Skip to main content Accessibility help

Doing More with Less in Health Care: Findings from a Multi-Method Study of Decommissioning in the English National Health Service



In the context of an austere financial climate, local health care budget holders are increasingly expected to make and enact decisions to decommission (reduce or stop providing) services. However, little is currently known about the experiences of those seeking to decommission. This paper presents the first national study of decommissioning in the English National Health Service drawing on multiple methods, including: an interview-based review of the contemporary policy landscape of health care decommissioning; a national online survey of commissioners of health care services responsible for managing and enacting budget allocation decisions locally; and illustrative vignettes provided by those who have led decommissioning activities. Findings are presented and discussed in relation to four themes: national-local relationships; organisational capacity and resources for decommissioning; the extent and nature of decommissioning; and intended outcomes of decommissioning. Whilst it is unlikely that local commissioners will be able to ‘successfully’ implement decommissioning decisions unless aspects of engagement, local context and outcomes are addressed, it remains unclear what ‘success’ looks like in terms of a decommissioning process.



Hide All
Abbott, S., Procter, S. and Iacovou, N. (2009),‘NHS purchaser/provider relationships in England and Wales: the view from primary care’, Social Policy and Administration, 43 (1), 114.
Alderwick, H., Dunn, P., McKenna, H., Walsh, N. and Ham, C. (2016), Sustainability and transformation plans in the NHS, How are they being developed in practice? London: Kings Fund
Bate, A., Donaldson, C. and Murtagh, M. J. (2007), ‘Managing to manage healthcare resources in the English NHS? What can health economics teach? What can health economics learn?Health Policy, 84 (2–3), 249–61.
Lord Carter of Coles (2016), Operational productivity and performance in English NHS acute hospitals: Unwarranted variations, (accessed 20/04/2017)
Checkland, K., Coleman, A., Harrison, S. and Hiroeh, U. (2009), “‘We can't get anything done because. . .’: making sense of ‘barriers’ to Practice-based CommissioningJournal of Health Services Research and Policy, 14 (1), 2026.
Checkland, K., Harrison, S., Snow, S., McDermott, I. and Coleman, A. (2012), “Commissioning in the English National Health Service: What's the Problem?Journal of Social Policy, 41 (3), 533550
Checkland, K., McDermott, I., Coleman, A. and Perkins, N. (2015), “Complexity in the new NHS: longitudinal case studies of CCGs in EnglandBritish Medical Journal doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2015-010199
Creswell, J. W. and Clark, V. L. P. (2011), Designing and conducting mixed methods research, London: Sage.
Daniels, T., Williams, I., Robinson, S. and Spence, K. (2013), “Tackling disinvestment in health care services: the views of resource allocators in the English NHSJournal of health organization and management; 28–27 (6), 762–80.
Department of Health (2010), Equity and Excellence: Liberating the NHS, London: The Stationary Office.
Edwards, N. (2016), ‘What do we know about STPs so far?’. Nuffield Trust comment, 25 November 2016. (accessed 20/04/17)
Greenhalgh, T., Howick, J. and Maskrey, N. (2014), “Evidence based medicine: a movement in crisis?British Medical Journal 348, g3725.
Committee, Health Select (2010), Commissioning, House of Commons Health Committee 4th Report of Session 2009–2010, London: The Stationery Office.
Health Select Committee (2011), Commissioning: Further Issues, London: The Stationery Office.
HM Treasury (2016), Autumn Statement 2016 (accessed 20/04/2017)
HM Treasury (2017), Spring Budget 2017 (accessed 20/04/2017)
Hurley, R. (2014), “Can doctors reduce harmful medical overuse worldwide?British Medical Journal, 349, d4289.
Johnstone, P.L. (2004), “Mixed Methods, Mixed Methodology Health Services Research in PracticeQualitative Health Research, 14 (2), 259271.
Klein, R. (2013), The New Politics of the NHS, (Seventh edition), London: Radcliffe Publishing.
Lafond, S., Charlesworth, A. and Roberts, A. (2016), A perfect storm: an impossible climate for NHS providers’ finances? An analysis of NHS finances and factors associated with financial performance (accessed 20/04/2017)
Malhotra, A., Maughan, D., Ansell, J., Lehman, R., Henderson, A., Gray, M., Stephenson, T. and Bailey, S. (2015), “Choosing Wisely in the UK: the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges’ initiative to reduce the harms of too much medicine”, British Medical Journal; 350, h2308
McCafferty, S., Williams, I., Hunter, D., Robinson, S., Donaldson, C. and Bate, A. (2012), “Implementing world class commissioning competencies”, Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 17 (1), 4048.
McDermott, I., Checkland, K., Coleman, A., Osipovič, D., Petsoulas, C. and Perkins, N. (2017), “Engaging GPs in commissioning: realist evaluation of the early experiences of Clinical Commissioning Groups in the English NHS”, Journal of health services research & policy, 22 (1), 411.
Monitor (2013), Closing the NHS funding gap: how to get better value healthcare for patients, (accessed 20/04/2017)
NHS Confederation (2014), “Health service is driving change but needs support, survey finds”, (accessed 20/04/2017)
NHS England (2014), Five Year Forward View (accessed 20/04/2017)
Pierson, P. (1994), Dismantling the welfare state? Reagan, Thatcher, and the Politics of Retrenchment, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Robert, G., Harlock, J. and Williams, I. (2014), “Disentangling rhetoric and reality: an international Delphi study of factors and processes that facilitate the successful implementation of decisions to decommission healthcare services”, Implementation Science, 9 (1), 123
Robinson, S., Williams, I., Dickinson, H., Freeman, T. and Rumbold, B. (2012), “Priority-setting and rationing in healthcare: evidence from the English experience”, Social Science & Medicine, 75 (12), 23862393.
Robinson, S., Glasby, J. and Allen, K. (2013), “‘It ain't what you do it's the way that you do it’: lessons for health care from decommissioning of older people's services”, Health & social care in the community, 21 (6), 614622.
Sampson, F., O'Cathain, A., Strong, M., Pickin, M. and Esmonde, L. (2012), “Commissioning processes in primary care trusts: a repeated cross-sectional survey of health care commissioners in England”, Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 17 (1), 3139.
Smith, J., Porter, A., Shaw, S., Rosen, R., Blunt, I. and Mays, N. (2013), Commissioning high quality care for people with long-term conditions, London: Nuffield Trust.
Wenzl, M., McCuskee, S. and Mossialos, E. (2015), “Commissioning for equity in the NHS: rhetoric and practice”, British medical bulletin, 115 (1), 517.
Williams, I., Harlock, J., Robert, G., Mannion, R., Brearley, S. and Hall, K. (2017), Decommissioning health care: identifying best practice through primary and secondary research. National Institute for Health Research.


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed