Skip to main content Accessibility help

Seneca's Scientific Fictions: Models as Fictions in the Natural Questions

  • Courtney Ann Roby (a1)


Seneca's Naturales Quaestiones explains the causes and functional mechanisms of natural phenomena, from common sights like rainbows to exotically out-of-reach ones like comets. The vividness with which he brings them all within the reader's grasp is certainly a literary feat as much as a scientific one, but the rhetorical power of his explanations does not cost them their epistemological validity. Analyses drawn from current philosophy of science reveal elements of fictionality omnipresent in scientific models and experiments, suggesting an approach to Seneca's ‘scientific fictions’ not as failed analogies but as a sophisticated expansion of the tradition of analogical scientific explanation.


Corresponding author


Hide All
Alexander, W. H. 1955: ‘Change of color in moribund fishes (Seneca, Nat. Quaest. 3.17–18)’, The Classical Weekly 48, no. 14, 192–3
Armisen-Marchetti, M. 1989: Sapientiae facies: étude sur les images de Sénèque, Paris
Armisen-Marchetti, M. 2001: ‘L'imaginaire analogique et la construction du savoir dans les Questions Naturelles de Sénèque’, in Courrént, M. and Thomas, J. (eds), Imaginaire et modes de construction du savoir antique dans les textes scientifiques et techniques, Perpignan, 155–74
Barberousse, A., and Ludwig, P. 2009: ‘Models as fictions’, in Suárez 2009, 56–73
Barton, C. A. 1993: The Sorrows of the Ancient Romans: The Gladiator and the Monster, Princeton, NJ
Blanché, R. 1973: Le raisonnement, Paris
Bokulich, A. 2009: ‘Explanatory fictions’, in Suárez 2009, 91–109
Boon, M., and Knuuttila, T. 2011: ‘Breaking up with the epochal break: the case of engineering sciences’, in Nordmann, A., Radder, H. and Schiemann, G. (eds), Science Transformed? Debating Claims of an Epochal Break, Pittsburgh, Pa., 6679
Boroditsky, L. 2001: ‘First, we assume a spherical cow …’, Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24, no. 4, 656–7
Cartwright, N. 1983: How the Laws of Physics Lie, Oxford/New York
Cartwright, N. 1989: Nature's Capacities and Their Measurement, Oxford/New York
Chadarevian, S. de, and Hopwood, N. 2004: Models: The Third Dimension of Science, Stanford, Calif.
Conte, G. B. 1994: Genres and Readers: Lucretius, Love Elegy, Pliny's Encyclopedia, Baltimore, Md
Edelstein, L. 1967: ‘Empiricism and skepticism in the teaching of the Greek empiricist school’, in Temkin, O. and Temkin, C. L. (eds), Ancient Medicine; Selected Papers of Ludwig Edelstein, Baltimore, Md, 349–66
Elgin, C. 2009: ‘Exemplification, idealization, and scientific understanding’, in Suárez 2009, 77–90
Giere, R. N. 2004: ‘How models are used to represent reality’, Philosophy of Science 71, no. 5, 742–52
Goldstein, B. R. 2008: ‘The status of models in ancient and medieval astronomy’, Centaurus: International Magazine of the History of Mathematics, Science, and Technology 50, 168–83
Hacking, I. 1983: Representing and Intervening: Introductory Topics in the Philosophy of Natural Science, Cambridge
Hacking, I. 1992: ‘The self-vindication of the laboratory sciences’, in Pickering, A. (ed.), Science as Practice and Culture, Chicago, 2964
Harré, R. 1970: The Principles of Scientific Thinking, Chicago
Hempel, C. G. 1965: Aspects of Scientific Explanation, and Other Essays in the Philosophy of Science, New York
Hine, H. M. 1996: Studies in the Text of Seneca's “Naturales Quaestiones”, Stuttgart
Holmes, B. 2010: The Symptom and the Subject: The Emergence of the Physical Body in Ancient Greece, Princeton, NJ
Hughes, R. I. G. 1997: ‘Models and representation’, Philosophy of Science 64 (December 1, 1997), S325S336
Humphreys, P. 2012: Models, Simulations, and Representations, New York
Inwood, B. 2005: ‘God and human knowledge in Seneca's Natural Questions’, in Inwood, B., Reading Seneca: Stoic Philosophy at Rome, Oxford, 157200
Knuuttila, T. 2005: ‘Models, representation, and mediation’, Philosophy of Science 72, no. 5, 1260–71
Kullmann, W. 2010: Naturgesetz in der Vorstellung der Antike, besonders der Stoa: eine Begriffsuntersuchung, Stuttgart
Kyle, D. G. 1998: Spectacles of Death in Ancient Rome, New York
Leach, E. W. 1988: The Rhetoric of Space: Literary and Artistic Representations of Landscape in Republican and Augustan Rome, Princeton, NJ
Lehoux, D. 2012: What Did the Romans Know? An Inquiry into Science and Worldmaking, Chicago
Lehoux, D. 2013: ‘Seeing and unseeing, seen and unseen’, in Lehoux, D., Morrison, A. D. and Sharrock, A. (eds), Lucretius: Poetry, Philosophy, Science, Oxford, 131–51
Lloyd, G. E. R. 1966: Polarity and Analogy; Two Types of Argumentation in Early Greek Thought, Cambridge
Morrison, M. 2009: ‘Fictions, representations, and reality’, in Suárez 2009, 110–38
Norton Wise, M. 2006: ‘Making Visible’, Isis 97, no. 1 (March 1, 2006), 7582
Payne, M. 2007: Theocritus and the Invention of Fiction, Cambridge/New York
Platt, V. J. 2011: Facing the Gods: Epiphany and Representation in Graeco-Roman Art, Literature and Religion, Cambridge/New York
Rouse, J. 1987: Knowledge and Power: Toward a Political Philosophy of Science, Ithaca, NY
Rouse, J. 2009: ‘Laboratory fictions’, in Suárez 2009, 37–55
Salmon, W. C. 1984: Scientific Explanation and the Causal Structure of the World, Princeton, NJ
Seneca 1996: L. Annaei Senecae Naturalium quaestionum libros (Ed. Hine, H. M.), Stuttgart
Seneca 2010: Natural Questions (Trans. Hine, H. M.), Chicago
Suárez, M. 2004: ‘An inferential conception of scientific representation’, Philosophy of Science 71, no. 5, 767–79
Suárez, M. (ed.) 2009: Fictions in Science: Philosophical Essays on Modeling and Idealization, New York
Taub, L. C. 2003: Ancient Meteorology, London/New York
von Staden, H. 1975: ‘Experiment and experience in Hellenistic medicine’, Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 22, no. 1, 178–99
von Staden, H. 1994: ‘Author and authority: Celsus on the construction of a scientific self’, in Vázquez Buján, M. E. (ed.), Tradición e innovación de la medicina latina de la antigüedad y de la alta edad media: actas del IV Coloquio Internacional sobre los “Textos Médicos Latinos Antiguos”, Santiago de Compostela, 103–17
Webb, R. 2009: Ekphrasis, Imagination and Persuasion in Ancient Rhetorical Theory and Practice, Farnham/Burlington, VT
Williams, G. 2005: ‘Interactions: physics, morality, and narrative in Seneca Natural Questions 1’, Classical Philology 100, no. 3, 142–65
Williams, G. 2007: ‘Seneca on comets and ancient cometary theory in Natural Questions 7’, Ramus: Critical Studies in Greek and Roman Literature 36, no. 2, 97117
Williams, G. 2012: The Cosmic Viewpoint: A Study of Seneca's Natural Questions, Oxford/New York
Woodward, J. 2003: Making Things Happen: A Theory of Causal Explanation, Oxford/New York


Seneca's Scientific Fictions: Models as Fictions in the Natural Questions

  • Courtney Ann Roby (a1)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed