Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

When the workplace is the home: labour inspectors’ discretionary power in the field of domestic work – an institutional analysis

  • Rebecca Paraciani (a1) and Roberto Rizza (a1)

Abstract

This article builds on previous studies concerning the question of street-level bureaucracy, an expression coined by Lipsky (1980) – Street-Level Bureaucracy. Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services (New York: Russel Sage Foundation) – to highlight the importance of the discretionary power that professionals in public agencies exercise during the implementation of laws, standards and guidelines. Discretion may depend on the need to compromise between the limited resources available and the claims of citizens, or between administrative policy directives and assessments, on the one hand, and their interpretation by “street-level” bureaucrats, on the other. This article focuses on the dilemmas that labour inspectors face when dealing with employment irregularities involving domestic workers. Based on nine months of observations in a local office of the Italian Labour Inspectorate, it aims to understand how labour inspectors make use of their discretionary power when the workplace is the home. This article connects studies of street-level bureaucracy with the new institutional organisational analysis, focusing on the isomorphic pressures from the institutional field in which the labour inspectors operate, together with the manner in which such pressures shape labour inspectors’ discretion. Through this connection, the article aims to extend the scope of both theories.

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Corresponding author. Email: roberto.rizza@unibo.it

References

Hide All
Ambrosini, M (2005) Sociologia delle migrazioni. Bologna: Il Mulino.
Andall, J (2000) Gender, Migration and Domestic Service. The Politics of Black Women in Italy. London: Routledge.
Anderson, B (2007) A Very Private Business. Exploring the Demand for Migrant Domestic Workers. European Journal of Women’s Studies, 14(3): 247264.
Berman, P (1978) The Study of Macro and Micro Implementation of Social Policy. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation.
Bettio, F, Simonazzi, A and Villa, P (2006) Change in Care Regimes and Female Migration: The ‘Care Drain’in the Mediterranean. Journal of European Social Policy, 16(3): 271285.
Bonazzi, G (2002) Come studiare le organizzazioni. Bologna: Il Mulino.
Borghi, V and Rizza, R (2006) L’organizzazione sociale del lavoro. Lo statuto del lavoro e le sue trasformazioni. Milano: Mondadori.
Borghi, V and Van Berkel, R (2007) Individualised Service Provision in an Era of Activation and New Governance. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 27(9/10): 413424.
Brodkin, EZ and Marston, G (2013) Work and the Welfare State. Street-Level Organisation and Workfare Politics. Washington DC: Georgetown University Press.
Castles, S and Miller, MJ (1993) The Age of Migration. International Population Movements in the Modem World. New York: Basingstoke.
Caswell, D, Larsen, F, van Berkel, R and Kupka, P (2017) Conclusions and Topics for Future Research. In van Berkel, R, Caswell, D, Kupka, P and Larsen, F (eds.), Frontline Delivery of Welfare‐to‐Work Policies in Europe. Activating the Unemployed. London: Routledge.
Catanzaro, R and Colombo, A (2009) (eds.) Badanti & Co. Il lavoro domestico straniero in Italia. Bologna: il Mulino.
Cooper, H (2001) Homework for All in Moderation. Educational Leadership, 58(7): 3438.
Davis, KC (1969) Discretionary Justice. A Preliminary Inquiry. Louisiana: Louisiana State University Press.
DiMaggio, P and Powell, W (1983) The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality In Organizational Fields. American Sociological Review, 48: 147160.
Epp, CR (2009) Making Rights Real: Activists, Bureaucrats, and the Creation of the Legalistic State. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Epp, CR, Maynard‐Moody, S and Haider‐Markel, D (2017) Beyond Profiling: The Institutional Sources of Racial Disparities in Policing. Public Administration Review, 77(2): 168178.
Evans, T and Harris, J (2004) Street-level Bureaucracy, Social Work and the (Exaggerated) Death of Discretion. British Journal of Social Work, 34(6): 871–895.
Fassin, D (2013) La forza dell’ordine. Antropologia della polizia nelle periferie urbane. Bologna: La Linea.
Ferrari, S (2002) Event marketing: i grandi eventi e gli eventi speciali come strumenti di marketing. Padova: Cedam.
Fineman, S (1998) Street-level Bureaucrats and the Social Construction of Environmental Control. Organization Studies, 19(6): 953974.
Flood, AB and Fennell, ML (1995) Through the Lenses of Organizational Sociology: The Role of Organizational Theory and Research in Conceptualizing and Examining Our Health Care System. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, Extra Issue: 154169.
FRA (2015) Severe Labour Exploitation: Workers Moving Within or Into the European Union. States’ Obligations and Victims’ Rights. Vienna: FRA.
Fullin, G and Vercelloni, V (2009) Dentro la trappola. Percezioni e immagini del lavoro domestico e di cura nei percorsi delle donne immigrate. Polis, 22(3): 427462.
Garrow, EE and Grusky, O (2012) Institutional Logic and Street-Level Discretion: The Case of HIV Test Counseling. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 23(1): 103131.
Geertz, C (1982) The Way we Think Now: Toward an Ethnography of Modern Thought. Bulletin of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 35: 1434.
Gilboy, JA (1992) Penetrability of Administrative Systems: Political “Casework” and Immigration Inspections. Law & Society Review, 26(2): 273314.
Goosensen, H and Bueren, van E (2011) De professional versus de professionele organisatie: opvattingen over professioneel toezicht, Congres Toezicht en Wetenschap Vide & TU Delft 21-22 June 2011.
Goosensen, HR and Voort van der, HG (2009) Risk Based Oversight: the Story of Street-Level Inspectors. In nn (eds.), Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Law and Society Association. Denver: Blackwell Publishing.
Ham, C and Hill, M (1986) Introduzione all’analisi delle politiche pubbliche. il Mulino: Bologna.
Hawkins, K (1984) Environment and Enforcement. Regulation and the Social Definition of Pollution. Oxford: Clarendon.
Hupe, P (2013) Dimensions of Discretion: Specifying the Object of Street-Level Bureaucracy Research. Der Moderne Staat, 6: 425440.
Hupe, P and Buffat, A (2014) A Public Service Gap: Capturing Contexts in a Comparative Approach of Street-Level Bureaucracy. Public Management Review, 16(4): 548569.
Hupe, P and Hill, M (2007) Street-level Bureaucracy and Public Accountability. Public Administration, 85(2):279299.
Hupe, P, Hill, M and Buffat, A (2015) (eds.) Understanding Street-Level Bureaucracy, Bristol: Policy Press.
Kazepov, Y and Barberis, E (2012) Social assistance governance in Europe. Towards a Multi-level Perspective. In Marx, I and Nelson, K (eds.), Minimum Income Protection in Flux, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kelly, M (1994) Theories of Justice and Street-Level Discretion Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory, 4(2): 119140.
Kluin, MAH (2014) Optic Compliance: Enforcement and Compliance in the Dutch Chemical Industry, Delft: Ridderprint.
Lehmann Nielsen, V (2006) Are Street-Level Bureaucrats Compelled or Enticed to Cope? Public Administration, 84(4): 861889.
Lipsky, M (1980) Street-Level Bureaucracy. Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. New York: Russel Sage Foundation.
Loyens, K (2016) Law Enforcement and Policy Alienation – Coping by Labour Inspectors and Federal Police Officers. In Hupe, P, Hill, M and Buffat, A (eds.), Understanding Street Level Bureaucracy. Bristol: Policy Press.
May, PJ and Wood, RS (2003) At the Regulatory Front Lines: Inspectors’ Enforcement Styles and Regulatory Compliance. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 13(2): 117139.
Maynard-Moody, S and Musheno, M (2003) Cops, Teachers, Counselors: Stories from the Front Lines of Public Service. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Nielsen, VL (2007) Differential Treatment and Communicative Interactions: Why the Character of Social Interaction is Important. Law and Policy, 29(2): 257283.
Piore, MJ (2011) Beyond Markets: Sociology, Street Level Bureaucracy and the Management of the Public Sector. Regulation & Governance, 5: 145164.
Piore, MJ and Schrank, A (2006) Trading Up: An Embryonic Model for Easing the Human Costs of Free Markets. Boston Review, 31(5): 1114.
Piore, MJ and Schrank, A (2008) Toward Managed Flexibility: The Revival of Labour Inspection in the Latin World. International Labour Review, 147(1): 124.
Power, M (1997) The Audit Society: Rituals of Verification, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Raaphorst, N and Loyens, K (2018) From Poker Games to Kitchen Tables: How Social Dynamics Affect Frontline Decision Making. Administration & Society. doi: 0095399718761651.
Rice, D (2012) Street-Level Bureaucrats and the Welfare State: Toward a Micro-Institutionalist Theory of Policy Implementation. Administration & Society, 45(9): 10381062.
Riccucci, N (2005) Street-Level Bureaucrat and Intrastate Variation in the Implementation of Temporary Assistance for Needy Families Policies. Journal of Public Administration, 15: 89111.
Sarti, R (2010) (eds.), Lavoro domestico e di cura. Quali diritti? Roma: Ediesse.
Saruis, T (2015) Gli operatori sociali nel nuovo welfare. Roma: Carocci.
Thornton, PH and Ocasio, W (2017) Institutional Logics. In Greenwood, R, Oliver, C, Lawrence, TB and Meyer, RE (eds.), The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism, London: Sage.
Wiering, M (1999) Contexten van handhaving bij de mestregelgeving in Nederland en Vlaanderen. In Bakker, W and van Waarden, F (eds.), Ruimte rond regels. Stijlen van regulering en beleidsuitvoering vergeleken. Amsterdam: Boom.

Keywords

When the workplace is the home: labour inspectors’ discretionary power in the field of domestic work – an institutional analysis

  • Rebecca Paraciani (a1) and Roberto Rizza (a1)

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed