity were present across all the reviewed studies. The degree to which specific neuropsychological abilities have particular relevance to decisional capacity remains uncertain, but the existing studies provide a solid basis for a priori hypotheses for future investigations. These ongoing efforts represent an important conceptual and empirical bridge between bioethical, legal, and neuropsychological approaches to understanding meaningful decision-making processes. (JINS, 2007, 13, 1047–1059.)

Copyright

Corresponding author

Correspondence and reprint requests to: Barton W. Palmer, Ph.D., Division of Geriatric Psychiatry 116A-1, University of California, San Diego, Veterans Affairs San Diego Healthcare System, 3350 La Jolla Village Drive, San Diego, CA 92161. E-mail: bpalmer@ucsd.edu

References

Hide All

REFERENCES

Appelbaum, P.S. & Grisso, T. (1988). Assessing patients' capacities to consent to treatment. New England Journal of Medicine, 319, 16351638.
Appelbaum, P.S. & Grisso, T. (2001). MacCAT-CR: MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool for Clinical Research. Sarasota, FL: Professional Resource Press.
Appelbaum, P.S. & Roth, L.H. (1982). Competency to consent to research: A psychiatric overview. Archives of General Psychiatry, 39, 951958.
Awad, N., Gagnon, M., & Messier, C. (2004). The relationship between impaired glucose tolerance, type 2 diabetes, and cognitive function. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 26, 10441080.
Bambara, J.K., Griffith, H.R., Martin, R.C., Faught, E., Wadley, V.G., & Marson, D.C. (2007). Medical decision-making abilities in older adults with chronic partial epilepsy. Epilepsy and Behavior, 10, 6368.
Barton, C.D., Jr., Mallik, H.S., Orr, W.B., & Janofsky, J.S. (1996). Clinicians' judgement of capacity of nursing home patients to give informed consent. Psychiatric Services, 47, 956960.
Bishop, C.L., Temple, R.O., Tremont, G., Westervelt, H.J., & Stern, R.A. (2003). Utility of the neuropsychological evaluation in an acute medical hospital. Clinical Neuropsychology, 17, 468473.
Bowie, C.R., Reichenberg, A., Patterson, T.L., Heaton, R.K., & Harvey, P.D. (2006). Determinants of real-world functional performance in schizophrenia subjects: Correlations with cognition, functional capacity, and symptoms. American Journal of Psychiatry, 163, 418425.
Brewer, N.T., Chapman, G.B., Schwartz, J.A., & Bergus, G.R. (2007). The influence of irrelevant anchors on the judgments and choices of doctors and patients. Medical Decision Making, 27, 203211.
Carpenter, W.T., Gold, J.M., Lahti, A.C., Queern, C.A., Conley, R.R., Bartko, J.J., Kovnick, J., & Appelbaum, P.S. (2000). Decisional capacity for informed consent in schizophrenia research. Archives of General Psychiatry, 57, 533538.
Casarett, D.J., Karlawish, J.H., & Hirschman, K.B. (2003). Identifying ambulatory cancer patients at risk of impaired capacity to consent to research. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 26, 615624.
Chapman, L.J. & Chapman, J.P. (1978). The measurement of differential deficit. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 14, 303311.
Cohen, J. & Cohen, P. (1983). Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for Behavioral Sciences (2nd ed., pp. 5657). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Earlbaum Associates.
Collie, A. (2005). Cognition in liver disease. Liver International, 25, 18.
Delis, D., Kaplan, E., & Kramer, J. (2001). Delis-Kaplan Executive Function Scale (D-KEFS): Examiner's Manual. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.
Dunn, L.B., Candilis, P.J., & Roberts, L.W. (2006a). Emerging empirical evidence on the ethics of schizophrenia research. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 32, 4768.
Dunn, L.B. & Jeste, D.V. (2001). Enhancing informed consent for research and treatment. Neuropsychopharmacology, 24, 595607.
Dunn, L.B., Nowrangi, M., Palmer, B.W., Jeste, D.V., & Saks, E. (2006b). Assessing capacity to consent to treatment and research: A review of instruments. American Journal of Psychiatry, 163, 13231334.
Dunn, L.B., Palmer, B.W., Appelbaum, P.S., Saks, E.R., Aarons, G.A., & Jeste, D.V. (2007a). Prevalence and correlates of adequate performance on a measure of abilities related to decisional capacity: Differences among three standards for the MacCAT-CR in patients with schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Research, 89, 110118.
Dunn, L.B., Palmer, B.W., & Karlawish, J.H. (2007b). Frontal dysfunction and capacity to consent to treatment or research: Conceptual considerations and empirical evidence. In B. Miller & J.L. Cummings (Eds.), The Human Frontal Lobes: Functions and Disorders (2nd ed., pp. 335344). New York: Guilford Press.
Dymek, M.P., Atchison, P., Harrell, L., & Marson, D.C. (2001). Competency to consent to medical treatment in cognitively impaired patients with Parkinson's disease. Neurology, 56, 1724.
Dymek, M.P., Marson, D.C., & Harrell, L. (1999). Factor structure of capacity to consent to medical treatment in patients with Alzheimer's disease: An exploratory study. Journal of Forensic Neuropsychology, 1, 2748.
Earnst, K.S., Marson, D.C., & Harrell, L.E. (2000). Cognitive models of physicians' legal standard and personal judgments of competency in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Journal of the American Geriatric Society, 48, 919927.
Etchells, E., Katz, M.R., Shuchman, M., Wong, G., Workman, S., Choudhry, N.K., Craven, J., & Singer, P.A. (1997). Accuracy of clinical impressions and Mini-Mental State Exam scores for assessing capacity to consent to major medical treatment. Comparison with criterion-standard psychiatric assessments. Psychosomatics, 38, 239245.
Eyler, L.T. & Jeste, D.V. (2006). Enhancing the informed consent process: A conceptual overview. Behavioral Sciences & The Law, 24, 553568.
Eyler, L.T., Olsen, R.K., Nayak, G.V., Mirzakhanian, H., Brown, G.G., & Jeste, D.V. (2007). Brain response correlates of decisional capacity in schizophrenia: A preliminary FMRI study. Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences, 19, 137144.
Faden, R., Beauchamp, T., & King, N. (1986). A History and Theory of Informed Consent. New York: Oxford University Press.
Fagerlin, A., Wang, C., & Ubel, P.A. (2005). Reducing the influence of anecdotal reasoning on people's health care decisions: Is a picture worth a thousand statistics? Medical Decision Making, 25, 398405.
Fioravanti, M., Carlone, O., Vitale, B., Cinti, M.E., & Clare, L. (2005). A meta-analysis of cognitive deficits in adults with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Neuropsychology Review, 15, 7395.
Fisher, C.B., Cea, C.D., Davidson, P.W., & Fried, A.L. (2006). Capacity of persons with mental retardation to consent to participate in randomized clinical trials. American Journal of Psychiatry, 163, 18131820.
Fitten, L.J. & Waite, M.S. (1990). Impact of medical hospitalization on treatment decision-making capacity in the elderly. Archives of Internal Medicine, 150, 17171721.
Flory, J. & Emanuel, E. (2004). Interventions to improve research participants' understanding in informed consent for research: A systematic review. Journal of the American Medical Association, 292, 15931601.
Ganzini, L., Volicer, L., Nelson, W.A., Fox, E., & Derse, A.R. (2005). Ten myths about decision-making capacity. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 6(Suppl.), S100S104.
Gladsjo, J.A., McAdams, L.A., Palmer, B.W., Moore, D.J., Jeste, D.V., & Heaton, R.K. (2004). A six-factor model of cognition in schizophrenia and related psychotic disorders: Relationships with clinical symptoms and functional capacity. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 30, 739754.
Green, M.F., Kern, R.S., Braff, D.L., & Mintz, J. (2000). Neurocognitive deficits and functional outcome in schizophrenia: Are we measuring the “right stuff”? Schizophrenia Bulletin, 26, 119136.
Grisso, T. & Appelbaum, P.S. (1995). The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. III: Abilities of patients to consent to psychiatric and medical treatments. Law and Human Behavior, 19, 149174.
Grisso, T. & Appelbaum, P.S. (1998). Assessing Competence to Consent to Treatment: A Guide for Physicians and Other Health Professionals. New York: Oxford University Press.
Grisso, T., Appelbaum, P.S., & Hill-Fotouhi, C. (1997). The MacCAT-T: A clinical tool to assess patients' capacities to make treatment decisions. Psychiatric Services, 48, 14151419.
Gurrera, R.J., Karel, M.J., Azar, A.R., & Moye, J. (2007). Agreement between instruments for rating treatment decisional capacity. American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 15, 168173.
Gurrera, R.J., Moye, J., Karel, M.J., Azar, A.R., & Armesto, J.C. (2006). Cognitive performance predicts treatment decisional abilities in mild to moderate dementia. Neurology, 66, 13671372.
Halpern, S.D. (2005). Towards evidence based bioethics. BMJ, 331, 901903.
Heinrichs, R.W. & Zakzanis, K.K. (1998). Neurocognitive deficit in schizophrenia: A quantitative review of the evidence. Neuropsychology, 12, 426445.
Hey, C.T., Hynes, S.M., Reese, R.L., Benjamin, M.L., Arndt, S., Schultz, S.K., Andreasen, N.C., & Moser, D.J. (2006). Cognitive and psychiatric factors associated with capacity for informed consent in schizophrenia research [abstract]. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 12(Suppl. S1), 240.
Jefferson, A.L., Paul, R.H., Ozonoff, A., & Cohen, R.A. (2006). Evaluating elements of executive functioning as predictors of instrumental activities of daily living (IADLs). Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology, 21, 311320.
Kaplan, E. (1988). A process approach to neuropsychological assessment. In M. Dennis, E. Kaplan, M.I. Posner, D.G. Stein, & R.F. Thompson (Eds.), Clinical Neuropsychology and Brain Function: Research, Measurment, and Practice (pp. 129167). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
Karlawish, J.H., Casarett, D.J., James, B.D., Xie, S.X., & Kim, S.Y. (2005). The ability of persons with Alzheimer disease (AD) to make a decision about taking an AD treatment. Neurology, 64, 15141519.
Kim, S.Y. (2004). Evidence-based ethics for neurology and psychiatry research. NeuroRx, 1, 372377.
Kim, S.Y. & Caine, E.D. (2002). Utility and limits of the mini mental state examination in evaluating consent capacity in Alzheimer's disease. Psychiatric Services, 53, 13221324.
Kim, S.Y., Cox, C., & Caine, E.D. (2002). Impaired decision-making ability in subjects with Alzheimer's disease and willingness to participate in research. American Journal of Psychiatry, 159, 797802.
Knight, R.A. & Silverstein, S.M. (2001). A process-oriented approach for averting confounds resulting from general performance deficiencies in schizophrenia. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 110, 1530.
Kovnick, J.A., Appelbaum, P.S., Hoge, S.K., & Leadbetter, R.A. (2003). Competence to consent to research among long-stay inpatients with chronic schizophrenia. Psychiatric Services, 54, 12471252.
Marson, D.C. (2001). Loss of competency in Alzheimer's disease: Conceptual and psychometric approaches. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 24, 267283.
Marson, D.C., Annis, S.M., McInturff, B., Bartolucci, A., & Harrell, L.E. (1999). Error behaviors associated with loss of competency in Alzheimer's disease. Neurology, 53, 19831992.
Marson, D.C., Chatterjee, A., Ingram, K.K., & Harrell, L.E. (1996). Toward a neurologic model of competency: Cognitive predictors of capacity to consent in Alzheimer's disease using three different legal standards. Neurology, 46, 666672.
Marson, D.C., Cody, H.A., Ingram, K.K., & Harrell, L.E. (1995a). Neuropsychologic predictors of competency in Alzheimer's disease using a rational reasons legal standard. Archives of Neurology, 52, 955959.
Marson, D.C. & Harrell, L. (1999). Executive dysfunction and loss of capacity to consent to medical treatment in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Seminars in Clinical Neuropsychiatry, 4, 4149.
Marson, D.C., Hawkins, L., McInturff, B., & Harrell, L.E. (1997). Cognitive models that predict physician judgments of capacity to consent in mild Alzheimer's disease. Journal of the American Geriatric Society, 45, 458464.
Marson, D.C. & Ingram, K.K. (1996). Competency to consent to treatment: A growing field of research: Commentary. Journal of Ethics, Law, and Aging, 2, 5963.
Marson, D.C., Ingram, K.K., Cody, H.A., & Harrell, L.E. (1995b). Assessing the competency of patients with Alzheimer's disease under different legal standards. A prototype instrument. Archives Neurology, 52, 949954.
Marson, D.C., Ingram, K.K., & Harrell, L. (1993). Neuropsychological correlates of competency loss in dementia using a simple legal standard [abstract]. Journal of the American Geriatric Society, 41, SA43.
Meisel, A., Roth, L.H., & Lidz, C.W. (1977). Toward a model of the legal doctrine of informed consent. American Journal of Psychiatry, 134, 285289.
Moser, D.J., Schultz, S.K., Arndt, S., Benjamin, M.L., Fleming, F.W., Brems, C.S., Paulsen, J.S., Appelbaum, P.S., & Andreasen, N.C. (2002). Capacity to provide informed consent for participation in schizophrenia and HIV research. American Journal of Psychiatry, 159, 12011207.
Moye, J. & Karel, M.J. (1999). Evaluating decisional capacities in older adults: Results of two clinical studies. Advances in Medical Psychotherapy, 10, 7184.
Moye, J., Karel, M.J., Azar, A.R., & Gurrera, R.J. (2004a). Capacity to consent to treatment: Empirical comparison of three instruments in older adults with and without dementia. Gerontologist, 44, 166175.
Moye, J., Karel, M.J., Azar, A.R., & Gurrera, R.J. (2004b). Hopes and cautions for instrument-based evaluation of consent capacity: Results of a construct validity study of three instruments. Journal of Ethics, Law, and Aging Review, 10, 3961.
Moye, J., Karel, M.J., Gurrera, R.J., & Azar, A.R. (2006). Neuropsychological predictors of decision-making capacity over 9 months in mild-to-moderate dementia. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 21, 7883.
Moye, J. & Marson, D.C. (2007). Assessment of decision-making capacity in older adults: An emerging area of practice and research. The Journals of Gerontology. Series B, Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences, 62B, P3P11.
National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1979). The Belmont Report: Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research. http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/humansubjects/guidance/belmont.htm. Accessed May 24, 2007.
Newman, M.F., Kirchner, J.L., Phillips-Bute, B., Gaver, V., Grocott, H., Jones, R.H., Mark, D.B., Reves, J.G., & Blumenthal, J.A. (2001). Longitudinal assessment of neurocognitive function after coronary-artery bypass surgery. New England Journal of Medicine, 344, 395402.
Northoff, G. (2006). Neuroscience of decision making and informed consent: An investigation in neuroethics. Journal of Medical Ethics, 32, 7073.
Palmer, B.W. (2006). Informed consent for schizophrenia research: What is an investigator (or IRB) to do? Behavioral Sciences & The Law, 24, 447452.
Palmer, B.W., Dunn, L.B., Appelbaum, P.S., & Jeste, D.V. (2004). Correlates of treatment-related decision-making capacity among middle-aged and older patients with schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry, 61, 230236.
Palmer, B.W., Dunn, L.B., Appelbaum, P.S., Mudaliar, S., Thal, L., Henry, R., Golshan, S., & Jeste, D.V. (2005). Assessment of capacity to consent to research among older persons with schizophrenia, Alzheimer disease, or diabetes mellitus: Comparison of a 3-item questionnaire with a comprehensive standardized capacity instrument. Archives of General Psychiatry, 62, 726733.
Palmer, B.W., Dunn, L.B., Depp, C.A., Eyler, L.T., & Jeste, D.V. (2007). Decisional capacity to consent to research among patients with bipolar disorder: Comparison with schizophrenia patients and healthy subjects. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 68, 689696.
Palmer, B.W. & Heaton, R. (2000). Executive dysfunction in schizophrenia. In T. Sharma & P. Harvey (Eds.), Cognition in Schizophrenia: Impairments, Importance and Treatment Strategies (pp. 5272). New York: Oxford University Press.
Palmer, B.W. & Jeste, D.V. (2006). Relationship of individual cognitive abilities to specific components of decisional capacity among middle-aged and older patients with schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 32, 98106.
Pucci, E., Belardinelli, N., Borsetti, G., Rodriguez, D., & Signorino, M. (2001). Information and competency for consent to pharmacologic clinical trials in Alzheimer disease: An empirical analysis in patients and family caregivers. Alzheimer Disease and Associated Disorders, 15, 146154.
Randolph, C. (1998). RBANS—Manual—Repeatable Battery for the Assessment of Neuropsychological Status. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.
Raymont, V., Bingley, W., Buchanan, A., David, A.S., Hayward, P., Wessely, S., & Hotopf, M. (2004). Prevalence of mental incapacity in medical inpatients and associated risk factors: Cross-sectional study. Lancet, 364, 14211427.
Resnick, B., Gruber-Baldini, A.L., Pretzer-Aboff, I., Galik, E., Buie, V.C., Russ, K., & Zimmerman, S. (2007). Reliability and validity of the evaluation to sign consent measure. Gerontologist, 47, 6977.
Reynolds, C.F., III. (2007). Assessing the capacity to make everyday decisions about functional problems: Where does the field go from here? American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 15, 8991.
Roth, L.H., Meisel, A., & Lidz, C.W. (1977). Tests of competency to consent to treatment. American Journal of Psychiatry, 134, 279284.
Royall, D.R. (2002). Back to the future of mental capacity assessment. Journal of the American Geriatric Society, 50, 18841885.
Salmon, D.P. & Bondi, M.W. (1999). Neuropsychology of Alzheimer disease. In D.P. Salmon & M.W. Bondi (Eds.), Alzheimer Disease (2nd ed., pp. 3956). Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
Salthouse, T.A. & Becker, J.T. (1998). Independent effects of Alzheimer's disease on neuropsychological functioning. Neuropsychology, 12, 242252.
Savla, G.N., Moore, D.J., & Palmer, B.W., (in press). Cognitive functioning in schizophrenia. In K.T. Mueser & D.V. Jeste (Eds.), Clinical Handbook of Schizophrenia. New York: Guilford Press.
Schillerstrom, J.E., Rickenbacker, D., Joshi, K.G., & Royall, D.R. (2007). Executive function and capacity to consent to a noninvasive research protocol. American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 15, 159162.
Sedlmeier, P. & Jaeger, S. (2007). The impact of post-event information on study-related memories: An exploration of the roles of judgemental anchoring, specific expectations about change, and motivational influences. Memory, 15, 7092.
Smith, D.M., Schwarz, N., Roberts, T.R., & Ubel, P.A. (2006). Why are you calling me? How study introductions change response patterns. Quality of Life Research, 15, 621630.
Stroup, S., Appelbaum, P., Swartz, M., Patel, M., Davis, S., Jeste, D., Kim, S., Keefe, R., Manschreck, T., McEvoy, J., & Lieberman, J. (2005). Decision-making capacity for research participation among individuals in the CATIE schizophrenia trial. Schizophrenia Research, 80, 18.
Tabachnick, B.G. & Fidell, L.S. (1996). Using Multivariate Statistics—Third Edition. New York: HarperCollins College Publishers.
The Psychological Corporation. (1997). WAIS-III/WMS-III Technical Manual. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.
Thompson, B. (1995). Stepwise regression and stepwise discriminant analysis need not apply here: A guidelines editorial. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 55, 525534.
Tversky, A. & Kahneman, D. (1974). Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science, 185, 11241131.
Waldstein, S.R., Manuck, S.B., Ryan, C.M., & Muldoon, M.F. (1991). Neuropsychological correlates of hypertension: Review and methodologic considerations. Psychology Bulletin, 110, 451468.
Wechsler, D. (1997). Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale—Third Edition (WAIS-III). Administration and Scoring Manual. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.

Keywords

The association of specific neuropsychological deficits with capacity to consent to research or treatment

  • BARTON W. PALMER (a1) and GAURI N. SAVLA (a1) (a2)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed